INTRODUCTION
The creation of more and better jobs is undoubtedly a solution to redu- cing unemployment and minimising migration (internal or external) as Clark (2010) argues that most peoples’ well-being will be low when they are unem- ployed. The focus of internal migration is to seek a better life for oneself; hence migrants move to urban centres for better opportunities (Awumbila & Ardayfio-Schandorf, 2008; Tufeiru, 2014). This is because the urban centres are associated with concepts like modernisation and socio-economic develo- pment (Cyril, Oldroyd & Renzaho, 2013). This line of reasoning is justified by better infrastructure and services, including employment opportunities, health care, and education enjoyed by urban dwellers in comparison with rural dwellers (Rice, 2008; White, 2016). The skewed distribution of resou- rces in developing countries greatly impacts both structured and unstructured businesses of which head portering business is not exempted. Head portering
© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 233
234 Osafroadu
business has gradually gained recognition in Ghana and is an option for pre- dominantly the less-educated female youth migrants because, as Rose (2003) argues, some people work because they want to earn income (the provisioning motive), irrespective of the persistence of psycho-physio-social challenges.
Primarily, the age category of individuals who engage in rural-urban migra- tion in developing countries such as Ghana has been observed to be from 18 to 24 years (Awumbila & Ardayfio-Schandorf, 2008; Tufeiru, 2014; White, 2016). Most of these individuals are adolescents who deny themselves the very pleasures of their adolescent lives and assume hard core roles just to make ends meet as well as support their families back home. A typical busi- ness for most of these adolescent migrants is head-load carrying (kayayoo) business. According to Agarwal, Attah, Apt et al. (1997) and Tufeiru (2014), the “kayayoo” business involves conveying goods from one point to another through human effort, for an unregulated fee.
Several studies have focused mainly on the negative psychosocial impact of this business on the individual and the country at large, to the neglect of what this business represents to the adolescent, adult, and the country (e.g., Alatinga, 2019; Opare, 2003). The question to be answered here is, is this job ‘bad’ in all forms, or it could be that although it is seen to be objecti- vely bad due to its many bad features, it may be good subjectively? This is because Knox, Warhurst, Nickson and Dutton (2015; p. 1551 and 1552) note that “subjectivity is affected by workers’ characteristics such as sex, age, eth- nicity, qualifications and socio-economic background”. Yet, this notion of subjectivity which can make an objectively bad job be perceived positively by different workers appears unresearched so far as the head portering task is concerned, and thus, represents a gap that needs to be filled. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to understand the dynamics of systemic re- orientation of the head portering task from being an objectively “bad” job to a subjectively “good” job and determine whether such systemic transition manifests a business that could be deemed a blessing or otherwise to the soci- oeconomic development of Ghana. In this regard, the study sought answers to the following questions: i. Why do migrants engage in head portering? ii. Do migrants perceive head portering as a business?
LITERATURE REVIEW
The growth theory rests on the tenets that productivity and economic gro- wth of a country reside in the desires and wants of the populace. Therefore, economic growth does not result from external factors but from entrepre- neurship, knowledge, innovation and technology. Liu (2007) elaborates that the growth theory emphasises the relevance of human capital in the growth process. Therefore, “to account for sustained growth, the modern theory needs to postulate continuous improvements in technology or in know- ledge or in human capital…as an engine of growth” (Lucas, 1988; p. 9). It is argued that citizens (e.g., head porters) can enhance economic growth through entrepreneurial activities, using their human capital.
The Systemic Transitioning Strategy of Re-Orienting “Head-Portering” Task 235
Although limited studies have been done on head porters, there appears to be a significant number of studies on migration. Ackah and Medvedev (2010) conclude that factors that determined rural-urban migration could be broadly categorised into individual and community level factors. Enu (2014) and Aliyev (2008) reported that some factors that motivated migra- tion included employment and access to social amenities like good drinking water, good and quality health care (hospital), good roads, good and qua- lity education, electricity, and entertainment. Also, people migrate to urban centres because of limited income sources, lack of employment opportuni- ties, poor economic conditions, ethnic conflicts, and lack of social amenities in the rural communities (Aliyev, 2008). Beals, Levy & Moses (1976) also posit that one’s original locality’s income negatively impacted rural-urban migration. Households’ own income have equally been reported to positi- vely impact the probability to migrate (Caldwell, 1968). In another study, Machaia (2003) found that rural-urban migration also resulted from unba- lanced development. This finding suggests that reasons for migrating are not limited to the individual and community level but rather to a national level where uneven distribution of resources leads to unbalanced development, the same reasons why citizens from less developed countries will migrate to deve- loped ones. Migration networks, i.e., the presence of friends or relatives in the destination locality, is another determinant (Caldwell,1968; Tutu,1995).
Unfortunately, the conditions migrants must endure in the urban centres have been observed to be unfavourable. On a rather critical analysis, one would think these conditions should have deterred or discouraged migrants from wanting to seek permanent stay in the urban centres. In the urban slums in Ghana, some of the unfavourable conditions include unsanitary conditions, lack of access to basic facilities like clean water, health services and sanitation, overcrowding and dense population, and unsafe buildings (Owusu, Agyei-Mensah, & Lund, 2008). Based on these unfavourable living conditions, Owusu et al. (2008) concluded that urban slums may be the face of poverty. This view by Owusu et al. (2008) is affirmed in Alatinga’s (2019) study which found that although adolescents migrated from the north to the south to escape poverty, the “kayayoo” business did not offer them the kind of lives they expected. Yet, these porters were able to make remittances, and this offered food security for their families.
Rural-urban migration has been noted to have varying effects on the indi- vidual and the country at large, despite its negation consequences. As such, contrary to the findings above, Awumbila, Owusu, & Teye (2014) criti- cally assessed the wellbeing of migrants (head porters) juxtaposed the skewed negative perception people hold of migrants. The researchers reported that indeed migrants lived in harsh environments with little social protection. Fur- thermore, regardless of this state of living, majority of the migrants reported their wellbeing was greatly improved after migrating to Accra. Thus, the researchers suggested that rural-urban migration leads to positive outcomes, contrary to the popular belief that urban slums are breeding spaces of despair and misery. These so-called urban slums provide migrants with hope and opportunities to utilise their capabilities regardless of the challenges they face. Asante (1995) suggested that the remittances of migrants impact the
236 Osafroadu
economic welfare of the country at large and further pushes the country closer to materialising the vision of sustainable development goals. The remittances migrants forward to their households in the rural areas do not only greatly improve the households’ welfare but further narrow the welfare gap between the rural and urban communities. This finding was supported by Boakye- Yiadom’s (2008) study when it reported that the welfare of internal migrants was enhanced significantly following rural-urban migration regardless of the welfare losses these migrants experienced on the average. For instance, the households of migrants in comparison with household with non- migrants revealed some interesting findings. Tsegai (2005) found that migrant hou- seholds had higher incomes in comparison with non-migrant households. Similarly, Ackah and Medvedev (2010) found that households with migrants compared with households without migrants tend to be better off. The benefit of rural- urban migration is not restricted to the households of the migrants as it has been reported that migrants, in comparison with non-migrants, have a higher standard of living (Litchfield & Waddington, 2003).
METHODOLOGY
The primary objective of this study was to examine if head portering busi- ness could be considered as a possible microbusiness targetted at dealing with unemployment. To achieve this purpose, forty head porters were recruited from Madina and Kaneshie to respond to a semi-structured questionnaire. The population under study represents a hard-to-reach population (due to the language barrier), as such there is usually difficulty in sampling from such a population using a probability technique (Gile & Handcock, 2010). There was no sampling frame because there is no empirical statistics on female head porters in Ghana (Lattof, 2018). Therefore, the purposive and snowballing sampling technique was used to recruit participants. The semi- structured interview which allowed all respondents to be asked same questions as well as given the opportunity to raise relevant issues was employed. Interviews using the guide lasted for at most 30 minutes due to language barriers. Also, focus groups were used. Ethical protocols of informed consent were sought before interviews began. Participants were assured of complete anonymity and confidentiality. Participants were compensated for their time, through the provision of lunch, and voluntarily participated. Data was manually analy- sed thematically because the sample size was manageable. After transcribing the recordings, themes and subthemes were inductively developed. In pre- senting the analysis which were peer reviewed, narratives and quotes from respondents were provided.
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS Rationale for Migrating to Engage in Head-Portering
One of the objectives of this study was to identify the reasons why migrants migrate to the urban centres. A critical analysis grouped the various rea- sons for migrating to the urban centres submitted by respondents into three: financial, employment and flexibility factors.
The Systemic Transitioning Strategy of Re-Orienting “Head-Portering” Task 237
Financial Challenges Mainly, participants reported that they migrated to join the head portering business in order to acquire enough money to cater for themselves as well as acquire needed items. An individual expressed her opinion as:
“It helps me buy anything I want. In my first week of work, I was told my child was unwell and I was able to gather some funds for his treatment” (Respondent 3).
The responses of other participants sided with this view. For instance, another expressed her opinion as follows: “I choose this job because it will help me get money to support my livelih- ood. It is because of hardship, mainly because of the money” (Respondent 8).
Employment Analysis suggested that others felt the unfair distribution of national resou- rces had led to lack of jobs in the rural areas, hence their reason for migrating to the urban areas. Alternatively, others felt that even in the urban centres, there are limited job opportunities that is why they chose to go into the head portering business. For instance, an interviewee submitted that:
“Well, there is no work in my hometown, so that’s why we chose to come down here to be head porters” (Respondent 12).
Another affirmed this assertion with the following response: “There is no other job for me to do, that’s why I chose this job.” (Respondent 2).
Flexibility There is no academic requirement for engaging in the head portering trade. Also, it is not capital intensive and demands no registration. All one requires to engage in this business is physical ability and a head pan, as highlighted in the following comments by a respondent.
“I carefully assessed other options available and settled for the head por- tering business because it was the only option that suited my capability” - (Respondent 1).
There is high demand for such services due to the nature of the design of markets in Ghana. The trade is not seasonal, as observed by a respondent in the following comment: “With this job, I work every day because people always come to shop, even on Sundays” (respondent 5).
Additionally, it was seen as a stepping-stone/springboard. For the majority (97%), it is being used for raising capital for petty trading and learning a trade. As was observed, all respondents had been in the trade for barely 6 months and had no intentions of holding on even in the nearest future.
Migrants’ Perception of Head- Portering as a Business Based on their motivations, it was essential to find migrants’ characterisation of the head-portering task. Two main recurring themes were echoed by the respondents, namely, economic empowerment and stability.
238 Osafroadu
Economic Empowerment Although it is reported that head portering business had some major chal- lenges, they equally indicated that it provided them with income to support themselves and their extended families, culminating in financial freedom. This level of financial independence alleviated their burdens. An interviewee had this to say:
“It has really helped us. We get money to cater for ourselves and are some- times able to send money home to our folks in our hometowns. We can make 100 cedis a day. Sometimes when business is very bad, we make 30, 40 or 20 cedis” (Respondent 2). Another reiterated that: “It has helped empower me to meet my daily economic needs. I will encourage them [others] to come and join this profession” (Respondent 3).
This request is not surprising because, on average, many of these head porters, even on a ‘bad day’, earn more than the average daily wage (12.53 cedis, 2021).
Stability For other respondents, the head portering business offers general stability. Thus, although the business was not their optimum choice, the stability it offered was enough. The demand for their services by patrons, due to the design of Ghanaian markets, provides security to them. Since the trade is not seasonal, the tendency of raising enough funds within the shortest time is high.
DISCUSSION
Human capital can be utilised in several pathways for the benefit of both the individual and the country at large. However, it appears some utilisation of human capital is frowned upon although it greatly impacts the wellbeing of the individual and can be critically assessed to drill out how it can be signi- ficantly improved so as to consequently advance the economy at large. It is against this background that this present study sought to explore the head portering business as a possible business avenue for the country at large. This study, thus, critically assessed why migrants engaged in the head portering business, what the business meant to them and the ways forward. It was revealed that the main reason for their migration to the urban centres inclu- ded financial challenges and unemployment in the rural areas and flexible requirements of the head portering trade. The business, despite its psychoso- cial challenges, provided the head porters with economic empowerment and stability.
Aliyev (2008), Beals et al. (1976), Caldwell (1968) and Enu (2014) captu- red a wide range of reasons why migrants migrate to the urban centres. These reasons included lack of social amenities, ethnic conflicts, poor economic conditions, financial challenges and unemployment in the rural areas. The two last reasons identified were affirmed in this study. This suggests that individuals in the rural areas have a poor socioeconomic status and by exten- sion, a rather stagnant socioeconomic development. This not only provides
The Systemic Transitioning Strategy of Re-Orienting “Head-Portering” Task 239
evidence for the unfair economic structure of the economy, but further high- lights the impact of this unbalanced economic structure on the welfare of the individuals. Since the wellbeing of people are enhanced through employ- ment (Clark, 2010), these migrants chose to migrate instead of remaining unemployed. From their recounts, their fortunes have improved, affirming the assertion of Tsegai (2005) and Ackah and Medvedev (2010).
To demean this form of business will be an error. This is because, although the head porters may lose significantly if their services are not patronised, patrons stand to lose significantly if these head porters quit. This further situates the growth theory that economic development centres on entrepre- neurship, knowledge, innovation and technology (Lucas, 1988). Arguably, these porters are entrepreneurs since they have identified a problem (poor design of market spaces) and offered a solution. Instead of they being depen- dent on others, they have chosen to make do with their human capital/labour and that is innovative enough to bring about a steady economic development since they have the provisioning motive for engaging in the trade (Rose, 2000). Understanding what this head portering business meant to the head por- ters will provide an understanding of how this job can be improved for the betterment of individuals and the economy. The head portering business did not just empower these individuals; it offered them some form of stability. This finding suggests that the finding of Awumbila et al. (2014) has relevant implication for today’s economy. This line of reasoning centres around the fact that, onlookers may consider the head portering business undesirable, but these head porters’ wellbeing improved significantly because they had jobs that empowered them economically and provided them with the type of stability and flexibility they needed. This mirrors the assertion by Knox et al., (2015) that workers’ characteristics subjectively affected their job qua- lity. These head porters seem happy with their jobs because of their features (women, relatively young, no/low qualifications, from poor socio-economic backgrounds, and mainly from the underdeveloped parts of Ghana).
CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATION Head porters provide citizens with valuable services that cannot be dismissed. The findings of this study imply that head portering business may be critically considered as a business in its own right. It is, therefore, concluded that the head portering task serves as a subjectively “good” job-engagement pathway for the less-educated youths and thus, serves as a business that helps alle- viate unemployment in Ghana. Thus, instead of considering collapsing the business, what these migrants need is better conditions of service. Therefore, aside from considering a vocational training centre for these head porters, there should equally be a legal framework to regulate their activities as well as protect them from those who exploit them. Since the trade is highly labour intensive, head porters should be encouraged to use trolleys instead of having the loads in pans on their heads. This way, they become ‘porters’ and not ‘head porters’ and the risks associated with the business can be minimised. Since the business is legal, a secretariat can be established to formalise their
240 Osafroadu
operations. They can also be encouraged to create a union in order to benefit from a strong voice.
A major limitation of this study was language and semantic barrier. Most of the participants were less educated, as such even posing the questions in the very simplistic form was challenging. As a qualitative study, generalisation is impossible.
REFERENCES
Ackah, G. C., & Medvedev, D. (2010). Internal migration in Ghana: Determinants and welfare impacts. International Journal of Social Economics, 1–23. Agarwal, S., Attah, M., Apt, N., Grieco, M., Kwakye, E.A., & Turner, J. (1997).
Bearing the weight: The kayayoo, Ghana’s working girl child. International Social Work, 40(3), 245–263. Alatinga, A. K. (2019). Internal migration, socio-economic status and remittances: Experiences of migrant adolescent girl head porters in Ghana. African Human Mobility Review, 5(3), 1717–1748. Aliyev, I. (2008). Rural-urban migration in Azerbaijan. Central European University. Awumbila, M. & Ardayfio-Schandorf, E. (2008). Gendered poverty, migration
and livelihood strategies of female porters in Accra, Ghana. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography, 62(3), 171–179. Awumbila, M., Owusu, G., & Teye, J. K. (2014). Can rural-urban migration into slums reduce poverty? Evidence from Ghana. Migrating Out of Poverty Working Paper, 13, 1–41. Asante, Y.(1995) “Migration-Development Interrelationships.”In K.A.Twum-Baah,
J. S. Nabila & A. F. Aryee. Migration Research Study in Ghana. Accra. Ghana Statistical Service. Beals, R. E., Levy, B. M., & Moses, N. L. (1967). Rationality and Migration in Ghana.
Review of Economics and Statistics. Caldwell, J. C. (1968). Determinants of Rural-Urban Migration in Ghana. Population Studies, A Journal of Demography. Clark, A. E. (2010). Work, jobs and well-being across the millennium. International
differences in well-being. Oxford University Press, 436-468. Cyril, S., Oldroyd, J.C., & Renzaho, A. (2013). Urbanisation, urbanicity, and health: A systematic review of the reliability and validity of urbanicity scales. BMC Public Health, 13(1), 513. Enu, P. (2014). The effects of rural urban migration in Ghana: Empirical evide-
nce from the Okaishie community Greater Accra Region. ResearchGate, 2(10), 416–428 Gile, K.J., & Handcock, M.S. (2010). Respondent-driven sampling: An assessment of current methodology.Sociological Methodology, 40(1), 285–327. Knox, A., Warhurst, C., Nickson, D., & Dutton, E. (2015). More than a fee-
ling: Using hotel room attendants to improve understanding of job quality. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 26(12), 1547–1567. Lattof, S.R. (2018). Health insurance and care-seeking behaviours of female migrants in Accra, Ghana. Health Policy and Planning, 33(4), 505–515. Litchfield, J., & H. Waddington. (2003). “Migration and Poverty in Ghana: Evidence
from the Ghana Living Standards Survey.” Sussex Migration Working Paper, 10. Liu, D. (2007). Growth theory and application: The case of South Africa. University of Pretoria.
The Systemic Transitioning Strategy of Re-Orienting “Head-Portering” Task 241
Lucas, R. E. Jr. (1988). On the mechanics of economic development. Journal of Monetary Economics, 22(1), 3–42. Machaia (2003). Migration in Kenya, an Impact on the Labour Market. American
University, United States of America. Opare, J.A. (2003). Kayayei: The women head porters of Southern Ghana. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 18(2), 33–48. Owusu, G., Agyei-Mensah, S. & Lund, R. (2008). Slums of hope and slums of
despair: Mobility and livelihoods in Nima, Accra.Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift, 62, 180–190. Rice, J. (2008). The urbanization of poverty and urban slum prevalence: The impact of the built environment on population-level patterns of social well-being in the less developed countries. Research in the Sociology of Health Care, 26, 205–234. Rose, M. (2000). Work attitudes in the expanding occupations. Changing Boundaries
in Employment, Bristol: Bristol Academic Press, ISBN 0, 9513762(7), 6. Tsegai, D. (2006). Migration and Household Income Differentials. 11th EADI General Conference on Insecurity and Development. Bonn. Tufeiru, A. (2014). The nexus of female capital and North–South labor migration in
Ghana: A potential remedy from microfinance. Journal of Developing Societies, 30(1), 91–114. Tutu, K. A. (1995). Determinants of Internal Migration. In K.A. Twum-Baah, J.
S. Nabila & A. F. Aryee. Migration Research Study in Ghana, Accra. Ghana Statistical Service. White, M.J. (Ed.). (2016). International handbook of migration and population distribution. Netherlands: Springer.