INTRODUCTION
The biomechanical overload disorders of the musculoskeletal system are constantly increasing in Italy and became the most reported occupational diseases to INAIL (Italian Workers’ Compensation Authority). The Tab. 1 summarizes the percentages of major diseases defined positively by INAIL in the period between 1994 and 2009, relating to their total (10,236 respectively in 1994 and 14,648 in 2009).
Table. 1 – Percentage of occupational diseases positively defined by INAIL – Source National Society of Prevention Operators (SNOP)
1994 2009 Musculoskeletal diseases 2 61 Hearing loss 58,3 19 Neoplasms (asbestos, wood dust, leather dust) 0,4 3,2 Silicosis 5 0,6 Asbestosis 1,8 2 Skin diseases 6,5 0,8 Diseases caused by vibrating tools 2,9 0,6
The Tables. 2 and 3, taken from MalProf data (national system for recording and analysis of reported occupational diseases reached the observation of Local Health Authorities, which allow the analysis of up to 2010), show the distribution of musculoskeletal diseases by economic activity (ATECO code 91) and by job. Clearly shows that most of these technopathies hit in descending order construction equipment (11% of MalProf reports), healthcare (6%), engineering and industries of food and drinks (each with 5%) and agriculture (3%). The analysis for tasks raises once again highlight the construction workers (14% of reports), workers specialized food processing, wood, textiles (12%) and metal workers (9%). Agriculture reaches only 3% of the reports. The limited number of occupational diseases in agriculture that reach the observation of Local Health Authority (much lower than you might expect, even in view of the significant increase in complaints registered on the contrary INAIL) could be explained by the prevalence of self-employed workers in this sector (farmers) and their lack of attention to the preventive aspects with limited guidance on risk assessment and health surveillance.
Table. 2 – Distribution of musculoskeletal diseases by ATECO class - Data MalProf 2000 - 2010 Total Diseases of the rachis MSK diseases (excluding rachis and Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (STC)
STC)
Economic Activity (ATECO91) Valore % Valore % Valore % Valore % Undefined 2543 36 2016 26 1578 30 6137 31
Construction 1009 14 855 11 275 5 2139 11
215 3 398 5 300 6 913 5
Manufacture of fabricated metal products, except machinery and equipment
156 2 453 6 345 7 954 5
Manufacture of food products and beverages
Manufacture of machinery and equipment, including installation, assembly, repair and maintenance Health and other social services 776 11 325 4 104 2 1205 6
Agriculture, hunting and related services
Manufacture of other transport equipment Production of metals and their alloys 72 1 77 1 72 1 221 1 Other ATECO activities 1729 25 2740 36 2055 39 6524 33
Total 7024 100 7631 100 5224 100 19879 10 0
For this reason, going back to what emerged from INAIL Report on occupational diseases published in July 2010, the Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry of the Republic Senate about the phenomenon of industrial accidents with a special reference to the so-called "white deaths", in its Second Middle Report on the activity already carried out, during the meeting held on November 23rd 2010, verbatim states “Diseases of the musculoskeletal system (tendini- tis, diseases of the intervertebral discs, carpal tunnel syndrome, etc.) exponentially grew due to biomechanical over- load with nearly 18,000 reported cases - +36 per cent compared to 2008 and twice as many compared to 2005 when they were little less than 9,000, proved to be the most frequent form of technopathy. According to INAIL, this sud- den rise, rather than the worsening of healthiness conditions in the workplaces, is due to several factors which have been contributing for years to the emergence of what experts call "hidden or lost diseases (i.e., unreported)”.
Table. 3 – Distribution of musculoskeletal diseases by job - Data MalProf 2000 - 2010
Diseases of the
Carpal Tunnel Total
rachis
MSK diseases (excluding rachis Syndrome and STC) (STC)
Economic activity (ATECO91) Valore % Valore % Valore % Valore % Undefined 1637 23 1402 18 1376 26 4415 22
Semi-skilled workers of stationary machines for working in series and workers involved in the mounting Conductors of vehicles, mobile machinery and lifting 696 10 135 2 50 1 881 4
Conductors of industrial plants 110 2 132 2 86 2 328 2
Skilled occupations in the social, cultural, security, cleaning and similar
Total 7024 100 7631 100 5224 100 19879 10 0
Some sectors, such as agriculture, health and crafts, generally show a particular rise of these diseases while other sectors (such as fishing) are still struggling to bring out the work-related diseases.
The Apulia Region included in the Regional Plan for Prevention 2010 - 2012 initiatives in order to secure a better understanding of the tools both for the assessment of risk due to the biomechanical overload of the musculoskeletal system and for the prevention of the diseases related to them.
THE PROJECT The Local Health Authority of Bari developed considerable long expertise in these issues thanks to the partnership with the EPM Research Unit Foundation Don Gnocchi - Milan (which is one of the main international point of reference in ergonomics and developed some of the international standards concerning the ergonomic risk assessment). In accordance with the Resolution no. 973 dated May 2011 of the General Manager of Local Health Authority of Bari, an agreement was approved for activities in cooperation with the Research Unit EPM Foundation Don Gnocchi Onlus of Milan and the University of Milan, so the South Section of the EPM International Ergonomics School started. This South Section, in line with the same quality parameters of the same kind of Schools already opened in Milan, Pisa and in several foreign countries (Spain, France, Brazil and Argentina) started its activity by offering some training.
Between 2012 and 2013 two training courses on the topics of Biomechanical overload of the musculoskeletal system were carried out particularly addressed to SPESAL (Services of Prevention and Safety in the Workplace) Health Workers of Apulia (physicians and technicians who work for prevention), as well as an edition of a similar course addressed to qualified physicians and business consultants. No. 19 physicians and N. 40 prevention technicians belonging to the Local Health Authorities of Apulia were trained, together with no. 27 qualified physicians and no. 8 business consultants working as professionals.
The production of ergonomic insights on agricultural processes, typical of the territories of each Local Health Authority, is one of the requirements aimed to obtain final certificates of participation in these courses. This approach allowed us to collect items of interest in order to better know the ergonomic risk in Apulian agriculture and to define the future prevention policies. At the end of these courses, an International Conference was held in Giovinazzo (Ba). On this occasion, the first results concerning the ergonomic analysis of many agricultural crops, were presented. These pre assessments are available on the Internet site of Apulia Region (http://www.sanita.puglia.it/portal/page/portal/SAUSSC/Prevenzione/Ergonomia%20e%20lavoro) with attachments concerning reference movies which led to these assessments. The goal is to make available these pre-assessments for workers of the agricultural sector (employers and consultants) using a software (under construction by EPM) which allows to weight the different tasks carried out in an annual cycle. The final figures will be a synthetic index of the exposure at risk as an annual average.
The Technical Committee of the Regions concerning safety at work places, aims to enhance expertise developed in Apulia extending it to the different working sectors. For this reason, in the next National Prevention Plan, a specific line of activities dedicated to the prevention of musculoskeletal disorders due to biomechanical overload, will be expected. This work will be included in the National Plan for Prevention of Occupational Diseases to come, which will be developed in the different Italian regions.
THE RESULTS At the moment we have studied the following crops: vegetables (fennel, tomatoes, cherry tomatoes in the greenhouse, cucumber, cauliflower, carrots, artichokes, potatoes, broccoli both from the point of view of cultivation than the packaging), fruit (grapes both from the point of view of cultivation than the packaging, cherries, peaches, watermelon, clementines, cantaloupes), olive, corn and crops in the nursery of flowers and plants. We proceeded to the following stages for each studied cultivation:
- preliminary investigation by the method of preliminary mapping (which helped to identify the processes at increased risk for which necessitated a more thorough risk assessment) – Figure. 1
Figure. 1 – Preliminary mapping example in employee of chainsaw in cultivation of olives
- Study of the various processing stages, of the workforce employed in the different periods of the year and of the quantities of products used for the cultivation of crops and final – Pict. 2
- Analysis of the annual cycle of collection with the study of various intrinsic indices (Pict.. 3) of each task using the methods of the OCRA checklist and Niosh
Figure 2 – Example of organizational data in a company producing table grapes
Figure. 3 – Example of intrinsic indices in a company producing table grapes
- Development of the synthetic index of annual risk for repetitive movements of the upper limbs and manual handling of loads (Figure. 4)
- Collection of any examples of ergonomic solutions freely identified from various growers in order to reduce the ergonomic load of the various operations
The intrinsic indices identified in the course of this project will be used to build (using a dedicated software) occupational exposure of each culture and define the specific synthetic index risk for the different farms. In other words, farms in which there are multiple crops throughout the year (for example, various types of vegetables and/or fruit) in respect of the various seasons and organization, will be able to calculate the annual synthetic risk of biomechanics overload of the musculoskeletal system using the different intrinsic indices previously calculated for the different work tasks.
Figure. 4 – Example of a synthetic annual index in a company producing flowers in greenhouses 8-6-12 copyright DANIELA COLOMBINI
CONCLUSIONS
The Puglia Region project has allowed to start studying the risk of biomechanical overload of the musculoskeletal system in some of the agricultural processing more frequent in the area. It was possible to begin to experience the method of study of the OCRA checklist in an annual perspective, taking into account the peculiar variability of work tasks in this production sector. The farm operator in the space of a year is called to perform multiple tasks in different types of crops. The annual risk index must necessarily take into account the extreme variability of the indices of risk inherent in each task and exposure (in terms of time) to these occupational hazards. The weighted average, calculated as a function of exposure time in a year, of all these indices will provide us with the average exposure of individual workers to the risk of biomechanical overload of the musculoskeletal system. To facilitate the calculation and use of these intrinsic indices, is being developed a special software with which you can calculate the synthetic index simply by copying the intrinsic indices previously evaluated for each task actually performed in the individual farm. To do this, you will need to increase the number of tasks studied and the intrinsic indices previously evaluated.
REFERENCES
Colombini D, Occhipinti E (1996), “La movimentazione manuale di carichi”, in Dossier Ambiente, No 33. pp 81-87 Colombini D, Occhipinti E , Grieco A (2002), “Risk assessment and management of repetitive movements and exertions of upper limbs”, in Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Colombini D, Occhipinti E, Fanti M (2005), “Il metodo OCRA per l'analisi e la prevenzione del rischio da movimenti ripetuti”,
in Milano: Collana Salute e lavoro, Franco Angeli Editore Colombini D., Di Leone G., Occhipinti E., Montomoli L., Ruschioni A., Giambartolomei M., Ardissone S., Fanti M., Pressiani S., Placci M., Cerbai M., Preite S. (2009), “Working hypothesis of simplified techniques for the first mapping of occupational hazards in handicraft. First part: ergonomics hazards”, in G Ital Med Lav Erg, no 31:3. pp 292-296 Colombini D., Occhipinti E., Di Leone G. (2011), “A preliminary mapping methodology for occupational hazards and
biomechanical risk evaluation: presentation of a simple, computerized tool kit for ergonomic hazards identification and risck assessment”, in MedLav no 102,1. pp 6-28 Colombini D., Occhipinti E., Di Leone G. (2012), “A simple tool for preliminary hazard identification and quick assessment in craftwork and small/medium enterprises (SME)” in Work no41 Suppl 1. Pp 3948-55 Di Leone G., Nicoletti S., Monopoli L., Montomoli L., Colombini D. (2011), “Use of premapping of risks data sheet in artistic ceramics industries” in MedLav no 102,1. pp 43-53 Occhipinti E , Colombini D (2004), “The Occupational Repetitive Action (OCRA) Methods: OCRA Index and OCRA Checklist”,
in Stanton N, et al (eds): Handbook of human factors and ergonomics methods. Boca Raton: CRC Press, chapter 15. pp 1- 14 Occhipinti E, Colombini D (2004), “Metodo Ocra: aggiorna-mento dei valori di riferimento e dei modelli di previsio-ne dell'occorrenza di patologie muscolo-scheletriche correlate al lavoro degli arti superiori (UL-WMSDs) in popolazioni lavorative esposte a movimenti e sforzi ripetuti degli arti superiori”, in Med Lav no 95. pp 305-319 Occhipinti E, Colombini D (2006), “Repetitive actions and movements of the upper limbs. In Karwowski W (ed): Handbook of
Standards and Guidelines” in Ergonomics and Human Factors, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. pp 243-254 Water T, Lu Ml, Occhipinti E (2007), “New procedure for assessing sequential manual lifting jobs using the NIOSH Lifting Equation” in Ergonomics no. 50. p 1761 Waters Tr, Putz-Anderson V, Garg A (1994), “Applications Manual for the Revised NIOSH Lifting Equation” in DHHS
(NIOSH) Publication No. 94-110. Cincinnati, Ohio: National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. p 45226