Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Multi-expert Cooperative Development of Painting-themed Tourist Souvenirs Based on ICCO Model

1 Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts, Guangzhou 510261, China ↗
2 Zhongkai University of Agriculture and Engineering, Guangzhou 510220, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1004241

Abstract

The museum's painting collection has gradually become a vital reference resource for developing souvenirs. This study adopts ICCO theoretical framework and studies 534 kinds of souvenirs from the official Taobao flagship store of the Forbidden City according to the ideas of import, classi-fication, comparison, and export. Adopt = Houyi collector to collect data, EXCEL to sort out data, and organize several experts to analyze painting types, techniques, and crafts. As a result, tourists' favorite painting is "A Thousand Miles of Mountains and Rivers," and their favorite souvenirs are delicate flower-and-bird paintings and souvenirs of multi-expert cooperation are the main ones. Best-selling goods can be divided into auspicious meanings, festivals, and life scenes. Most products with large total sales volume are priced below 300 yuan. The products most accepted by consumers are souvenirs (50 yuan), bags (100 yuan), cups (200 yuan), silk scarves (250 yuan), and lamps (300 yuan). To sum up, the collaborative design method of many experts can provide more possibilities for the design of tourist souvenirs with flower-and-bird painting as the theme, and more different souvenirs can be developed according to the styles and preferences of different users.

INTRODUCTION

Tourist souvenirs, characterized by specific scenery and craft elements of tourist destinations, hold special memories for travelers. Flower-and-bird painting, a traditional Chinese art form, has been widely used in crafting souvenirs since ancient times. However, changing lifestyles and preferences have influenced souvenir choices. In response, the General Office of the State Council of China collaborated with various departments to promote cultural and creative product development in 2016 and reiterated this commitment in 2021. The Palace Museum and Guangdong Provincial Museum collabo- rated with creative teams to enhance flower and bird painting souvenirs. Yet, reinventing flower and bird paintings poses challenges, requiring expertise in multiple disciplines.

The Forbidden City Taobao flagship store, known for its rich variety and sales volume, is experienced in developing Chinese painting-themed

© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 244

Multi-Expert Cooperative Development of Painting-Themed Tourist Souvenirs 245

souvenirs. This study analyzes their pricing, sales, painting styles, and produc- tion methods to uncover strategies for painting-themed product development.

OBJECTIVES This study aims to:

  • Identify characteristics of tourists’ favorite paintings.
  • Examine the relationship between best-selling items, pricing, and sales volume.
  • Investigate the correlation between specific painting-themed souvenirs, their types, and pricing.
  • Explore the impact of multi-expert cooperation on the pricing of painting- themed souvenirs.

LITERATURE REVIEW

Research on the Design of Tourist Souvenirs Jointly Designed by Many Experts Different Subjects Dominate the Design When multiple experts collaborate, the leading expert’s identity significantly affects the innovation of tourist souvenirs. An artist-led design tends to emphasize artistic elements, while a designer-led approach innovates tra- ditional art into contemporary styles. Discussions between artisans and designers also contribute to product innovation, with artisans’ individu- ality influencing souvenir craftsmanship. Additionally, visitor experiences and tourist participation in the development process foster innovation and enhance the emotional connection to souvenirs.

Multi-Professional Experts Jointly Conduct Brainstorming The brainstorming method, initially proposed by Osborn, has been proven effective in design problem-solving by numerous researchers. Guided by experienced moderators, collaborative brainstorming enables the generation of more ideas in a shorter time, enhancing creative output. Recent stud- ies exploring network and electronic brainstorming methods offer valuable insights for multi-expert creative cooperation.

Prototype Using Multiple Techniques Chinese paintings encompass various styles, such as figure paintings, land- scape paintings, and flower and bird paintings, which offer diverse artistic expression. Combining craftsmanship and painting techniques can enrich the presentation of these works.

Festival Painting Tourist Souvenirs Festival-themed tourist souvenirs, inspired by significant traditional Chinese festivals, garner widespread interest among cultural tourists. Notably, the Spring Festival attracts high demand for related souvenirs, providing oppor- tunities for creating unique and regionally distinctive products. Personalized

246 Ou-Yang and Ling

New Year products jointly developed by artists hold particular appeal for younger audiences, warranting attention to tourists’ preferences and needs in this context.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Research Case

The Palace Museum has pioneered the development of Chinese painting col- lections into tourist souvenirs, with years of experience. The popularity of the Forbidden City as a tourist destination remains strong, thanks to various factors such as documentaries, reality shows, and the integration of Forbid- den City Cat IP into souvenirs. Taobao, a major online shopping platform in China, hosts the Palace Museum Cultural and Creative Flagship Store, offer- ing a diverse range of souvenirs at different price points. The sales quantity of these products is typically approximated in rounded figures, occasionally leading to minor data errors.

Figure 1: ICCo theoretical framework. (Constructed by the author, 2023.)
Original PDF Figure 1:

Data Collection Techniques This research focuses on souvenirs jointly developed by multi-experts in painting, including artisans, graphic designers, and product designers. Data from painting-related souvenirs in the Forbidden City Cultural and Creative Flagship Store on Taobao Mall were collected using crawler software. The data was then sorted, classified, and statistically analyzed using Excel soft- ware. Four stages of experimentation were conducted (see Figure 1).: input stage (selecting representative paintings and comparing souvenir sales based on themes), classification stage (comparing sales volume of products with dif- ferent painting themes but of the same type), comparison stage (evaluating the popularity of products designed by different experts), and output stage (deducing characteristics of tourists’ favorite paintings, best-selling item types and pricing strategies, best-selling categories, design directions, and trends in painting-themed souvenirs).

Multi-Expert Cooperative Development of Painting-Themed Tourist Souvenirs 247

Data Analysis Descriptive statistical analysis was primarily used in this study to measure the sum and percentage of sample data and compare relationships between samples.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Import The Palace Museum Cultural and Creative Flagship Store offers 534 products for classification, generating sales revenue of around 220,543,095 yuan. Data on painting-themed souvenirs is limited, necessitating manual supplemen- tation from various perspectives. The research will focus on classification, comparison, and output based on the available data.

Classification Experts categorized the store’s souvenirs into four groups: handicrafts, paint- ing reproductions, fabric/utensil-themed souvenirs, and painting-themed sou- venirs. Among the 534 items, 173 creative souvenirs based on paintings were analyzed, generating about 96,963,054 yuan in sales revenue, accounting for 44% of total sales. Notably, 37 painting reproductions without cre- ative transformations contributed 21.6% of painting souvenirs’ total income. The following section provides a comparative analysis of the remaining 173 creative painting-themed souvenirs.

Comparison Sales Volume of Painting-Themed Souvenirs Data on souvenirs based on the same Chinese painting was analyzed to iden- tify factors influencing users’ purchases of creative and best-selling items. Factors compared include the number of uniquely developed products, price ranges, purchase volumes, main development categories, and total sales revenue.

The products were divided into four price ranges: below 100 yuan, 101– 299 yuan, 300–499 yuan, and 500–699 yuan. Among 23 paintings, a total of 48 product types were developed. “A Thousand Miles of Rivers and Moun- tains,” “Du Fu’s Poetry Intentions,” and “Ice Playing Pictures” were the top three in total revenue. “A Thousand Miles of Rivers and Mountains” had the most variants, followed by “Industrial Double Rabbit Picture” and “Peony Picture” in the Song Dynasty. Certain individual products, such as “Flowers and Birds,” “The Qing Dynasty Painted Women Gods,” “Fish and Butterfly,” “Embroidered Orchid Hall Wealthy Picture Tongjing Screen,” and “Pictured Emerald Phoenix Pattern Head Flower,” outperformed “Tang Yin Shi Ming Tu” and “Du Fu’s Poetry Intentions” in sales volume.

The best-selling theme was “A Thousand Miles of Rivers and Mountains,” with diverse product categories, high total income, and various price points. Another popular theme was “Du Fu’s Poetry Intentions,” with bookmark products priced below 100 yuan and over 60,000 pieces sold.

248 Ou-Yang and Ling

Painting themes were clustered based on similar total sales into four ranges: 8 million to 6.01 million, 6 million to 3.01 million, 3 million to 1.01 million, and below 1 million. Among these, flower and bird paintings dom- inated, symbolizing special meanings in Chinese culture, with some flowers representing festival symbols.

Best-Selling Items of Painting-Themed Souvenirs The top-selling painting-themed souvenirs were identified based on the high- est selling price for each single product. The products were classified into four price ranges: below 100 yuan, 100–299 yuan, 300–499 yuan, and 500–699 yuan. Main categories included stationery, daily utilitarian items, travel supplies, and clothing accessories. Low-value items like stationery, coasters, badges, night lights, and pillowcases exhibited high sales volumes, with some reaching over 60,000 in sales, such as bookmarks featuring Du Fu’s Poems and Intentions (see Table 1).

Table 1. Best-selling items of painting-themed souvenirs (data from the official flagship store of the Forbidden City.2022).

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Title Souvenir type Price Sales

Cutlery Set 399 3000+

Fish and butterfly illustration Winder 18 1000+ A thousand miles of rivers and mountains Insulation pads 24 40000+ Meme sticky note 29 10000+ Peony illustration coaster 39 10000+ Zhu Zhanji’s music tour glasses case 39 6000+ Point emerald phoenix pattern head flower Luggage tag 46 10000+ Even God Sticky note brick 49 20000+ Du Fu’s Poems Bookmark 68 60000+ Ice play _ Bookmark 72 20000+ Bird and flower Pillowcase 99 9000+ Kesi Plum Magpie Chart Scroll Night light 119 6000+ Twenty-four kinds of peonies Pillow 139 1000 Picture of the sea in the Qing Dynasty Travel pillow 156 10000+ Flower Atlas Desk mat 162 7000+ Indus double rabbit Zodiac badges 199 10000+ 100,000 albums Folding fan 199 1000+ Animal Spectrum Deer Coin Purse 248 1000+ Tang Yin’s tea ceremony Paper Carved Lamp 286 6032 Danfeng and deer Mug to mug 299 1000+ Qingming Riverside Map Paper Carved Lamp 299 10000+ Embroidered thread orchid hall wealth map through the scene screen Tableware 459 900+ Green-painted gold pine, bamboo, and plum pattern powder wax paper

Yurman Qing Tour Map Silk scarf 598 1000

Best-Selling Painting-Themed Souvenirs in a Single Product Painting-themed souvenirs were classified into categories such as cups, bags, lamps, cushions, fans, scarves, aromatherapy, umbrellas, keychains, badges, bookmarks, etc. Some themes like “Ice Playing Picture,” “A Thousand Miles of Rivers and Mountains,” “Across the River during Qingming Festival,” and “Flowers and Birds”had multiple best-selling items. The royal fan and zodiac

Multi-Expert Cooperative Development of Painting-Themed Tourist Souvenirs 249

badge also had multiple themes, with the royal fan being individually pur- chased and the zodiac badge sold as sets. Among the top-selling products, bookmarks, canvas bags, and coasters stood out due to promotional activities and consumer acceptance of products priced around 50 yuan.

Cooperation Mode of Experts in Painting - Themed Souvenirs of the Same Product Type Analyzing the varieties of cups developed, their sales volumes, and expert cooperation methods, it was observed that certain design techniques influ- enced product sales. The top-selling cups were “Ice Playing” (10,000+ pieces), “Good Omen of the Year” by Zhu Jianshen (5,000+ pieces), and “A Thousand Miles of Rivers and Mountains” by Wang Ximeng (3,000+ pieces). Innovative coffee cups, with modern design elements, showed high consumer acceptance, while traditional shapes also performed well.

Lower-priced products had a wider customer base, while high-priced items with handicraft value were also recognized by consumers, although total sales revenue may vary significantly. Consumer preferences for color also played a role, with green-toned products being popular. Red-themed souvenirs were favored for weddings and New Year’s festivals, while traditional white prod- ucts were preferred for birthdays and gifts to elders. Moreover, sharing-type tea sets were more popular than personal use cups for the “Song Dynasty Peony Picture” creative souvenirs.

Output Characteristics of Tourists’ Favorite Paintings Painting Style Characteristics and Price Range Among the analyzed paintings, most (20 paintings) exhibit a neat and col- orful meticulous style, while one is a freehand painting predominantly in black. The popularity and total income of a painting are closely related, with well-known works like “A Thousand Miles of Rivers and Mountains” and “Across the River during Qingming Festival” having significant promotion. Traditional folk images like Bingxitu and door gods also contribute to sou- venir sales. Bird-and-flower images are relatively less known, and works in the third and fourth intervals are less familiar to the public.

Types of Best-Selling Items and Pricing Strategies The painting themes are divided into three categories: auspicious implica- tions, festivals, and life scenes. Different paintings can belong to multiple classifications, such as auspicious meaning and New Year themes. Among the categories, auspicious meaning themes include flower sets, peonies, plum blossoms, animals, and exotic animals, while festival themes comprise New Year and Mid-Autumn Festival, and life scene themes include court life and civilian life.

BEST-SELLING CATEGORY TYPE AND DESIGN DIRECTION Analyzing the pricing and sales of best-selling items in 12 categories, products priced around 50 yuan have total sales revenue below 6 million. Items priced

250 Ou-Yang and Ling

Table 2. Cooperation mode of experts in painting - themed souvenirs of the same product type. (Data from the official flagship store of the Forbidden City.2022.) (Constructed by the author, 2023.)

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Cooperation method

Title Rank Price / Sales Expert cooperation Ice play 1 178/ 10000+ Graphic designer lead

2 528/ 5000+ Craftsman-led Craftsman: Ceramics, Glazing

Graphic designer: Extract characters and fish elements to design shapes and colors, and add yellow and green stripes. Craftsmen: ceramics, stickers, gold-painting 22 298/ 25 Craftsman-led Craftsmen: ceramic craftsmanship, hand painting A good omen of the year 3 498/ 3000+ Craftsman-led Craftsmen: ceramic craftsmanship, hand painting 5 1180/ 3000+ Craftsman-led Craftsman: Ceramics, Glazing A thousand miles of rivers and mountains

v12 258/ 700+ Product designer-led

Product Designer: Design a new look with mountains and colors as elements Craftsmen: hand spray gradient glaze 14 418/ 500 + Graphic designer lead

Graphic designer: Extract the elements of cranes and mountains to design shapes and colors. Craftsmen: ceramic craftsmanship, hand-painted gold, low-temperature decals 15 188/ 500 + Craftsman-led Graphic designer: extracting mountain elements to design modeling. Craftsmen: hand-blown, 580

  • C decals, gold tracing 17 298/ 200+ Craftsman-led Graphic designer: extracting mountain elements to design modeling. Craftsmen: hand-blown, 580
  • C decals, gold tracing 18 328/ 200+ Product designer-led

Product Designer: Design a new look with mountains and colors as elements Craftsmen: hand spray gradient glaze Kesi Sui Chao Tu

4 126/ 3000+ Graphic designer lead

Graphic Designer: Extract Floral Shape Design Patterns Craftsmen: ceramic work, decals, gilding 7 398/ 2000+ Craftsman-led Craftsmen: ceramic work, decals, gilding 13 339/ 600+ Graphic designer lead

Graphic Designer: Extract Floral Shape Design Patterns Craftsmen: ceramic craftsmanship, hand-painted gold Peony illustration

Graphic Designer: Extract Floral Shape Design Patterns

6 199/ 3000 + Graphic Designer + Prod- uct Designer + Craft Product Designer: Design Styling Craftsmen: hand-blown, high-temperature roasted flowers 8 79/ 2000 + Graphic designer lead

Graphic Designer: Extract Floral Shape Design Patterns

Graphic designer: extract flower shape design pattern artisan: ceramic crafts, decals, gold tracing 23 139/ 5 Graphic Designer Product Designer Craft Craftsman: Manual blow molding, manual drilling of the cup handle, high-temperature roasting

Multi-Expert Cooperative Development of Painting-Themed Tourist Souvenirs 251

at 100–200 yuan also have high consumer acceptance. The cup set priced at 178 yuan achieved the highest total revenue, followed by silk scarves priced at 238 yuan and lamps priced at 299 yuan. Designers can consider these price points when designing different categories of souvenirs.

Design Direction of Painting-Themed Souvenirs Based on the analysis, four expert cooperation strategies for painting-themed cup products are identified (see Table 3).

Firstly, souvenirs dominated by craftsmanship, featuring meaningful and traditional red tea sets priced in the range of 500–600 yuan, are well-received by consumers and are particularly suitable for gifting to elders, weddings, or during the New Year.

Secondly, souvenirs led by graphic designers, offering coffee cups with vibrant patterns and colors at a price below 200 yuan, are favored by con- sumers, making them ideal as birthday gifts for friends or for personal use, especially among young individuals.

Thirdly, a combination of graphic designers, product designers, and craft collaboration leads to tea sets or coffee cups priced between 100–200 yuan, well-received by consumers, particularly suitable for personal use, and appealing to young individuals with a taste for refined living.

Lastly, souvenirs led by product designers, offering tea sets priced between 250–350 yuan, are well-accepted by consumers, especially those with dis- cerning preferences for quality living, making them suitable for personal use and catering to young individuals who frequently travel for work.

Table 3. The way of cooperation of experts on the subject of painting. (Constructed by the author, 2023.)

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Expert cooperation Cooperation method

Graphic Designer: Extract elements from paintings to design. Tools used: AI, PS.

Graphic designer lead Graphic Designer: Extract elements from paintings to design. Tools used: AI, PS. Craftsman ceramic craftsmanship, low-temperature decal paper, gold tracing craftsmanship Graphic Designer + Product Designer + Craftsman Product Designer: Design Styling Craftsman: hand-blown, high-temperature roasted flowers Craftsman-led Craftsmen: ceramics, hand painting, glazing, 580

  • C processing decals, gold tracing Product designer-led Product Designer: Design a new look and colors as elements Craftsman: hand spray gradient glaze

252 Ou-Yang and Ling

CONCLUSION

This study examined the potential of multi-expert cooperation in developing tourist souvenirs using data from the Palace Museum’s online store. Valuable insights were gained, with meticulous paintings, especially those with floral themes, proving popular among Forbidden City painting-themed souvenirs. Widely recognized paintings significantly contributed to souvenir sales. Sou- venirs priced around 100 yuan, particularly those around 50 yuan, such as stationery, coasters, badges, and night lights, performed well. Designs led by different experts were crucial in meeting the preferences of diverse consumers.

Using data from Taobao’s online store enabled efficient analysis of user acceptance and price preferences. However, data authenticity and emotional aspects of expert evaluations require further scrutiny. Improving user eval- uations and understanding the reasons behind the best-selling categories of painting-themed souvenirs will refine design directions.

Future research could explore Chinese flower-themed paintings as sou- venirs, tapping into their broad appeal and economic potential. Embracing multi-expert collaboration offers exciting opportunities to create diverse souvenirs catering to various user preferences.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support provided by the Academic Promotion Program of Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts for the research on “Innovative Design of Traditional Festival Products in the Greater Bay Area”(Project Number: 20XSB07). The support from the Teach- ing Team of Art Education and Cultural Innovation Design at Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts (Project Number: 6040319091) and the Guangdong Provincial Department of Education for the project “Green Gift Packag- ing Design Based on Lingnan Festival Culture in 2022” (Project Number: 22ZX027) has been instrumental in this study.

REFERENCES

Aldalalah O. M. A. A. (2022) ‘Employment the Word Cloud in Brainstorming via the Web and Its Effectiveness in Developing the Design Thinking Skill’, International Journal of Instruction, 15(1), pp. 1045–1064. Bonnardel N. and Didier J. (2020) ‘Brainstorming variants to favor creative design’,

Applied Ergonomics, 83, p. 102987. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aper go.2019.102987. Cultural and Creative Flagship Store of the Palace Museum (no date). Available at: https://palacemuseum.tmall.com/ (Accessed: 16 October 2022). Department of Policies and Regulations - Wenlvzhengfafa [2021] No. 40 (2021)

Notice of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism on Printing and Distributing the “14th Five-Year Plan for Culture and Tourism Development”. Available at: https:// zwgk.mct.gov.cn/zfxxgkml/ghjh/202106/t20210602_924956.html (Accessed: 15 February 2022). Hsieh, M.-H. and Guan, S.-S. (no date) ‘INVESTIGATING ARTISTIC COMMOD- ITY DESIGN THROUGH THE SHIFT BETWEEN ART AND DESIGN’, p. 10.

Multi-Expert Cooperative Development of Painting-Themed Tourist Souvenirs 253

Littrell, M. A., Anderson, L. F. and Brown, P. J. (1993) ‘What makes a craft souvenir authentic?’, Annals of Tourism Research, 20(1), pp. 197–215. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/0160-7383(93)90118-M. Maaravi Y. et al. (2021) ‘Ideation in the digital age: literature review and integra-

tive model for electronic brainstorming’, Review of Managerial Science, 15(6), pp. 1431–1464. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11846-020-00400-5. Osborn, A. F. (1953) ‘Applied imagination.’ Oxley, N. L., Dzindolet, M. T. and Paulus, P. B. (no date) ‘The Effects of Facilitators on the Performance of Brainstorming Groups’, JOURNAL OF SOCIAL BEHAVIOR AND PERSONALITY, p. 16. Prihutomo, A. and Paramita, R. D. (2020) ‘Collaborative Fashion Project with

the Artisan; Changing Tradition into Contemporary Design’, SSRN Electronic Journal [Preprint]. Available at: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3807676. Putman V. L. and Paulus P. B. (2009) ‘Brainstorming, Brainstorming Rules and Decision Making’, The Journal of Creative Behavior, 43(1), pp. 29–40. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2162-6057.2009.tb01304.x. Rodgers, P. A. et al. (2022) ‘The Intergenerational Co-Design of Glasgow COP26

Souvenirs’, Proceedings of the Design Society, 2, pp. 2223–2232. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1017/pds.2022.225. Rossiter, J. R. and Lilien, G. L. (1994) ‘New “Brainstorming” Principles’, Australian Journal of Management, 19(1), pp. 61–72. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/ 031289629401900104. Zulaikha, E. and Brereton, M. (2011) ‘Collaborative design learning for traditional

crafts industry’, Sustainable Design in Creative Industry Towards Better Human Life: Proceeding, pp. 1–6. Zulaikha, E. et al. (2012) ‘Participatory innovation to develop traditional Indonesian craft industries’, Proceedings of the Participatory Innovation Conference 2012, p. 6.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human-Centered Design and User Experience

Explore the complete digital volume

Human-Centered Design and User Experience

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-90-2

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →