Minoru Kobayashi (2024). The Importance and Necessity of Early-stage Financial Support for Startup and Venture Companies in Japan. In: Human Factors, Business Management and Society. AHFE Open Access, vol. 135, pp. 104–110. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1004935
For startups and venture companies, I conducted research not only on the period before starting a business but also on the early stages of the business from the immediate aftermath of starting. In this study I examined financial support during this period, considering financial assistance from the preparation stage to the early stages of the business in its entirety. The year before last, the government of Japan announced the "Grand Design and Implementation Plan for New Capitalism - Realization of Investment in People, Technology, and Startups." It formulated a "5-years Startup Development Plan" and strengthened its startup support policies, especially those aimed at promoting entrepreneurship, declaring 2022 as the "Year of Startup Creation." Currently, there is an increase in support policies for entrepreneurship, and their content is becoming more advanced. However, it is still said that there are few startups and venture companies that continue to the business stability period.In this context, I conducted the questionnaire survey targeting companies in business incubation facilities nationwide. I have also added questions to evaluate the deliberations on the introduction of the new collateral system, business growth collateral rights. The business incubation facilities targeted 17 (16 prefectures) of the national facilities established as public industrial creation support facilities in Japan. All facilities are currently operated by public interest incorporated foundations of local governments. The questionnaire survey consisted of 22 questions and was conducted by using mail methods. Surprisingly, the results show that funding and fundraising in the early stages of business after starting a business are difficult. Many companies are experiencing a serious lack of operating funds and research and development funds. Specifically, fundraising is an important management issue regardless of industry, and that the evaluation of the past support policies is low regardless of company size, indicating a need for improvement in the future.Although the survey period and target were different from previous studies, the results were found to be similar or more severe. It is also significant that the surveyed companies were in an environment where they could receive sufficient advice from various consultation services and incubators from the startup preparation stage. It also became clear that there is a strong desire for the introduction of thed newly planned business growth collateral rights regardless of industry. It was confirmed that fundraising is an important management issue regardless of industry, company size, or founding background. Financial support in the early stages of business is very important for companies in business incubation facilities. It is necessary to improve the situation of insufficient operating funds and research and development funds. The establishment of business growth collateral rights is seen as a policy that is expected to be implemented. It is necessary for companies, incubation facilities, and financial institutions to understand this system and to make it a major means of fundraising in the early stages of business. Considering the utilization of this system, it is becoming increasingly important to enhance corporate value.
Venture companies and entrepreneurs require adequate and accessible finan- cial support before and during the startup process. In 2022, the Japanese government announced its Grand Design and Implementation Plan for New Capitalism - Realization of Investment in People, Technology, and Startups. The government thereby strengthened its efforts toward startup support policies, especially policies aimed at promoting entrepreneurship, and also declared 2022 as the Year of Startup Creation (Cabinet Secretariat, 2022).
This study focuses on the importance of integrating financial support for each stage and for the preparation stage to the growth stage, emphasizing the importance of post-startup financial support for the companies’ survival and development. The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (2022) of Japan has issued guidebooks, while education and support measures until startup have increased and been enhanced. While few venture companies continue to operate until a period of stability (Eisenmann 2021), this study investigated the current situation in Japan. This study focused on the role of
The Importance and Necessity of Early-Stage Financial Support 105
post-startup financial support policies within Japan’s innovation system, aim- ing to clarify such policies’ importance. The study used a postal mail survey of startup and venture companies in business incubation centers nationwide to gain insight. Preparations are underway for introducing “business growth collateral rights” in Japan’s financial system, and the survey also investi- gated sentiments on this new collateral system from the business owners’ perspective.
Storey (1994) analysed lending and policies for small- and medium-sized enterprises in general. His study did not discuss the importance of support during the startup phase, though clearly discussed collateral’s role as a signal for bank financing. However, that study was centered on the situations in Europe and the United States, and on changes over time, so the findings are difficult to apply to the present study. Berger and Udell (1998) emphasized the importance of support during the startup phase, highlighting the need for awareness of the differences in the financial environment between Japan and other countries, including venture capital. Yamori (2019) was based on a postal mail survey conducted in collaboration with the Aichi Guarantee, targeting companies with <7 years of business history and that had used the Association’s guaranteed services. That study found 54.6% of respon- dents reported experiencing financial difficulties within 2 years of starting their business. Uchida et al. (2018, 2019) used an online survey in 2017 and 2018 targeting 1,700 and 1,287 monitors, respectively, who had experience starting a business. Both surveys were part of a project on startup finance supporting regional revitalization. In this survey, about 40% of respon- dents reported experiencing financial difficulties shortly after starting their business.
The present study targeted companies in business incubation facilities nationwide, focused on the importance of post-startup financial support, evaluated financial support policies, and investigated sentiments on the intro- duction of business growth collateral rights. It also serves as a post-policy assessment following the government’s startup-fostering initiatives that began in 2022.
METHODS
The survey was conducted as follows.
Pre-Survey Interviews Interviews were conducted to assist with questionnaire development. The interviews were conducted with three businesses selected in collaboration with Ishikawa Create Lab (a business incubation facility operated by the Ishikawa Prefecture Industrial Support Organization), connected with the Japan Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (Ishikawa, Japan). The interviews covered topics such as patents, intellectual property-backed financing, use of support systems during startup, current use of support sys- tems, future use of such systems, post-startup funding, use of bank loans, and management issues. The interview results were used in formulating the final questionnaire.
106 Kobayashi
Selection of Survey Targets For the selection of survey targets, business incubation facilities with 20 or more occupancy rooms were chosen from the Business Incubation Overview: New Business Creation Support Facility Directory 2003 (which listed 266 facilities). A total of 20 facilities were selected, factoring in that the directory was published around 20 years ago; the Japan Association of New Busi- ness Incubation Organizations, which published the directory, is no longer operating; and the Japan Business Incubation Association, the current equiv- alent organization, does not publicly list facilities. The facilities’ current status was confirmed through their websites. The final 20 resulted after nar- rowing down the selection to ensure diverse industries and regions. Each facility’s management office was then contacted by phone to request permis- sion for distributing questionnaires to resident companies and asking for their assistance in distributing the questionnaires. Two facilities declined, one did not respond, and ultimately, the subjects were 17 facilities in 16 Japanese prefectures: Hokkaido, Iwate, Miyagi, Yamagata, Ibaraki, Chiba, Kana- gawa, Aichi, Ishikawa, Hiroshima, Kagawa, Tokushima, Ehime, Fukuoka, Kumamoto, and Okinawa.
Questionnaire Distribution The resident companies themselves were expected to provide responses and the questionnaires could be sent directly to the companies with the facilities’ permission (in fact, seven facilities indicated they could not assist with distri- bution). Ultimately, questionnaires were sent to 293 companies from the 17 facilities.
Survey Overview The questionnaire survey was distributed via postal mail in October 2022. The survey comprised 22 multiple-choice questions and included a free-entry section for comments. A total of 84 responses were received (82 from corpo- rations, two from sole proprietors), resulting in a response rate of 29%. Of these, 30% included comments in the free-entry section.
Problem Awareness and Survey Items The main issues addressed in the questionnaire included the importance of financial support for startup and venture companies in Japan, especially in the period immediately after startup; current reliance on bank loans for financial support; significance of fundraising as a critical management issue; and the desire for the business growth collateral rights currently under governmental consideration as a financial support policy.
RESULTS
A total of 32 companies (38%) reported their operating funds were sufficient or presented no difficulties, while 60% had faced difficult situations; of these, 26 (31%) were currently experiencing difficulties (Table 1).
The Importance and Necessity of Early-Stage Financial Support 107
Table 1. Financial situation since startup.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Equation reproduced from the original PDF.
19 23
Sufficient funds have been secured since startup 11 13 Funds were not sufficient, but there were no difficulties 21 25 There were difficult periods after startup, but no issues now 25 30 Difficulties have persisted since startup (including effects of the COVID-19 pandemic)
7 8
Difficulties have persisted since startup (excluding effects of the COVID-19 pandemic) Do not know 0 0 Total 83
More than half of the respondents mentioned periods of financial diffi- culty within 4 years after startup. Six companies (24%) reported financial difficulties immediately after startup (Table 2).
Table 2. Periods of financial difficulty.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Responses (N = 25) Number % Immediately after founding 6 24 1 -2 years after founding 7 28 3 -4 years after founding 5 20 5 -10 after founding 7 28 10+ years or more after founding 0 0
Total 25
Regarding funding, 32 companies (39%) indicated they had sufficient funds, while the remaining 51 (61%) experienced fund shortages. Notably, 22 companies (27%) reported having no funds for regular operations and 27 (33%) reported a lack of research and development funds (Table 3).
Table 3. Current funding situation.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Responses (multiple answers) Number % Sufficient 32 39 Insufficient fund for regular operations 22 27 Insufficient fund for research and development 27 33 Insufficient fund for equipment 22 27 Others 2 2 Do not know 0 0
Total 105
At the time of the survey, Japan’s Financial Services Agency had a working group on systems to support lending practices focused on the nature of the business, and the Ministry of Justice was deliberating on business growth
108 Kobayashi
collateral rights. A total of 49 companies (60%) expressed a strong desire for early introduction of this security system. In the free-response section on startup-support policies, 26 companies (30%) provided suggestions and recommendations (Table 4).
Table 4. Demand for business growth collateral rights.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Responses (N = 82) Number % Want early introduction 49 60 Not necessary, current collateral system is sufficient 7 9 Do not know 26 30
Total 82
DISCUSSION
The survey revealed that cash flow and fundraising are challenging in the early stages of business after startup. Many companies lacked working cap- ital and research and development funds – a severe situation. The results were consistent with previous studies. Notably, the survey targeted compa- nies in an environment in which they could receive appropriate advice from consulting services and incubators from the startup preparation stage. This will be further investigated through interviews in the future. The importance of fundraising, sentiments on financial support policies, and sentiments on the introduction of business growth collateral right might vary by industry, company size, and founding history. However, there were no substantial dif- ferences regarding fundraising by industry, size, or history. There were also no substantial differences in sentiment about support policies by industry, size, or history. Similarly, were no substantial differences regarding business growth collateral rights by industry, size, or history. Likewise, no substan- tial differences were seen regarding patents, insufficient collateral, and other collateral issues. The results clarify fundraising as an imperative manage- ment issue regardless of industry, sentiments on past support policies are low regardless of company size, and improvements are required in the future. A desire was also seen for introducing business growth collateral rights regardless of industry.
CONCLUSION
While the survey had a limited group of companies, the results revealed that insufficient support was provided up to the point of business startup and improvements are also needed in post startup financial support. Fundrais- ing was the most important current management issue and many companies clearly were having difficulty raising funds from external sources. The chal- lenges appear especially weighty considering the respondent companies were located in public business incubation centers and an environment in which they could receive sufficient support and advice for their business plans and operations. A similar or higher percentage of companies than in previous
The Importance and Necessity of Early-Stage Financial Support 109
studies (e.g., Yamori [2019]; Uchida et al. [2018, 2019]) reported fac- ing financial difficulties in the early business stages. Insufficient funds for research and development and for equipment were also reported at high rates of around 30% each. Financial institutions evidently need to have more flexible lending practices, considering that startup and venture com- panies often have limited assets and poor performance. Of the respondents, 60% expressed a desire for the introduction of business growth collateral rights. Yet while this system should expand lending opportunities, 30% of respondents indicated they were unsure about its introduction. This uncer- tainty suggests the present importance of promoting understanding of the system. Enhancing corporate value is also critical for companies. It is cur- rently unclear whether financial institutions will actively use this system, and that issue warrants further investigation. Few responses indicated that financial support policies for both the startup and post-startup periods were sufficient. The issues behind this require further examination and considera- tion of more appropriate policies is needed. As the survey grouped questions related to financial support policies, future surveys may need to classify them more precisely, such as into loans, subsidies, and grants (including the use of the Small Business Innovation Research system). Crowdfunding, a form of alternative financing, is becoming more prevalent in Japan, though this topic was beyond the scope of the survey. Crowdfunding’s effectiveness in financial support policies is another topic for future research. This survey also helped in recognizing the importance of the nation’s public business incubation facilities. Conducting the survey heightened the realization that these facilities facilitate awareness of regional disparities. Regional differ- ences in the momentum of business incubation facilities were recognized, as were facilities in currently revitalizing cities outside major metropolitan areas. As digitization and so-called fintech rapidly progress, the survey also con- firmed that it is crucial to investigate and research business incubation’s role in nurturing and supporting startup and venture companies and the factors contributing to regional disparities. Further exploring the challenges iden- tified in this study will promote the growth and continuity of startup and venture companies.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Professor Akiya Nagata (Kyushu University) provided guidance on the ques- tionnaire survey. Any errors in this paper are my sole responsibility. I also sincerely thank all the companies that responded to the survey, and the business incubation facilities that participated.
REFERENCES
Berger, A. N., Udell, G. F. (1998), “The economics of small business finance: The roles of private equity and debt markets in the financial growth cycle”, Journal of Banking and Finance Volume 22, pp. 613–673. Cabinet Secretariat (2022), “Grand Design and Implementation Plan for New
Capitalism - Realizing Investment in People, Technology, and Start-ups”. Cabinet Secretariat (2022), “Startup Development Five-year Plan”.
110 Kobayashi
Eisenmann, T. (2021), “Why Start-ups Fail It’s not always the horse or the jockey”, Harvard Busuness Review Volume 99, No. 3, pp. 77–85. Financial Services Agency Financial System Council (2023), “Report of the Working
Group on the Review of Systems to Support Lending Practices Focused on Business Nature”. Japan New Business Support Organization (2003), Business Incubation Overview 2003 - New Business Creation Support Facility Directory, Tokyo: Nichigai Associates. Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (2022), “List of Ministry of Economy,
Trade and Industry Start-up Support Measures (June 2022 edition)”. Storey, D. J. (1994), Understanding the Small Business Sector, London: Routledge. Uchida, Hiroshi, Charly Guo, Kazuro Yamada (2018), Summary of results of survey on entrepreneurship and fundraising, Business Research, Volume 65. Uchida, Hiroshi, Charly Guo, Kazuro Yamada (2019), Summary of results of sur-
vey on entrepreneurship and fundraising (follow-up survey), Business Research, Volume 67. Yamori, Nobuyoshi (2019), “Supporting entrepreneurship utilizing credit guarantee systems: Role of credit guarantee associations and cooperation with financial institutions”, Tokyo: Chuo Keizai Sha.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors, Business Management and Society
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-964867-11-3
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional