Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Non-right-handedness as a contributor to incidents/accidents reported within the Aviation Safety Reporting System

1 Psychology Department, Montclair State University, Montclair, NJ, 07043, USA ↗
2 Fort Hill Group, 470 L’Enfant Plaza Ste 4106, Washington, DC, 20024, USA ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1005201

Abstract

Individual differences in hand use preference are associated with individual differences in cognition, emotion, and behavior. Additional work suggests that non-right-handers (NRH) are more accident prone generally, more likely to suffer from a physical accident resulting in head or severe injury, are involved in more car accidents, and die earlier than righthanders (RH). It is unclear what causal factors result in these accident-related differences between handedness groups, but likely there is an interplay between both cognition and environment. Additionally, the ‘right-hand world hypothesis’ suggests that the environment is constructed in a manner that is implicitly biased toward right-handers, resulting in physical constraints on NRH performance. Given these differences between RH and NRH, the current work sought to determine if NRH was associated with incidents in air transportation as reported via the Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS), a public database consisting of voluntary safety reports about aviation safety events. Out of 225,897 reports from January 1988 to September 2023, two reports referred to left-handedness as being detrimental to performance as a result of the configuration of the environment. Broadly, results suggest limited impacts of NRH on ASRS reported incidents, though study limitations may result in underestimation of NRH-incident relationships.

INTRODUCTION

Individual differences in hand use preference are associated with individ- ual differences in brain organization, cognition, emotion, and behavior. For example, Non-Right-Handers (NRH) relative to Right-Handers (RH) have a larger corpus callosum (Luders et al., 2010), increased interhemispheric interaction (Westerhausen et al., 2004; Cherbuin & Brinkman, 2006), and decreased cerebral lateralization (Prichard, Propper & Christman, 2013; Propper et al., 2010). These between-handedness group differences in hemi- spheric organization have been suggested to underly the superior episodic memory, superior spatial task performance, increased susceptibility to per- suasion (Prichard, Propper & Christman, 2013), increased negative affect (e.g. Propper et al., 2010), and increased incidence of mental disorders (Rodriguez et al., 2010; van der Hoorn et al., 2010) in NRH compared to RH.

© 2024. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 115

While some traits associated with NRH can be considered positive (such as superior episodic memory and spatial task performance), other associa- tions are more negative. In fact, research suggests that NRH differ from RH in accident-proneness. The NRH are more accident prone generally (Fritsche & Lindell, 2019; Larson et al., 1997; Mandal, Suar & Bhattacharya, 2001; Voyer & Voyer, 2015), more likely to suffer a head injury (Macniven, 1994; Zverev & Adeloye, 2001), more likely to suffer from physical accidents resulting in death or severe injury (Coren, 1993), are involved in more car accidents, and may die earlier, than RH (Coren & Halpern, 1991; Halpern & Coren, 1991). In fact, Coren (1993) reported a 6-fold increase in risk of accident-related death in NRH, compared with RH.

It is unclear what the causal factors might be that result in these accident- related differences between handedness groups, but likely there is an interplay between cortically-mediated cognitive processes and environmental factors. For example, NRH is associated with higher scores on the Cognitive Failures Questionnaire (CFQ; Broadbent et al., 1982) and with increased ‘mishaps’, including injuries resulting in hospitalizations, number of car accidents, and fall/jump-related injuries (Larson et al., 1997). Although increased cogni- tive failures, such as decreased vigilance, inattention, and lapses in attention may increase accident likeliness, Larson et al.’s (1997) analyses suggested that the association between NRH, increased accidents, and cognitive errors was mediated by additional factors.

One such mediator may be environmental design. Specifically, Coren (1993) suggested that the environment is constructed in a manner that is implicitly biased toward RH, resulting in physical constraints on NRH per- formance that can result in injury. Supporting this interpretation, within the transportation sector, a study of Indian railway drivers reported more loco- motive accidents in NRH versus RH (Bhushan & Kahn, 2006). Specifically, Bhushan and Kahn found that 89% of NRH reported having had a rail acci- dent, compared with only 16% of RH. It was proposed that locomotive cabin design strongly favored RH, such that various driving configurations might obscure the view for NRH, contributing to the higher frequency of accidents in NRH (Bhushan & Kahn, 2006). Interestingly, in the aviation sector, Gawron and Priest (1996) reported decreased performance in a fly- ing simulator when individuals were forced to use their non-dominant hand, regardless of whether the non-dominant hand was the left or the right. In fact, pilots using their non-dominant hand had decreased performance, reported increased workload, and did not show improvement in non-dominant hand ability following training. These results suggest the possibility of an impact of design features within the Air Traffic Organization (ATO) on performance as a function of handedness, or at the very least, the possibility for handedness to impact performance in the aviation sector generally.

In sum, several lines of research indicate the potential for individual dif- ferences in handedness to be associated with incidents within the domain of aviation, with these including cortically-mediated cognitive processing biases as well as environmental design favoring the RH. Thus, the current study examined reports in the voluntary reporting system of the Aviation Safety

Non-Right-Handedness as a Contributor to Incidents/Accidents Reported 117

Reporting System (ASRS) to determine if NRH is associated with incidents within the National Airspace System (NAS).

METHODOLOGY

The ASRS is a public database consisting of voluntary safety reports and related data for aviation safety events and issues (NASA, 2023). ASRS narratives can be examined for themes related to safety to aid in deter- mining contributing factors to incidents, and for developing mitigations. Additionally, reports can be sorted and selected based on many different domains/features, including based on key words within the narratives them- selves. It should be noted that ASRS reports are voluntary, and therefore the caveats associated with voluntarily self-reported data apply here. For exam- ple, individuals who feel most strongly about an event might be more or even less likely to allow it to be accessed within the system, resulting in selection bias. Additionally, ASRS does not include reports wherein an actual accident occurred. Instead, issues associated with non-accident situations, such as run- way incursions, loss of separation between aircraft, or unexpected situations, as well as other events, are within the database. These incidents, similarly to accidents, represent situations wherein lapses in cognitive processes, along with potential environmental factors, could impact performance.

The online ASRS database (225,897 reports from January 1988 to September 2023) was searched within narratives for the keywords: “Left Hand, Hander, Left Handed, Lefty, Leftie, Southpaw, South Paw, Handed- ness, or Ambidextrous”. In addition, the above words, in addition to those compound phrases with hyphenation, were also searched within a slightly smaller database that included reports until April, 2023 (e.g. Left-Hand, Left-Handed, South-Paw). This slightly smaller database was used because it leveraged a previously downloaded offline version of the database that enabled hyphenated search terms using Microsoft Excel, a feature unavail- able within the online ASRS dataset. It is important to note that the terms ‘Left hand’ and ‘Left-hand’ were also used in the search, but ultimately were rejected as search terms (see below). All reporter roles listed in ASRS were included within the search. Inclusion criteria required the reporter to refer to themselves or to someone else being NRH in some manner.

RESULTS

Left Hand (865 reports) and Left-Hand (214 reports) reports were examined for relevancy by extracting the 20 characters before, and the 70 characters after, the keywords/phrase to determine context without the need to read each entire narrative. Additionally, a randomized reading by two indepen- dent judges of more than 100 of these reports was also conducted. Results of these analyses revealed that no reports discussed being NRH. Instead, the reports containing Left Hand or Left-Hand focused on ‘left hand traffic pat- terns’, other aviation-related circumstances, or the side (e.g. the ‘left hand window’). Ultimately, the search terms Left Hand and Left-Hand did not result in any reports referring to personal handedness of either the reporter

or of anyone else. On the other hand, derivatives of these terms (e.g. left handedness, left-handed) were retained for examination.

Of 225,897 total reports, using the other words/phrases listed in Methods, 6 reports were returned as matches. Of these, review by two independent judges revealed that 4 reports did not use the terms as being related to hand use preference. Two reports referred to left-handedness specifically. This is a.00088% incidence of NRH implicated in ASRS reports. In both instances it was daylight, and left-handedness was reported as detrimental to performance as a result of the configuration of the environment.

In Report 1 (November, 2005), a Flight Engineer (FE) was reported to have let aircraft stairs down onto a groundworker, resulting in severe injuries. The FE was unable to see the groundworker due to the configuration of the stairs and his use of his left hand.

“…ultimately he (the reporter) believes the cause of the accident was the FE’s left handedness. Because of the location of B727-200’s aft airstair handle, a R-Handed person can lower the stair and easily look out to the aft of the aircraft as the stair descends. When a person lowers the airstair left handedly, they must face more forward, making it difficult to observe obstacles in the airstair’s descent path.”

In Report 2 (July, 2009), an emergency situation resulted in the disengage- ment of autopilot and the requirement of the pilot to perform multiple actions at once. The pilot reported that the situation was negatively influenced by his own left-handedness and the placement of items in the cockpit.

“Autopilot disengaged, HSI distracting and covered with post-it note. Used co-pilots DG and magnetic compass and GPS for heading changes. Hand flying and copying new clearance problematic (being left-handed makes this worse).”

CONCLUSION

Broadly, results indicate a very limited impact of NRH on ASRS reported inci- dents. Nonetheless, non-right-handedness, and specifically left-handedness, was associated with exacerbating the impact of a situation. In 2005, field of view was impaired due to left-hand use of equipment, resulting in severe injury to a groundcrew. In 2009, a pilot reported that “being left-handed makes this worse” during an emergency situation. Thus, although rarely reported, environmental factors may negatively impact NRH performance within the NAS, sometimes with severe consequences.

There are limitations to the present research that may result in the under- estimation of the impact of NRH within the NAS. First, it is important to note that ASRS is a voluntary, self-reported database, and that therefore it is subject to the biases associated with all such data, for example self-selection. Additionally, individuals may not always be aware of, or report, how their NRH contributed to a given incident, and questions about hand use pref- erence are not included within the ASRS system. Second, accidents are not included within ASRS reports. It is possible that accident-related situations associated with being NRH might occur if the factors involved are more likely

Non-Right-Handedness as a Contributor to Incidents/Accidents Reported 119

to produce severe impacts. Third and relatedly, it is possible that additional search terms may capture more incidents. For example, future research could examine all reports containing the word ‘hand’, which was not feasible here. Thus, it may be that NRH is more frequently associated with incidents than is reported here.

Additional research could assess handedness directly in individuals involved in incidents, in order to determine the impact of NRH on incident frequency, and to gain additional insight into the relationship between NRH and the environment within the NAS. Such research could potentially offer avenues for mitigating any environmental factors that constrain or reduce the performance of NRH.

REFERENCES

Bhushan, B. and Khan, S. M., 2006. Laterality and accident proneness: a study of locomotive drivers. Laterality, 11(5), pp. 395–404. Broadbent, D. E., Cooper, P. F., FitzGerald, P. and Parkes, K. R., 1982. The cog-

nitive failures questionnaire (CFQ) and its correlates. British journal of clinical psychology, 21(1), pp. 1–16. Cherbuin, N. and Brinkman, C., 2006. Hemispheric interactions are different in lefthanded individuals. Neuropsychology, 20(6), p. 700. Coren, S., 1993. The left-hander syndrome: The causes and consequences of left-

handedness. Vintage. Coren, S. and Halpern, D. F., 1991. Left-handedness: a marker for decreased survival fitness. Psychological bulletin, 109(1), p. 90. Fritsche, S. A. and Lindell, A. K., 2019. On the other hand: The costs and benefits of

left-handedness. Acta Neuropsychologica, 17, pp. 69–86. Gawron, V. J. and Priest, J. E., 1996, October. Evaluation of hand-dominance on manual control of aircraft. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting (Vol. 40, No. 2, pp. 72–76). Sage CA: Los Angeles, CA: SAGE Publications. Halpern, D. F. and Coren, S., 1991. Handedness and life span. The New England

journal of medicine, 324(14), pp. 998–998. Larson, G. E., Alderton, D. L., Neideffer, M. and Underhill, E., 1997. Further evidence on dimensionality and correlates of the Cognitive Failures Question- naire. British Journal of psychology, 88(1), pp. 29–38. Luders, E., Cherbuin, N., Thompson, P. M., Gutman, B., Anstey, K. J., Sachdev, P.

and Toga, A. W., 2010. When more is less: associations between corpus callosum size and handedness lateralization. Neuroimage, 52(1), pp. 43–49. Mandal, M. K., Suar, D. and Bhattacharya, T., 2001. Side bias and accidents: Are they related?. International journal of Neuroscience, 109(1-2), pp. 139–146. Macniven, E., 1994. Increased prevalence of left-handedness in victims of head

trauma. Brain Injury, 8(5), pp. 457–462. NASA. (2023). Aviation Safety Reporting System. https://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/ Prichard, E., Propper, R. E. and Christman, S. D., 2013. Degree of handedness, but not direction, is a systematic predictor of cognitive performance. Frontiers in psychology, 4, p. 9. Propper, R. E., Brunyé, T. T., Christman, S. D. and Bologna, J., 2010. Negative emo-

tional valence is associated with non-right-handedness and increased imbalance of hemispheric activation as measured by tympanic membrane temperature. The Journal of nervous and mental disease, 198(9), pp. 691–694.

Propper, R. E., O’Donnell, L. J., Whalen, S., Tie, Y., Norton, I. H., Suarez, R. O., Zollei, L., Radmanesh, A. and Golby, A. J., 2010. A combined fMRI and DTI examination of functional language lateralization and arcuate fasciculus structure: Effects of degree versus direction of hand preference. Brain and cognition, 73(2), pp. 85–92. Rodriguez, A., Kaakinen, M., Moilanen, I., Taanila, A., McGough, J. J., Loo, S. and

Järvelin, M. R., 2010. Mixed-handedness is linked to mental health problems in children and adolescents. Pediatrics, 125(2), pp. e340–e348. van der Hoorn, A., Oldehinkel, A. J., Ormel, J., Bruggeman, R., Uiterwaal, C. S. and Burger, H., 2010. Non-right-handedness and mental health problems among ado- lescents from the general population: The Trails Study. Laterality: Asymmetries of Body, Brain and Cognition, 15(3), pp. 304–316. Voyer, S. D. and Voyer, D., 2015. Laterality, spatial abilities, and accident prone-

ness. Journal of clinical and experimental neuropsychology, 37(1), pp. 27–36. Westerhausen, R., Kreuder, F., Sequeira, S. D. S., Walter, C., Woerner, W., Wittling, R. A., Schweiger, E. and Wittling, W., 2004. Effects of handedness and gender on macro-and microstructure of the corpus callosum and its subregions: a combined high-resolution and diffusion-tensor MRI study. Cognitive brain research, 21(3), pp. 418–426. Zverev, Y. and Adeloye, A., 2001. Left-handedness as a risk factor for head

injuries. East African medical journal, 78(1), pp. 22–24.

Cover of the proceedings volume Advances in Human Factors of Transportation

Explore the complete digital volume

Advances in Human Factors of Transportation

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-24-3

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →