Dimitrios Ziakkas, Debra Henneberry, Konstantinos Pechlivanis (2024). Application of Emerging Technologies in Electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing CBTA Training. In: Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing. AHFE Open Access, vol. 159, pp. 2087–2095. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1005776
The advent of electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing (eVTOL) aircraft signifies a transformative shift in urban air mobility, promising to revolutionize transportation in densely populated areas. As the industry evolves, the need for specialized training methodologies becomes paramount to ensure the safety, efficiency, and effectiveness of eVTOL operations. The Competency-Based Training and Assessment (CBTA) approach, rooted in tailoring instruction to specific competencies required for operational roles, presents itself as an optimal framework for eVTOL pilot training. This paper explores the application of the CBTA approach enhanced with emerging technologies in the context of eVTOL training, highlighting its potential to address the unique challenges posed by this emerging technology.Traditional pilot training methodologies, designed around fixed-wing and rotary-wing aircraft, are increasingly inadequate for the novel demands of eVTOL operations. eVTOL aircraft differ fundamentally in terms of design, operational environment, and flight characteristics, necessitating a training paradigm that is both adaptive and comprehensive. The CBTA framework, endorsed by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) for its focus on developing specific competencies, is well-suited to meet these requirements.This paper outlines the core competencies essential for eVTOL operations, including situational awareness in urban environments, energy management, automation management, and emergency response. These competencies are mapped against the unique operational contexts of eVTOLs, which include low-altitude urban navigation, integration with existing air traffic management systems, and the potential for highly automated flight. By aligning the CBTA approach with these competencies, we propose a structured training program that can be adapted to various eVTOL models and operational scenarios.The paper further discusses integrating emerging technologies, such as virtual reality (VR) and artificial intelligence (AI) -Simulated Air Traffic Control Environment (SATCE) into the CBTA framework to enhance training efficacy. VR can simulate complex urban environments, providing pilots with immersive training experiences that closely mimic real-world conditions. AI-driven adaptive learning systems can personalize training modules, ensuring that each pilot achieves mastery of the required competencies at their own pace. These technologies enhance the learning experience and offer scalability and flexibility, which are critical for the widespread adoption of eVTOL operations.Moreover, the paper examines the regulatory implications of adopting a CBTA approach for eVTOL training. As eVTOLs represent a new category of aircraft, regulatory bodies must adapt existing frameworks or develop new standards to accommodate the specific needs of this technology. The CBTA approach offers a robust foundation for such regulatory development, focusing on measurable outcomes and continuous assessment, which align well with aviation authorities' safety and operational performance standards.We also present case studies from early adopters of eVTOL training programs implementing the CBTA approach, as the F.A.S.T case study. These case studies provide valuable insights into this training methodology's practical challenges and successes. The findings suggest that while the CBTA approach is highly effective, its implementation requires significant investment in curriculum development, instructor training, and technology integration.Finally, the paper addresses the future of eVTOL training within the broader aviation ecosystem. As eVTOL technology continues to evolve, so must the training programs supporting it. The CBTA approach, emphasizing continuous improvement and adaptability, is well-positioned to accommodate these changes. However, the success of this approach will depend on close collaboration between industry stakeholders, including aircraft manufacturers, training providers, and regulatory bodies.In conclusion, implementing the CBTA approach in eVTOL training represents a critical step forward in preparing pilots for the challenges of urban air mobility. By focusing on competency development, integrating advanced training technologies, and aligning with regulatory requirements, this approach can ensure that eVTOL pilots have the skills and knowledge necessary to operate safely and efficiently in complex urban environments. This paper contributes to the growing body of research on eVTOL operations. It provides a roadmap for developing effective training programs that can support the safe and sustainable growth of the eVTOL industry.
The rise of Electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing (eVTOL) aircraft represents a major shift in the aviation landscape, especially in the context of Urban Air Mobility (UAM) / Advanced Air Mobility (AAM), (Airbus, 2023). These aircraft, which can take off and land vertically using electric propulsion, offer rapid, low-emission urban transportation potential. However, introducing eVTOLs also necessitates rethinking pilot training approaches due to these aircraft’s novel operational challenges, particularly in dense urban airspaces (Ehang, 2023).
Competency-Based Training and Assessment (CBTA) has emerged as a critical approach for eVTOL training, emphasizing the development of key competencies beyond traditional pilot training frameworks. CBTA ensures that pilots are equipped with the skills and knowledge necessary to operate eVTOLs safely in complex environments. At the same time, emerging technologies such as Virtual Reality (VR), Augmented Reality (AR), Artificial Intelligence (AI), and advanced simulation tools are transforming the way pilots are trained, offering immersive, real-world training experiences that can enhance learning outcomes, minimizing the training cost and time (Table 1).
Table 1. Presentation of CBTA approach in the implementation of CBTA training programs for eVTOL pilots (Ziakkas et al., 2024).
Table available in the original PDF paper.
CBTA Competencies Pilot Competencies PC 0 Application of Knowledge PC 1 Application of Procedures PC 2 Communication PC 3 Aeroplane Flight Path Management, automation PC 4 Aeroplane Flight Path Management, manual control PC 5 Leadership & Teamwork PC 6 Problem-Solving & Decision Making PC 7 Situation Awareness and Management of Information PC 8 Workload Management
This paper applies the ADDIE model (Analyze, Design, Develop, Implement, Evaluate) to explore the development and implementation of CBTA training programs for eVTOL pilots. It also provides a detailed comparison of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and European Union Aviation Safety Agency EASA regulatory approaches and includes real- world business case studies from Joby Aviation, Volocopter, and Lilium to illustrate how these companies are addressing the challenges of eVTOL pilot training (Table 2. Ziakkas et al., 2024).
METHODOLOGY
The current research uses qualitative and quantitative methods to evaluate the impact of developing technologies on electric vertical take-off and landing CBTA training. The interpretivism approach was selected to study Emerging
The Application of Emerging Technologies in Electric Vertical Take-Off 2089
Technologies and CBTA Training in Advanced Air Mobility. Through an extensive literature review and research with Future Aviation Simulation Technologies Gmbh (FAST) in Berlin, Germany, the Human Factors research team examines how human-centered design and AI affect CBTA training in upcoming electric vertical take-off vehicles (FAST, 2024). Future Aviation Simulation Technologies investigates and develops novel simulation models for eVTOL simulator adaptation, CBTA eVTOL pilot training using machine learning, and realistic winch simulations. The Research Onion approach (Saunders, 2019) is the foundation of the research methodology, as illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1: Emerging technologies implementation on electric vertical take-off and landing CBTA training research methodology.
The ADDIE Model Our interpretivism approach follows the ICAO ADDIE model; ADDIE is a systematic instructional design framework used to develop aviation training programs. Table 2 presents the literature review findings focusing on the selected methodology, research objective, key activities, and examples from eVTOL companies worldwide.
This methodology provides a structured approach for designing and implementing CBTA programs, particularly for the emerging eVTOL market, in the following way:
Analyze: Understanding the specific competencies required for eVTOL pilots based on operational and regulatory demands.
Design: Creating training programs that integrate emerging technologies to address these competencies.
Develop: Building training modules using VR, AI, and simulation tools to provide immersive learning experiences.
Implement: Applying these training modules in real-world pilot training environments.
Evaluate: Continuously assess the effectiveness of the training programs using data analytics and competency assessments.
Table 2. Presentation of the ADDIE model in the implementation of CBTA training programs for eVTOL pilots (Ziakkas et al., 2024).
Table available in the original PDF paper.
ADDIE Phase Objective Key Activities Examples from eVTOL Companies Analyze Identify training needs for eVTOL operations
1. Assess industry requirements (FAA, EASA standards) 2. Analyze skills gaps and challenges 3. Identify competencies for eVTOL pilots 4. Engage stakeholders
Volocopter: Collaborating with EASA for certification standards for urban air mobility pilots. Joby Aviation: Working closely with FAA on operational safety standards and SiPO for eVTOL operations. Design Create the CBTA training blueprint
Joby: Incorporating flight simulations and e-learning to teach new operational standards.
1. Define measurable objectives 2. Develop an eVTOL-specific curriculum 3. Integrate emerging tech (wearables, VR, AR) 4. Plan training phases
Develop Create training materials and resources
Volocopter: Leveraging VR/AR to simulate urban flight paths. Joby: Creating simulations of high-density urban airspace.
1. Develop e-learning modules, flight scenarios, and evaluation tools 2. Program simulators with real-world eVTOL scenarios 3. Pilot-test training resources
Implement Deliver training to eVTOL pilots
1. Launch the CBTA program 2. Conduct training using simulators and VR/AR. 3. Use wearables for performance tracking 4. Provide feedback
Lilium: Implementing the training program for the first commercial pilots by 2024. Volocopter: Integrating wearable tech in training to monitor real-time, Evaluate Assess and improve training effectiveness
Joby: Evaluating pilot readiness based on FAA-defined competencies.
1. Gather performance data 2. Collect feedback from trainees and instructors 3. Analyze the achievement of objectives 4. Adjust the program as needed.
ANALYSIS Emerging technologies such as VR, AR, AI, and advanced simulations play a vital role in enhancing the effectiveness of CBTA programs for eVTOL training (Archer, 2023). Based on the literature review:
Virtual Reality (VR): Provides immersive simulations of real-world urban environments, allowing pilots to practice navigation and emergency procedures without the risks associated with live flight (Ziakkas et al., 2023).
Artificial Intelligence (AI): Facilitates personalized training by analyzing pilot performance and adjusting training scenarios based on individual needs (EASA, 2023).
Simulation Tools: Advanced simulation software can replicate complex flight scenarios, including system failures, weather challenges, and urban airspace congestion.
The Application of Emerging Technologies in Electric Vertical Take-Off 2091
Wearable Technologies: Devices such as biometric sensors can track pilot stress levels and other physiological indicators during training, providing insights into a pilot’s readiness.
The FAA and EASA have both developed frameworks for regulating eVTOL operations, but their approaches to CBTA training differ in several key areas:
The FAA emphasizes adapting existing Part 135 and Part 61 regulations to cover eVTOL operations (FAA, 2024). However, the FAA is still in the process of developing specific guidelines for competency-based training in UAM environments.
The EASA has been more proactive in creating the Special Condition for VTOL aircraft (SC-VTOL), which provides specific UAM and eVTOL pilot training guidelines. EASA’s regulations also emphasize the use of emerging technologies in training, particularly for situational awareness and decision-making competencies.
FINDINGS The development and operation of Electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing (eVTOL) aircraft require significant investments in technology and human capital. Beyond the technical capabilities of eVTOLs, the training infrastructure for pilots plays a key role in the business models of companies and training organizations. This section provides a detailed analysis of the financial aspects, including operating costs, return on investment (ROI), and training costs. We also discuss how established aviation training companies like FAST, CAE, and FlightSafety International are critical in developing training programs tailored to eVTOL operators. The transition towards eVTOL operations is characterized by notable technological and methodological progress. The following areas or domains of new technologies influence the application of CBTA in the AAM-UAM aviation ecosystem:
Operating Costs of eVTOLs and ROI for Operators Operating Costs Operating costs for eVTOLs differ from traditional aircraft in several key ways, mainly due to the reliance on electric propulsion and reduced mechanical complexity. However, the relatively novel nature of these aircraft means operators must make significant upfront investments, including training pilots and establishing maintenance infrastructure.
According to various industry estimates, the key components of operating costs include: Battery and Energy Costs: Electric power consumption for eVTOLs is significantly lower than fuel-based aircraft, but maintaining and replacing batteries remains challenging. It is estimated that battery replacement could account for up to 30% of operating costs over the aircraft’s lifespan.
Maintenance Costs: While eVTOLs have fewer moving parts, they require regular maintenance. The reliance on electric propulsion systems
and the novelty of urban air mobility introduce additional requirements for specialized maintenance, driving up costs in the initial phases.
Infrastructure Costs: Developing vertiports and charging infrastructure for urban air mobility will be necessary. These costs are factored into the operating expenses for early adopters and will be a crucial element of any business plan.
Pilot Training Costs: The cost of training eVTOL pilots is a significant part of the operational expenditure, as companies need to invest in competency- based training programs and technologies like VR, AI, and simulation tools.
Return on Investment (ROI) Several studies estimate that early-stage ROI for eVTOL operators will be dependent on key factors, such as: Urban Air Mobility Demand: With the rise in demand for efficient urban transportation, eVTOL operators stand to gain if cities embrace UAM infrastructure. Some estimates suggest that urban air mobility could become a $1 trillion market by 2040.
Regulatory Approvals: ROI projections depend heavily on the speed at which regulators like the FAA and EASA approve eVTOL operations. Early movers like Joby Aviation and Lilium have already secured substantial investments, betting on the successful rollout of UAM services in the coming years.
Technology Adoption: Adopting advanced training technologies significantly reduces long-term training costs and improves pilot competency, ultimately leading to fewer operational risks and lower insurance costs.
For operators, breaking even on initial investments is projected to take anywhere from five to ten years, depending on the regulatory environment, the efficiency of infrastructure deployment, and the scalability of their services (Ziakkas et al., 2022).
Cost of Training and Training Organizations’ Role Training Costs Training costs for eVTOL pilots are substantial due to the need for specialized programs that focus on the unique operational and regulatory challenges posed by UAM (Vertical Aerospace, 2023). According to early estimates from companies like FAST, the average cost of training a single eVTOL pilot is between $50,000 to $100,000, depending on the use of advanced technologies like VR and AI.
The identified key training costs include:
Simulator Development: High-fidelity simulators replicating eVTOL urban operations can cost millions to develop. For example, FAST has invested heavily in full-motion simulators using VR-AR-MR, which provide pilots with an immersive training experience and minimize training costs.
Virtual Reality (VR) Training Modules: VR training reduces the need for expensive in-air training hours and provides a safe environment for pilots to learn how to handle emergencies (SkyDrive, 2023). VR
The Application of Emerging Technologies in Electric Vertical Take-Off 2093
systems can cost $200,000 to $500,000 to set up for large-scale training programs.
Instructor Fees: Using experienced eVTOL instructors, many of whom come from traditional helicopter or fixed-wing backgrounds, adds to the overall cost. On average, flight instructor salaries range from $80,000 to $150,000 per year.
FAST, a global leader in aviation training has already established itself as a key player in the eVTOL space. The company has signed agreements with multiple eVTOL manufacturers to develop tailored pilot training programs that meet both FAA and EASA regulatory requirements.
CAE has partnered with companies like Volocopter to develop specialized training programs using advanced simulation technologies. These programs are designed to align with EASA’s eVTOL framework and include scenario- based training that incorporates IATA/CBTA competencies. Furthermore, CAE has invested in cutting-edge full-flight simulators and VR-based training modules that enable pilots to experience complex urban air mobility scenarios. These tools enhance pilots’ decision-making, situational awareness, and flight path management skills. CAE projects a significant return on its investment in eVTOL training due to the expected growth of the UAM market. The company plans to scale its training programs across global locations as demand for eVTOL pilots increases (CAE, 2023).
FlightSafety International (FSI) is another major player in the aviation training industry, focusing on providing high-fidelity simulators and advanced pilot training programs (FSI, 2023). FSI plans to create a range of advanced simulators specifically for eVTOL operations. FSI has worked closely with Lilium to ensure its training modules align with the aircraft’s specific technical and operational requirements.
Business Case Studies: Joby Aviation, Volocopter, and Lilium Joby Aviation (USA) aims to integrate VR and AI-driven simulators into its training programs to create immersive and realistic urban air mobility scenarios. The company’s training programs are designed to meet FAA guidelines and focus on CBTA principles. Joby has secured over $800 million in funding and has invested substantially in aircraft development and training infrastructure. Joby’s ROI projections are based on the assumption that its aircraft will enter service by 2025, with a focus on urban transportation networks in cities like Los Angeles and San Francisco (Joby, 2023).
Volocopter (Germany) has collaborated with CAE to develop its pilot training programs, which align with EASA’s SC-VTOL standards. The use of VR and AI-driven performance assessment tools has enabled the company to reduce training times and costs while improving the quality of training. Volocopter has raised over €400 million and invested heavily in aircraft certification and pilot training. Volocopter anticipates breaking even within 7 to 8 years of launching its UAM services in European cities like Paris and Berlin (Volocopter, 2022).
Lilium’s (Germany) training program incorporates AI-driven analytics to evaluate real-time pilot performance. The company has partnered with
FlightSafety International to create advanced simulators tailored to the unique flight dynamics of its eVTOL aircraft. Lilium has raised over $1 billion in funding and has invested significantly in training infrastructure. Lilium expects to begin commercial operations by 2026, with an expected ROI driven by its plans to operate eVTOL air taxis in multiple European and American cities (Lilium, 2023).
CONCLUSION
Developing specialized training programs for eVTOL pilots is essential for these aircraft’s safe and efficient operation. Emerging technologies like VR, AI, and advanced simulators are critical in reducing training costs, improving pilot competency, and enhancing safety. Companies like FAST, CAE, and FlightSafety International are at the forefront of developing these training solutions, working closely with both FAA and EASA to ensure compliance with regulatory standards and implementing the CBTA concept. However, despite the promise of emerging technologies, challenges remain. The high upfront costs of developing eVTOL-specific simulators and training modules are significant, and the ROI for operators will depend heavily on the regulatory environment, demand for urban air mobility, and the scalability of training programs.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors thank faculty members of Purdue University and Human Factors analysts from HF Horizons and FAST Gmbh for their invaluable feedback and contribution to this work.
REFERENCES
Archer Aviation. (2023). Training and development for eVTOL operations. Archer Aviation. https://www.archer.com Airbus. (2023). CityAirbus NextGen: The future of urban air mobility. Airbus. https:
//www.airbus.com/innovation/urban-air-mobility/cityairbus-nextgen.html CAE. (2023). CAE partners with eVTOL manufacturers to enhance pilot training with VR and AI. CAE. https://www.cae.com EASA. (2023). Artificial Intelligence Roadmap 2.0: Human-centric approach to AI
in aviation. EHang. (2023). EHang: Autonomous flight and AI-driven training systems for urban air mobility. EHang. https://www.ehang.com FAST-Group – future aviation simulation technologies. (2024). https://fast-group.a
ero/ Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), “Pilot Certification and Operating Requirements,” [Online]. Available: https://www.faa.gov. FlightSafety International (FSI). (2023). FlightSafety and Lilium collaborate on advanced eVTOL pilot training solutions. FlightSafety International. https://ww w.flightsafety.com Joby Aviation. (2023). Joby Aviation’s approach to pilot training and AI-enhanced
simulators. Joby Aviation. https://www.jobyaviation.com Lilium. (2023). Lilium partners with FlightSafety International for eVTOL pilot training. Lilium. https://www.lilium.com
The Application of Emerging Technologies in Electric Vertical Take-Off 2095
Saunders, M., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2019). Research Methods for Business Students Eighth Edition. In Research Methods for Business Students. Pearson Education Limited. Shackelford, S. J. (2020). SkyDrive. (2023). SkyDrive’s pilot training program and AI-enhanced learning
modules for eVTOL. SkyDrive. https://www.skydrive2023.com Vertical Aerospace. (2023). Vertical Aerospace: eVTOL pilot training and operational cost models. Vertical Aerospace. https://www.vertical-aerospace.com Volocopter. (2022). Volocopter announces collaboration with CAE for comprehensive eVTOL training programs. Volocopter. https://www.voloco pter.com Ziakkas, D., Plioutsias, A., & Pechlivanis, K. (2022). Artificial Intelligence in aviation decision making process. The transition from extended Minimum Crew Operations to Single Pilot Operations (SiPO). In T. Ahram, J. Kalra, & W. Karwowski (Eds.), Artificial Intelligence and Social Computing. AHFE (2022) International Conference. https://doi.org/http://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1001452. Ziakkas, D., Vink, L.-S., Pechlivanis, K., & Flores, A. (2023). Implementation guide
for artificial intelligence in aviation: a human-centric guide for practitioners and organizations.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-964867-35-9
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional