Benjamen Sunkanmi Adeyemi, Clinton Aigbavboa, Wellington D Thwala (2022). Factors Affecting Total Quality Management Implementation in the Construction Industry. In: Human Factors in Management and Leadership. AHFE Open Access, vol. 55, pp. 141–147. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002243
Total quality management (TQM) is an organisation idea that regularly enhances the superiority of products as well as services by concentrating on the customers’ necessities and desires to improve customer satisfaction. This paper aimed to review previous literatures on various issues affecting TQM implementation in the construction industry such as absence of benchmarking, employee confrontation to change, absence of understanding, inadequate preparation, absence of top management obligation, absence of customer focus, absence of rewards and acknowledgment, inadequate evaluation processes, insufficient fund, inefficient management, inadequate raw materials, lack of proper communication and unproductive leadership. This research source for information through recognised articles in journals, conference papers, government reports and so on. The findings from the extensive literature review form previous studies are cross-sectional. According to the previous research, it was revealed that those challenges of total quality management are vary. It is recommended that construction stakeholders should always avoid any obstacle that can affect total quality management in the construction industry.
TQM comprises entire organisation employees in the way of meeting custo- mers’ desires by applying problem solving approaches to improve the supe- riority of all managerial products as well as services. The foremost emphasis of TQM idea is to accomplish an extensive incorporation among organisati- onal construction professionals and their purposes so as to achieve improved development, advancement, and maintenance of services superiority to attain customer contentment (Talib, 2013). However, TQM is still deliberated as innovative idea and its philosophies and implements are unacquainted for a huge range of establishments, leaders and personnel most specifically in the construction industry. According to Gharakhani et al (2013), TQM com- prises numerous quality tools and techniques, in accumulation to different
philosophies and opinions that every employee within the same establishment shares. Esin and Hilal (2014) sees TQM as a company-extensive organisation idea of constantly enhancing the superiority of the services by concentrating on the clients wants as well as anticipations to improve customer fulfilment and industry efficiency. Ayandele and Akpan (2015) described TQM as a methodical quality enhancement way for company extensive organisation for the tenacity of enhancing efficiency regarding superiority, output, customer’s contentment as well as efficiency. TQM as a plan that targets to generates and interchange additional proficient and quality products, through accomplish- ing collaboration among organization members (Lakhal, Pasin, and Liman, 2006). This paper reviews previous literature on numerous factors affecting construction industry TQM practices.
FACTORS AFFECTING TQM IMPLEMENTATION IN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY Understanding various obstacles that are probable to obstruct the practice of the TQM, permits construction professionals to improve additional active approaches for enhancing the probabilities of fruitfully organise TQM and so to accomplish superiority in the industry (Jacobsen, 2008). According to Johnson and Kleiner (2013), the main obstructions were revealed as absence of benchmarking and personnel confrontation to change. Establi- shments should recognise that benchmarking is a device applied to ascer- tain capability as well as feebleness in disparity by means of the finest firms in every industry. However, personnel confrontation might be ove- rwhelmed by suitable instruction and including them in the scheduling and application stages of TQM. It was likewise revealed that inadequate materials are among the challenges of total quality management. A study carried out by Ahmed and Hassan (2003) exhibited that the subsequent are the issue recognised in the application of TQM: lack of idea of qua- lity in the industry; absence of unblemished idea, undertaking and solid quality strategy for the organisation; lack of understanding on modern concept and obligation by the leader; organisations have deprived obse- rvation, upkeep and control of superiority of industrial implementation; absence of time as well as resources and majority of industries prefer tem- porary desires to the lasting ones; the course of accomplishing TQM is difficult comprising all participants of the organization; and firms need ade- quate period to transform employees’ old-style perspective to the idea of superiority.
Based on the assertion of Panuwatwanich and Nguyen (2017), the disap- pointment of TQM practices is mainly because of inadequate incorporation of TQM with cultural transformation. It is a slightly a composite task for an establishment. Though various research have recognised the kinds of orga- nization culture to guarantee fruitful application of TQM and link these establishment cultures among one another to demonstrate their cooperation constructively and destructively to TQM efficiency (Prajojo, & McDer- mott, 2005). A study conducted by Ezeani and Ibijola (2017) recognised some major factors affecting TQM such as insufficient fund, unproductive
Factors Affecting Total Quality Management Implementation in the Construction Industry 143
management, inadequate raw materials, little profit, and inexperienced employees. The discovery in Ezeani and Ibijola (2017) agreed with the perce- ption of Anunibe (2009) and Osadebe (2010) who both perceived that the challenges linked with TQM application are habitually possess a decreasing impact on efficiency, employees, absence of raw materials, insufficient fund product advancement that do not satisfy the necessity conditions of a supe- riority product. However, when the ratio contribution is greater than what the stage of efficiency would be, this will critically affect the efficiency of the establishments. Assensoh-Kodua and Imrith (2016) identified various major challenges of TQM such as absence of understanding, inadequate prepara- tion (no financial plan, no sponsor), confrontation to change, absence of top management obligation, absence of Customer Focus, absence of rewards and acknowledgment and inadequate evaluation processes and benchmark indices.
According to Suleman and Gul (2015), studies have discovered that insuf- ficient understanding, absence of tools, absence of capital, absence of viable leadership obligation, deprived data and placement strategies, obstinacy of disorganized application, improbable anticipations, and insufficient manage- rial skills are several probable obstacles in the course of fruitful application of TQM. Brown et al (1994) stated that lack of upper management obliga- tion obstructs TQM capability destructively which is among the foremost causes of disappointment in TQM efforts. Dale et al (2007) opined that inef- ficient leadership; obstacle to transformation; inconsistent rules; unsuitable organisational structure; and deprived organisation of the transformation procedure are additional inadequacies in applying TQM. A study by Kosgei (2014) recognized that several barriers in applying TQM were absence of management obligation as well as some employees, professionals’ organizati- onal philosophy, deprived documentation, insufficient training of employees, and inadequate communication.
Hamidi and Zamanparrar (2008) cited in Ater (2013), described issues as well as challenges for TQM implementation as absence of top as well as central management obligation. They stated that the absence of mana- gement obligation and making proper and helpful organizational culture, there would be no improvement. They further opined that in emerged and emerging nations, absence of top management obligation was recognised as a significant issue that results to disappointment information in TQM practi- ces. They likewise specified training platforms for leaders and employees for improving their capability in methods and total quality implements as vital issues for active TQM achievement. Likewise, Rosa and Amaral (2007) indi- cates a number of obstacles in applying TQM in an organisation such as lack of proper communication; the challenges in measuring higher organisation performance, the co-existence of numerous determinations and aims for an organisation, the focuses in the individualism and important amount of inner opposition; the administrative policymaking procedure; and the absence of a good leadership, extremely dedicated to the notions and philosophies it needs to apply as well as capable of comprising all the organisation members. Table 1 demonstrates the summary of previous literature review on factors affecting TQM.
Table 1. Summary of previous literature review.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Factors Affecting TQM Authors Johnson (2013) Absence of benchmarking and personnel con- frontation to change
Ahmed and Hassan (2003)
lack of idea of quality in the industry, abse- nce of unblemished vision, mission and solid quality strategy for the organisation; lack of understanding on modern concept and obliga- tion by the leader; organisations have deprived observation, upkeep and control of superiority of industrial implementation; absence of time as well as resources.
Ezeani and Ibijola (2017)
Insufficient fund, inefficient management, inade- quate raw materials, little profit and inexperie- nced employees.
Anunibe (2009) and Osadebe (2010)
A decreasing impact on efficiency, employees, absence of raw materials, insufficient fund pro- duct advancement.
Assensoh-Kodua and Imrih (2016)
Absence of understanding, inadequate prepara- tion (no financial plan, no sponsor), confron- tation to change, absence of Top Management obligation, absence of customer focus, absence of rewards and acknowledgment and inadequate evaluation processes and benchmark indices.
Suleman and Gul (2015)
Insufficient knowledge, absence of implements, absence of finance, deprived data, and place- ment strategies, obstinacy of disorganized imple- mentation, improbable anticipations, and insuf- ficient managerial skills.
Dale et al (2007) Inefficient leadership; obstacle to transforma- tion; inconsistent rules; unsuitable organisatio- nal structure; and deprived organisation of the change procedure.
Kosgei (2014) Absence of management commitment as well as some employees, professionals organizatio- nal philosophy, deprived documentation, insuf- ficient training of employees, and inadequate communication.
Hamidi and Zamaparrar (2008)
Absence of top and middle management commi- tment.
Rosa and Amaral (2009)
Lack of proper communication; the challenges in measuring higher organization performance, the coexistence of numerous determinations and aims for an organisation, the focuses in the indi- vidualism and important amount of inner oppo- sition, the administrative policymaking proce- dure, and the absence of a good leadership.
Factors Affecting Total Quality Management Implementation in the Construction Industry 145
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY This research paper reviewed previous literatures on several issues of constru- ction industry TQM implementation. The research source for information through the use of recognised articles in journals, conference papers, govern- ment reports, internets, and thesis. However, this article will therefore present the findings that were gotten from an extensive reviewed of previous literatures.
FINDINGS The findings pertaining the extensive literature review from previous studies have revealed several issues influencing TQM in the construction industry generally. A study by Johnson (2013) identified most notable obstruction of total quality management which are absence of benchmarking as well as personnel confrontation to change. However, any Organizations need to recognise that benchmarking is a device adopted to ascertain capability and flaws in contrast with the superlative firms in every industry. Also, personnel confrontation might be overwhelmed by suitable instruction and encompas- sing them in the preparation and application stages of TQM. It was similarly discovered by Ahmed and Hassan (2003) that TQM are mostly affected through absence of idea of quality in the industry; absence of unblemished vision, mission, and solid quality strategy for the organisation; lack of under- standing on modern concept and obligation by the leader. However, lack of idea by construction professionals in order to ensure in the construction usu- ally has adverse effect on total quality management. Likewise, it was revealed by Ezeani and Ibijola (2017) that insufficient fund, inefficient management, and inadequate raw materials are foremost issues of TQM. Hence, in a situa- tion whereby there is inadequate fund in any organisation, it will surely affect the TQM of the organisation. Also, absence of raw material can never ensure quality of service in the construction industry. Moreover, absence of under- standing, inadequate preparation, confrontation to change, and absence of top management obligation are among the major challenges of TQM (2016). However, deprived preparation among professionals in the construction on how to perform a task can definitely affect the TQM.
CONCLUSION
In this article, various literatures that are relating to this particular study has been discussed. It was found through the numerous existing literatu- res that some major issues affecting TQM in the construction industry are absence of benchmarking and employee confrontation to change, absence of understanding, inadequate preparation, lack of top management obliga- tion, absence of customer focus, absence of rewards and acknowledgment, inadequate evaluation processes, insufficient fund, inefficient management, inadequate raw materials, lack of proper communication and unproductive leadership. Therefore, it is recommended that all issues that can affect TQM in the construction industry should be evaded.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge National Research Foundation (NRF) for the financial supports during this study.
REFERENCES
Ahmed, S. and Hassan, M. (2003) “Survey and case investigations on application of quality management tools and techniques in SMIs”, International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, vol. 20, no. 7, pp. 795–826. Anunibe, C. E. (2009). An appraisal of Total Quality Management (TQM). Journal
of Potential Business Administrators and Managers (JOPBAAMS), 111–116. Ater, J.A. (2013). Challenges facing the implementation of total quality management practices in public secondary and secondary in Kenya (A survey of schools in Migory county). Page 1–54. Ayandele, I.A and Akpan, (2015). The Practice, Challenges and Benefits of Total
Quality Management (TQM) In A Manufacturing Firms in Nigeria. International Journal of Economic and Business Management. Vol. 3(5), pp. 62–74. Brown, M.G., Hitchcock, D.E. and Willard, M.L. (1994). Why TQM fails and what to do about it, Irwin, Burr Ridge, Illinois. Dale, B.G., Van der Wiele, T., Van Iwaarden, J. (2007). Managing Quality, 5th
edition, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing Ltd. pp. 134–137. Esin Sadikoglu and Hilal Olcay (2014). The Effects of Total Quality Management Practices on Performance and the Reasons of and the Barriers to TQM Practices in Turkey. Advances in Decision Sciences Volume 2014. Ezeani, N.S and Ibijola, E.Y (2017). Prospects And Problems of Total Quality Mana-
gement on the Productivity and Profitability of Manufacturing Organizations. European Journal of Research and Reflection in Management Sciences. Vol. 5 No. 1. Gharakhani, D., Rahmati ,H., Farrokhi, M. , Farahmandian, A. (2013). Total Quality Management and Organizational Performance, American Journal of Industrial Engineering, Vol. 1, No. 3, 46–50. DOI: 10.12691/ajie-1-3-2 Hamidi, Y. and Zamanparvar, A. (2008). Quality management in health systems of
developed and developing countries; which approaches and models are appropri- ate? JRHS, 8(2): 40–50 Jacobsen, J. (2008), Avoiding mistakes of the past: lessons learned on what makes or breaks quality initiatives, The Journal for Quality and Participation, Vol. 31 No. 2, p. 49. Johnson, S., Kleiner, B., (2013) TQM can encompass success Industrial Management,
Volume 55, Issue 2, pp. 27–30 Kodua and Imrith (2016). Effects of Total Quality Management Implementation in a Manufacturing Industry. Risk Governance & Control: Financial Markets & Institutions. Volume 6, Issue 4. Kosgei, J.M. (2014). Challenges Facing the Implementation of Total Quality Manage-
ment in Secondary Schools: A Case of Eldoret East District, Kenya, Global Journal of Human Resource Management, 3 (1), 12–18 Lakhal, L, Pasin, F. and Liman M. (2006). Quality management practices and their impact on performance. International Journal of Quality &Reliability Mana- gement, 23(6): 625–646. Lam, S.S.K. (1995). Quality management and job satisfaction: an empirical study. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 12(4): 72–78.
Factors Affecting Total Quality Management Implementation in the Construction Industry 147
Osadebe, A. E. (2010). Implications of Total Quality Management on the Performance of Business Organizations, Unpublished Manuscript Panuwatwanich, K. & Nguyen, T.T. (2017). Influence of Total Quality Manage-
ment on performance of Vietnamese construction firms. Procedia Engineering, 182, 548–555. Prajojo, D.J. & McDermott, C.M. (2005). The relationship between total quality management practices and organisation culture. International Journal of Operation Production Management, 25(11), 1101–1122. Rosa, M.J. and Amaral, A. (2007) A Self-Assessment of Higher Education Institu-
tions from the Perspective of the TQM Excellence Model. In: Westerheijen, D.F., Stensaker, B. and Rosa, M.J., Eds., Quality Assurance in Higher Education: Trends in Regulation, Sulaman, Q and Gul, R. (2015). Challenges to Successful Total Quality Management Implementation in Public Secondary Schools: A Case Study of Kohat District, Pakistan. Journal of Education and Practice. Vol. 6, No. 15. Talib, F. (2013). An Overview of Total Quality Management: Understanding the
Fundamentals in Service Organization. International Journal of Advanced Quality Management 2013, Volume 1, Issue 1, pp. 1–20.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors in Management and Leadership
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-31-5
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional