Babatunde Fatai Ogunbayo, Clinton Aigbavboa, Opeoluwa Akinradewo, Olusegun Oguntona, Didi Thwala (2022). Validation of Maintenance Management Core Elements for Higher Educational Institution Buildings in developing Countries Education Sector. In: Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure. AHFE Open Access, vol. 58, pp. 316–322. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002367
1 Cidb Center of Excellence and Sustainable Human Settlement and Construction Research Center, Faculty of Engineering and the Built Environment, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa ↗
2 Department of Built Environment, Walter Sisulu University, Eastern Cape, South Africa ↗
3 Department of Civil Engineering, College of Science, Engineering and Technology, University of South Africa (UNISA), Pretoria, South Africa ↗
Maintenance management (MM) is a preventive management philosophy that provides a platform to retain assets value, improve life quality, improve risk cost and productivity in maintenance organisations. Given this contextual setting, the study examines whether core elements of MM utilised in developed countries are relevant in developing countries, using higher education institutional (HEI) buildings in the Nigeria education sector as a case study. In obtaining data for this study, an empirical research design was employed. Precisely, a Delphi study piloted showed eight (8) core elements that influence effective maintenance management of HEI buildings in Nigeria. Of these eight (5) cores elements, five (5) of the elements have a very high influence on maintenance management of HEI buildings (VHI: 9.00 -10.00), and three (3) other elements had a high influence (HI: 7.00-8.99). The key finding from the study reveals that the core elements that influence maintenance management of HEI buildings include organisational maintenance policies, maintenance budget, human resources management, training, monitoring and supervision, maintenance information, communication among stakeholders, and maintenance culture. The study's finding indicated that these core elements are related to those of other countries, and effective MM of HEI buildings in developing countries education sectors is guaranteed when these core elements are integrated into the maintenance processes and operations.
In ensuring building optimal performance over its life cycle, there is a need for an effective maintenance system. Based on the important maintenance aspect, this paper defines maintenance as the essential services and proces- ses carried out to care for a building structure and its attached components.
Validation of Maintenance Management Core-Elements 317
According to Lateef (2009), maintenance is the required services undertaken after completion, refurbishment, repair, or replacement to current standards of a building to serve its anticipated functions throughout its entire life- span without affecting its basic features and function. Wahab et al. (2013) postulated that maintenance is required in a building to sustain its value and keep it acceptable. Maintenance is an arrangement that helps the buil- ding fulfill its usage and purpose (Ogunbayo et al., 2019). One thing that is common to both definitions is that maintenance is a continuous activity that is important to both in-used and proposed buildings. It shows that maintenance helps a building preserve all its attached components and its auxiliaries’ structure and services to their original status as required by the users. However, on the other hand, management is the process of engaging in the four major functions of planning, organising, leading, and control- ling in attaining organisational set goals (Martin, 1998). It is also intended to achieve organisational objectives through working with other people to obtain the most from the available resources (Ogunbayo et al., 2021). Main- tenance Management is fundamentally a preventive management philosophy that can be considered a function that provides the opportunity to retain quality, life, and value of building and improve risk, cost, and production concern in maintenance organisation (Karia et al., 2014). In concept, effe- ctive MM will positively affect maintenance organisations by improving their operations cost and productivity (Spedding 1994). The significance of MM within maintenance organisations in maintaining buildings and other atta- ched components cannot be over-emphasised. The significance of MM in the maintenance process is to support the core business process through workable human resources management (Ogunbayo et al., 2018). The signi- ficance of MM in maintaining buildings is to make sure that buildings and their attached components are performing well (Amaratunga, 2000). MM within an organisation should be dynamic, capable, and straightforward of periodic review as the needs arise to technological advancements and users value system (Basari, 2009). It involves the combinations of technical and administrative action and supervision actions anticipated to keep an item (building) in or restore it to a state where it can perform the required function (Arditi, 1999). As shown above, the significance of MM indicates that MM needs people with technical knowledge, a variety of skills, and site experie- nce (Takata et al., 2004). Because of the significance of MM toward running a proper maintenance process, researchers have identified different core ele- ments for an effective maintenance process in their study (Cobbinah, 2010). In identifying core elements for MM appropriate for maintaining buildings and other structures, the researchers have different opinions. The MM model, as developed by Campbell (1995), showed that the MM core elements would include: organisational maintenance policy, human resources management, monitory and supervision, maintenance information system (MIS), main- tenance budget, and training. Wireman (2005) model indicates that MM core elements will include: organisational maintenance policy, MIS, provision of spare parts; training; maintenance approach; human resources manage- ment; maintenance budget; monitoring and supervision. Takata’s life cycle maintenance model (2004) shows that the MM core elements include spare
part management, monitory and supervision, outsource strategy, training, human resources management, and maintenance budget. The supporting structure pillars model by Marques et al. (2006) also specifies that the MM core elements will include MIS, outsource strategy, organisational mainte- nance policy, human resources management, monitoring and supervision, training, and maintenance budget. However, Faghihinia [29] noted that all these identified MM core elements are more like guidelines or strategies for maintenance decisions with maintenance operation and process. However, the review shows that different MM core elements influence MM’s effecti- veness (Oke et al., 2006). Nevertheless, there are varying interpretations of the specific core elements that constitute MM of buildings. Hence, this study provides a holistic framework that combines the different models for develo- ping practical MM core elements for maintenance operations, especially for MM of HEI of buildings in developing countries’ education sector.
METHODOLOGY
This study employed the Delphi techniques in affirming the core elements of MM for the maintenance of HEI buildings in the Nigerian education sector. The Delphi study applies to both qualitative and quantitative academic rese- arch (Ogunbayo et al., 2022). As a research tool, its usage involves using a structured questionnaire to solicit selected expert panellists’ opinions, with the consensus built from their responses through rounds of the questionnaire (Fletcher et al., 2014). The Delphi technique is essential for capturing data in qualitative and quantitative studies (Aigbavboa, 2014). The strength of the qualitative and qualitative study is anchored on the scrupulous methodo- logy (Leung, 2001). Hence, quantitative was used in this study and adapted detailed Delphi process as suggested by (Ogunbayo et al., 2022). To ascertain relevant core elements of MM that influence the maintenance of HEI buil- dings in the developing countries’ education sector, the relevant literature on the subject matter was first reviewed. As detailed in Aigbavboa (2014) study, experts were then selected to represent a broad spectrum of opinions on the subject under investigation. In achieving a comprehensive outcome for the Delphi study, the experts were drawn from industry and academia based on their practical experience and adequate theoretical knowledge of buil- ding maintenance works and processes (Somiah et al., 2020). In selecting the experts for the study, purposive non –probability sampling was adopted, and the selection was based on the researcher’s experience, knowledge, and desi- rable respondents’ characteristics (Leung, 2001). In all, fifteen (15) experts participated in the Delphi survey. The sample size of fifteen (15) experts was considered suitable and used for this study based on the recommendation of the previous studies that 10-15 participant provides adequate coverage in Delphi studies (Loo, 2002). The Delphi survey was structured on a 10-points influence scale: where 1-2 signify no influence; 3-4 signify low influence; 5- 6 signify medium impact; 7-8 signify high influence, and 9-10 denote very high impact. The Delphi survey calculated and analyzed an appraised stati- cal view of the experts’ panelist using mean, median, standard deviation, and interquartile deviation.
Validation of Maintenance Management Core-Elements 319
Table 1. Delphi survey results–elements of maintenance management.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
MM core-elements Median Mean
IQD Mean scores
(¯x) (M)
Standard deviation
ranking (R)
(σx)
9 9.12 0.50 0.00 1
Organizational maintenance policies
9 8.54 0.81 1.00 5
Maintenance budget 8 8.35 0.87 1.00 8 Human resources management
8 8.38 0.88 1.00 7
Training factors 9 8.68 0.47 1.00 4 Monitoring and supervision
8 8.47 0.50 1.00 6
Maintenance information system
9 8.80 0.40 0.05 3
Communication among stakeholders Maintenance culture 9 8.86 0.34 0.00 2
RESULT OF THE DELPHI STUDY As shown in Table 1, the elements of MM in the Delphi survey result were constituted by eight (8) core elements. Among the eight (8) core elements, four (4) elements which are: organisational maintenance policy’, maintenance cul- ture, ‘communication among stakeholders,’ ‘training factors,’ and ‘human resources management and were ranked very high impact (VHI: 9.00-10.00) by the panellists with a median score of nine (9), while three (3) other core-elements which are: ‘maintenance information system,’ ‘monitoring and supervision, and ‘maintenance budget’ were ranked by the panellists to have a high impact (HI: 7.00-8.99). Besides, consensus levels among the elements varied, while the standard deviation scores among the elements suggest strong consistency levels and little variability in the panellists’ responses.
DISCUSSION
This study aims to establish whether MM’s core elements (found in other countries) that influence MM are relevant to the MM of HEI buildings in the Nigerian education sector. Eight elements (8) of MM were identified. Among the eight (8) elements, five (5) elements have a very high impact with a median score range (VHI: 9:00-10.00), while three (3) other elements had a high impact (HI: 7.00-8.99). Although the level of consensus varied among the ele- ments, the IQD scores indicate consensus, with the IQD being ≤1 for all the eight (8) core-elements elements. Similarly, the elements’ respective standard deviation (σx) indicates consistency in the experts’ responses as their respe- ctive σx values were at most (1). Out of the eight (8) core-elements, the five elements (5) that recorded (VHI: 9.00-10.00) were: ‘organisational mainte- nance policy’ with mean value (¯x) value of (+9.12) ranked first, maintenance culture with ¯x of (8.86) ranked second, ‘communication among stakehol- ders’ with ¯x of (8.80) ranked third, ‘training factors’ with ¯x of (8.68) ranked
fourth, and ‘human resources management with ¯x of (8.54) ranked fifth as core-elements that influence the MM of HEI buildings in the Nigeria edu- cation sector. This finding is similar to findings of the studies by (Campbell, 1995; Takata et al., 2004; Wireman, 2005). Relatively, three (3) other core- elements that recorded (HI: 7.00-8.99) were: ‘MIS’ with ¯x of (8.47) ranked sixth, monitoring and supervision with ¯x of (8.38) ranked seventh, and main- tenance budget with ¯x (8.35) ranked eighth as core-elements that influence MM of HEI buildings in the Nigeria education sector. This finding is con- sistent with those presented by (Campbell, 1995; Wireman, 2005; Marquez et al., 2006). Subsequently, finding from the study shows that all the eight (8) core elements validated by the panellists’ recorded good consensus with five (5) of the core-element had very high influence score (VHI: 9.00-10.00) with RII value of 0.80-1.00 and IQD value of ≤1. While the other three (3) core elements had a high influence score (HI: 7.00-8.99) with an RII value of 0.60-0.79 and IQD of ≥1, 1≤2. Consequently, these eight core elements influence MM of HEI buildings within the developing countries’ education sector.
CONCLUSION
This study was carried out to validate MM core elements for MM of HEI of buildings in the education sector of developing countries. The expert pan- elists appraised the eight (8) core elements of MM that were perceived to have influenced MM. All the core elements evaluated were found to have influenced the MM of HEI buildings in the developing countries’ education sector. Moreover, these elements were coherent with MM core elements that have been identified in earlier studies and some national contexts. Hence, the study recommends that the following elements are significant in develo- ping MM to maintain HEI buildings in the developing countries’ education sector. Namely: organisational maintenance policies; maintenance budget; human resources management; training factors; monitoring and supervision; maintenance information system; communication among stakeholders and maintenance culture. The study concluded that the MM core elements that determine MM of HEI building in the developing countries’ education sector are largely similar to other geographical contexts. Additionally, based on the findings of this study, an effective MM of HEI buildings is guaranteed if there is a serious consideration of these core elements in the development of MM for the maintenance of the HEI buildings in the developing countries’ education sector.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge the cidb Centre of Excellence, Faculty of Engineering, and the Built Environment, University of Johannesburg, South Africa.
Validation of Maintenance Management Core-Elements 321
REFERENCES
Ab Wahab, Y., Basari, A. S. H., and Samad, A. (2013). Building maintenance management preliminary finding of a case study in Icym. Middle-East Journal of Science Research, 1260–1268. Aigbavboa, C. O. (2014). An integrated beneficiary-centered satisfaction model for
publicly funded housing schemes in South Africa. Published doctoral dissertation, University of Johannesburg. Amaratunga, D. and Baldry, D (2000). Assessment of facilities management performance in higher education properties, Facilities, 18 (7/8), 293–301. Arditi, D., and Nawakorawit, M. (1999). Designing buildings for maintenance:
designers’ perspective. Journal of Architectural Engineering, 5(4), 107–116. Basari, A. S. H. (2009). Maintenance modeling tools with special to incomplete data, published doctoral dissertation, Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka (UTeM), Malaysia). Campbell, J.D. (1995), “Outsourcing in maintenance management: A valid alter-
native to self-provision,” Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, Vol. 1 No. 3, pp. 18–24. Cobbinah, P. J. (2010). Maintenance of Buildings of Public Institutions in Ghana.
Case Study of Selected Institutions in the Ashanti Region of Ghana. Published doctoral dissertation, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology. Faghihinia, E., and Mollaverdi, N. (2012). Building a maintenance policy through a multi-criterion decision-making model. Journal of Industrial Engineering Interna- tional, 8(1), 1–15. Fletcher, A. J., and Marchildon, G. P. (2014). Using the Delphi method for qualita-
tive, participatory action research in health leadership. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 13(1), 1–18. Karia, N., Asaari, M. H. A. H., and Saleh, H.: Exploring Maintenance Management in Service Sector: a Case Study. In Proceedings of International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operation Management, 7–9 January, Bali, Indonesia, pp. 3119–3128. Lateef, O. A. (2009). Building maintenance management in Malaysia. Journal of
Building Appraisal, 4(3), 207–214. Leung, W. C. (2001). How to design a questionnaire, University of East Anglia: BMJ, 322: 1-9 (Suppl S6). Loo, R. (2002). The Delphi method: a powerful tool for strategic management.
Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management.., 25 (4), 762–769. Marquez, A. C., and Gupta, J. N. (2006). Contemporary maintenance management: process, framework, and supporting pillars. Omega, 34(3), 313–326. Martin, D. C., & Bartol, K. M. (1998). Performance appraisal: Maintaining system
effectiveness. Public Personnel Management, 27(2), 223–230. Ogunbayo, B. F., Aigbavboa, C. O., Amusan, L. M., Ogundipe, K. E., and Akinradewo, O. I. (2021). Appraisal of facility provisions in public-private partnership housing delivery in southwest Nigeria. African Journal of Reproductive Health, 25. Ogunbayo, B. F., Ajao, A. M., ALAGBE, O. T., Ogundipe, K. E., Tunji-Olayeni, P. F.,
& Ogunde, A. (2018). Residents’facilities Satisfaction In Housing Project Deli- vered By Public-Private Partnership (Ppp) In Ogun State, Nigeria. International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET), 9(1), 562–577.
Ogunbayo, B. F., & Aigbavboa, O. C. (2019). Maintenance requirements of students’ residential facility in higher educational institution (HEI) in Nigeria. In IOP Con- ference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (Vol. 640, No. 1, p. 012014). IOP Publishing. Ogunbayo, B.F., Ohis Aigbavboa, C., Thwala, W.D. and Akinradewo, O.I. (2022),
“Assessing maintenance budget elements for building maintenance management in Nigerian built environment: a Delphi study,” Built Environment Project and Asset Management, Vol. ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-print. Oke, S. A., & Charles-Owaba, O. E. (2006). An approach for evaluating preventive maintenance scheduling cost. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management. 23 (7), 847–879. Somiah, M. K., Aigbavboa, C. O., & Thwala, W. D. (2021). Validating elements
of competitive intelligence for competitive advantage of construction firms in Ghana: A Delphi study. African Journal of Science, Technology, Innovation and Development, 13(3), 377–386. Spedding, A., & Holmes, R. Facilities management (1994). CIOB Book of Facilities Management, London: Longman Scientific & Technical. Takata, S., Kirnura, F., van Houten, F. J., Westkamper, E., Shpitalni, M., Ceglarek,
D., and Lee, J. (2004). Maintenance: changing role in life cycle management. CIRP annuals, 53 (2), 643–655. Wireman, T. (2005). Developing performance indicators for managing maintenance.
New York: Industrial Press Inc.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-34-6
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional