Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

A Comparison of Physical Environmental Design/Assessment Methods in Elderly Care Facilities between UK and China

School of Architecture, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L69 7ZN, UK ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1002338

Abstract

This study presented a comparative analysis of design/assessment methods of elderly care facility between UK and China, including eleven British instruments and three Chinese instruments, which were achieved using a systematic review. Two typical assessment methods were chosen to conduct a cross-country comparison, such as EVOLVE (UK) and CASCO (China). Compared with the British instrument, the Chinese method focused on the facility management; there was a clear lack of practical strategies for planning and assessing environmental performances. It is necessary to carry on more studies to develop reliable and valid assessment methods in Chinese elderly care facilities.

INTRODUCTION

The physical environment is critical to the achievement of health and well- being, safety, and independence among older people living in residential care facilities (RCFs) (WHO 1997). In the care home industry, it is generally required to conduct an assessment for the quality of physical environment of elderly care facilities across their planning, construction, and post-occupancy stages. From 1992 to 2020, several key assessment schemes have been produced in UK, such as Sheffield Care Environment Assessment Matrix (SCEAM) (Parker et al. 2004), Evaluation of Older People’s Living Environ- ments (EVOLVE) (Lewis et al. 2010, Orrell et al. 2013), etc. These schemes were applied to evaluate the design of institutional housing for older peo- ple, and how well a building contributes to physical support and personal well-being. In China, from 1999 to 2019, the Ministry of Civil Affairs has issued 16 building codes to guide the development of elderly care facilities (www.gov.cn/fuwu/zt/ylfw), which are mainly used for the rating of these facilities.

This paper aimed to implement a cross-country comparative analysis of assessment methods between UK and China and tried to identify their differences according to the applications in practice.

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 91

92 Li and Du

Table 1. Names and abbreviations of 14 assessment methods.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Name of instrument Abbreviation

SAECE

Scales for the Assessment of Environments for the Confused Elderly Dementia Care Mapping DCM Sheffield Care Environment Assessment Matrix SCEAM Assessment of Residential Environments CARE Extra Care Housing Toolkit ECHT Design Checks for people with dementia in healthcare premises DDC Evaluation of Older people’s Living Environments EVOLVE Design Audit Tool DAT Housing in later life: planning ahead for specialist housing for older people

EHE-DCT

Housing in later life Enhancing the Healing Environment dementia care tool for care homes

MCSSCO

Patient-Led Assessments of the Care PLACE Classification and accreditation for senior care organization CASCO Measurement of customer satisfaction for senior care organiza- tion

BSFPESCO

Basic Specification for falls prevention of the elderly in senior care organization

METHODS

This study was conducted using two steps. First, a systematic review was com- pleted to identify typical elderly facility assessment methods in UK and China, through the method of Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) (Moher et al. 2009; Page et al. 2021). Second, a cross-country comparative analysis (Cacace et al. 2013) was adopted to compare two representatives.

STUDY DESIGN AND SETTINGS This systematic review used the PICO principle (Schardt et al. 2007) to classify the search terms into four parts: 1) subjects: older people, senior population, care facility, nursing home, long-term care. 2) domain: physical environment, built environment, environment design, assessment, evalua- tion, survey, standard. 3) tool-related terms: scale, instrument, tool, toolkit. 4) countries: China, UK. A Boolean search strategy was applied based on a combination of these terms (Page et al. 2021). Databases applied inclu- ded China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Data (WD), China Science and Technology Journal Database (CSTJD), PubMed, Medline, PsycINFO, web of science, and Scopus, while Google scholar was used for the supplementary search. In addition, relevant building codes were also inclu- ded in the search. To be included in the review, papers should focus on older people, care facilities, built environment, and assessment method. For articles that were concerned with children, older people stay at home, assessment for design were excluded.

A Comparison of Physical Environmental Design/Assessment Methods 93

Table 2. 11 British instruments for elderly facility assessment.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Instruments Year Type of building Purpose SAECE (Bowie et al. 1992)

1992 Institutional care facilities

Evaluate the environment quality on long-stay wards for elderly patients with dementia. DCM (Brooker 2005) 1997 Dementia-care settings.

Improve practices in care homes for people with dementia. SCEAM (Parker et al. 2004)

2004 Residential care facilities.

Correlate building design features against an assessment of the quality of life of people living in care homes. CARE (Faulkner and Davies 2006)

2006 Care homes. Celebrate what works well in a home and identify areas that need attention. ECHT (Housing LIN 2006)

2006 Extra care housing. Help to plan extra housing and service provision. DDC (HFS 2007) 2007 All healthcare properties.

Assess suitability as accommodation for older people.

2010 Retirement villages, sheltered housing and individual private houses.

Ensure that the built environment does not present insurmountable barriers to its users. EVOLVE (Lewis et al. 2010, Orrell et al. 2013) DAT (Kelly et al. 2011)

For local planners and commissioners to use when planning for specialist housing for older people.

2011 Care homes. Examine the dementia care environments. Housing in later life (Housing 2012)

2012 Housing built to assist older people with their accommodation and support needs in later life.

How the environment or services might be enhanced.

PLACE (Flanagan et al. 2013)

2013 2019 Hospitals and hospices providing NHS-funded care in both the NHS and private/inde- pendent sectors.

2014 2020 Care homes. Creating more supportive care environments for people with cognitive problems and dementia.

EHE-DCT (Waller & Masterson 2015)

After articles screening, the assessment methods of elderly care facility were selected according to the following criteria: 1) The tool must have at least one domain associated with the environment. 2) The tool must evaluate multiple aspects of the environment. However, tools that were only used for assessing single element, such as noise, light, and thermal, will not be included. 3) The tool must be applied in UK or China. 4) Tools that were not written in English or Chinese were excluded.

94 Li and Du

SEARCH OUTCOMES Based on the systematic review, 335 articles were found. Through scree- ning and analysis, 14 assessment methods were selected for a period of 1992~2022, including 11 from UK and three from China.

RESULT

ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT METHODS IN UK AND CHINA The 14 assessment methods and their abbreviations were listed in Table 1. In addition, Table 2 and Table 3 showed more details of these methods in UK and China, respectively.

For the 11 British methods (Table 2), six instruments were developed for assessing the built environment in elderly care homes, such as SCEAM (Par- ker et al. 2004), EVOLVE (Lewis et al. 2010, Orrell et al. 2013), and CARE (Faulkner and Davies 2006). Three instruments were specifically designed for evaluating the environment in dementia care settings, such as SAECE (Bowie et al. 1992), DCM (Brooker 2005), and EHE-DCT (Waller and Master- son 2015). One instrument PLACE was used for the buildings in the NHS healthcare system (Flanagan et al. 2013).

Given methods in Chinese elderly care facilities (Table 3), some studies examined the environmental assessment instruments translated from English as reliable and valid, such as PCQ-P (Fang et al. 2020) and TOPAS (Li et al. 2021). There were three codes available in China: CASCO (Classification and accreditation for senior care organization) (SAMR 2018), MCSSCO (Mea- surement of customer satisfaction for senior care organization) (MOCAC 2019), and BSFPESCO (Basic Specification for falls prevention of the elderly in senior care organization) (MOCAC 2022). However, no studies relating to the evaluation of these codes can be found in China.

CASCO can be used to assess the physical environment and services of elderly care facility, while MCSSCO was mainly applied for general servi- ces of elderly care facility (only 10% of items for the physical environment). BSFPESCO focused on specific risks occurring in elderly care environment.

Table 3. Three Chinese instruments for elderly facility assessment.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Instruments Year Type of Purpose building

CASCO (SAMR 2018) 2019 Senior care organization

A practical evaluation tool for conducting the rating process of elderly care organizations. MCSSCO (MOCAC 2019)

2019 Senior care organization

Assessing the satisfaction of the residents living in senior care organizations and make an improvement to the quality of services and facilities in the organizations. BSFPESCO (MOCAC 2022)

2022 Senior care organization

Provide the basic requirements for fall prevention and the fall risk assessment scale.

A Comparison of Physical Environmental Design/Assessment Methods 95

Table 4. Comparison of main characteristics between EVOVLE and CASCO.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

EVOLVE CASCO

A practical evaluation tool for conducting the rating process of elderly care facilities

Year of publication 2010 2019 Purpose Evaluating the design of housing schemes or individual dwellings to assess their suitability as accommodation for older people.

All types of elderly care facilities

Subjects Retirement villages, sheltered housing and individual private houses, excluding residential care homes and nursing homes.

Developer Developed by the University of Sheffield, with PSSRU, University of Kent and supported by the Housing LIN.

Total score.

Department of Social Welfare and Charity Promotion, Ministry of Civil Affairs, Social Welfare Centre, Ministry of Civil Affairs, China Institute of Public Welfare, Beijing Normal University. Using stage Design stage or using stage. Using stage. Scoring Yes, no, not in use, n/a. Scoring, different scores depending on what is being assessed. Evaluation results Scores are given numerically and shown as a histogram, with the length of the bar representing the highest possible score attainable in that domain.

Assessors Architects, housing providers, commissioners, individuals, and researchers.

Familiar with relevant laws and policies, familiar with the work of elderly services, and have undergone rating training and passed the assessment. Using methods Walk-in. Commissioned assessment agency or self-assessment. Domains 2 domains: Universal, Older people’s requirements.

565 questions.

4 domains: Environment, Equipment and facilities, Operation Management, Services. Questions 487 items for a single dwelling; about 2000 items for a housing scheme.

96 Li and Du

Table 5. Comparison of domain ratio between EVOVLE and CASCO.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Domain EVOVLE CASCO

49.8% 19.3%

Environment. 32.1% 17.7% Equipment and facilities (layout, services and systems, fitting and building elements of accommo- dation).

Management. 8.0% 21.1% Health services. 0% 41.9% Others (changing rooms, finishes). 10.1% 0%

A CROSS-COUNTRY COMPARISON OF ASSESSMENT METHODS In this study, we selected one assessment instrument as a representative from each country for a comparison. The principles for the instrument selection were as follows: 1) The instrument is still in use, 2) The instrument can be applied for various types of care facility, and 3) The instrument has public- access questionnaire. Thus, EVOLVE (UK) and CASCO (China) were finally chosen based on these criteria.

According to the Table 4, there were some differences found between EVO- LVE and CASCO. 1) Types of care facilities: EVOLVE can be applied to assess environmental qualities in retirement villages, sheltered housing, and individual private houses while excluding residential care homes and nursing homes. All types of residential care facilities in China can be evaluated using CASCO, including care homes, care retirement communities, nursing homes attached to a medical institution, and apartment buildings for older people. 2) Scoring systems: a qualitative scoring method is adopted in the EVOLVE (Yes, No, Not in use and n/a), while CASCO adopts a complex quantitative system (scoring on each item; a total score will be calculated for the final assessment).

Table 5 indicated significant differences in domain between the two instru- ments. In terms of the ‘environment’, CASCO has only 17.7% items to justify the performance in care facilities, while there were 32.1% items in EVO- LVE for this assessment. EVOLVE has a higher item percentage set for the ‘layout, services and systems, fitting and building elements of accommoda- tion’ (49.8%), compared with the value of 19.3% for CASCO. As for the part of ‘management’, CASCO has 21.1% items, which is higher than the value in EVOLVE (8%). There are 42.0% items used for the ‘health services’ in CASCO. No items can be found for this domain in EVOLVE.

CONCLUSION

Based on the comparison, it can be found: the British system focused on the environmental and architectural characteristics of care facilities, while the environmental management of care facilities was emphasized in Chinese systems. In addition, the systematic review showed that most assessment methods of Chinese care facilities used self-define tools, which were not public access and therefore not fully discussed in this article. In general,

A Comparison of Physical Environmental Design/Assessment Methods 97

compared with the British system, the Chinese methods had a clear lack of practical guidelines to support planning and assessing the environmental factors. Thus, more research is still needed to improve the assessment method of elderly care facility in China.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The authors thank fund support from China Scholarship Council and University of Liverpool.

REFERENCES

Bowie, P., Mountain, G., & Clayden, D. (1992). Assessing the environmental quality of long-stay wards for the confused elderly. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 7(2), 95–104. Brooker, D. (2005). Dementia care mapping: a review of the research literature. The

gerontologist, 45(suppl_1), 11–18. Cacace, M., Ettelt, S., Mays, N., & Nolte, E. (2013). Assessing quality in crosscountry comparisons of health systems and policies: towards a set of generic quality criteria. Health Policy, 112(1-2), 156–162. Fang, J., Yao, J., Huang, W., and Liu, Y. (2020). Reliability and Validity of the Chi-

nese Version of Person-Centered Climate Questionnaire (Patient Version). Nursing Journal of Chinese People’s Liberation Army, 37(6), 16–19. (in Chinese). Faulkner, M., & Davies, S. (2006). The CARE (Combined Assessment of Residential Environments) profiles: a new approach to improving quality in care homes. Quality in Ageing and Older Adults. Flanagan, P., Williamson, N., Grocott, R., & Scaife, G. (2013). 011 A Hospice Expe-

rience of Patient-Led Assessments of the Care and Environment. BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care, 3(Suppl 1), A4–A5. HFS (Health Facilities Scotland). (2007). Dementia Design Checklist Design checks for people with dementia in healthcare premises. www.nss.nhs.scot/media/1567. (final access: 01/12/2021). Housing LIN. (2006). Extra Care Housing Toolkit. CSIP. www.housinglin.org.uk/Topics/type/Extra-Care-Housing-Toolkit (final access: 01/12/2021). Housing LIN. (2012). Housing in later life: planning ahead for specialist housing for

older people. www.housinglin.org.uk/Topics/type/Housing-in-later-life-planning- ahead-for-specialist-housing-for-older-people. (final access: 01/12/2021). Kelly, F., Innes, A., & Dincarslan, O. (2011). Improving care home design for people with dementia. Journal of Care Services Management, 5(3), 147–155. Lewis, A., Torrington, J., Barnes, S., Darton, R., Holder, J., McKee, K., Netten, A.

& Orrell, A. (2010). EVOLVE: a tool for evaluating the design of older people’s housing. Housing, Care and Support, 13, 36–41. Li, C. P., Lee, S. F., Bergland, Å., and Edvardsson, D. (2021). Psychometric properties of the Chinese version thriving of older people assessment scale. International Journal of Older People Nursing, 16(1), e12346. MOCAC (Ministry of Civil Affairs of the People’s Republic of China). (2019). Mea-

surement of Customer Satisfaction for Senior Care Organization. Beijing, China. (MZ/T 133-2019). MOCAC (Ministry of Civil Affairs of the People’s Republic of China). (2022). Basic Specification for falls prevention of the elderly in senior care organization. Beijing, China. (MZ/T 185-2021).

98 Li and Du

Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G., and Prisma Group. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS medicine, 6(7), e1000097. Orrell, A., McKee, K., Torrington, J., Barnes, S., Darton, R., Netten, A., & Lewis, A.

(2013). The relationship between building design and residents’ quality of life in extra care housing schemes. Health & Place, 21, 52–64. Page, M. J., McKenzie, J. E., Bossuyt, P. M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T. C., Mulrow, C. D., and Moher, D. (2021). The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ, 372n71. Parker, C., Barnes, S., McKee, K., Morgan, K., Torrington, J., & Tregenza, P. (2004).

Quality of life and building design in residential and nursing homes for older people. Ageing and Society, 24, 941–962. SAMR (State Administration for Market Regulation). (2018). Classification and Accreditation for Senior Care Organization. Beijing, China. (GB/T 37276-2018). Schardt, C., Adams, M. B., Owens, T., Keitz, S., & Fontelo, P. (2007). Utilization of

the PICO framework to improve searching PubMed for clinical questions. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 7, 16. Waller, S., & Masterson, A. (2015). Designing dementia-friendly hospital environments. Future Hospital Journal, 2(1), 63. WHO (World Health Organization). (1997). WHOQOL: Measuring quality of life.

Geneva: WHO/MSA/MNH/PSF/97.4. Switzerland.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-34-6

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →