Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction: Insights for proactive interaction Design

College of design and innovation, Tongji University, Shanghai, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1003804

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly evolving, and systems are becoming more proficient in collaborating with humans. These systems not only respond to users' requests but can also anticipate their potential needs and meet them. However, the understanding of proactivity in the context of human-vehicle interaction is limited, and existing research is based on common sense rather than a clear concept of proactivity. In this study, we explore the theme and concept of proactivity in human-vehicle interaction through a literature review and case study. We also provide insights about the content that needs to be designed for proactive interaction. The study's findings will help researchers and designers better comprehend proactive interaction in the new relationships between humans and vehicles and support interaction design in this field.

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this paper is to explore the concept of proactive interaction from existing literature and illustrate its application in proactive interaction design. By doing so, we aim to enhance the comprehension of proactive interaction design. Furthermore, we intend to identify the content of human vehicle pro- active interaction, which can be leveraged to create effective and efficient proactive interaction designs.

THE RELATED WORKS OF PROACTIVITY To explore the means of proactivity in human-vehicle interaction, we fol- low the prior study in many different disciplines, including human-computer interaction(HCI), human-robot interaction(HRI), human-vehicle interaction, and occupational psychology. It’s worth understanding one term from diffe- rent views in different contexts. We choose 20 critical papers from hundred related papers for inductive analysis.

We summarize information from a set of research papers, and categories them including author, year, context, description, discipline, and keywords in Table 1. The context is the proactivity-related context in the paper. The description is the proactivity-related description in the paper. Keywords are

© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 182

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction 183 Continued

User preferences, give suggestion

Respond to external stimuli, humans are

above the loop, human supervised,

Understanding user behavior and the

world.

and appropriate are the important

features in proactive assistant

Context-sensitive, behalf of user,

initiatinon autonomously, cause changes

rather than react

metrics, system making suggestion and

decision

Action in advance, anticipatory action,

system-initiated behaviour; future

situation Explicit, and implicit proactive assistance are extended the

described basic functionalities by collecting user

preferences and suggesting appropriate meals to users.

using sensors and actuators, respond to external stimuli at

faster-than-human speeds, and move from human-centered

to human-supervised (or even unsupervised) computing.”

“By proactive, we mean that the assistant, in addition to

answering queries, will make unsolicited suggestions.” Unsolicited suggestions, understandable

“Proactive behaviors are intended to cause changes, rather

than just to react to changes. Two critical features of

proactive system: behalf of user, taking initiative

autonomously, without user’s explicit command.”

This work frame proactivity by using responsibility for

taking action. Agent solely responsible for acting,

“Proactivity in technical systems is an autonomous,

anticipatory system-initiated behaviour, with the purpose

to act in advance of a future situation, rather than only

reacting to it.”

This work examined the effects of interface

assistants as compared to traditional

documentation in helping people use an unfamiliar

text-editing tool. The proactive suggestion of the

assistant did not improve performance but was

viewed as helpful.

suggest a typology that distinguishes between 6

modes of proactive resource management.

that expresses potential balances of proactivity

between the user and the system. They also consider

the associated metrics.

systems and how these influence the effectiveness of

turn-taking.

proactive dialogue strategies on user acceptance and

UX.

proposal three loci for proactive computing. “Will be intimately connected to the world around them by

HCI

Table 1. The description of proactivity in different disciplines.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

No.Authorsyear Context Description Key words

1(Tennenhouse, 2000) Describe a new paradigm for computer systems and

2(Xiao, Catrambone and

Stasko, 2003)

3(Salovaara and Oulasvirta, 2004) This work clarify the concept of proactivity and

4(Isbell and Pierce, 2005) Presents an interface-proactivity (IP) continuum

5(Nothdurft, Ultes and Minker, 2015) Present the challenges of proactiveness in dialogue

6(Kraus et al., 2020) Present an empirical study on the effects of

184 Li and Sun

Continued

Automatic levels, information levels, user

attention, user’s attention resources

robots initiate, impact

impending needs

environment commences

Situation clue, identify requirement of

situation, acts instantly

“They developed proactivity in 5 levels based on the

robot’s automatic levels, the amount of information sent

by the robot through proactive behavior and the user’s

attention resources are used to implement the social

interaction.”

“Defined the proactivity as the anticipatory action that

robots initiate to impact themselves and/or others. “ Anticipation, autonomy dimensions,

“A proactive robot anticipated a user’s impending needs

and initiated an action to complete a task.” Anticipate, initiated by robot, user’s

“Proactive interaction in which the intelligent environment

commences interaction guided by its internal reasoning.” Internal reasonin(robot), intelligent

“Proactive robots: Robots which identify the requirement

of a certain situation and acts instantly without any

instructions from outside.”

proactivity in social robot behavior and a user’s

perception of anthropomorphic attributes. The

result indicated that all anthropomorphic attributes

of different proactivity levels have a significant

difference.

assistive robots and domotic environments. The

proactive interaction in more useful in emergency

and healthcare situation than on-demand

interactions and proactive suggestion situation.

This work assesses intelligent systems which were

capable of evaluating the emotional state of humans

prior to an interaction, and identifies the cues and

evaluation techniques that were utilized by such

intelligent agents to simulate and evaluate the

suitability of a proactive interaction.

3levels on user perceptions and interaction behaviors.

effect user perception. The result shows that having

a robot perform expressive movements greatly

affects how interaction is perceived by the user.

HRI

8(Cesta et al., 2007) This work evaluate elderly people’s perception of

11(Tan et al., 2020) This work explore the relationship between

Table 1. Continued.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

No.Authorsyear Context Description Key words

7(Mok et al., 2015) This work examines how proactivity and expression

9(Sirithunge, Jayasekara and

Chandima, 2019)

10(Peng et al., 2019) Evaluate the effects of DMS robot’s proactivity in

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction 185 Continued

supervised by the user, the right

information at the right time to the right

user, recommendations

Relies on contest, user not to submit any

request, current situation

Delivered without explicit user request;

explanations ; proactive

recommendations; comprehensibility

Context, drivers’ needs, preferences and

intentions

Active role in the scene, influential agent,

Proactive navigation

“Proactive systems works on tasks and is supervised by the

user, instead of the system answering user queries

interactively.”

“Proactivity means that the system pushes

recommendations to the user when the current situation

seems appropriate.”

“Proactive recommendations are delivered without explicit

user request. Adding explanations is a promising method

to improve the comprehensibility of a recommendation.”

“The next step in the development of proactive systems is

appearance of systems based on prediction of the user

behavior, his/her future locations or actions, as well as

situation recognition.”

“Proactive navigation is a major challenge on the way to

integrating the autonomous vehicle in the shared space as

an influential agent, taking an active role in the scene and

not merely reacting to it.”

mobile recommender systems, which relies on

domain-dependent context modeling in several

categories.

proactive recommender systems that can leverage

contextual information such as the driver’s location,

traffic conditions, weather, and time of day to

provide personalized recommendations.

of a proactive driver support approach that involves

continuous monitoring, analysis, intervention, and

adaptation to improve driver safety and

performance.

Establish a pedestrian-vehicle behavioral

model,which is capable of describing and predicting

agents’ behaviors when interacting with a vehicle in

both lateral and frontal crossing scenarios.

tailored to proactive recommendations in

automotive scenarios.

Human-vehicle interaction

Table 1. Continued.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

No.Authorsyear Context Description Key words

12(Bader, Woerndl and Prinz, 2010) Proposal a new model for situation awareness

13(Woerndl et al., 2011) This work introduce a model for proactivity in

14(Bader, 2013) Thesis development of a conceptual framework for

15(Smirnov, Shilov and Gusikhin, 2015) Regarding proactive interaction is the development

16(Kabtoul, Spalanzani and

Martinet, 2020)

186 Li and Sun

enviornment

Not passively adapting to conditions,

personal initiative

Proactive behavior, anticipatory action,

take to impact themselves and/or their

environments

Acting in anticipation, taking control,

self-initiation.

“Proactive behavior is behavior that directly to alters

environment.” Directly and intentionally change the

“Proactive behavior as taking initiative in improving

current circumstances or creating new ones; it involves

challenging the status rather than passively adapting to

present conditions.”

“Define proactive behavior as anticipatory action that

employees take to impact themselves and/or their

environments. Two characteristics of proactive behavior is

acting in advance and intended impact.”

“In most definitions of proactive behavior have 3

elements:acting in anticipation, taking control and

self-initiation.”

proactive behavior: proactive personality, personal

initiative, role breadth self-efficacy, and taking

charge.

generalize across specific manifestations of

proactivity, describing the nature, dimensions,

situational antecedents, psychological mechanisms,

dispositional moderators, and consequences of

proactive behavior.

interrelationships among multiple types of

proactive behavior.

toward proactive behavior. To enhance our

understanding and predicting of behaviors, we need

to declare proactive construct.

Occupational psychology

Table 1. Continued.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

No.Authorsyear Context Description Key words

17(Bateman and Crant, 1993) This study investigated a personal disposition

18(Crant, 2000) This work describe four constructs related to

19(Parker and Collins, 2010) This work develop a framework designed to

20(Parker and Collins, 2010) This work clarify the similarities, differences, and

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction 187

refined from the proactivity-related descriptions, it’s also an original label of the proactivity concept inductive analysis.

DEVELOPING CONCEPT OF PROACTIVE INTERACTION The Theme of Proactivity

We follow the coding process in inductive analysis (Thomas, 2003). The spe- cific segments are the proactivity-related description from the papers. Then, label the segments to create categories, which is the keywords in Table 2. Reduce overlap and redundancy among those categories to 18 categories, including context, human supervised, autonomy action, explanatory, take autonomous action, relevance, user agent, different from react, function list, understandable, anticipation, initiate by system(robot), impact, user’s needs, user preferences, action in advance, anticipatory action, metrics. Last, create a model incorporating most important categories to create five sum- mary categories, which is consider and manage context, anticipation and predictive ability, autonomy and action, understandability and transparency, proactive functions. 01 Consider and manage context: the system takes into account the user’s context, including their environment, device, activity, and task, to perception and comprehension of context, to support and inform its actions. 02 Autonomy and action: the system’s ability to use predictive analytics to anticipate user needs and preferences and initiate actions to impact others. 03 Anticipation and predictive ability: the system is designed to anticipate the user’s needs and preferences and take anticipatory actions, using predictive analytics and other technologies to improve its accuracy. 04 Understandability and transparency: in collaboration between the user and the system, the system should make its actions transparent and under- standable to the user, including providing feedback and explanations in plain language. In order to build trust and promote efficient collaboration, the system must provide transparent feedback and explanations that help the user understand what actions are being taken and why.

The 02 and 03 both concepts involve the system’s ability to use predictive analytics to anticipate user needs and preferences and take proactive actions. Autonomy and action emphasize the initiation action part; Anticipation and

Table 2. First categories and summary categories for inductive analysis.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

First categories Summary categories

Anticipation and predictive ability

Context, relevance, impact Consider and manage context Different from react, action in advance, anticipation, anticipatory action Autonomy and action Human supervised, take autonomous action, autonomy action, user agent, initiate by system(robot)

Understandability and transparency

Explanatory, understandable, metrics, user’s needs, user preferences Function list Proactive functions

188 Li and Sun

predictive ability emphasis understanding the reasons behind the initiation of the action and the contents and ways of the specific action that should be taken to meet the user’s needs and preferences.

The functions of proactivity are an important part of proactive interaction research, not belong to the theme of the proactivity concept.

Concept of Proactive Interaction in Autonomous Vehicles Following the theme of proactivity, we propose the concept of proactivity, which refers to the ability of a system to take initiative and act without prior prompting, based on an understanding of the user’s goals and the context in which they are operating. This can involve the system offering advice or taking control in a situation where it is deemed necessary to enhance safety, efficiency, or convenience.

To achieve this, the system must anticipate the user’s needs and prefere- nces based on their previous behavior and the current situation. This allows the system to provide personalized recommendations or assistance that are tailored to the user’s goals and preferences.

Furthermore, the system should communicate its knowledge of the user’s goals and the environmental context in a transparent and understanda- ble way, which can help to build trust and enhance the user’s engagement with the system. This is particularly important in the case of autonomous vehicles, where safety and trust are critical factors in user acceptance and adoption.

THE CASES OF PROACTIVE INTERACTION DESIGN IN VEHICLE MARKET Many brands now offer a range of features designed to improve safety and convenience. Tesla’s Autopilot system, Ford, Volkswagen Front Assist system, General Motors’ Super Cruise system, and Toyota’s Safety Sense system offers a range of proactive features, such as automatic braking to avoid collisions, pedestrian detection, proactive lane-keeping, automatic lane changing and speed control, automatic cruise control, smart parking that find available parking spaces and guide the driver to them. These features can improve safety and convenience by alerting drivers to potential hazards and taking action to prevent accidents.

Although proactive features have been shown to offer several benefits, it is important to conduct further research to determine how these features impact user experiences. Given the highly complex nature of the driving context, particularly with higher levels of autonomy, there may be greater scope for the design of proactive features that extend service-related content, such as actions based on users’ preferences and state, rerouting based on users’ goals and events, and other similar functions.

In some of its models, the BMW Vision iNEXT is equipped with a digital assistant that can help passengers with a variety of tasks, such as boo- king restaurant reservations, ordering groceries, and finding parking spots. MBUX (Mercedes-Benz User Experience) system learns user behavior based

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction 189

on sensor data and event and location information. The car will recom- mend these activities to the user at the appropriate time. HANA (Honda Automated Network Assistant) determines the driver’s current emotional state by analyzing body language, physical readings, and current actions. HANA can measure the driver’s emotions and provide music recommendati- ons or suggestions, as well as other media and entertainment options based on their mood. “Xiaodu Car OS Intelligent Scene Engine” developed by Baidu can recognize the current scene and suggest services based on that scene, such as recommending playlists, providing automatic appointment reminders for upcoming maintenance times, and implementing facial recognition automatic payment in payment scenarios.

Those many cases in the market take the form of a wide range of functions and services, the emphasis on the initiation of action is predictions of user’s needs in context is an important shifting and orientation.

THE CONTENTS OF PROACTIVE INTERACTION DESIGN IN AUTONOMOUS VEHICLE According to the concept and the functions and services related features, the design contents can be constructed. There are 3 parts involved. Anticipation of goal and need based on scenario, proactive behavior based on proactivity functions, and context-aware communication based on collaboration

Anticipation of Goal and Need Based on Scenario The driving scenario is the space where human-vehicle interaction occurs. Bringing the proactive interaction behavior of AVs into specific scenarios for analysis is a precondition for design and research. A typical scenario is one that is representative and has a high probability of occurrence in driving context.

The study recruited volunteers who were licensed drivers with at least two years driving and who drove frequently, with more than 50% of their weekly trips being by car. The volunteers were asked to use a GoPro camera to film a 15–30 minute driving video based on their daily activities. The driving videos we collected were primarily filmed in Shanghai, China, and San Francisco, California, the US. totaling 2 hours and 30 minutes in duration.

The collected video materials were then analyzed to classify the driving scenarios into purpose-driven scenarios, which have clear goals and involve activities such as commuting, traveling, and running errands, and function- driven events, which are fragmented and include tasks such as finding parking spaces, refueling, or answering phone calls. By analyzing the scenarios, the researchers identified the users’ goals and need in various driving scenarios, which helped establish a design target in proactive interaction design. The user goals of each scenario can be summarized in Table 3. These goals encom- pass eight types: information acquisition, problem-solving, making plans, executing plans, routine activities, status monitoring, security assistance, and information entertainment. Designers can refer to these effectively locate the user’s needs and align user goals at design time.

190 Li and Sun

Table 3. The goals of (1) purpose-driven scenarios and (2) function-driven events. (1) Purpose-driven scenarios User goals

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Commuting Get to work on time and relax on the way home. Business trips Arrive at the destination and avoid emergencies. Going to grocery Arrive at the destination and find an available parking lot. Traveling Arrive at the destination and enjoy the scenery along the way. Going to the hospital Arrive before the appointment time and find a parking space. Visiting friends Arrive at a friend’s house at the appointed time.

(2) Function-driven events User goals Traffic jam Relieve anxiety, get traffic information factually Play music Quickly find the target music and choose music according to the context Find a parking space Quickly find an available parking space that suits the situation (free/ close to an exit/…) Find a restaurant Find a favorite one/ the most time-saving one/… Get gas Plan your trip reasonably and find the right gas station Pedestrians across Drive safely, avoid danger Schedule change Update the schedule, don’t delay the original plan Route change Plan a better route without delaying the itinerary Cart approaching Drive safely and keep a safe distance Vehicle wear/maintenance information Keep your vehicle in good condition before something goes wrong Extreme weather Drive safely, avoid danger

Proactive Behavior Based on Proactivity Functions The autonomy of proactive interaction refers to the ability of a system to independently take actions. The degree of autonomy in proactive interaction can be manifested in the strength of the system’s ability to act independently during the execution of tasks. This can be implemented in design through the integration of proactive functions.

In human-vehicle cooperation, the proactive autonomy functions of inte- raction can be classified into seven types based on the different behaviors exhibited by intelligent vehicles. These types include push, remind, recom- mend, suggest, inquire, request, and execute (report or silent). Each type comprises several application contents, as outlined in Table 4. These contents can be developed into design cases to improve design efficiency.

Context-Aware Communication Based on Collaboration The degree of situational awareness conveyed to users is a critical dimen- sion of communication between users and systems, serving as an indicator of the system’s ability and as a basis for establishing trust. When the system supports or violates their goals and attracts users’ attention, it will positively or negatively affect their acceptance, user experience, and trust. In contrast to literature that focuses on macro-technical planning(Omeiza

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction 191

Table 4. Autonomy function type and application contents in AVs.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Autonomy function type Application contents Information push News information, service information, managed information Recommended Points of interest(POI), infotainment content, system applications Reminder Danger prediction, event prediction, information service Ask Abnormal state ask, event ask, plan ask Requests Functional requests, permission requests Suggestions Locations suggest, user behavior suggest, plan suggest, security operations suggest Execution (reporting/silence) Emergency decision-making, safety decision-making, safety supervision, service on the road decision-making, in-vehicle environment adjustment, functional autonomous execution

et al., 2021)(Atakishiyev et al., 2021), this study pays more attention to the relationship between system behavior and user experience.

The proactive interactions in context-aware communication involve infor- mative and explanatory information. Informative information presents the vehicle system’s situational awareness results and proactive behaviors, while explanatory information provides content-based, reason-based, and intera- ctive presentations regarding the proactive behavior and its contents. Infor- mative information comprises changes in user status, environmental status, and task status.

CONCLUSION

The concept of human-vehicle proactive interaction has gained significant attention in recent years due to its potential to improve road safety and enh- ance the driving experience. This approach enables vehicles to anticipate the driver’s intentions and respond in advance, using advanced sensors, algo- rithms, and communication systems. In this work, we sum up the theme of proactive interaction by inductive analysis of literature and define the concept of proactive interaction in AVs. The function-based and service-based cases are the directions we can follow. As a result, the content of proactive inte- raction design in AVs is the early guideline to support proactive interaction design in the process.

REFERENCES

Atakishiyev, S. et al. (2021) ‘Explainable Artificial Intelligence for Autonomous Driving: A Comprehensive Overview and Field Guide for Future Research Dire- ctions’, arXiv preprint arXiv:2112.11561 [Preprint]. Bader, R. (no date) ‘Proactive Recommender Systems in Automotive Scenarios’,

p. 348. Bader, R., Woerndl, W. and Prinz, V. (2010) ‘Situation Awareness for Proactive In-Car Recommendations of Points-Of-Interest (POI)’, p. 10. Bateman, T. S. and Crant, J. M. (1993) ‘The proactive component of organizational

behavior: A measure and correlates’, Journal of organizational behavior, 14(2), pp. 103–118.

192 Li and Sun

Cesta, A. et al. (2007) ‘Proactive Assistive Technology: An Empirical Study’, in C. Baranauskas et al. (eds) Human-Computer Interaction – INTERACT 2007. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer (Lecture Notes in Computer Science), pp. 255–268. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-74796-3_25. Crant, J. M. (2000) ‘Proactive behavior in organizations’, Journal of Manage-

ment, 26(3), pp. 435–462. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0149-2063(00) 00044-1. Isbell, C. L. and Pierce, J. S. (2005) ‘An IP Continuum for Adaptive Interface Design’, p. 10. Kabtoul, M., Spalanzani, A. and Martinet, P. (2020) ‘Towards Proactive Navigation:

A Pedestrian-Vehicle Cooperation Based Behavioral Model’, in ICRA 2020 - IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Paris, France (IEEE Inter- national Conference on Robotics and Automation Proceedings), pp. 6958–6964. Available at: https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02509637 (Accessed: 4 May 2022). Kraus, M. et al. (2020) ‘A Comparison of Explicit and Implicit Proactive Dialogue Strategies for Conversational Recommendation’, in Proceedings of The 12th Language Resources and Evaluation Conference. LREC 2020, Marseille, France: European Language Resources Association, pp. 429–435. Available at: https://www.aclweb.org/anthology/2020.lrec-1.54 (Accessed: 20 August 2020). Mok, B. K.-J. et al. (2015) ‘A place for every tool and every tool in its place: Perfor-

ming collaborative tasks with interactive robotic drawers’, in 2015 24th IEEE International Symposium on Robot and Human Interactive Communication (RO-MAN). IEEE, pp. 700–706. Nothdurft, F., Ultes, S. and Minker, W. (no date) ‘Finding Appropriate Interaction Strategies for Proactive Dialogue Systems—An Open Quest’, p. 8. Omeiza, D. et al. (2021) ‘Explanations in autonomous driving: A survey’, IEEE

Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems [Preprint]. Parker, S. K. and Collins, C. G. (2010) ‘Taking stock: Integrating and differentiating multiple proactive behaviors’, Journal of management, 36(3), pp. 633–662. Peng, Z. et al. (2019) ‘Design and Evaluation of Service Robot’s Proactivity in

Decision-Making Support Process’, in Proceedings of the 2019 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems - CHI’19. the 2019 CHI Conference, Glasgow, Scotland Uk: ACM Press, pp. 1–13. Available at: https://doi.org/10. 1145/3290605.3300328. Salovaara, A. and Oulasvirta, A. (2004) ‘Six Modes of Proactive Resource Management: A User-Centric Typology for Proactive Behaviors’, p. 4. Sirithunge, C., Jayasekara, A. G. B. P. and Chandima, D. P. (2019) ‘Proactive Robots

With the Perception of Nonverbal Human Behavior: A Review’, IEEE Access, 7, pp. 77308–77327. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2921986. Smirnov, A., Shilov, N. and Gusikhin, O. (2015) ‘Socio-cyberphysical system for proactive driver support approach and case study’, in 2015 12th International Conference on Informatics in Control, Automation and Robotics (ICINCO). 2015 12th International Conference on Informatics in Control, Automation and Robotics (ICINCO), pp. 289–295. Tan, H. et al. (2020) ‘Relationship between social robot proactive behavior and the

human perception of anthropomorphic attributes’, Advanced Robotics, 34(20), pp. 1324–1336. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/01691864.2020.1831699. Tennenhouse, D. (2000) ‘Proactive computing’, Communications of the ACM, 43(5), pp. 43–50. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1145/332833.332837. Thomas, D. R. (2003) ‘A general inductive approach for qualitative data analysis’.

Exploring Proactivity in Human-Vehicle Interaction 193

Woerndl, W. et al. (2011) ‘A model for proactivity in mobile, context-aware recommender systems’, in Proceedings of the fifth ACM conference on Recommender systems. New York, NY, USA: Association for Computing Machinery (RecSys’ 11), pp. 273–276. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1145/2043932.2043981. Xiao, J., Catrambone, R. and Stasko, J. (2003) ‘Be Quiet? Evaluating Proactive and

Reactive User Interface Assistants’, p. 10.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Factors in Transportation

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Factors in Transportation

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-71-1

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →