Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Gesture Interaction Preference of Healthy APP for Elderly Users

East China University of Science and Technology, 200237 Shanghai, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1001726

Abstract

Purpose: With the increase in the number of elderly people, the social problems of aging are becoming more and more prominent, and the consumption for the elderly is forming a larger market, and health issues are more important. Therefore, using smartphones to solve health issues will become an effective measure. At the same time, with the continuous development of information technology, the way of human-computer interaction has gradually changed from buttons and knobs to a way closer to normal communication. Gesture interaction has attracted much attention due to its natural, effective and friendly characteristics. According to the survey, there are currently many types of health apps, but they lack consideration of the needs of the elderly. Today, 28% of the elderly have mastered the use of mobile phones, but there is a big difference in usage habits and physical and psychological needs from young people. It is of great significance to study the gesture interaction preferences of the elderly in the field of health apps. Combining the physiological and psychological characteristics of elderly users, we are committed to developing an exclusive gesture interaction system for elderly users.Methods: Firstly, the theory and current situation of gesture interaction were summarized, and the concept and supporting technology of gesture interaction were clarified. The second part analyzes the characteristics of the elderly population from the aspects of physiology and psychology. The third part draws on the previous research results and summarizes the existing health app gesture operations. The specific interaction gestures are mainly divided into nine types, mainly including: 1. Return, 2. Confirm, 3. Cancel, 4. Move, 5. Delete, 6. Return to home page, 7. Call out multitasking, 8. Zoom in and out, 9. Rotate. Each operation corresponds to a variety of gestures, such as: return includes single-click, right-click, right-swipe on the screen, and so on. Then, through the quantitative method of questionnaire survey, the gesture interaction of the elderly is investigated, so as to obtain the gesture interaction preference of the elderly in the field of health app, and use this as a guide to improve the user experience of the elderly group.Results: For the "Back" task, the "click the 'Back' button" gesture action was the best action; for the "OK" and "Cancel" tasks, the "Click 'OK'" and "Click the 'Cancel' button" actions is the best operation; for the "move" task, the "one-finger press and drag" gesture is the best operation; for the "delete" task, the "long press the target point to delete" gesture operation is the best operation; for the return home page For multitasking and calling out, the best gesture actions are the third: "click the Home button" and "long press the Home button"; for "zoom" and "rotation" tasks, "two-finger pinch" and "two-finger pinch" The "Rotate" gesture operation is the best operation.Conclusion :Through the experiment, the preference of the elderly about the gesture interaction corresponding to 9 kinds of operations in the field of health app is obtained, which provides a better experience for the elderly users, has certain guiding significance, and provides theoretical guidance for designers.

INTRODUCTION

As the number of older people increases, the social issue of ageing is beco- ming increasingly prominent, while a larger market is forming for health consumption aimed at older people. According to surveys, in the smart device market, more and more middle-aged and older people are choosing to use mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets (Ai Rui Consulting Group, 2014). However, even with the intention of learning how to use smart devi- ces, most middle-aged and older people still find it difficult to quickly accept the new technology that smart devices bring and often feel uncomfortable and anxious in using them (Turner, 2008). With the continuous development of information technology, human-computer interaction has gradually shifted from buttons and knobs to a way that is closer to normal communication. Gesture interaction has attracted much attention with its natural, effective

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 336

Gesture Interaction Preference of Healthy App for Elderly Users 337

and friendly characteristics, and many studies are now proving the usability problems of gestures in supporting the elderly (Salman et al., 2019; Cáliz et al., 2016). By studying the gesture interaction of elderly users, we can solve the difficulties when using smart devices, and apply them in more sce- narios to truly realize smart old age care. With the “Healthy China 2030” goal put forward, the big health industry will develop more vigorously, and self-health management will become increasingly important. However, alth- ough there are many types of health apps, they lack consideration of the needs of the elderly. Today, 28% of the elderly are skilled Master the use of mobile phones, but they are quite different from young people in terms of usage habits and physical and psychological needs, and face many problems in human-computer interaction.

Current domestic and international research related to interactive gestures for older people focuses on two aspects: first, empirical studies in diffe- rent perspectives to confirm the characteristics and advantages of older people when using touch screen mobile phones, for example, Leah Find- later et al (2013) compared the efficiency of older and younger people in touch screen operations, although older people were much slower than younger people, but proved that touch screen narrowed the performance gap relative to desktop and Gao et al. (2015) investigated the usability of four touchscreen gestures (click, move, zoom, rotate) among older and younger users, experimenting with the results that older people prefer click and younger users prefer convenient, fun and fast operation, and propo- sing a set of guidelines for the design of touchscreen user interfaces. The second is to propose guidelines or laws for interaction design by studying the physical and mental cognitive characteristics and performance experi- ments of the middle-aged and elderly. For example, Stößel (2009) proposed the importance of familiarity in the design of touch screen gestures for the elderly through a comparative study of gestural interaction with the elderly. Zhao and Men (2016) analyse the operation patterns, finger stru- cture, finger dexterity and frequency of use of touch screen mobile phones by the elderly from an ergonomic perspective, and propose that the design of smart touch screen mobile phones based on the elderly needs to be more scientific and reasonable to make it simpler and more comfortable to be used.

Overall, the above research presents principles of touchscreen gesture design in demonstrating the importance of gesture interaction for older peo- ple, and analyses the differences between older and younger users and gesture preferences under a variety of touchscreen gestures. The current study does not focus on gesture preferences in a particular domain, so this study starts with the health domain scenario, first analysing the user characteristics of older people, then summarising the touch screen operations and gesture types based on existing health apps and interviews, and then investiga- ting the gesture preferences of older people through a questionnaire survey to come up with a touch screen gesture system that is suitable for older people.

338 Liang and Guo

CHARACTERISTICS OF ELDERLY USERS The defined age of old age is changing, and this study takes middle-aged and elderly people over 50 years old as the research object. At this stage, the physiology and psychology of the elderly will change. The following mainly analyzes the characteristics of the elderly from these two aspects.

Physiological Characteristics As the elderly age, the main physiological symptoms are a decline in sen- sory functions and reduced mobility, such as reduced vision, reduced hearing sensitivity, slowed mobility or a variety of pain and discomfort caused by other diseases. The deterioration of the physiological systems of the elderly is accompanied by a decrease in the accuracy of movements and slower reaction times.

The main dimensions related to gestural interaction are motor function, haptics, and cognition, with motor performance characteristics including slo- wed reaction and poor finger dexterity; haptic performance characteristics including dry and inelastic skin, tactile insensitivity to pressure on the skin, and finger-end epilepsy; and cognitive performance characteristics including severe decline in short-term memory, better retention of long-term memory, and reduced learning ability.

According to Mi-randa A. Farage, the following points can be summarised: motor function can be improved by reducing the difficulty of finger manipula- tion, avoiding incoherent movement design, and not having too long intervals between manipulations; haptic can be improved by enhancing feedback sti- mulation and differentiating significantly; cognitive can be improved by using symbols of older people’s experience, being easy to learn, and interacting consistently (Farage et al., 2012).

Psychological Characteristics After retirement, the range of activities of older people is significantly redu- ced compared to their working life, and the centre of activity changes from the workplace to the home community, socialising mainly with family and neighbours. Due to the influence of physiological characteristics, such as the decline of memory and thinking ability, the elderly are less able to learn new things, less able to adapt to society and the environment, and also easily develop a sense of inferiority. Therefore, the design of mobile phone interfa- ces should give emotional care to the elderly and design gestures according to their behavioural habits, following design principles related to matching, ease of use, guidance, fault tolerance, standardisation and feedback (Xiuhua et al., 2015), effectively solve the elderly’s fear of mobile phones, think with scien- tific thinking and methods, and effectively improve the life happiness of the elderly.

CASE STUDIES Wu et al. (2016) put forward the principles of gesture design and its kinds of alternative gestures when studying the touch screen gestures of the elderly,

Gesture Interaction Preference of Healthy App for Elderly Users 339

Table 1. Alternative gestures corresponding to the nine operations.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

which laid some foundation for their research on the gesture interaction preferences of elderly users in health apps. On the basis of the previous research, combined with the actual research, the alternative gesture types corresponding to each type of operation under the health app application scenario were analyzed and derived, as shown in Table 1.

Through a short interview and market health app research, from the inte- rview, we know that the elderly mainly focus on four modules in health: health knowledge reading, health file recording, health information viewing and health behaviour assessment. In this paper, we have researched several health apps with high download numbers, such as Miao Health, Dingxiang Doctor and Mint Health. Through the actual operation of these apps, we have analysed the characteristics of their centralised gesture operations such

340 Liang and Guo

Table 2. Basic information on elderly users.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Variables Category Quantity/person Percentage/% Gender Male 50 46.3 Female 58 53.7 Age 50-60 years old 54 50.0 61-70 years 29 26.9 71-80 years 16 14.8 81 and above 9 8.3 Average monthly income

Up to and including 1000 3 2.8 1000-3000 (including 3000) 27 25.0 3000-5000 (including 5000) 45 41.7 5000 or more 33 30.6

as open, close, rotate, delete and return, and found that for the “select” ope- ration corresponding to “click” gesture, “browse up and down” operation corresponds to “single point down slide” gesture, these gesture design has become the industry standard, but also found that the nine basic operation gestures These include: 1) back, 2) OK, 3) cancel, 4) move, 5) delete, 6) return to home, 7) call out multitasking, 8) zoom in and out, and 9) rotate.

Participants The criteria for participants in this study were: 1) Seniors over 50, 2) expe- rience of using a health app, 3) consent to be interviewed anonymously and to be recorded.

Questionnaire Research The questionnaire is divided into two parts: the first part is the basic informa- tion, including the user’s age group, education level and other information; the second part is the interaction gesture preference of the elderly when using the health app, including nine kinds of operations, each operation corre- sponds to an alternative scheme, mainly from the four dimensions of ease of learning, efficiency, memorability, satisfaction to compare and filter the best usability gesture scheme. The subjective attitudes of elderly users were evaluated using a 1–5 Likert scale, mainly through both online and offline distribution. 108 questionnaires were collected and the basic profile of elderly users is shown in Table 2.

Results

The experimental data were processed and analysed using SPSS software. Table 3 shows some of the intercepted data.

Specifically, for the ‘Back’ operation, there were significant differences (P<0.01) in efficiency, memorability and overall score, with the usability level of one click being significantly better than that of one swipe from the left edge to the right edge of the screen and one finger right swipe. For the ‘OK’ operation, there was a highly significant difference (P<0.01) in ease of lear- ning, satisfaction, efficiency, memorability and overall score, with click being

Gesture Interaction Preference of Healthy App for Elderly Users 341

Table 3. “Return” dimension and total score ANOVA results.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Gestural evaluation dimensions

Operation Gestures Ease of learning Satisfaction Efficient Memorability Total points Average Da Average Da Average Da Average Da Average Da value value value value value

Back 1 −0.266 A 0.468 A 1.087 B 1.029 B 0.423 C 2 −0.065 A 0.231 A −0.686 A −0.610 A −0.284 A 3 −0.089 A 0.516 A −0.498 A −0.505 A −0.023 B F 0.733 1.921 100.578*** 28.699*** 19.630***

significantly better than one-finger tick and one-finger down. For the ‘Cancel’ operation, there was a highly significant difference (P< 0.01) in ease of lear- ning, satisfaction, efficiency, memorability and overall score, with click being significantly more usable overall than one-finger ‘x’ and one-finger up. For the Move operation, there was a highly significant difference (P<0.05) in ease of learning, satisfaction, efficiency, memorability and overall score, with the overall usability level of single-finger press and drag significantly better than two-finger press and drag and click and long press and then click on the target location. For the ‘Delete’ operation, the three operations differed significan- tly (P<0.01) only in terms of efficiency. For the ‘back to home’ operation, there were significant differences (P<0.05) in ease of learning, satisfaction, efficiency and overall scores, with the ‘home’ click being significantly bet- ter than the four-finger open pinch and the five-finger open pinch in terms of overall usability. Five-finger open pinch. For the ‘call out multitasking’ operation, there was a highly significant difference (P<0.01) in satisfaction, efficiency and overall score, with long presses on the home key significantly outperforming five-finger open pinch and four-finger downward swipes on the screen. For the ‘zoom’ operation, there was a highly significant differe- nce (P<0.01) in ease of learning, satisfaction, memorability and overall score, with two-finger open being significantly more usable than five-finger open and one finger tapping and one finger swiping up and down. For the ‘rotate’ operation, there were highly significant differences (P< 0.05) in satisfaction, efficiency and overall score, with two-finger rotate being significantly more usable than two-finger turn and one-finger tap-hold, one-finger rotate.

DISCUSSION

The experimental study found that the gestures suitable for the elderly were mainly one-click and one-finger patterns, while some faster and more vivid interaction methods (e.g. four-finger up-call multi-tasking) did not show advantages among the middle-aged and elderly subjects due to the comple- xity of the gestures themselves. Therefore, in the design of gestures for the middle-aged and elderly, higher attention should be paid to the simplicity and efficiency of the gestures, and correspondingly, less attention should be paid to the metaphorical and fun aspects of the gestures.

The best gesture for return is option 1: “Click the ‘back’ button”. Although “one-finger right swipe” is more in line with everyday cognitive schemas,

342 Liang and Guo

it is more metaphorical and for young users, the one-finger right swipe is undoubtedly the most convenient gesture. However, for older people, due to their reduced motor skills, the choice of gesture is more efficient in order to avoid misuse.

The best gesture action for the OK action is option 1: “click”. As the OK command is a more frequently used command on the touch screen, users are influenced by their subconscious experiences when using it. Although ‘one- finger draw’ and ‘one-finger swipe’ are more natural gestures, they are often used without the aid of a pop-up box, making them more difficult for older people to use without textual cues and with a higher degree of metaphor. This may be due to the reduced accuracy of motor functions in the middle-aged and elderly.

The best gesture for cancellation was option 1: “Click the ‘Cancel’ but- ton”. Although the more metaphorical “one-finger stroke ×” and “click up” were easier to learn, the “click”gesture scored much higher in terms of efficie- ncy than the other options. Again, this suggests that efficiency is an important aspect of gesture design for the middle-aged and elderly due to their reduced motor function.

For mobile actions, the best gesture was Option 1: “Press and drag with one finger”. Option 1 scored higher than the other options in terms of sati- sfaction, efficiency and memorability, while the three options differed less in terms of ease of learning. Compared to the ‘two-finger press and drag’ option, the ‘one-finger press and drag’ option has an additional long press response time, but due to physiological changes in the middle-aged and elderly, finger dexterity is poor and the process is slower, making the two-finger drag much less efficient. The efficiency of two-finger dragging is much lower than that of single-finger dragging. Therefore, the advantages of two-finger dragging are not as obvious.

For the delete operation, the best gesture action when option 1: “long press on the target point to delete”. Subjects generally use Android phones, and long presses to delete will generally result in a prompt that has confirmed whether or not the deletion has taken place, which is designed to be fault- tolerant and suitable for older people. For “right swipe target bar tap to delete” and “left swipe target bar tap to delete”, where right swipe is more efficient and smoother, the drawback of this gesture is that there are no visual prompts, leading to a lot of possible confusion during use.

The best gestures for returning to the home page and for calling out to multitasking are option 3: “Click on the Home key” and “Press and hold the Home key”. There is little difference in terms of ease of learning, satisfa- ction and memorability, but in terms of efficiency, “Click Home” or “Press and hold Home” are far more effective than the other options. Multi-finger swipes are less efficient, but the fun aspect of the operation can improve the experience in another way. However, fun is not an important factor in the design of gestures for older people who are not skilled in their own use.

The best gestures for zooming and rotating are: “two-finger open” and “two-finger rotate”, respectively. Although two-handed gestures are proposed to improve efficiency, the lack of synergy between two-handed

Gesture Interaction Preference of Healthy App for Elderly Users 343

movements makes one-handed gestures more usable than two-handed gestu- res in terms of overall usability.

In a study of gesture preferences on health app touchscreen phones, older adults operated “back”, “OK”, “cancel”, “move “, “delete”, “return to home”, “call out multitasking”, “zoom in and out”, “rotate”. The best gestu- res for the commands with inconsistent gestures are “click”, “click”, “click”, “Single finger press and drag”, “Long press on target point to delete”, “Click on Home” , “long press on Home”, “two fingers open and close”, “two fin- gers rotate”. Therefore, in the gesture design, priority is given to gestures that are more preferred by older users.

CONCLUSION

With the advent of ageing, the elderly population is gradually expanding, and the contradictions caused by their physiological and psychological changes and rapid social development have led to an unsatisfactory human-computer interaction experience for the elderly, with problems such as misuse, con- fusion and accuracy seriously affecting user experience, for example: (1) many gestures have metaphorical and unguided nature, making it difficult for users to discover them, and elderly users generally use gestures they are familiar with to operate in This is in line with their own cognitive habits, so gesture design must give users guidance and feedback. (2) At present, gesture operation has not formed a unified standard, and often requires different gestures for the same task, which brings confusion to users. The occurrence of these problems reflects the inadequacy of gesture interaction, which brings convenience to the user while also bringing frustration to the experience. As a natural form of human-computer interaction, gesture interaction has low learning costs and is more in line with human lifestyles, so gesture intera- ction has great potential in the elderly market (Zhang et al., 2017). Designing according to the needs and behavioural habits of the elderly and following the above design principles in the design process will greatly improve the user experience of the elderly and increase their level of security, social moti- vation, happiness and self-confidence, and will no longer This will no longer be considered as a marginal user group.

This paper is limited by the limited scope of the study, such as the lack of data and the relatively homogeneous geographical location of the respon- dents, and more extensive and representative studies could be conducted in the future.

REFERENCES

Ai Rui Consulting Group. (2014-05-19) China Mobile Internet User Behavior Research Report [EB/OL]. [2015-04-27]. http://report.iresearch.cn/2164.html. Cáliz D., Alamán X., Martínez L., Cáliz R., Terán C., Peñafiel V. (2016) Exami-

ning the Usability of Touch Screen Gestures for Elderly People. in: García C., Caballero-Gil P., Burmester M., Quesada-Arencibia A. (eds) Ubiquitous Compu- ting and Ambient Intelligence. uCAmI 2016. lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol 10069. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-48746-5_43

344 Liang and Guo

Farage MA, Miller KW, Ajayi F, et al. (2012) Design Princi-ples to Accommodate Older Adults [J]. Global Journal of Health Science, 4(2) : 2–25. Findlater, L., Froehlich, J.E., Fattal, K., Wobbrock, J.O., Dastyar, T. (2013) Age-

related differences in performance with touchscreens compared to traditional mouse input. in: Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI 2013), pp. 343–346. acm, New York, doi:10.1372/jo urnal.com/journal.com/journal.com/journal.com/journal.com/journal.com York, doi:10.1145/2470654.2470703 Gao, Q., Sun, Q., (2015). Examining the usability of touch screen gestures for older and younger adults. Hum. Factors 57 (5), 835–863. https://doi.org/10.1177/0018720815581293. Salman H.M., Wan Ahmad W.F., Sulaiman S. (2019) Usability Evaluation of Smart-

phone Gestures in Supporting Elderly Users. in: Badioze Zaman H. et al. (eds) Advances in Visual Informatics. IVIC 2019. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol 11870. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030- 34032-2_60 Stößel C. (2009) Familiarity as a Factor in Designing Finger Gestures for Elderly Users [C]//Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction with Mobile Devices and Services. New York, NY: ACM: 78. Sun X., Zhou B., Li T. (2015) Design elements and principles of spaced gesture

interaction [J]. Packaging Engineering, 2015, 36(8): 10–13. Turner P. (2008) Being - with: A Study of Familiarity [J]. Interacting with Computers, 20(4-5):447–454. Wu J., Li H., Wang C., Xu Y., Zhuang M., Chen R. (2016) A study on usa-

bility of touch screen gestures for mobile devices based on middle-aged and elderly users[J]. Human Ergonomics, 22(02):12–20. DOI:10.13837/j.issn.1006– 8309.2016.02.0003. Zhang J., Li C., Wang X., Hu X. (2017). An exploration of three-dimensional gesture interaction for the elderly [J]. Popular Literature and Arts, (16):108. Zhao Y., Men D. (2016) Analysis and Research on the Gesture-Based Interaction

of Touch-Screen Smartphones for the Elderly Based on Ergonomics. in: Rebelo F., Soares M. (eds) Advances in Ergonomics in Design. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, vol 485. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978- 3-319-41983-1_37

Cover of the proceedings volume Usability and User Experience

Explore the complete digital volume

Usability and User Experience

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-15-5

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →