Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Evaluation of Elements Layout Design of Ink Painting Posters Based on Aesthetics Model

School of Mechanical Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1001759

Abstract

With the development of the times, perceptual design, as an important part of humanized design, has received great attention. Through experimental research, people have repeatedly verified the correlation attribute between sensibility and rationality, and confirmed that there is a strong correlation between the beauty and usability of design. Aesthetic evaluation is a calculation method that abstracts the interface elements that affect the user's aesthetic experience from the interface layout by using the theories and methods of perceptual engineering, graphics, system engineering and psychophysics. It includes 12 evaluation indexes such as balance, simplicity and symmetry. Aesthetic evaluation has become an important research direction in the fields of graphic design, product design and interface design.Ink painting is a painting made by mixing water and ink into different shades of ink. It is a form of painting and is regarded as traditional Chinese painting. Chinese painting has a long history and is a powerful carrier for the Chinese nation to inherit culture. It embodies the national consciousness and aesthetic taste of the Chinese nation. Due to its characteristics in materials, writing and artistic conception, it is unique and systematic in the field of world art.With the return of local consciousness, more and more designers choose to obtain design inspiration from their own culture. The ingenious application of ink elements in modern poster design shows the broad space for the combination of ink elements and graphic design. Ink transportation by lines is a traditional Chinese painting form. It combines with graphic design to show a unique national language and show the profound cultural connotation and spiritual heritage of the Chinese nation to the people of the world.Through the research on the attractiveness of graphic poster design with ink painting as the background, this paper abstracts the interface elements that affect the user's aesthetic experience from the interface layout, studies the main constituent elements in ink painting as modules, and obtains a unified result by means of quantitative calculation of the public's aesthetic investigation and beauty, in order to obtain the key factors affecting the attractiveness of ink painting form posters. The experimental results show that the most significant factors affecting the beauty of poster typesetting with ink painting as the background are symmetry, integrity and rhythm. In addition to the "degree of balance", they all correspond to the application of the law of formal beauty of ink painting. This conclusion can be applied to provide quantitative optimization basis for the typesetting form of the combination of ink elements and poster design, so as to better integrate traditional art into modern design.

INTRODUCTION

Ink painting is a painting made by mixing water and ink into different shades of ink. It is regarded as the representative of traditional Chinese painting. A complete ink painting creation process includes painting into a work, title and seal.

The composition of ink painting emphasizes the harmony and unity of points, lines and surfaces, which also corresponds to the unity principle of graphic design. The change of ink in water can be divided into five colors, black and white as the main color matching; the strong contrast of color matching conforms to the principle of harmony and contrast in the formal beauty of graphic design; Chinese style often use large area of white space to highlight the traditional, simple temperament. At the same time, the use of

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 43

44 Ma and Xue

white space will focus on the main expression, which is also in line with the principle of graphic design balance.

To sum up, ink painting and graphic design principles have a lot in com- mon, can be combined with poster design. Previous studies only studied the blank space of ink and wash elements and the aesthetic feeling of words. This paper comprehensively considered the influence of these factors and put forward the hypothesis that the position and size of the main graphic elements and words in the background of ink and wash painting have an important influence on aesthetic feeling.

DESIGNSIGNIFICANT FACTORS AFFECTING THE VISUAL BEAUTY OF INK POSTER The rule of formal beauty refers to the experience summary and abstract summary of the formal law of beauty in the process of creating the form and beauty. Wenjie Ji pointed out that the highest realm of Chinese ink and wash painting is the application of the rules of formal beauty, such as symmetry and balance, cadence and rhythm, diversity and unity, and associ- ative artistic conception. Balance refers to the distribution of visual weight in a picture, and visual weight refers to the heavier visual perception of an object. Unity refers to continuity. Rhythm is a kind of regular repetition. In the plane composition, basic figures are arranged and combined repeatedly according to equal proportion and distance, or regular sequence is made to produce rhythm. Based on this, this paper selects four kinds of beauty degree: balance, cohesion, unity degree, rhythm value as the research object. Then explore the influence of these visual beauty degree on the ink painting posters.

EXPERIMENTS Subjects

There are 44 students in a graduate school in Nanjing, including 19 boys and 25 girls, aged between 20 and 24, with normal vision and corrected vision. The subjects had not learned graphic design knowledge or formal painting skills.

Steps One typical posters are selected with ink painting as the background, whose constituent elements can be clearly distinguished. Any painting elements and words on the poster can be moved and zoomed. The poster is desi- gned into five different styles by scaling and rearranging the constituent elements (a total of 25 pieces) as the evaluation materials. Then make the subjects sort the subjective aesthetics of the posters in a relaxed state, and collected the scale data. At last, Calculate the beauty value of poster type- setting, and analyze the correlation between it and the subjective ranking of subjects.

Evaluation of Elements Layout Design of Ink Painting Posters Based on Aesthetics Model 45

Table 1. Sample human systems integration test parameters.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Average first second third fourth fifth ranking Typesetting 1 29 3 8 2 2 1.75 Typesetting 2 6 12 12 12 2 2.82 Typesetting 3 4 22 11 7 0 2.48 Typesetting 4 3 2 3 7 29 4.30 Typesetting 5 2 5 10 16 11 3.66

Figure 1: Poster model of “Moonlight in lotus pond”.
Original PDF Figure 1:

RESULTS AND DATA PROCESSING The experimental results recorded the poster types and aesthetic prefere- nce of the subjects. The experimental results were statistically analyzed by questionnaire network.

Statistics of Subjects 44 subjects ranked the five posters (as shown in Figure 3–7) from the first (most beautiful) to the fifth (least beautiful) in order of subjective aesthetic degree. The questionnaire is shown in Appendix 1. The order statistics of the posters of Moonlight over the lotus pond are shown in the Table 1. Take the poster “Moonlight in lotus pond”as an example to simplify the poster model. Its prototype and simplified model are shown in Figure 2, and its attribute data is shown in Table 2.

CALCULATION RESULTS AND CONCLUSION OF POSTER VISUAL BEAUTY According to David Chek Ling NGO, the calculation of balance, symmetry, integrity and rhythm is showed in the picture 2. The degree of balance (BM) represents the difference between the total weight of the components on both

46 Ma and Xue

Table 2. Attribute data table of poster model.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Layout (2268*3402) Object X Y Width Height Typesetting 1 (2204*900) 1 46 735 822 738 2 882 289 518 1290 3 598 1617 1040 149 4 1272 1798 446 252 5 436 2152 752 454 6 48 2676 530 684 7 1208 2612 1040 788 Typesetting 2 (2258*3203) 1 222 191 152 616 2 446 527 1236 636 3 1794 719 252 1667 4 794 1295 932 503 5 2 1615 904 751 6 498 2414 1064 200 7 0 2650 503 748 8 1114 2670 1136 724 Typesetting 3 (2247*3291) 1 902 227 356 1579 2 1318 103 128 568 3 1518 1527 712 411 4 638 1946 1008 128 5 86 2110 676 544 6 10 2818 532 576 7 826 2410 1432 980 Typesetting 4 (2084*3327) 1 57 51 184 756 2 33 1335 680 487 3 1049 1039 184 1219 4 1421 1411 720 383 5 685 2290 1012 124 6 17 2866 440 512 7 541 2470 1260 2122 Typesetting 5 (2240*2863) 1 1121 659 124 112 2 1473 527 136 568 3 1025 907 288 424 4 709 1303 204 308 5 1329 1299 292 268 6 1 1699 684 563 7 1093 1563 200 359 8 1357 2110 843 436 9 1248 2582 992 108 10 1 2790 520 596 11 684 2758 880 640

sides of the horizontal and vertical axes, Symmetry (EM) shows the difference between the center of the displayed large element and the physical center of the screen, Integrity (UM) is achieved by using similar dimensions while lea- ving less space between the elements of the screen than at the edges. Integrity (RHM) measures the aggregation degree of screen elements. This paper use matlab program to input four beauty calculations, taking BM as an example,

Evaluation of Elements Layout Design of Ink Painting Posters Based on Aesthetics Model 47

Figure 2: Formula of balance, symmetry, integrity and rhythm.
Original PDF Figure 2:
Figure 3: Calculation code of BM.
Original PDF Figure 3:

(P (I, 1), P (I, 2), P (I, 3); P (I, 4) represents x, y, W, h respectively), program- ming is shown in Figure 3. The data statistics of each poster model are shown in table 2.

The beauty degree calculation results of the poster are shown in table 3. Finally, use matlab program to calculate the correlation coefficients betw- een the average ranking of each picture and the four beauty values, as shown below, where rank represents the average ranking score of five pictures, taking BM as an example:

48 Ma and Xue

Table 3. Calculation results of beauty degree of moonlight in lotus pond.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

A B C D E BM 0.3856 0.6438 0.4296 0.4883 0.3680 EM 0.7494 0.9843 0.9866 0.9432 0.9662 UM 2.3202 0.0650 0.0718 0.5328 0.0472 RHM 0.3660 0.4025 0.4421 0.4362 0.3969

Figure 4: The calculation of correlation coefficients.
Original PDF Figure 4:

The correlation coefficients of BM, EM, um, RHM and rank were 0.1165, 0.5685, −0.5705, 0.5235, respectively. According to the principle: correla- tion coefficient 0.00 −± 0.3 is micro correlation, ± 0.30 −± 0.50 is real correlation, ± 0.50 −± 0.80 is significant correlation, ± 0.80 −± 1.00 is high correlation, it is concluded that the subjective aesthetic value of the poster is slightly correlated with balance um, and significantly correlated with symmetry em, integrity um and rhythm RHM.

CONCLUSION

Experiments show that symmetry, integrity and rhythm are the most signi- ficant factors affecting the beauty of poster layout. In addition to “balance degree”, they all correspond to the application of the law of formal beauty in ink and wash painting. Therefore, in the design of ink theme poster, we should pay attention to the “symmetry rule”in the rule of formal beauty, that is, pay attention to creating a visual center, and coordinate with the layout of the whole poster; reasonably apply the “rhythm rule” to make the layout elements regular, and give the variable typesetting and “unity rule” - use the same proportion of elements, so that the elements are more than the edge. Leave less space and make the elements as external as possible instead of internal.Only in this way can the layout of the whole poster be harmonious and uniform, and change regularly, in line with human aesthetic habits.

REFERENCES

Chan, C., Akleman, E and Chen, J. (2002, October). Two methods for creating Chinese painting. In 10th Pacific Conference on Computer Graphics and Applications, 2002. Proceedings. (pp. 403–412). IEEE. David Chek Ling Ngo,Lian Seng Teo,John G. Byrne. Modelling interface aesthetics

[J]. Information Sciences, 2003, 152.

Evaluation of Elements Layout Design of Ink Painting Posters Based on Aesthetics Model 49

Lee, J. (1999). Simulating oriental black-ink painting. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 19(3), 74–81. Miller, L. J. (1972). Experiment in Ink and Poster Paint. Design, 73(5), 36–38. Qin Wang,Qiming Huang & Chuan Qin. (2012). Application of Chinese Ink Wash Drawing in Product Design. Physics Procedia (C). doi:10.1016/ j.phpro.2012.05.258.

Cover of the proceedings volume Kansei Engineering

Explore the complete digital volume

Kansei Engineering

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-16-2

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →