Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Thermal comfort prediction of aged industrial workers based on occupants' basal metabolic rate

1 Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Bologna Bologna, BO 40135, Italy ↗
2 Department of Engineering “Enzo Ferrari” - DIEF, University of Modena and Reggio, Emilia, via Pietro Vivarelli 10, 41125 Modena, Italy ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1002666

Abstract

The increasing workforce ageing brings benefits and challenges in industrial structures. Industries consider aged workers as essential resources thanks to their experience and skills. Conversely, the aged workers' progressive functional and cognitive decline reduce their tolerance to industrial environmental conditions, negatively impacting performance. In particular, after age 30, there is a progressive inefficiency in the physiological response to temperature changes. Therefore, thermal discomfort conditions have a worse impact as the workers' age increases. The Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) methodology is conventionally used to predict the human sensation of thermal comfort on a seven-point thermal sensation scale. Such methodology does not take account of progressive decline in thermoregulation capacity with age. This paper aims to fill this gap by proposing an analytic model for the prediction of thermal comfort. The Metabolic rate (M) parameter in the PMV equation is calculated from the Harris-Benedict equations revised by Mifflin and St Jeor (1990) for the Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR), including the age factor for a more accurate evaluation of the workers' thermal sensation. The aim is to safeguard the aged workers' health and well-being to enhance their performance during work.

INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE REVIEW People are living longer. The increase in life expectancy and the decline in fertility rates lead to an increase in the share of aged people in the total popu- lation and, consequently, in the working population (Caporale et al. 2022). Statistics on workforce ageing estimate that nearly one-fifth of workers will be over 50 by 2050. Although everyone ages differently, a characteristic distinguishing the age factor is the progressive health decline (Varianou- Mikellidou et al. 2019). The cardiovascular and respiratory systems change after age 30, altering the thermoregulation phenomenon and limiting tolera- nce to environmental stresses. At the same time, the inability of individuals to respond to prolonged environmental stress results in cardiovascular diseases

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 120

Thermal Comfort Prediction of Aged Industrial Workers Based on Occupants’ 121

Table 1. Seven-point thermal sensation scale, from UNI EN ISO 7730:2005.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

+ 3 Hot + 2 Warm + 1 Slightly warm 0 Neutral −1 Slightly cool −2 Cool −3 Cold

(Isa & Atim 2019). Proper thermoregulation requires that the Metabolic rate (M), i.e., the heat generated from energy in the human body, balances the heat that the human body is losing. A decrease in the efficiency of the physiological response to changes in temperature (e.g., the release of sweat to decrease the temperature) prevents the achievement of thermal comfort. Thermal comfort depends on environmental parameters (i.e., air temperature, mean radiant temperature, relative humidity, and ventilation rates). At the same time, it expresses a subjective satisfaction with the thermal environment (Sun et al. 2019). The indices used to evaluate thermal comfort derive from a theoreti- cal approach based on the application of the energy balance equation to the human body. In 1960 Ole Fanger proposed the Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) methodology to predict the average thermal sensation of large populations on a seven-point thermal sensation scale (Fanger, 1970). The adaptability of the Fanger model makes it fundamental in the thermal comfort analysis of large populations, representing, on the other hand, one of its limitations. In 2019, Broday et al. reported the presence of substantial disparities when comparing the PMV values to the actual thermal sensation reported by occupants. These discrepancies underline the differences in the thermoregulatory response of individuals in a given environmental condition. More recently, Arakawa Mar- tins et al. (2022) reported that people with lower thermal sensitivity, such as aged workers, present thermal management and adaptation difficulties. The highlighted discrepancies suggest that one of the Fanger model limitations relates to an incorrect determination of the users’ M value (Broday et al. 2019). This paper aims to fill this gap by proposing a thermal comfort pre- diction model including the operators’ age and considering M as a junction between changes in body thermoregulation and PMV calculations.

PREDICTED MEAN VOTE The PMV represents the mean value of the thermal sensation votes of a group of people occupying a specific environment on a 7-point thermal sensation scale from −3 (cold) to 3 (hot) (see Table 1). The Predicted Percentage of Dis- satisfied (PPD) index quantifies the percentage of occupants whose thermal sensation vote differs from the PMV value.

The ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2020, the UNI EN ISO 7730:2005, and the UNI EN 16798-1:2019 recommend that the optimal indoor temperature is defined when PPD is lower than 10%, which corresponds to PMV values

Table 2. Default categories for designing a mechanical heated and cooled building, defined in Annex B “Default criteria for the indoor environment” in the UNI EN 16798-1:2019 standard.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Category Thermal state of the body as a whole Predicted percentage of dissatisfied PPD [%] Predicted mean vote PMV

I <6 −0.2 < PMV < + 0.2 II <10 −0.5 < PMV < + 0.5 III <15 −0.7 < PMV < + 0.7 IV <25 −1.0 < PMV < + 1.0

between −0.5 and 0.5. Table 2 highlights the matches between PMV, PPD, and the reference categories.

METHOD

The analytic model proposed in this paper addresses the thermal comfort prediction of industrial operators, using the Equation proposed by Harris- Benedict (1919) and revised by Mifflin and St Jeor (1990) for calculating the Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) of individual workers. The model propo- ses a detailed evaluation of PMV and PPD, considering the BMR values in

Table 3. Index and parameters for revised PMV model.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.

Parameters M the Metabolic rate [W/m2] W the effective mechanical power [W/m2] BMR the Basal Metabolic Rate in watts [W] PAR the Physical Activity Ratio PAL the Physical Activity Level BSA the Body Surface Area [m2] w the person weight [kg] h the person height [cm] y the person age [years] ti the duration of activity i [min] T the duration of the work cycle considered [min], equal to the sum of the partial durations ti Pa the water vapor partial pressure [Pa] ta the air temperature [

  • C] fcl the clothing surface area factor tcl the clothing surface temperature [
  • C] tr the mean radiant temperature [
  • C] hcl the convective heat transfer coefficient [W/(m2 × K)] Var the relative air velocity [m/s] RH the Relative Humidity expressed as the percentage [%]of the water vapor pressure to the saturation vapor pressure at a given temperature Icl the clothing thermal insulation [clo] MET the Metabolic Equivalent of Task [met]

Thermal Comfort Prediction of Aged Industrial Workers Based on Occupants’ 123

relation to the operators’ age within the M parameter in the Fanger model. The aim is to improve aged workers’ health and well-being and enhance their performance at work.

Table 3 shows the index and parameters used in the proposed model. The analytic formulations of the models’ functions are as follows.

PMV = [0.303 × exp (−0.036 × M) + 0.028] × {(M −W) −3.05 × 10−3 × [5733 −6.99 × (M −W) −pa] −0.42 × [(M −W) −58.15]

−1.7 × 10−5 × M ×

5867 −pa

−0.0014 × M × (34 −ta) −3.96 × 10−8 × fcl × [(tcl + 273)4 −(tr + 273)4] −fcl × hcl × (tcl −ta) } (1)

n X

ti × PARi (4)

T ×

10 × w + 6.25 × h −5 × y −5

× Pn

10 × w + 6.25 × h −5 × y −161

× Pn

Equation (1) computes the PMV values, as in the ISO 7730:2005 standard. The relationship between the M, the BMR and the contribution of energy consumption derived from the Physical Activity Level (PAL) is in Equation (2). The product between these factors is subsequently divided by the Body Surface Area (BSA). Equations (3a) and (3b) are from the Mifflin and St Jeor’s formulas for male and female BMR calculation, respectively (Mifflin et al. 1990). Equations (3a) and (3b) consider individual weight (w), height (h), and age (y) in the BMR definition. Equation (4) represents the time-weighted average of Physical Activity Ratio (PAR). PAR values represent the energy cost of physical activity expressed as a ratio of BMR. The Du Bois formula for the BSA calculation is in Equation (5), given the individual weight (w) and height (h) (Du Bois and Du Bois, 1989).

Table 4. Constrained individual and environmental parameters.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Individual parameters Environmental parameters Gender w[kg] h [cm] Icl [clo] ta [

  • C] tr [
  • C] Var [m/s] RH [%]

Male 79 176 0.5 24.5 27.5 0.10 50 Female 65 163 0.5 24.5 27.5 0.10 50

Equations (6a) and (6b) integrate Mifflin and St Jeor’s formulas into the male and female M equation, respectively.

The following feasibility constraints give consistence to the model: M 46 W/m2 to 232 W/m2 (0,8 met to 4 met) (7) Icl 0 m2 · K/W to 0,310 m2 · K/W (0 clo to 2 clo) (8) ta 10

  • C to 30
  • C (9) tr 10
  • C to 40
  • C (10) Var 0 m/s to 1 m/s (11) Pa 0 Pa to 2 700 Pa (12)

The following Section applies the proposed model to three simulated work activities and discusses the main results and key findings.

CASE STUDY This Section introduces the analytic model’s application, proposing a multi- scenario analysis. This simulation involves the thermal comfort analysis of 12 operators involved in three different industrial processes. Specifically, the first Scenario investigates the operators’ thermal comfort during office work. The second Scenario refers to an assembly activity. Finally, the third Scenario simulates the variation of operators’ thermal comfort during a lifting activity. The aim is to analyze the impact of the age of the operators on their thermal sensation, defined with the PMV, based on the application of the Equations proposed by Mifflin and St Jeor (3a and 3b) in the calculation of operators’ M value (6a and 6b). The multi-scenario analysis aims to compare the resulting PMVs to varying ages only. The environmental parameters, i.e., ta, tr, Var, RH, and the individual parameters, i.e., Icl, w, and h, are constant in each Scenario.

The following Table 4 collects the values of the constrained parameters for the evaluation of PMV in each Scenario.

Table 4 shows the environmental parameters and the thermal insula- tion provided by clothing, following the ranges described in the UNI EN 16798-1:2019. This standard defines the minimum quality criteria that the environmental parameters must respect to guarantee both the energy per- formance of the building and the operators’ thermal comfort. In the three scenarios, the selected configuration simulates the optimal microclimatic conditions of an industrial environment during the summer period. Litera- ture studies highlight the risks associated with the ageing of workers both

Thermal Comfort Prediction of Aged Industrial Workers Based on Occupants’ 125

Table 5. Hourly BMR calculation in the reference multi-scenario analysis.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Gender Male Female Age 20 30 40 50 60 65 20 30 40 50 60 65

BSA [m2] 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.70 1.70 1.70 1.70 1.70 1.70 BMR [W] 1785 1735 1685 1635 1585 1560 1407 1357 1307 1257 1207 1182 BMR/h [W/h] 74 72 70 68 66 65 58 56 54 52 50 49

Table 6. Calculation of metabolic expenditure for individual activities.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Gender Male Female Age 20 30 40 50 60 65 20 30 40 50 60 65

Scenario 1: Office work PAR 1.5 M [W/m2] 57 55 53 52 50 49 51 49 48 46 44 43 MET [met] 0.98 0.95 0.93 0.90 0.87 0.86 0.89 0.86 0.82 0.79 0.76 0.75 Scenario 2: Assembly activity PAR 2.5 M [W/m2] 95 92 89 87 84 83 86 83 80 77 73 72 MET [met] 1.64 1.59 1.54 1.50 1.45 1.43 1.48 1.43 1.38 1.32 1.27 1.24 Scenario 3: Lifting activity PAR 4.0 M [W/m2] 152 148 143 139 135 133 137 133 128 123 118 115 MET [met] 2.62 2.55 2.47 2.40 2.33 2.29 2.37 2.29 2.20 2.12 2.04 1.99

during the winter and in the summer due to their reduced ability to regu- late the body temperature in hot and cold environments (Calzavara et al. 2020). This multi-scenario analysis considers the summer period and repre- sents only a first verification of the importance of the age factor in achieving thermal comfort. The analysis of the age impact on the individual environ- mental comfort involved the definition of 12 ideal profiles. In Table 4, the operators’ weight and height values were established following 50th mass and height percentiles of male and female Caucasian populations (Cassola et al. 2011). The six male operators share the values of weight (79kg) and height (176cm) and differ in age (i.e., 20y, 30y, 40y, 50y, 60y, 65y). In the same way, the six female profiles share equal values of weight (65kg) and height (163cm) and different values of age (i.e., 20y, 30y, 40y, 50y, 60y, 65y).

In Table 5, the BMR in watts [W] was calculated with Equations (3a) and (3b) for men and women, respectively.

Since this calculation derives the daily BMR, in the following line, this result has been divided by 24, resulting in hourly BMR. The Body Surface Area (BSA) in [m2] was calculated with the Du Bois formula (5) starting from the operators’ weight and height. Values of w and h are constant in this multi- scenario analysis; therefore, BSA values are common to six male (1.95m2) and six female (1.70m2) operators, respectively. Table 6 illustrates the M values of the 12 operators during the three scenarios.

M [W/m2] was calculated using Equations (6a) and (6b) considering for each Scenario ti = 1h and the Physical Activity Ratio (PAR) value in Table 6.

Table 7. Change in PMV as worker’s age increases.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Gender Male Female Age 20 30 40 50 60 65 20 30 40 50 60 65

Scenario 1: Office work PMV −0.13 −0.27 −0.37 −0.52 −0.69 −0.75 −0.58 −0.75 −1.00 −1.20 −1.42 −1.50 PPD [%] 5 7 8 11 15 17 12 17 26 35 47 51 category I II II III III IV III IV IV IV IV IV Scenario 2: Assembly activity PMV 0.57 0.54 0.49 0.45 0.41 0.39 0.44 0.39 0.34 0.29 0.24 0.21 PPD [%] 12 11 10 9 8 8 9 8 7 7 6 6 category III III II II II II II II II II II I Scenario 3: Lifting activity PMV 1.42 1.36 1.28 1.23 1.16 1.12 1.19 1.12 1.04 0.97 0.91 0.86 PPD [%] 47 43 39 37 33 31 35 31 28 25 22 21 category IV IV IV IV IV IV IV IV IV IV IV IV

The PAR values used to represent the energy costs of the selected activi- ties are from Ainsworth et al. (1993). The M [W/m2]value was converted to the Metabolic Equivalent of Task (MET) using the conversion formula 1met = 58 W/m2. The PMV values for each Scenario and operator are in the following Section.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

This Section introduces the results of applying the thermal comfort predi- ction model to the multi-scenario industrial case study. The aim is to verify the impact of workers’ age on the individual response to the microclimatic conditions of an industrial environment during the performance of different activities.

Table 7 shows the individual parameters (i.e., gender and age) of the 12 operators involved, the values of PMV and PPD, and the reference scenario (i.e., office work, assembly activity, lifting activity).

The CBE thermal comfort tool (Tartarini et al. 2020) allowed the calcula- tion of the comfort indices following the ASHRAE 55–2020, ISO 7730:2005, and EN 16798–1:2019 Standard. PMV, PPD, and category were calculated only by varying the MET values in Table 6. The values in Table 7 show that, for each of the three case studies, the age of workers significantly influences the response to the thermal environment.

The values in Table 5 show a condition of thermal neutrality for the 20- year-old male worker (PMV = −0.13) with a PPD equal to 5%, in the case of office work (Scenario 1). As age increases, PPD increases, reaching 17% (category IV) for the 65-year-old male operator. The PMV negative value (- 0.75) highlights the workers’ thermal sensation, changing from neutral to slightly cool, as indicated in Table 1.

The 20-year-old male worker experiences a condition halfway between thermal neutrality and slightly warm (PMV = 0.57) during the assembly acti- vity (Scenario 2). These results place him in category III with a PPD of 12%.

Thermal Comfort Prediction of Aged Industrial Workers Based on Occupants’ 127

In this case, the assembly activity produces a PAR of 2.5, increasing the ope- rators’ MET. For this reason, the PMV value of the 65-year-old operator in Scenario 2 is lower than the PMV values for the younger operators in the same Scenario. The increase in metabolic activity due to the activity carried out compensates for the cool feeling in Scenario 1.

The workers in Scenario 3 perform an intense activity (PAR 4), which pla- ces them in category IV with slightly warm to warm sensations. PMV and PPD variations are similar to those in Scenario 2. The feeling of thermal neu- trality requires a warmer environment as worker age increases; because of the drop in the BMR values. The metabolic decline compensates for the increase in the MET when performing intense work activities.

The results for the 6 female workers in Table 7 show that these operators present lower PMV values than their male counterparts of the same age and in similar environmental conditions. The environmental conditions in Scena- rio 1 (Table 4) are insufficient to guarantee the thermal comfort of female operators over 50 years old. The UNI EN 16798-1:2019 standard does not consider PMV values equal to or lower than -1.20.

Conversely, the BMR values for the female operator ensure comfortable conditions in conjunction with the medium-intensity assembly activity in Sce- nario 2 (PAR values equal to 2.5). In Scenario 3, all the female workers are in category IV. However, the comparison of their PMV values with those of male operators shows a slight improvement.

CONCLUSION

The ageing of the working population and the strategies to protect the aged workers’ well-being and productivity represent fundamental issues within industrial settings. The literature highlights that all workers need favorable environmental conditions. Aged workers need thermal comfort conditions to improve their health and to remain in the labor market. This paper propo- sed integration to the Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) methodology, including the age factor to calculate the Metabolic rate (M) of workers during the performance of three different work activities, i.e., office work, assembly activity, and lifting activity. The multi-scenario analysis introduced in this paper shows that the increase in age corresponds to a Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) decline and a consequent decrease in M. The drop in BMR values implies that, as age increases, the feeling of thermal neutrality requires higher ambient temperatures. So, in a cold or slightly cold environment, aged wor- kers suffer more than their younger colleagues. Finally, female workers have lower BMR values than male workers. Therefore, female workers suffer more from a cold environment than male counterparts of the same age and in similar environmental conditions. Considering the impact of changes in thermoregulation systems due to advancing age and gender in thermal com- fort assessments allows for better plant management, work shifts definition, and the supply of appropriate clothing and tools. This study represents a preliminary assessment of the impact of age on workers’ thermal comfort. Future developments of this study will include more in-depth evaluations and

field analyses, extending the analysis sample, the reference period, and the monitored activities.

REFERENCES

ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55–2020. “Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy”, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers. Ainsworth, B.E., Haskell, W.L., Leon, A.S., Jacobs, D.R., Montoye, H.J., Sallis, J.F.

and Paffenbarger, R.S. (1993), “Compendium of physical activities: Classification of energy costs of human physical activities.” Medicine and science in sports and exercise, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 71–74. Arakawa Martins, L., Soebarto, V., and Williamson, T. (2022), “A systematic review of personal thermal comfort models.” Building and Environment, 207(PA), 108502. Broday, E. E., Moreto, J. A., Xavier, A. A. de P., and de Oliveira, R. (2019), “The

approximation between thermal sensation votes (TSV) and predicted mean vote (PMV): A comparative analysis.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 69(September 2018), 1–8. Calzavara, M., Battini, D., Bogataj, D., Sgarbossa, F., and Zennaro, I. (2020), “Ageing workforce management in manufacturing systems: state of the art and future research agenda”, International Journal of Production Research, 58(3), pp. 729–747. Caporale, A., Botti, L., Galizia, G. F. and Mora, C (2022) “Assessing the impact of

environmental quality factors on the industrial performance of aged workers: A literature review.” Safety Science, 149, p. 105680. Du Bois D and Du Bois EF. (1989), “A formula to estimate the approximate surface area if height and weight be known.” Nutrition, 5 (5): 303-11; discussion 312–3. Fanger, O.P., 1970. “Thermal Comfort: Analysis and Applications in Environmental

Engineering”. McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York. Isa, K., and Atim, A. (2019), “Working environment: How important is it to make your employees happy.” International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology, 9(1), 6505–6509. Mifflin, M. D., St Jeor, S. T., Hill, L. A., Scott, B. J., Daugherty, S. A., and Koh, Y.

O. (1990), “A new predictive equation for resting energy expenditure in healthy individuals.” The American journal of clinical nutrition, 51(2), 241–247. Cassola, V. F., Milian, F. M., Kramer, R., De Oliveira Lira, C. A.B., and Khoury, H. J. (2011), “Standing adult human phantoms based on 10th, 50th and 90th mass and height percentiles of male and female Caucasian populations”, Physics in Medicine and Biology, 56(13), pp. 3749–3772. Sun, S., Zheng, X., Villalba-Díez, J., and Ordieres-Meré, J. (2019), “Indoor

air-quality data-monitoring system: Long-term monitoring benefits.” Sensors (Switzerland), 19(19), 1–18. Tartarini, F., Schiavon, S., Cheung, T., and Hoyt, T., (2020) “CBE Thermal Comfort Tool: online tool for thermal comfort calculations and visualizations.” SoftwareX 12, 100563. UNI EN ISO 7730:2005: Ergonomics of the thermal environment - Analytical deter-

mination and interpretation of thermal comfort using calculation of the PMV and PPD indices and local thermal comfort criteria.

Thermal Comfort Prediction of Aged Industrial Workers Based on Occupants’ 129

UNI EN 16798-1:2019: Energy performance of buildings - Ventilation for buildings - Part 1: Indoor environmental input parameters for design and asses- sment of energy performance of buildings addressing indoor air quality, thermal environment, lighting and acoustics - Module M1-6. Varianou-Mikellidou, C., Boustras, G., Dimopoulos, C., Wybo, J. L., Guldenmund,

F. W., Nicolaidou, O., and Anyfantis, I. (2019), “Occupational health and safety management in the context of an ageing workforce.” Safety Science, 116(May 2018), 231–244.

Cover of the proceedings volume Social and Occupational Ergonomics

Explore the complete digital volume

Social and Occupational Ergonomics

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-41-4

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →