Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Evaluation of Student Attitudes in Problem-Based Learning within Interdisciplinary Integrated Courses on User Interface Design

Yuan Ze University, Taoyuan City, 320 Taiwan ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1005424

Abstract

Problem-Based Learning (PBL) is an instructional approach that utilizes real-world scenarios to cultivate students' skills in inquiry, reasoning, and decision-making, ultimately enhancing their problem-solving capabilities and professional development. PBL is characterized by collaborative group learning, which deepens students' abilities to effectively identify and resolve issues. It also promotes teamwork skills and offers a framework for the development and evaluation of interdisciplinary curricula. In the context of this particular study, PBL is introduced within a user interface design course. The course encompasses diverse themes such as smart homes, digital learning, pandemic and life, audiovisual entertainment, and financial business. Current events are utilized as guiding principles for learning, creating a dynamic and engaging learning environment. Students with various backgrounds, including design and technology, collaborate in a learner-centered approach with a focus on fostering creative problem-solving. Additionally, industry experts are involved to provide feedback and guidance to students, and user testing is employed to refine their work. The overall assessment of teaching effectiveness, utilizing statistical methods, indicates positive feedback with high reliability (Cronbach's alpha: 0.93). Notably, there is a notable difference in how PBL is perceived between students with design backgrounds and those with technology backgrounds, particularly regarding teamwork and information gathering skills. As a result, the students' work demonstrates improved creativity and the development of integrated interdisciplinary projects. This instructional approach empowers educators to comprehend and assess students' cognitive processes and attitudes, enabling them to offer personalized guidance and support. With PBL and a student-centered approach, it is well-suited for guiding students in both user experience and user interface design. In future curriculum planning, this approach can continue to be employed, leveraging the expertise of students from diverse interdisciplinary backgrounds to effectively address relevant topics and projects.

INTRODUCTION

The research project focuses on integrating Problem-Based Learning (PBL) into the teaching of User Experience (UX) and User Interface (UI) Design

© 2024. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 144

Evaluation of Student Attitudes in Problem-Based Learning 145

in university-level courses. The project aims to encourage students to inde- pendently learn and practically apply the principles of UX and UI in project design, guided by instructors. Besides lectures, the course emphasizes expe- riential learning, allowing students to practice these skills in class and culminating in the presentation of mobile device projects at the end of the term. The project presentations highlight interface design and innovation in UX evaluation.

The objectives in this research are:

1. To use Problem-Based Learning to cultivate students’ abilities in autonomous learning and problem-solving. Workshops focusing on user experience methods will help students explore user needs and manage the workflow of UX-related projects. 2. To require students to integrate their learning into presentations and deliver oral reports, thereby enhancing their synthesis and presenta- tion skills. 3. To provide hands-on experience with interface design techniques in the classroom. Students will receive insights from industry experts and analyse real-world demands. The course also incorporates user testing methods to refine and improve students’ project work.

LITERATURE REVIEW

Problem-Based Learning (PBL) In PBL, students engage in both independent learning and teamwork to solve complex and loosely structured problems, drawing from real-life contexts (Barrows & Tamblyn, 1980). PBL is learner-centered, using problems as a catalyst for learning, making it a dynamic process where students indepen- dently learn and understand problem-solving (Fidan & Tuncel, 2019). The steps of PBL can be summarized as follows (Torp & Sage, 1998):

(1) Engage: Presenting the problem to make students understand the context and its connection to their lives. (2) Analyse: Establishing a framework for discussion, such as ideas, facts, learning issues, and action plans, outlining content, possible solutions, and discussion frameworks. (3) Explore: Students work in groups to collect relevant information and devise solutions. (4) Present Solutions: Groups report and present collected information and outcomes, evaluating each solution. (5) Assess Learning Outcomes: Feedback on learning and assessment of learning effectiveness.

This research project follows these teaching steps. Learning how to become a designer is crucial for students in design-related fields; observing and prac- ticing designer behaviors aids their learning (Budge, 2016). Design courses aim to provide students with the ability to generate creative designs (Sawyer, 2017). Thus, the teaching methods go beyond mere knowledge transfer in the classroom, considering the cultivation of creativity and design behaviors.

146 Huang

This project’s teaching methods, taking into account UX and UI design, focus not just on theoretical knowledge but also on experiential learning, using PBL to teach how to undertake design projects, aiming to develop students’ autonomous learning abilities and align with industry needs.

User Experience Design and Teaching User Experience (UX) is vital in both industry and academic research, with high demand for UX design in the technology industry (Anderson, 2020). UX designers should adopt a user-centered approach, prioritizing users’ chang- ing experiences, attitudes, skills, habits, and personalities (Institution, 2019). Research on integrating UX into service design shows the need to explore user needs and possibilities (Leinonen & Roto, 2023). Incorporating UX’s user-centered focus in interdisciplinary innovative product design courses enables students to effectively understand and apply course content creatively (Raviv, 2015). Teaching UX design requires solving real problems, develop- ing core competencies of UX designers, establishing industry relations, and using industry feedback to adjust course content (Getto & Beecher, 2016). Workshops on UX have been proposed to develop course designs, covering themes like visual and interactive performance, social and research meth- ods, design philosophy, technical skills, teamwork and leadership, and global awareness (Vorvoreanu et al., 2017). Beyond practical UX design, consistent learning and planning are required in information architecture and design, visual rhetoric, ethics, and communication with technology (Getto et al., 2013).

RESEARCH METHOD This research focuses on mobile devices as the primary development plat- form through the implementation of problem-based learning. The research structure is divided into three main parts: User Experience (UX) Design, User Interface (UI) Design, and Project Integration and Evaluation.

In the UX Design phase, students engage in workshops where they practice UX design methods such as personas, service blueprints, and user journey maps. These methods help students understand and meet user needs, shaping the functional specifications of the project.

In UI Design, the process involves introducing design project workflows and visual requirements. The students develop and design the visual interface of mobile devices through software demonstrations and practice.

To enhance the project’s feasibility and foster design innovation, advices from industry experts are incorporated. Furthermore, user testing is con- ducted to refine and optimize the completeness of the design project.

RESULTS

This research used the questionnaire at the end of the semester to understand students’ learning feedback. In addition to understanding the personal infor- mation of the respondents, including grade (junior or senior year), group (design or technology), and any relevant internship or work experience,

Evaluation of Student Attitudes in Problem-Based Learning 147

the questionnaire consists of thirty-three questions divided into four main aspects. The response format is based on the Likert scale, with options rang- ing from 1 to 5, representing ‘strongly disagree’, ‘disagree’, ‘neutral’, ‘agree’, and ‘strongly agree’. Below is the analysis table of the learning feedback questionnaire, with higher feedback scores displayed on a blue background.

Table 1. Analysis table of the learning feedback questionnaire.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Category Question Mean SD I feel that PBL can promote my ability to think diversely 4.04 0.713 Problem-Based Learning (PBL)

4.31 0.512

PBL can link to my learning experiences 3.92 0.679 PBL can stimulate my interest in this course 3.98 0.668 The PBL method suits my abilities and level 4 0.715 I feel I can learn how to cooperate in groups 4.27 0.536 I believe group discussions are conducive to my learning 4.27 0.644 PBL helps enhance my problem-solving skills 4.21 0.582 PBL aids in my ability to collect and use various information 4.29 0.544 User Experience I believe the user experience design taught in this course is well related to future work

4.35 0.565

I think the user experience design taught in this course will enhance my professional skills

4.35 0.601

The user experience design workshop can provide tools useful for future work 4.25 0.601 The content of the user experience design workshop offers clear tools for future application

4.04 0.683

I have a good understanding of the design of “Empathy Maps” and can operate them myself

3.88 0.789

I have a good understanding of “Personas” design and can operate them myself 4.27 0.676 I have a good understanding of “User Journey Maps” design and can operate them myself

3.98 0.729

I have a good understanding of “Service Blueprint” design and can operate them myself

4.27 0.536

User Interface Design

I believe the user interface design taught in this course is well related to future work

4.29 0.617

I think the user interface design taught in this course will enhance my professional skills

4.31 0.624

The principles of visual design in user interface design can be useful for future work

4.21 0.504

User interface design provides a clear process for future application 4.23 0.66 I have a good understanding of Figma and can operate it myself 4.15 0.618 User Testing and Design Thinking

I believe the user testing taught in this course is well related to future design professions

4.25 0.668

I understand the importance of user testing and its relation to actual projects 4.1 0.555 I have a good understanding of user testing and can conduct it myself 4.17 0.595 I understand that the results of user testing need to be reflected in my design 4.23 0.472 I understand that industry expert advice is substantially helpful for my design work

4.29 0.544

I comprehend the content and focus of mid-term and final project presentations 4.33 0.519 I can learn different features and contents from other students’ works 4.42 0.613 I understand the relationship between user experience and user interface design 4.33 0.559 I believe that user experience tools can assist in planning and discussing before interface design

4.25 0.526

Connection between UX and UI

After the course, I understand the relationship between user experience and user interface design

4.15 0.505

I believe that user experience tools can assist in planning and discussing before interface design

3.92 0.767

After this course, would you be willing to work in UX or UI-related jobs if given the opportunity

Out of 48 valid questionnaires, the reliability analysis yielded a Cronbach Alpha value of 0.093, indicating high reliability. Subsequently, an indepen- dent samples t-test was conducted to examine the differences between two

148 Huang

groups (25 from the design group and 23 from the technology group), iden- tifying questions with significant differences (p-value < 0.05). The following items showed significant variance:

1. I feel that I can learn how to cooperate in groups. 2. PBL helps in my ability to collect and use various information. 3. I believe the user experience design taught in this course is well related to future work. 4. I believe the user interface design taught in this course is well related to future work. 5. The principles of visual design in user interface design can be useful for future work. 6. I believe the user testing taught in this course is well related to future design professions. 7. After the course, I understand the relationship between user experience and user interface design. 8. I believe that user experience tools can assist in planning and discussing before interface design.

Therefore, it is evident that students in the design group have a better understanding of the importance of self-collecting and using various informa- tion through PBL learning. They also show a greater comprehension of the professional relevance of user experience and user interface design to future professions.

CONCLUSION

Following the conclusion of the project, semi-structured interviews were con- ducted with three experts who participated in the expert review. The compiled recommendations are as follows:

1. PBL (Problem-Based Learning): The problems were set close to the stu- dents’ thoughts and life experiences, which engaged students more in discussions and development. Future recommendations include inte- grating considerations related to product strategy and marketing to cultivate students’ acuteness in real-world issues and planning methods for problem-solving. 2. UX and UI Teaching: The UI component needs to strengthen color schema designing skills. This reflects the fact that nearly half of the students are from the technology group, hence, using case studies in the future to explain methods of color schema could be beneficial for those students. 3. Presentations and Overall Performance: There were two group pre- sentations in whole semester. The recording and feedback from the first presentation allowed students for self-reflection and improvement, enabling a more focused approach to problem-solving in the second presentation and expert review.

Post-project and course completion, based on the analysis of student feed- back, student project performance, and results of expert interviews, the following points can be considered for future course arrangements:

Evaluation of Student Attitudes in Problem-Based Learning 149

1. PBL Course Design: Currently, major issues are set and considered before the course. As it aligns with the students’ perspective, it appro- priately guides them in developing comprehensive and detailed plans in user experience design and user interface operation and related design. Future courses can continue in this direction, considering the integra- tion of students’ expertise across different disciplines to appropriately develop related issues and projects. 2. Combining User Experience and User Interface: From the students’ work in this course, it is possible to deepen the design of service blueprints and user journey maps in user experience, linking them to the user interface design process. This will benefit students in integrating their overall planning and actualizing it in practical projects.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The author would like to thank the Ministry of Education of Taiwan and National Science and Technology Council, for financially supporting this research under Contract No. PHA1110217and Contract NSTC 112-2410- H-155-025-.

REFERENCES

Anderson, B. M. (2020). The Most In-Demand Hard and Soft Skills of 2020.

Retrieved 12/14 from https://www.linkedin.com/business/talent/blog/talent-strat egy/linkedin-most-in-demand-hard-and-soft-skills. Barrows, H. S., & Tamblyn, R. M. (1980). Problem-based learning: An approach to medical education. Springer Publication. Budge, K. (2016). Learning to Be: The Modelling of Art and Design Practice in Uni-

versity Art and Design Teaching. International Journal of Art & Design Education, 35(2), 243–258. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1111/jade.12060. Fidan, M., & Tuncel, M. (2019). Integrating augmented reality into problem based learning: The effects on learning achievement and attitude in physics education. Computers & Education, 142, 103635. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j. compedu.2019.103635. Getto, G., & Beecher, F. (2016). Toward a Model of UX Education: Training UX

Designers Within the Academy. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communica- tion, Fletcher, USA. Getto, G., Potts, L., & Salvo, M. (2013). Teaching UX: Designing programs to train the next generation of UX experts Proceedings of the 31st ACM international conference on Design of communication, Greenville, NC, USA. Institution, B. S. (2019). BS EN ISO 9241-210:2019 Ergonomics of Human-System

Interaction. Part 210: Human-Centred Design for Interactive Systems. In. London, UK: BSI Standards Limited. Leinonen, A., & Roto, V. (2023). Service Design Handover to user experience design – a systematic literature review. Information and Software Technology, 154, 107087. https://doi.org/doi.org/10.1016/j.infsof.2022.107087. Raviv, D. (2015). User-Based Approach to Teaching and Learning Product Design

CIRP 25th Design Conference Innovative Product Creation, https://creativecomm ons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/.

150 Huang

Sawyer, R.K.(2017). Teaching creativity in art and design studio classes: A systematic literature review. Educational Research Review, 22, 99–113. https://doi.org/https: //doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2017.07.002. Torp, L., & Sage, S. (1998). Problems as possibilities: Problem-based learning for

K-12 education. In (2 ed., pp. 33–43). Association Supervision and Curriculum Development. Vorvoreanu, M., Gray, C. M., Parsons, P., & Rasche, N. (2017). Advancing UX Education: A Model for Integrated Studio Pedagogy. 2017 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, Denver, CO, USA.

Cover of the proceedings volume Usability and User Experience

Explore the complete digital volume

Usability and User Experience

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-32-8

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →