Yaeko Kawaguchi, Yasunobu Ito (2022). The Invisible Work and its Value of Outpatient Nurses: A Case Study of an Internal Medicine Clinic in Fukuoka, Japan. In: The Human Side of Service Engineering. AHFE Open Access, vol. 62, pp. 134–142. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002551
In recent years, the environment surrounding medical care in Japan has been changing drastically with the development and sophistication of medical care and the declining birthrate and aging of the population. In response to the changes in medical care, nurses are now required to provide high quality direct care to patients with various diseases and living environments. For this reason, work that does not involve patients, such as clerical work, has been regarded as less valuable as a nurse’s job. However, in practice, many of the nurses’ jobs do not involve patients. These jobs are not valued by society and the nursing community, making them “invisible”. In order to visualize the nurses' work based on facts, it is necessary to clarify the invisible work of nurses and its value. Until now, there have been a few ethnographic studies that have attempted to reveal the invisible work of Japanese nurses. The purpose of this paper is to clarify the invisible work of outpatient nurses and what their value is through a case study of an internal medicine clinic in Japan. As a result of the study, it was found that outpatient nurses not only assist with medical treatment, which is defined by law as nurses’ work, but they play an important role in the functioning of outpatient clinics by performing other duties. This is where the value of the invisible work performed by outpatient nurses is thought to exist.
The purpose of this presentation is to clarify the invisible work of outpati- ent nurses in Japan based on an ethnographic study in an internal medicine clinic.
In recent years, the environment surrounding medical care in Japan has been changing drastically with the development and sophistication of medi- cal care and the declining birthrate and aging population. As a measure to curb the increase in medical costs, the development of a system where patients can receive treatment while living at home or in the community is being rapidly promoted. This has made it possible to treat patients with advanced treatments (e.g., anti-cancer drug therapy for cancer) and
The Invisible Work and its Value of Outpatient Nurses 135
chronic diseases that require long treatment periods without having to be hospitalized.
In response to these social and medical changes, the Japanese nursing community (mainly the Japanese Nursing Association (JNA)) has strongly stated that now is the call for nursing expertise (Japanese Nurse Association, 2021b). JNA is the largest nursing professional organization in Japan, establi- shed for public health nurses, midwives, and nurses, with 760,000 members as of 2021. The JNA launched the Certified Nurse Specialist certification system in 1994 to promote the use of specialist nurses who have a high level of expertise in meeting the diverse needs of patients (Japanese Nurse Association, 2016).
The expertise of the nurse is explained mainly through their interactions with patients. It is stated that the practice required of nurses is to support pati- ents physically, mentally, socially, and spiritually, and to help them achieve their full potential (Japanese Nurse Association, 2021a). In the basic nursing education program for nurse training in Japan, nursing students will be in charge of one inpatient per course of clinical practice at a hospital and learn about individualized care to meet the needs of that patient. They are taught that providing nursing care that deeply involves the patient is the important role of a nurse. Similarly, there are many previous studies in Japanese nursing that argue the need to provide quality care to patients with various diseases and living environments. Several of these studies point out that there are too many tasks in nurses’ work that do not involve patients (e.g., Nagai, 2008. Tsunoda, 2007). Tasks that do not involve patients include preparation and cleanup for consultations and treatments, clerical work such as entering vou- chers and electronic medical records, answering the phone for inquiries from outside, and managing medicines, supplies and equipment. These tasks are described as “indirect tasks” or “peripheral nursing” which can be perfor- med by less specialized non-nurses. It is argued that in order to enhance patient care, non-patient related tasks should be reduced and delegated to non-professionals.
Allen (2015) points out the ideal nurse job, to be engaging with pati- ents, is overstated and the work done by nurses is not properly evaluated. When engaging with patients is the only evaluating factor, Allen discusses how hospital nurses struggle with the gap between their non-patient work and ideal nursing work. In an interview study of generalist nurses working in psychiatric outpatient clinics in Japan, it reported that they felt that out- patient work was not nursing and that they were not good enough nurses (Fukuda, 2011). Allen (2015) argues that it is important to make the “invi- sible work” of nurses visible. In other words, she says that it is important to discuss not the ideal of what nurses should be doing, but focus on what nur- ses actually do and how their roles are shaped by the situations in which they work. Other studies have shown that the core of nurses’ work is a medical intermediary (Allen, 2004); the boundaries of nurses’ professional jurisdi- ction is much more ambiguous than those set by law (Abbott, 1988) and the work of nurses is similar to that of a physician (Hughes, 1988). What these studies reveal is that the work of nurses cannot be described solely in terms of direct patient care.
136 Kawaguchi and Ito
In Japan, nurses in outpatient and small clinics are predicted to do more non-patient work than nurses in wards and large hospitals respectively. According to 2021 statistics, more than half of all medical facilities in Japan are clinics, where about 150,000 nurses work. Clinics provide primary care to the local population. Japan has a universal health insurance system, which means that anyone can visit an outpatient clinic if they pay a certain fee. Every day, many patients visit the outpatient clinics, which are the most fami- liar medical institutions to local residents. As a result, the nurses in charge of outpatient care are very busy. Nurses not only engage with patients in taking blood samples and conducting tests, but they also do a lot of non-patient work in a limited amount of time.
Until now, there are only a few ethnographic study conducted on the per- spective of “what is the value of the invisible work of Japanese nurses.” This paper can contribute to correcting the society’s perception of outpatient nurses.
METHOD
The study was conducted at the I-Clinic in Kurume City, Fukuoka Prefecture, Japan. Kurume City is a rural city with a population of about 300,000 loca- ted in the southern part of Fukuoka Prefecture. This clinic has been providing community medical care for over 60 years. It offers outpatient services such as general internal medicine and hemodialysis, as well as an inpatient facility with about 10 beds. In recent years, physicians and nurses have also been visiting the homes of patients who are unable to visit the outpatient clinic due to deteriorating health. Patients who visit this clinic include those with acute symptoms such as fever and pain, those who are undergoing ongoing treatment for chronic diseases such as chronic renal failure, hypertension, and diabetes, as well as those who receive vaccinations for various infectious diseases, health checkups, and upper gastrointestinal endoscopy. The num- ber of outpatients per day ranges from 40 to 60, most of whom are elderly. The staff working at the clinic includes 3 physicians, 2 residents, 16-17 ward nurses, 5 outpatient nurses, 5 medical office staff, 1 medical social worker, 1 nutritionist, 2 occupational therapists, and 4 clinical engineers. Daily out- patient care is provided by two physicians, three to four outpatient nurses, and three to four medical clerks.
The research subjects of this study are the four outpatient nurses of I- Clinic. All of them are generalist nurses. An ethnographic survey was used to reveal the “invisible work” of nurses. The study period was from September 2021 to January 2022. One of the authors, who is also a nurse, conducted participant observations once a week. The author went to the clinic in the morning before the consultation started, changed into a white coat, and clea- ned the consultation room with the outpatient nurse. During the clinic hours, the author observed the workspace where the outpatient nurses worked and from the patient waiting room. Participant observation was conducted about 15 times, and interviews were conducted with four outpatient nurses (see Table 1).
The Invisible Work and its Value of Outpatient Nurses 137
Table 1. Attributes of outpatient nurses.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Previous work experience
Age/ Gender Nursing career
Worked at the I-Clinic
A 50s/female 20 years 6 years Clinics and Dialysis rooms in hospitals B 50s/female 36 years 2 years Hospital wards, clinics, and home visits C 40s/female 18 years 5 years Hospital wards, city health centers, health checkups D 40s/female 17 years 4 years Hospital wards and clinics
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
From the author’s fieldnotes, a timetable of a day of an outpatient nurse at the I-Clinic is shown below. In the table, the direct patient care tasks performed by the nurses are underlined. As this table shows, much of the work done by outpatient nurses does not involve direct patient involvement.
The following are characteristic findings of the work of the outpatient nurses at the I-Clinic through participant observation.
Work Before and After Medical Treatment Assistance: Preparation and Management The outpatient nurse at the I-Clinic would call the patient into the inspection room before the physician’s check-up. They would then perform the tests ordered by the physician. The main tests included blood tests, urine tests, hei- ght and weight measurements, electrocardiograms, x-rays, audiovisual tests, cognitive function tests, and others. Tests that are usually done by laboratory technicians in larger hospitals were also done by nurses in this clinic. This nurse work is defined in the scope as “assisting in medical treatment”.
Not only that, but in addition, the outpatient nurses had thoroughly prepa- red beforehand to perform this task. After the outpatient clinic was over, the nurses picked up who and what tests were to be performed from the electro- nic medical records of the patients scheduled on the next day and took notes. For each patient, they also checked to make sure that there were no omissions or duplications in the physician’s orders, and that the intervals between pre- vious similar tests were appropriate. If they had any doubts at all, they would check with the physician. The outpatient nurses then prepared and inspected the supplies and equipment needed for the tests. In preparation for a blood test, for example, the nurse would choose from several blood test slips and from a large number of blood tubes, the one that matched the physician’s order, write down the patient’s name on the attached sticker, and affix it to the tube. These were placed on a tray, one for each patient. The shelves in the examination room are always neatly lined with blood tubes and needles. The nurses replenish the shelves with new ones when the stock is low.
The management of vaccines for infectious diseases was one of the most important tasks of the nurses. Vaccines were stored in a special refrigerator. The temperature was checked once a day to make sure it was maintained at 5 degrees Celsius, and those who checked wrote their names down on a sheet posted on the front of the refrigerator. The nurses always paid attention
138 Kawaguchi and Ito
Table 2. Timetable of a day (3 outpatient nurses work schedule).
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Other Miscellaneous Work
AM Services Associated With Appointment Patients 8:30~ Start Work
- Answering patient calls(Notification of sudden changes in medical conditions, changes in appointments, etc.)
- Cleaning examination rooms and laboratories; changing sheets. - Review today’s patients with appointments and their scheduled tests in the electronic medical record or notes.
9:00∼Com- mence medical treatment
- Respond to inquiries from external parties such as home-nursing stations and pharmacies.
- Prepare test slips, syringes, and blood tubes. - Call the patient into the examination room. Perform drawing blood, urinalysis, EKG, X-rays, take height and weight measurements.
Two patients are booked every 15 minutes.
- Handover from ward nurses. - Answer questions from physici- ans and administrative staff. - Information exchanges among outpatient nurses and with phy- sicians. - Call or fax a report to a public agency about a person with an infectious disease that must be reported. - Prepare intravenous drugs and other items to be given to the home-nursing station. - Coordinate consultation times for patients without appointments. - Check itinerary routes for home-visit medical care, prepare supplies to bring. - Organize and replenish supplies and equipment. - Order items that are out of stock. - Inspect equipment. - Control of vaccines (Check the number of booked patients match with the number of remaining vaccines, check the temperature of the refrigerator)
- Check the type and severity of the patient’s symptoms, food intake or time of intake, and oral medications. - The test results are entered on a chart and carried to the doctor’s room. - Guide elderly patients from the waiting room to the examination room, assist in changing their clothes, etc. - Preparation, assistance, and cleanup of advanced tests performed by physicians, such as endoscopy and ultrasound. - After the consultation, the physician gives special instructions regarding tests and prescription drugs, if any. - Check the electronic medical records for the next visit date, tests, and prescription medications. - See the patient in the waiting room, confirm the schedule of the next visit, and explain the upcoming scheduled tests and medications prescribed today. - Consult with clerical staff if there are any problems with payment.
The Invisible Work and its Value of Outpatient Nurses 139
Table 2. Continued.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
PM Nurse A Nurse B Nurse C 12:30~13:30 Perform the same work as in the morning.
lunch break Primarily, Nurse A performs the same duties as in the morning. 13:30~14:30 lunch break Prepare to go out for home-visit 14:30~17:30 Perform the same work as in the morning.
Outpatient for fever (Covid-19 compatible).
Accompany a physician on a home-visit medical care. 17:30~18:00 the end of work
- Tidy up and do simple cleaning. - Check tomorrow’s patients with appointments and their exam schedules. - Prepare items and equipment for inspection. - Handover of medical conditions of patients who received home-visit medical care today.
to make sure that the number of patients requesting vaccines matched the number of vaccines in stock.
We determine the number of vaccines to be delivered based on our proje- ctions of how many patients will receive the vaccine. If we misjudge this, the vaccines will be discarded, resulting in financial loss for the clinic. We have to consider such things. (Interview with Nurse C, January 8, 2022).
Behind the scenes of assisting with medical treatment, such as drawing blood and conducting tests, which are defined as the duties of nurses, the work of nurses consisted of preparing in advance for these procedures and managing supplies and medications. For nurses, this may be usual work. However, this work is considered to have significant value as nurses’ job. In other words, adequate preparation and confirmation in advance contribu- ted to ensure smooth service operation of outpatient clinics and functioned to ensure that tests were performed on patients without error. Furthermore, the management of medicine contributes to the financial profit and loss of the clinic.
Nurse’s Borderline Work with the Physicians: Medical Judgment.
I-Clinic outpatient nurses may make the same kind of assessments that physi- cians make in their medical decisions. They triage the urgency and severity of a patient’s symptoms to determine whether or not they should be consulted.
Patients may have mild symptoms such as a headache or sleeplessness, but not severe enough to go to the hospital, so they may want a nurse to hear them out for a while. However, these mild symptoms may be the early signs of a serious illness. The nurse decides whether to recommend that the patient see a physician or just listen to what the patient has to say. The nurse also considers whether it would be better to ask the physician for a decision. It takes a lot of knowledge for a nurse to make a medical decision. (Interview with nurse B, January 8, 2022).
140 Kawaguchi and Ito
Sometimes I find myself wondering if it is okay for me to say so much to patients as a nurse. In that case, I try to answer after checking with the physician. (Interview with C nurse, January 8, 2022).
All of the outpatient nurses at the I-Clinic had nearly 20 years of nur- sing experience. Therefore, the outpatient nurses, like the physicians, had extensive knowledge of general internal medicine and all other diseases, from prevention to treatment, without being limited by age or gender. Utilizing their knowledge, if the patient’s complaint was not an initial complaint and the symptoms did not request urgent care, the nurses made the medical decision without asking for physician’s opinion. On the other hand, nurses consulted with a physician when there is a conflict about crossing the boun- dary of the nurse’s jurisdiction, whether it is appropriate to make a decision in their capacity as a nurse, rather than the nurses’ lack of knowledge.
Nurses’ Borderline Work with Medical Office: Clerical Work The work of the outpatient nurses at the I-Clinic included tasks that blur- red boundaries with the medical office staff. Making an appointment for a patient’s next visit or changing the date of the visit used to be the job of the medical clerks; but since the number of medical clerks decreased, and they were short-staffed, the outpatient nurses were now in charge. The nurses not only made appointments for the next visit, but also asked and confirmed the amount of medication left at home for the patient and explained the medica- tion prescribed on that day. At the same time, if there were any medications left at home, they would confirm the reason with the patient, and instruct the patient to make sure that the medications would be properly taken until the next visit.
Large hospitals have a strong organizational system with a large number of staff, so the boundary between the work of medical clerks and nurses may be clear. However, in small clinics, due to shortage of staff, the two job roles are not clear-cut. When the medical clerks are busy with their work, the nurses may assist them in their work. I believe that clerical work is not the job of nurses, but we support to make sure that outpatient care service runs smoothly. (Interview with nurse A, Nov. 27, 2021) The nurses paid attention to the time flow of the entire outpatient clinic and took on administrative tasks themselves. Although they were aware that such work was not under the jurisdiction of nurses, they understood that it was urgent for the seamless progression of outpatient clinic services and nurses took it upon themselves as the task they should do. It was inferred that the scope of nurses’ work varied depending on the size of the hospital organization. In the case of small clinics, the boundaries of work were even more ambiguous than in large hospitals. Here, the invisible work of nurses was to supplement the work of the boundary area between professions fle- xibly, according to the demands of the situation and enable organization to function smoothly.
CONCLUDING REMARKS Naturally, the main task of the outpatient nurses at the I-Clinic was to assist in medical treatment, as defined by the law. But that was not all. Before
The Invisible Work and its Value of Outpatient Nurses 141
and after this task was performed, there was careful preparation, cleanup, and management of supplies, equipment, and medicine. Outpatient nurses also crossed the boundaries between professions and took up some tasks in the realm of physicians and medical office workers. This kind of work by outpatient nurses was important for the smooth progress of outpatient care services. Their work also served as a check function to ensure that physicians did not miss orders or make mistakes. Moreover, it was a job that contributed to the clinic’s revenue. On the other hand, the interview data also showed the conflicts of nurses who believe that the boundaries of jurisdiction between professions should not be crossed. Outpatient care nurses did not overstep the boundaries of their work with other professions, but neither did they clearly draw the boundary. They successfully moved back and forth between the boundaries of the professions. This paper demonstrated that the smooth provision of services in the I-Clinic was due to the work of these outpatient nurses.
These results indicate that the invisible work of nurses was an intermedi- ary between professions, a glue-like role, as described earlier by Allen (2015; 2004). Also, as Abbott (1988) and Hughes (1988) have shown, the bounda- ries of the professional jurisdiction of physicians and nurses were found to be flexible. The invisible work performed by outpatient nurses was invaluable to the organization because of their initiative to take on many roles within the clinic. We would like to further examine the value of the invisible work of nurses, taking into account the size and culture of medical institutions.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge all the outpatient nurses, physicians, and other staff at I-Clinic for their understanding and cooperation. This work was supported in part by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers JP 18H00782 /19H0546
REFERENCES
Abbott, Andrew. (1988). The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Allen, Davina. (2004). Re-reading nursing and re-writing practice: towards an empi-
rically based reformulation of the nursing mandate, NURSING INQUIRY Volume 11 No. 4. Allen, Davina. (2015). The Invisible Work of Nurses: Hospitals, Organisation and Healthcare. New York: Routledge. Fukuda, Shouko. (2011). Thoughts of an outpatient nurse practicing nursing
in a psychiatric outpatient clinic, THE JAPANESE PSYCHIATRIC NURSING COCIETY Volume 54 No. 3. Hughes, David. (1988). When nurse knows best: some aspects of nurse/doctor interaction in a casualty department, SOCIOLOGY OF HEALTH & ILLNESS, Volume 10 No. 1. Japanese Nursing Association. (2016) Nursing in Japan. Japanese Nursing Associa-
Japanese Nursing Association. (2021a). “Nursing care standards”, in: Standards, guiding principles and guidelines 2021, Japanese Nursing Association Press. pp. 3–7. Japanese Nursing Association. (2021b). “The challenge of nursing toward 2025
future vision”, in: Standards, guiding principles and guidelines 2021, Japanese Nursing Association Press. pp. 8–24. Nagai, Makie. (2008). Classification of nursing tasks and Analysis of nursing practice in outpatient psychiatry, THE JAPANESE JOURNAL OF HOSPITAL AND COMMUNITY PSYCHIATRY Volume 50 No. 2. Tsunoda, Yuka. (2007). Deciphering the Work of Nurses from Economics: Political
Economy of Nursing. Japan: Igaku-Shoin Ltd.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
The Human Side of Service Engineering
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-38-4
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional