Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Differences in processes and outcomes between starting from in-house industrial designers and starting from R&D engineers in design-driven innovation

1 Suwa University of Science Chino, Nagano 391-0292, Japan ↗
2 Tokyo University of Science Chiyoda-Ku, Tokyo 102-0071, Japan ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1002558

Abstract

This research aims to clarify the differences in development processes, new product outlines, and post-launch results between two cases of design-driven innovation (DDI), one starting from industrial designers and the other starting from engineers.SignificanceThe importance of design for gaining a competitive advantage is well documented in many countries with a strong tradition of industrial design, such as Italy, Sweden, and Japan. The DDI concept proposed by Roberto Verganti has been developed based on the analysis of more than 50 case studies, mainly from the manufacturing industry. However, while several studies have been published on the practical process of DDI, there are still few empirical studies that focus on the differences in the processes and outcomes of DDI when starting from in-house industrial designers and when starting from R&D engineers.MethodologyThis study adopted a qualitative approach using Yin's methodology and selected two cases related to high-end model electric fans launched by two Japanese electronics companies in the electric fan market, which is a mature market.In both cases, information on the development process was collected mainly through the use of authenticated secondary sources, augmented in part by direct interviews. On the other hand, the overviews of the new products were based on the product catalogs, and the post-launch results were analyzed based on POS data.Findings/Discussion of resultsNew product development related to the DDI process includes the following stages: design research, idea generation, concept design, product planning, legal protection (patents, etc.), detail design, prototype manufacturing, testing, and production.In the two cases, the in-house designers play a strategic role in the product planning stage, but the main role of idea generation is different. In the case where idea generation was led by the in-house designers, the appearance of the conventional electric fan was retained, but incremental innovation through modularization was achieved. On the other hand, in the case where the ideas were generated by engineers in the R&D department, a different technology was adopted for the air blowing mechanism, resulting in newness in terms of appearance and product concept.Both models won the Good Design Award and succeeded in establishing a new domain of high-end electric fans in a mature market. The products originating from in-house industrial designers could only increase the number of fan blades in order to compete with other companies' products in subsequent product development. In contrast, the design by R&D engineers achieved less-than-satisfactory results in terms of sales due to the newness of its design, but it had a positive impact on the company's subsequent product development and business expansion by applying the adopted technology to products other than electric fans. As a result of this study's considerations, it was found that differences occur in the development processes, new product outlines, and post-launch results when the originators are in-house industrial designers and when they are engineers.Originality/valueThis novel qualitative study will advance the accumulation of DDI process research related to new product development and provide suggestions on how to effectively manage and utilize in-house industrial designers and engineers to ensure successful DDI and its outcomes.

INTRODUCTION

The importance of design for gaining a competitive advantage is well docu- mented in many countries with a strong tradition of industrial design (Borja de Mozota, 2003; Best, 2006; Utterback, Vedin, Alvarez, Ekman, Sanderson, Tether & Verganti, 2006), such as Italy (Verganti, 2003; 2009), Sweden (Aydin & Erkarslan, 2019), Turkish (Ünsal, 2018), and Japan (Kanno & Shibata, 2013). Verganti (2009) proposed a third approach to innovation based on design in addition to the traditional technology push and market pull strategies for product innovation. He introduced how the concept of DDI has been developed based on the analysis of more than 50 case studies, mainly from the manufacturing industry (Verganti, 2009). Ini- tially, the novelty of innovation assumed by DDI is that “...knowledge of the signs that can be used to deliver messages to users and the socio-cultural context in which users give meaning to those signs.” (Verganti 2003; 2006).

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 191

192 Kubo and Sato

Therefore, the leadership of industrial designers is expected in the practice of DDI. Moreover, DDI described design as a process of “making sense of things”(Norman & Verganti, 2014). In recent years, DDI has also been reco- gnized as the equivalent of value creation in NPD (De Goey, Hilletofth & Eriksson, 2019). In other words, the strategy of DDI, namely meaning inno- vation, focuses on understanding, anticipating, and influencing the meaning of new products that have not yet appeared (Conti & Chiarini, 2021). Hence, this study aims to address these identified to provide a more practical under- standing of the DDI process in NPD. In particular, it tries to identify whether IID are the only actors who can be the starting point for DDI process, or whether R&D engineers (RDE) have the potential to do so. Specifically, this study adopts a qualitative approach to analyze the Japanese home appliances cases, and from findings analysis a development process of high-end model electric fans. On top of this, this paper also focuses on two high-end model fans with contrasting appearances that were launched by major electronics companies after Dyson’s entry into the Japanese fan market. And after revi- ewing the frame of DDI theory in previous studies, this paper will contrast these two NPD cases and discuss them based on the findings in relation to the purpose of this study, and finally, future research topics will be discussed.

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK Products characterized by new meanings and innovating function do not arise from market requests (Verganti, 2003; 2009). Initially, Verganti (2009) pro- posed DDI that emphasized on communication with external interpreters in what he called design discourse to create new meaning. The argument for using design discourse as a starting point for DDI was derived from an analy- sis of case studies in Italy, focusing on the manufacturing industry. Therefore, there has been progress in research on how companies in different countries are practicing the origin of DDI and whether there really is such a thing as design discourse.

In Japan, through a case study of NTT Docomo’s i-Mode development, it is suggested that the starting point for implementing DDI should be to consider new applications for existing products (Sugino, 2013). In addition, an exploratory case study of five creative companies in Indonesia suggests that the starting point should be the prediction of future trends (Kembaren, Simatupang, Larso & Wiyancoko, 2014). In contrast, Goto & Ishida (2014), who analyzed the DDI process based on the upstream development of Pan- asonic’s TVs, argued that DDI is an interaction process between technology research and design research. Furthermore, Goto (2017) clarified through a case study of a new product by DDI of a prosthetic limb that the participa- tion of industrial designers in the development of the product is essential for the creation and communication of new meanings.

Verganti (2017) modified his advocacy by stating that the origin of DDI is the process of expressing the inner thought of an individual, which is cha- racterized by moving from inside to outside through interaction with the people around. One of the reasons for this argument is the existence of a

Differences in Processes and Outcomes between Starting 193

“radical circle” consisted of informal members discovered during the pro- cess of developing Microsoft’s Xbox game console (Verganti & Shani, 2016). Concerning the origin of DDI, although many case studies mainly for Ita- lian firms clarified that industrial designers were origin of DDI (Verganti, 2009), few DDI originating from RDEs were reported. Also, several studies on the DDI practice process have been published recently, such as Conti & Chiarini (2021), empirical studies focusing on the difference in processes and outcomes between the DDI process starting with IID and RDE are still rare.

RESEARCH OBJECTIVES As explained in the previous section, though practical DDI process has made progress, little empirical research on the starting point of DDI has been performed. In particular, as far as we know, there is no case study on the NPD by the DDI started from RDE. Therefore, this study has the following three objectives. (1) to discover NPD cases by the DDI originated from RDE, (2) to examine the differences in the DDI process between starting from IID and RDE, and (3) to reveal influence of the differences in the DDI origin on the performance after launch and subsequent ripple effects.

METHODOLOGY

Research Design This study adopted a qualitative approach using Yin’s methodology (Yin, 1994; 2018) and selected two cases related to high-end model electric fans launched by two Japanese major electronics companies in the “electric fan” market, which is a mature market. The “electric fan”, which is the subject of this study, has been priced low for many years in home appliances field, and major manufacturers have hardly devoted any manpower to its deve- lopment. Therefore, it was regarded as a commoditized item, and the major home appliance companies were gradually losing market share in this mature market. However, in Apr. 2010, Dyson in the UK (in the global market since Nov. 2009) launched high-end model electric fans in the Japanese market that have a price difference of 7 to 10 times compared to conventional electric fans. As a result, major Japanese electronics companies entered the high-end model electric fan market one after another, and by FY2016, the value com- position of high-end models in the living electric fan market had increased to account for about half of the market*1. Therefore, this paper seeks to examine the case of two high-end electric fans developed by; Company T and Company P, which have contrasting appearances among several electric appliance manufacturers that developed high-end model fans in the Japanese fan market after Dyson’s entry.

Data Collection In both cases, information on the development process were collected mainly through the use of authenticated secondary sources, augmented in part by direct interviews. Descriptions illustrating the development story of Com- pany T is based on web articles interviewed with several developers who

194 Kubo and Sato

joined the NPD process*2, *3. Because one of the authors worked for the organization, the descriptions of the case of Company P is based on the perspective of participant observation including direct interviews with the developers (Implementation Date: April 12, 2016), and are supplemented by web articles on the product development*4. In both cases, the overviews of the new products were based on each product catalog, and the post-launch results were analyzed based on POS data (Available from: Growth from Kno- wledge (GfK) Japan). In addition, open documents related to the awarding of the Good Design Award, one of the oldest design awards in Japan, are also taken into reference*5, *6.

CASE ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS Company T: ”SIENT” F-DLN100

Company T is a well-established company in the fan business in Japan, having developed Japan’s first electric fan in 1894. Over 100 years of manufacturing and selling electric fans, Company T was having a difficult time in 2007 as the size of the Japanese electric fan market had bottomed out. In order to deliver a breeze that can be used in combination with an air conditioner, Company T installed a function in the electric fan that automatically adjusts the airflow according to changes in the temperature and humidity of the room and rotates the blades as slowly as possible. In this way, Company T was the first in the market to emphasize the fact that it could deliver “wind that can be used with air conditioners” as the design language of its electric fans. The engineers at Company T recognized that a DC motor would be suitable for the task of creating a slower, gentler breeze, as the AC motors that had been used for years were overloaded and limited. However, they had given up on using DC motors for inexpensive electric fans because the cost of motor parts was about 10 times higher than AC motors at that time. Following the success in the Japanese market of high-end electric fans from Dyson, which were launched in April 2010 and cost 30k to 40k yen in actual sales, Company T was given the go-ahead to develop electric fans with DC motors in the summer of 2010. In the development of the DC motor electric fan “SIENT F-DLN100” of Company T, the IID (Head Office Design Center) took the lead even before the official kick-off, and the concept was being studied from the initial stage. In addition, in Sep. 2010, the IID had completed the idea sketches and were working on the design work in a short time so that the basic design could be advanced and incorporated into the commercialization decision plan. Their concern was that the product would look cheap and not worth the higher price. In order to prevent this, before making the product catalog, IID took the ownership in creating a handmade booklet to visualize the concept of this product, what kind of space it would be placed in, and what it would be selling. The booklet was distributed to the people concerned to share the design concept. Furthermore, SIENT has changed the blades from 4 to 7, which Company T has always persistently used. The reason for this change was that it would not be appealing from a planning point of view to have the same blades as the previous model, which is an important element of a conventional electric fan, even though the product is installed

Differences in Processes and Outcomes between Starting 195

with the new technology of DC inverter motor. As for why the number of blades was decided to be 7, it was discovered that 7 blades happened to be the best among several prototypes. In other words, the feel of the wind hitting the skin was natural, and the thickness of the blades could be slimmed down, which resulted in the seven blades being appropriate. Despite the new effects described above, the new product (“SIENT”) was not much different from conventional fans in terms of appearance and functionality, except that it had seven blades. The expectations of top management may have been for something that would surpass Dyson, but as a well-established electric fan manufacturer, to keep up with the high-end fan market pioneered by Dyson, IID took the leadership in focusing on speed and was able to launch the product in May 2011.

Company P: The Bladeless Air Generator “Q” F-BL25Z Company P had suspended the development of new fan products since FY2005 because they were less profitable, but they had been seeking to revive the development since around 2009. Mr. O, an engineer in the R&D Center in charge of the fan business at Company P had been warming up to the idea of an “urn-shaped air blower using induced airflow technology” since before Dyson entered the Japanese market. Then, after the successful launch of high-end electric fan called SIENT in May 2011, he proposed some ideas for a new electric fan to the head of the business unit in Dec. 2011. After that, the product planning division in charge of the fan business at that time had many other new product themes in the existing business, and the considera- tion of launching “urn-shaped fan using induced air technology” was put on hold for a while. Sometime later, in the summer of 2012, the inventor Mr. O set up an informal team to discuss the product concept and detailed design, inviting IID and product planning staff from within the company in order to commercialize the idea that had been postponed. This informal organization is a voluntary activity called for by Mr. O himself, and had nothing to do with the official activities of the R&D organization to which he belonged. Mr. O argued, “To focus on Dyson, pay attention to the circulator,” in the discussion and presented the technical prototype of an urn shape with high straight forwardness; he asked for opinions between in-house designers and product planning staff. The IID also accepted his initial idea of an urn shape, recognizing that a breakthrough would not be possible if they were stuck with the traditional design of electric fans. As the discussion progressed, the product planning staff member who did not specialize in electric fans sugge- sted changing the design to a spherical shape (ball) that resembled a soccer ball, which Mr. O initially rejected, arguing that it would lose the appeal of the functional beauty shape of the product using induced airflow technology. Later, in spring of 2013, after receiving the report from the product planning staff who participated in Mr. O’s informal gathering, the division manager set the scheduled launch date to Apr. 2015 and decided to accept Mr. O’s technical prototype concept based on the customer response and the evalu- ation of the assumed users. As a result, official NPD in the home appliance fan business unit started in May 2014. The new type of fans (Air Generator

196 Kubo and Sato

Table 1. DDI process and performance between the two cases.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Factors Company T SIENT Launched in May 2011

Company P “Q” Launched in May 2015 R&D Engineers(RDEs)

Originator of DDI In-house Industrial Designers(IIDs) Transmission methods of originator’s concept Design language (a booklet summarizing the product concept) Rapid prototyping (technological prototype) Design management style

IIDs take leadership (top-down approach)

DDI process

RDEs make suggestions (bottom-up approach) Collaborative style between IIDs and RDEs

IIDs communicated the verbalized design concept to RDEs, and RDEs implemented IID’s design concept with an extension of conventional technology.

User acceptance survey of product concepts

RDEs proposed a novel air blower distinct from conventional fans to IIDs using a prototype. IIDs modified the appearance of the prototype from an ergonomic perspective. Role of the Product Planning Department

Request of technological development for realizing the product concept Yes Yes

Contributed a new category creation

Received Received

Product appearance Typical Novel Good Design Award(in Japan)

Performance

+4.7% (−13.1%) −3.4% (−0.9%)

CAGR of unit sales in the first three years after launch(Fan market) Subsequent progress SIENT series discontinue in May 2016

Some air blowers based on this technology were launched in 2020

“Q”) that is visually and functionally significantly different from conventio- nal fans which is an air generator equipped with hidden blades were shipped Mar. 2015. In the development process, the contribution of IID was to give consideration to human-centered design to improve the usability of technical prototypes.

FINDINGS The findings from the two cases are summarized in Table 1. with the objecti- ves of this study. The starters of DDI in the case of Company T (“SIENT”) and Company P (Air Generator “Q”) were IID and RDE, respectively. Dif- ferences in DDI starters also influenced the DDI process, management style and role of product planning departments in NPD. In the two cases, those

Differences in Processes and Outcomes between Starting 197

factors were quite different. The appearance of SIENT started from the IID was typical and the appearance of Air Generator “Q” started from the RDE was novel, however the appearance designs of two products were both prai- sed and received the Good Design Award. With regard to the performance of two high-end model electric fans after launch, Company T succeeded in incre- asing the shipment value of its own hi-end fans, despite the shrinking electric fan industry Growth in Japan during the same period, though Company P’s high-end electric fan was not successful enough from a business point of view. On the other hand, the airflow technology applied to Air Generator “Q” has been applied to other products, contributing to the creation of new businesses for Company P. *7. The details will be discussed in the next section.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION We have examined two case studies of DDI practices Company T starting from IID and Company P starting from RDE. The results of these case studies are extracted in terms of how the conceptual design that was first imagi- ned was formulated and communicated, the design management style at that time, and the role of the product planning department. The previous literature of DDI theory has assumed that companies that launch innovative products should conduct research regarding several activities forecasting for the tar- get market trend, design research, and technology research. In this study, we revealed that the individual’s thought expression as a starting point for DDI is a design language in the case of IID and a technology prototype in the case of RDE. Furthermore, from the results regarding design management style, we understood that in case of starting from IID a top-down approach, while the bottom-up approach is used when the RDE is the starting point. This fact for example evaluates that IIDs can take a leadership role in NPD when the com- plexity is about the level of home appliances (Fujimoto, 1999). In addition, from the results regarding the role of the product planning department, we observed that the role was to request engineers to develop technology based on the design (language) concept when the IID was the starting point, and to investigate the acceptability of the product to the assumed users when the RDE was the starting point. Therefore, we examined the management diffe- rence in the initial stage of the NPD process between the case where the IID is the starting point and the case where the RDE is the starting point. However, IID and RDE appeared in both case studies, differences are also revealed in the relationship between IIDs and RDEs. between the case whereby IID is the starting point and the case whereby RDE is the starting point. We understand the two cases that IID had a few knowledge of technical means and asked the RDEs to develop technologies that fit their own concepts and when RDE proposed technological prototypes, they wanted to ignore the design icons of conventional products and try to adopt new technologies. In other words, this finding seems to be the reason for the differences in the external appearance of the developed products.

In summary, this study was performed to clarify influence of the differences in the DDI origin on process and post-launch performance and subsequent

198 Kubo and Sato

ripple effects, based on two cases of DDI in Japanese electric manufactu- res, one starting from IID and the other starting from RDE. We found the development of Air Generator “Q” in Company P as a rare example of DDI starting from RDE. We also confirmed that the DDI processes were different between the IID and RDE origins. Although it is generally known that the DDI process is often led by the IID, when the RDE was the starter of DDI, a bottom-up approach was used to share the ideas generated by the RDE with the technical prototypes. Therefore, this study contributes to the accumula- tion of DDI process research on NPD. In addition, we revealed influence of the differences in the DDI origin on the performance after launch and sub- sequent ripple effects. Our results showed that when the RDEs are starter of DDI, however new products may not be sufficiently successful in terms of business due to its novel appearance compared with the conventional pro- ducts, the new technology used in the new products is later applied to other products and contributes to the creation of new business. Thus, our findings offer several important practical implications for innovation management of existing businesses in mature markets. In general, it is inferred that it takes long time for NPD starting from RDE (e.g., Yadav, Nepal & Jain, 2007). Therefore, it is necessary to manage RDE so that they can be free to propose technological prototypes in the early stage of NPD, and to utilize them in a way differently from the DDI process originating from IID.

Further Studies We plan to explore the mechanism by which DDIs starting from IID and RDE make a difference not only in the DDI process, but also in post-launch results and subsequent ripple effects through further in-depth case studies.

ENDNOTES *1 Ougawara, Katsuyuki. (May 17, 2017) Panasonikku ga tsukutta “sekai- ichi takai semp¯uki” RINTO toha [What is RINTO, the “world’s most expensive fan” made by Panasonic?]. Kaden Watch Website: (in Japanese)

https://kaden.watch.impress.co.jp/docs/column/newtech/1059640.html *2 Pd Web Interview (Summer, 2011) DCimb¯at¯am¯ot¯a ni yoru semp¯uki no saij¯oi wo mezashite SIENT F-DLN100 no dezain kaihatsu [Design and development of “SIENT” F-DLN100, aiming at the top of the line living fan with DC inverter motor]. Product Design Website: (in Japanese) http://www.pdweb.jp/oldpdweb/interview/toshiba_SIENT.shtml *3 Seido, Keiichi. (July 27, 2012) Kokunai ¯otem¯ek¯a hatsuno k¯oky¯u semp¯uki, t¯oshiba “SIENT” ni himerareta kodawari [The secret mind behind Toshiba’s “SIENT”, the first high-end fan from a major Japanese manufactu- rer]. Kaden Watch Website: (in Japanese)

https://kaden.watch.impress.co.jp/docs/column/newtech/548130.html *4 Ikehara, Teruo. (Aug. 3, 2015) “Derukui ha utarenai” pana wakate y¯ushino aratana ch¯osen [The nail that sticks out doesn’t gets hammered down, A New Challenge for Young Panasonic Volunteers]. WEDGE Infinity Website: (in Japanese) https://wedge.ismedia.jp/articles/-/5196

Differences in Processes and Outcomes between Starting 199

*5 GOOD DESIGN AWARD (Oct., 2011) “semp¯uki”[SIENT F-DLN100] [The electric fan: SIENT F-DLN100]. JDP Website: (in Japanese) https://www.g-mark.org/award/describe/37430 *6 GOOD DESIGN AWARD (Oct., 2015) “s¯of¯uki” [Panasonic s¯of¯uki “Q”] [The air blower: Panasonic Bladeless Air Generator “Q”]. JDP Website: (in Japanese)

http://www.g-mark.org/award/describe/42265 *7 Panasonic News Release (Nov. 26, 2020) “ch¯oshitsu”, “jokin”, “kiry¯u” no gijutsu de, IAQ jigy¯o wo gur¯obaruni kakudai [Global expansion of IAQ (indoor air quality) business with technologies of “humidity control,” “sterilization,” and “air flow”]. Panasonic Website: (in Japanese) https://news.panasonic.com/jp/press/data/2020/11/jn201126-2/jn201126- 2.html

REFERENCES

Aydin, F., & Erkarslan, O. (2019). “Analysis of design-driven innovation practices in Turkish and Swedish furniture firms: An exploratory approach”. The Internatio- nal Journal of Design Management and Professional Practice, Volume13 Issue 1, pp. 29–56. Best, K. (2006). Design management: managing design strategy, process and imple-

mentation. Lausanne: AVA Publishing. Borja de Mozota, B. (2013) Design Management: Using Design to Build Brand Value and Corporate Innovation. New York: Allworth Press. Conti, E., & Chiarini, A. (2021). “Design-driven innovation: exploring new product

development in the home appliances and furniture industry”, The TQM Journal, Volume 33 Issue 7, pp. 148–175. De Goey, H., Hilletofth, P., Eriksson, L. (2019). “Design-driven innovation: a systematic literature review”, European Business Review, Volume 31 No. 1, pp. 92–114. Fujimoto, T. (1991). “Product integrity and the role of the designer as integrator”,

Design Management Journal (Former Series), Volume 2 No. 2, pp. 29–34. Goto, S. (2017). “Technology epiphany and an integrated product and service”, Journal of technology management & innovation, Volume 12 No. 2, pp. 34–44. Goto, S., & Ishida, S. (2014). “Technology development strategy for radical pro-

duct meaning”, International Journal of Business and Systems Research, Volume8 No.4, pp. 402–418. Kanno, Y., Shibata, S. (2013). “Organizational factors in the product design development process”, International Journal of Business and Management, Volume 8 No. 10, pp. 15–26. Kembaren, P., Togar, M., Simatupang, D.L. and Dudy, W. (2014). “Design dri-

ven innovation practices in design-preneur led creative industry”, Journal of Technology Management and Innovation, Volume 9 No. 3, pp. 91-105. Sugino, M., (2013). “Dezain-doribun · inob¯esyon ni okeru dezain purosesu -Verganti no inob¯esyon moderu ni motoduku dezain purosesu no tenkai” [A Design Process for Design-Driven Innovation -Exploration of Design Process Based on the Inno- vation Model Proposed by Verganti]., Dezaingaku kenky¯u [Research in Design Studies] (in Japanese), Volume 60 No. 4, pp. 11–20. Ünsal, T. (2018). “The Role of Industrial Design Within New Product Development

Process Turkey and West Europe”, Megaron, Volume 13 No. 2, pp. 286–296.

200 Kubo and Sato

Utterback, J., Vedin, B. A., Alvarez, E., Ekman, S., Sanderson, S. W., Tether, B., & Verganti, R. (2006). Design-inspired innovation and the design discourse. Hackensack: World Scientific. Verganti, R. (2003). “Design as brokering of languages: the role of designers in the

innovation strategy of Italian firms”, Design Management Journal, Volume 3, pp. 34–42. Verganti, R. (2006). “Innovation through design”, Harvard Business Review, Volume 84 No. 12, pp. 114–122. Verganti, R. (2009). Design-Driven Innovation: Changing the Rules of Competition

by Radically Innovating What Things Mean. Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Verganti, R. (2017). Overcrowded: Designing Meaningful Products in a World Awash with Ideas. Boston: MIT Press. Verganti, R., & Shani, A. B. R. (2016). “Vision transformation through radical

circles: Enhancing innovation capability development”, Organizational Dyna- mics, Volume 45, pp. 104–113. Yadav, O. P., Nepal, B. P., & Jain, R. (2007). “Managing product development process complexity and challenges: a state-of-the art review”, Journal of Design Research, Volume 6 No. 4, pp. 487–508. Yin, R.K. (1994). Case Study Research: Design and Methods, Second Edition. Beverly

Hills: Sage Publishing. Yin, R.K. (2018). Case Study Research and Application: Design and Methods, 6th Revised edition. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications Inc.

Cover of the proceedings volume The Human Side of Service Engineering

Explore the complete digital volume

The Human Side of Service Engineering

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-38-4

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →