Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Validation of a one-item acute stress scale for driving tasks

1 Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute (VTI), Linköping, Sweden ↗
2 Ambulance Services, Skaraborg Hospital, Sweden ↗
3 Chalmers University of Technology, Department of Electrical Engineering and SAFER, Vehicle and Traffic Safety Centre, Gothenburg, Sweden ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1005230

Abstract

Emergency personnel, such as ambulance crews and firefighters, must perform well both mentally and physically during emergency responses around the clock. The opportunity for recovery and rest is often limited during their shifts. This can lead to an increased risk of fatigue and perceived stress during emergency responses, which also increases the risk of traffic accidents. Stress has been identified as a contributing factor to road crashes due to its negative impact on driving performance [1-3]. Stress increases the crash risk by affecting cognitive abilities, resulting in inadequate information processing and imperfect perception which may, in turn, lead to deterioration of driver performance [4]. Physiological measurements can be used to detect driver stress but there is also a need for subjective ratings scales that are easy to use in a driving setting. Driver sleepiness is often measured with the 9-point one-item Karolinska Sleepiness Scale [5] but there is no equivalent measure of acute driver stress. In this study we investigated if a one-item stress scale could be used to measure acute driver stress in an ambulance simulator. The VTI acute stress scale (VSS) was developed to quantify perceived stress. The 9 verbal anchors are designed to match the verbal anchors of the Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (KSS). The VSS anchors are: 1 completely relaxed (feeling entirely calm and relaxed), 2 very relaxed, 3 relaxed, 4 rather relaxed, 5 neither relaxed nor stressed, 6 slightly stressed, 7 stressed (feeling some tension and pressure), 8 very stressed, 9 extremely stressed (feeling very tense and under high pressure, on the verge of what I can handle).A simulator trial was conducted with ambulance driving scenarios designed to induce various stress levels in emergency response personnel. Each participant performed three simulator tasks: task A was a low-stress routine drive, task B was a medium-stress urgent callout, task C was a high-stress emergency response. The tasks were counterbalanced between participants. The participants completed a questionnaire with questions about task load (NASA-TLX), stress (9-point VSS scale), and sleepiness (9-point KSS scale) after each drive.Participants (33 men and 16 women) were recruited among ambulance personnel and emergency response personnel in western Sweden. Data collections took place at two different ambulance stations on five different occasions in 2022. The study protocol was approved by the Swedish Ethical Review Authority (ref 2021-04352). Forty-eight drivers had VSS ratings from all three drives. The mean ratings were A=3.17 (SD 1.58, range 1-7), B=3.77 (SD 1.59, range 1-6), and C=4.65 (SD 1.77, range 1-7). An ANOVA with task (A, B, C) as a fixed factor and participant as a random factor showed that there was a significant difference in VSS ratings between tasks (F=22.9, p<0.001, η2=0.330). Post-hoc tests (TukeyHSD) showed that task A had significantly lower rating than task B (p=0.021) and task C (p<0.001) and task B had significantly lower ratings than task C (p<0.001). The stress ratings were moderate throughout the trials, with no ratings above 7 on the 9-point scale. This could be due to simulator scenarios not being perceived as equally stressful as real-life emergency driving situations. The VSS was significantly correlated with NASA-TLX subscales mental demand (r=0.606), physical demand (r=0.419), temporal demand (r=0.605), performance (r=0.313), effort (r=0.541), and frustration (r=0.553). These medium correlations show that the VSS acute stress score is related to but not identical to workload. In conclusion, the VSS can be used to measure acute driver stress in moderately stressful driving conditions.This study was funded by a grant from the strategic vehicle research and innovation (FFI) program at Sweden’s Innovation Agency (VINNOVA), grant number 2020-05157, and through the SUAB project financed by the European Social Fund, grant number 2020/00110.1.Mou, L., et al., Driver stress detection via multimodal fusion using attention-based CNN-LSTM. Expert Systems with Applications, 2021. 173: p. 114693.2.Rastgoo, M.N., et al., A critical review of proactive detection of driver stress levels based on multimodal measurements. ACM Computing Surveys (CSUR), 2018. 51(5): p. 1-35.3.Beanland, V., et al., Driver inattention and driver distraction in serious casualty crashes: Data from the Australian National Crash In-depth Study. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 2013. 54: p. 99-107.4.Wiberg, H., et al., Physiological responses related to moderate mental load during car driving in field conditions. Biological psychology, 2015. 108: p. 115-125.5.Åkerstedt, T. and M. Gillberg, Subjective and Objective Sleepiness in the Active Individual International Journal of Neuroscience, 1990. 52(1-2): p. 29-37.

INTRODUCTION

Emergency personnel, such as ambulance crews and firefighters, must per- form well both mentally and physically to provide effective emergency responses around the clock. The opportunity for recovery and rest between missions is often limited during work shifts. This can lead to an increased risk of fatigue and perceived stress during emergency responses, which also increases the risk of a crash. During emergency responses, personnel are exposed to acute stress physiological reactions, which are more pronounced in more urgent situations, such as priority 1 alarms in the case of traffic accidents (Karlsson, Niemelä et al., 2020). Stress has been identified as a contributing factor to road crashes due to its negative impact on driving per- formance (Beanland, Fitzharris et al., 2013; Mou, Zhou et al., 2021; Rastgoo, Nakisa et al., 2018). Stress increases the crash risk by affecting cognitive abili- ties, resulting in inadequate information processing and imperfect perception

© 2024. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 390

Validation of a One-Item Acute Stress Scale for Driving Tasks 391

that may in turn lead to deterioration of driver performance (Wiberg, Nilsson et al., 2015). Maintaining sufficient driving ability in all traffic situations is fundamental to prevent road crashes.

Physiological measurements, most often based on Heart Rate (HR) mea- sures, can be used to detect driver stress but there is also a need for subjective rating scales that are easy to use in a driving setting. For driver sleepi- ness, a scale often used is the 9-point one-item Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (Åkerstedt and Gillberg, 1990). This is a scale that has been proven sensi- tive and valid as an indicator of sleepiness, and particularly suitable for field studies (Åkerstedt, Anund et al., 2014). However, there is no equivalent mea- sure of acute driver stress. There are several validated instruments available for measuring perceived stress, such as Cohen’s Perceived Stress Scale (Cohen, Kamarck et al., 1983). Stress scales typically require the participant to answer several questions about their experiences to enable the calculation of a stress score. Validated one-item scales suitable for quick measurements of perceived acute stress are, however, lacking. In this study we investigated if a new one- item stress scale, named the VTI acute stress scale (VSS), could be used to measure acute driver stress in an ambulance simulator.

METHODS

A simulator trial was conducted with ambulance driving scenarios designed to induce various stress levels in emergency response personnel. Each par- ticipant performed three simulator tasks: Task A was a low-stress routine drive with a wildlife encounter towards the end, Task B was a medium-stress urgent callout, Task C was a high-stress emergency response (Table 1). The tasks were counterbalanced between participants. All participants had pre- vious experience using the ambulance simulator, but they were naïve to the specific driving tasks used in the study.

After each driving task, participants completed a questionnaire with ques- tions about perceived stress (9-point VSS scale), task load (NASA-TLX), and sleepiness (9-point KSS scale).

Table 1. Characteristics of the driving tasks.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Task Urgency Traffic density

Road type

Events Speed limit Time of day 50/70 kph Day

A Non-urgent Low Rural Wildlife encounter

50/70 kph Day

B Urgent Medium Urban None 50 kph Night C Life-threatening High Rural and Urban

Reversing car, traffic congestion, deteriorating patient

Participants Forty-nine participants (33 men and 16 women) were recruited among ambulance personnel and emergency response personnel in western Sweden. Everyone employed as ambulance paramedics, ambulance nurses or fire- fighters were eligible to participate. Exclusion criterium was self-reported previously diagnosed medical conditions that could affect physiological out- come measures that were included in the study but not reported in this paper, including cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and neurological diseases. Data collections took place at two different ambulance stations on five different occasions in year 2022. The study protocol was approved by the Swedish Ethical Review Authority (ref 2021-04352).

Measures The VTI acute stress scale (VSS) was developed for the present study to quantify perceived stress. It is a modified version of the Stockholm Uni- versity Stress scale (SUS; Dahlgren, Kecklund et al., 2005). The 9 verbal anchors of the VSS are designed to match the verbal anchors of the Karolin- ska Sleepiness Scale (KSS)(Åkerstedt and Gillberg, 1990). The VSS anchors are: 1 completely relaxed (feeling entirely calm and relaxed), 2 very relaxed, 3 relaxed, 4 rather relaxed, 5 neither relaxed nor stressed, 6 slightly stressed, 7 stressed (feeling some tension and pressure), 8 very stressed, 9 extremely stressed (feeling very tense and under high pressure, on the verge of what I can handle).

The NASA Task Load Index (NASA-TLX) is a multi-dimensional rating scale that provides workload ratings across six subscales: mental demand, physical demand, temporal demand, performance, effort, and frustration (Hart and Staveland, 1988).

Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (KSS) is a subjective rating scale where partici- pants can rate their own sleepiness level (Åkerstedt and Gillberg, 1990). The drivers indicated on a nine-point scale how sleepy they had felt (1 = extremely alert to 9 = very sleepy, great effort to keep awake, fighting sleep) on average during the driving task.

Before the study started the drivers were instructed on how to use the rating scales.

Statistical Analysis Results are generally presented as means with standard deviations (SD). Dif- ferences in questionnaire scores between the three driving tasks were analyzed using mixed model ANOVA. Separate regression models were created with each of the outcome measures as the dependent variable. Task (A, B, C) was included as a within-subjects factor and participant was included as a ran- dom factor. If the task effect was significant, pairwise comparisons were made between tasks with Tukey post-hoc tests. The significance level was set to 0.05. Statistical analyses were performed in IBM SPSS statistics version 29 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).

Validation of a One-Item Acute Stress Scale for Driving Tasks 393

RESULTS

Forty-eight drivers had VSS ratings from all three drives and were thus included in data analyses. The mean VSS ratings were A = 3.17 (SD 1.58, range 1–7), B = 3.77 (SD 1.59, range 1–6), and C = 4.65 (SD 1.77, range 1–7). The ANOVA with task (A, B, C) as a fixed factor and participant as a random factor showed that there was a significant difference in VSS ratings between tasks (Table 2). Post-hoc tests (Tukey) showed that task A had sig- nificantly lower rating than task B and task C, and task B had significantly lower ratings than task C (Table 2).

All NASA-TLX workload subscale scores were significantly higher for task C compared with task A and B (Table 2). Task B had significantly higher scores than task A regarding mental, physical, and temporal demand, effort, and frustration (Table 2). There was no significant difference in sleepiness between tasks (Table 2). KSS scores were generally low with mean ratings of A = 3.16 (SD 1.39), B = 3.31 (SD 1.23), and C = 2.78 (SD 1.12).

The VSS was significantly correlated with NASA-TLX subscales men- tal demand (r = 0.606), physical demand (r = 0.419), temporal demand (r = 0.605), performance (r = 0.313), effort (r = 0.541), and frustration (r = 0.553). The VSS was also moderately correlated with KSS (r = 0.304).

Table 2. ANOVA of differences in questionnaire scores between driving tasks.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Main effects (ANOVA) Post-hoc tests (Tukey) Task Participant Task A vs B Task A vs C Task B vs C

F p-value η2 F p-value η2 p-value p-value p-value VSS 22.9 <0.001 0.33 4.8 <0.001 0.71 0.021 <0.001 <0.001 Mental d. 33.0 <0.001 0.41 6.1 <0.001 0.75 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 Physical d. 18.3 <0.001 0.28 7.5 <0.001 0.79 0.009 <0.001 0.009 Temporal d. 78.7 <0.001 0.62 2.8 <0.001 0.59 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 Performance 7.2 0.001 0.13 2.5 <0.001 0.55 0.55 0.001 0.026 Effort 34.3 <0.001 0.42 6.4 <0.001 0.76 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 Frustration 40.1 <0.001 0.46 2.8 <0.001 0.58 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 KSS 6.7 0.002 0.12 6.6 <0.001 0.77 0.61 0.029 0.002

DISCUSSION

The focus of the study is to validate a new stress scale called VTI Acute Stress Scale (VSS), a scale built on similar approach as the KSS. The VSS could discriminate between the three driving tasks designed to induce varying levels of perceived stress. The medium correlations between VSS scores and NASA- TLX scores show that the VSS acute stress score is related to but not identical to workload.

The stress ratings were moderate throughout the trials, with no ratings above 7 on the 9-point scale. This could be due to simulator scenarios not being perceived as stressful as real-life emergency driving situations. Using simulators enabled a high control of the scenarios and consistency between participants. However, it is challenging to achieve the same feeling of urgency

as in real life emergency situations when driving in a simulator. Further eval- uation of the VSS in real-life and in very high stress scenarios is therefore warranted. Moreover, a challenge of studying stress in driving is that it nor- mally only occurs in isolated short events connected to a complex traffic scenario, making it difficult to capture the perceived stress level at the exact moment of high stress.

The main benefit with the VSS is that it matches the KSS in terms of range, increments, and verbal anchors. This allows the concurrent measurement of perceived stress and sleepiness in traffic safety studies. It is well-documented that fatigue is a contributing factor in 10–30% of all road crashes (Hallvig, Anund et al., 2014; Philip and Åkerstedt, 2006; Zwahlen, Jackowski et al., 2016). The link between stress and road crashes has not been studied to the same extent. Stress has been found to negatively affect driver performance and significantly increase the risk of a crash (Rastgoo, Nakisa et al., 2018). Australian national crash reports show that stress is among the ten leading contributors to serious casualty crashes (Beanland, Fitzharris et al., 2013).

Stress during driving depends on a multitude of factors (Gnardellis, Tzamalouka et al., 2008; Mamcarz, Dro´zdziel et al., 2019; Wang, Murphey et al., 2019) such as driving workload, quality of sleep, personality, and lifestyle. The literature suggests that professional drivers with long working days suffer significantly more driving stress compared to other drivers, with the corresponding effect on their driving style (Magaña, Pañeda et al., 2021). Ambulance personnel are exposed to several risk factors for future illnesses in their profession, including acute and chronic stress (Hegg-Deloye, Brassard et al., 2014). Work-related stress itself is a risk factor for developing cardio- vascular diseases and stroke (Huang, Xu et al., 2015; Steptoe and Kivimäki, 2013). The acute stress responses during an emergency mission is influenced by the current situation (acute stress), events earlier during the shift, and events in everyday life (chronic stress) (Karlsson, Niemelä et al., 2020). Future studies should investigate whether VSS ratings during emergency responses are affected by chronic stress levels.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the VSS can be used to measure acute driver stress in moder- ately stressful driving conditions. Future studies need to validate VSS during high stress scenarios, and in real road conditions with naturalistic driving.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The authors would like to acknowledge the contribution from Dr. Ke Lu and Jonas Åsberg in planning and participating in the data collection. This study was funded by a grant from the strategic vehicle research and innovation (FFI) program at Sweden’s Innovation Agency (VINNOVA), grant number 2020-05157, and through the SUAB project financed by the European Social Fund, grant number 2020/00110.

Validation of a One-Item Acute Stress Scale for Driving Tasks 395

REFERENCES

Åkerstedt, T. and Gillberg, M. 1990. Subjective and Objective Sleepiness in the Active Individual International Journal of Neuroscience 52(1–2) 29–37. Åkerstedt, T., Anund, A., Axelsson, J. and Kecklund, G. 2014. Subjective sleepiness

is a sensitive indicator of insufficient sleep and impaired waking function. J Sleep Res 23(3) 240–252. Beanland, V., Fitzharris, M., Young, K. L. and Lenné, M. G. 2013. Driver inattention and driver distraction in serious casualty crashes: Data from the Australian National Crash In-depth Study. Accident Analysis & Prevention 54 99–107. Cohen, S., Kamarck, T. and Mermelstein, R. 1983. A Global Measure of Perceived

Stress. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 24(4) 385–396. Dahlgren, A., Kecklund, G. and Åkerstedt, T. 2005. Different levels of work-related stress and the effects on sleep, fatigue and cortisol. Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health 277–285. Gnardellis, C., Tzamalouka, G., Papadakaki, M. and Chliaoutakis, J. E. 2008. An

investigation of the effect of sleepiness, drowsy driving, and lifestyle on vehicle crashes. Transportation research part F: Traffic psychology and behaviour 11(4) 270–281. Hallvig, D. et al. 2014. Real driving at night – Predicting lane departures from physiological and subjective sleepiness. Biological Psychology 101 18–23. Hart, S. G. and Staveland, L. E. 1988. Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load

Index): Results of Empirical and Theoretical Research. In P. A. Hancock and N. Meshkati eds. Advances in Psychology. North-Holland. pp. 139–183. Hegg-Deloye, S. et al. 2014. Current state of knowledge of post-traumatic stress, sleeping problems, obesity and cardiovascular disease in paramedics. Emerg Med J 31(3) 242–247. Huang, Y. et al. 2015. Association between job strain and risk of incident stroke: A

meta-analysis. Neurology 85(19) 1648–1654. Karlsson, K., Niemelä, P., Jonsson, A. and Törnhage, C.-J. 2020. Stress response in Swedish ambulance personnel during priority-1 alarms. Australasian Journal of Paramedicine 1–7. Magaña, V. C. et al. 2021. Beside and Behind the Wheel: Factors that Influence

Driving Stress and Driving Behavior. Sustainability 13(9) 4775. Mamcarz, P. et al. 2019. Level of occupational stress, personality and traffic incidents: Comparative study of public and freight transport drivers. Transportation Research Procedia 40 1453–1458. Mou, L. et al. 2021. Driver stress detection via multimodal fusion using attention-

based CNN-LSTM. Expert Systems with Applications 173 114693. Philip, P. and Åkerstedt, T. 2006. Transport and industrial safety, how are they affected by sleepiness and sleep restriction? Sleep Medicine Reviews 10(5) 347–356. Rastgoo, M. N. et al. 2018. A critical review of proactive detection of driver stress lev-

els based on multimodal measurements. ACM Computing Surveys (CSUR) 51(5) 1–35. Steptoe, A. and Kivimäki, M. 2013. Stress and cardiovascular disease: An update on current knowledge. Annual Review of Public Health. 337–354. Wang, K. et al. 2019. Detection of driver stress in real-world driving environ-

ment using physiological signals. 2019 IEEE 17th International Conference on Industrial Informatics (INDIN) pp. 1807–1814.

Wiberg, H. et al. 2015. Physiological responses related to moderate mental load during car driving in field conditions. Biological Psychology 108 115–125. Zwahlen, D., Jackowski, C. and Pfäffli, M. 2016. Sleepiness, driving, and motor

vehicle accidents: A questionnaire-based survey. Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 44 183–187.

Cover of the proceedings volume Advances in Human Factors of Transportation

Explore the complete digital volume

Advances in Human Factors of Transportation

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-24-3

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →