Tien-ling Yeh (2024). The Influence of Parent-child Toys and Time of Playing Together on Children’s Problem-Solving Skills in the Early Post-COVID Years. In: Usability and User Experience. AHFE Open Access, vol. 156, pp. 342–350. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1005445
The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted family lifestyles, children's capabilities, and parent-child interactions. This study aimed to explore the influences of parent-child interactions with toys and playing time on children’s problem-solving abilities in post-COVID-19. The research process included two phases: (1) Literature Review: The relationship among playtime, toy types, and children’s capability to solve problems.; and (2) Questionnaire Analyses. The questionnaire focuses on the influences of different types of parent-child toys and the time of playing together for age 2-6 kids on problem-solving skills. Choosing 32 questions from Social Problem-Solving Questionnaire (SPSQ) and Problem-Solving Style Questionnaire (PSSQ), preschool education specialists designed this questionnaire. Questionnaires were distributed in December 2023, and 30 of them were collected. The results are as follows. (1) Learning toys with numbers and symbols that aid in reading can help develop children’s logical thinking, thereby enhancing problem-solving skills. When parents and children engage in studying picture or illustration books together, it nurtures children's language capabilities and fosters interest in learning. Furthermore, sensory-motor playthings have a significant impact on the language development of children.; and (2) Children from families with accompanying playtime during 17:00-18:00 (before school time) or 21:00-22:00 (before/during bedtime) showed good analytical problem-solving capabilities. When faced with a complex problem, these children could identify the most crucial factor and, if they encountered a bottleneck, they would review the problem's context and related conditions to devise alternative solutions.
The COVID-19 pandemic has brought about unprecedented disruptions and profound changes to family life and education. The emergence of COVID-19 led to strict containment measures, including the closure of schools and day- care services, which significantly impacted families. Overnight, parents were forced to juggle their professional responsibilities, including telecommuting, while also managing the care and education of their children at home. These challenges continue to reverberate in the post-COVID era, reshaping the dynamics of family and education.
The Influence of Parent-Child Toys and Time of Playing Together 343
Based on the author’s previously published articles, extending from research results and keywords to this topic, the study utilized “Piagetian Game Cognition” and “Attachment Relationship.” The results showed that structured construction play materials, such as parents and children play- ing with building blocks, LEGO, puzzles, etc., can easily assist and motivate children to explore and learn. In this secure attachment relationship, it can stimulate a more positive attitude in children. If parents and children engage in playing structured construction toys together for an average of one hour each time, it can still generate a moderately intense attachment relationship. According to Kiromi (2018) stated that in role-playing, children create very familiar places and scenes, such as imitating the behaviours of family mem- bers and playing different roles around them. Through role-playing, children can increase their vocabulary. This is a way for them to practice commu- nication, cooperation, explore their world, mimic actions, and replicate the roles around them. Sutton-Smith’s play theory (Wood, Bruner & Ross, 1976) also supports the positive impact of diversified play behaviours on children’s creativity and problem-solving development. The purpose of this study is to explore the influences of parent-child toys and co-playing time on children’s problem-solving skills.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Parent-Child Interactions and Problem-Solving Relationship Rodick, Henggeler, and Hansen (1986) pointed out that positive and sup- portive communication between parents and children can reduce defensive reactions in children, promote problem-solving abilities, enhance empathy towards others’ issues and feelings, and foster trust in interpersonal rela- tionships. Children growing up in an environment filled with safety and encouragement are more likely to develop a sense of trust in themselves and others. They tend to express friendliness proactively and are also more likely to be liked and accepted by others (Wang, 1989). Pettit’s (1988) study found that early family experiences can predict children’s social abilities and problem-solving skills (cited in Lo, 1998). Naturally, a child’s emotional regulation will be more positive and effective when there is such commu- nication. Problem-solving is considered a cognitive process for individuals, and in parent-child interactions, it becomes an experience shared between them. It is a part of the overall behaviour in parent-child interactions. When parents engage in open and positive communication and interaction, pro- viding emotional support, it is correlated with a child’s performance in problem-solving.
Parent-Child Interactions and Play Relationship In a qualitative study on family co-parenting of preschool children by Lue (2002), it was discovered that parents participating together in children’s games serve as game partners, cooperate in teaching game rules, and provide ideas for problem-solving. A part of the content of parent-child interaction
344 Yeh
involves language communication, and research has shown that parents’ lan- guage use significantly influences their children’s problem-solving abilities (Hess, 1965; Panetta & Swank, 1979; cited in Chan, 1989).
Among Play, Toys and Problem-Solving Relationship In the developmental context of cognitive theory, Bruner presents different perspectives. He views games as sources of behavioural change (Rubin, Fein & Vandenberg, 1983), meaning that in games, children can experiment with various new behaviours and playstyles, which can later assist them in real-life situations that require problem-solving. Bateson’s game theory emphasizes the communication system of games. The communication messages include two parts: (1) the meaning in the game - children immerse themselves in roles and focus on pretend activities and items; (2) the meaning in real life - in addition to engaging in imaginative play, children also understand the roles they and others play in real life, as well as the functions of the items used in the game in the real world. In most studies on games and cog- nitive development, it has been found that games contribute to enhancing children’s IQ: conservation, problem-solving abilities, convergent and diver- gent thinking; language development and social skills (such as cooperation or emotional control), and creativity. “Exploratory play” is considered the most effective and direct way to cultivate children’s proactive learning, problem discovery, and problem-solving abilities. “Exploratory play”is considered the most effective and direct way to cultivate children’s proactive learning, prob- lem discovery, and problem-solving abilities. Exploration behaviour refers to spontaneous actions not triggered by external motives, and its nature is very similar to that of games. Information obtained from exploratory behaviour influences decision-making or changes in behaviour. Early expo- sure to “exploratory play”can help children develop active, autonomous, and free-trial capabilities. It allows children to discover problems, use old experi- ences and new experiences to engage in games and exploratory behaviours, seeking connections (Yang & Chen, 2007). Piaget (1962) regards play as a behaviour whose goal is to obtain happiness. It is an unstructured behaviour that plays an assimilative role in cognitive development, promoting individ- ual cognitive development. According to Piaget and the cognitive theory of play, toy forms are classified as symbolic play objects, fluid construction play materials, structured construction play materials, sensory-motor play objects, and learning toys for numbers and symbols. When parents and children play together through games and toys, the relationship between children’s adaptive behaviour, growth performance, and problem-solving abilities in different situations is explored.
RESEARCH METHODS
1. Subjects and survey duration
The research methods adopted include the questionnaire survey method and statistical methods. They were applied to explore the forms, time, and attachment relationships of parent-child co-play. Therefore, the
The Influence of Parent-Child Toys and Time of Playing Together 345
subjects for the questionnaire survey were set to parents with at least a preschool child aged 2 to 6.
Subjects: Dual-income families with parents of children aged 2–6 years old.
Number of questionnaires issued: 30.
Duration of survey: December 2023.
Place and method of survey: online.
2. Experimental variable
Independent variables: According to American Time Use Survey, time is divided into half hour. In this research, parents’ off-duty compan- ionship time for children is studied, therefore, the research is focused on: (1) the time period from 16:00–16:30 to 24:00, and each half hour is taken as one unit; (2) form of toys, based on the 6 categories of toys defined by Piaget’s theory: Symbolic play materials (Dolls, puppets, and models), Fluid construction toys (Clay), Structural construction toys (Building blocks), Sensory-motor playthings (Slide), and Learning toys for numbers and symbols (Number cards and letter cards) and the most common one: picture/illustration books.
Dependent variables: Measurement of Problem-Solving Ability: Adapting the questionnaire from Lin (1995) and Gülsüm Dü¸sek & Aynur Bütün Ayhan (2014), focusing on assessing problem-solving abilities in preschool children. The questionnaire, titled “Children’s Problem-Solving Ability Scale,” consists of 32 items, numbered from 1 to 32.
3. Research tool
Subjective perception scale, Likert Scale with a five-point measurement scale (“Strongly Agree, Agree, Unsure, Disagree, Strongly Disagree”). Respondents indicate their subjective feelings based on past experiences and observations of their child’s problem-solving skills and relationships with people and things. 4. Statistical analyses
1. Descriptive Statistics
2. One-way ANOVA:
Whether the form of parent-child play would influence child’s problem-solving skills.
Whether parenting time would influence child’s problem-solving skills.
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS Descriptive Statistics
The average educational background is mainly from a university or a univer- sity of science and technology, while the household income averages between NT$60,000 and NT$80,000. About 75% of females is primary caregivers, with 19 children aged 2 to 4 years old and 11 children aged 2 to 6 years old.
346 Yeh
Table 1. Demographic statistics.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Count No. Min. Max. Avg. S.D.
Gender of subject 30 1 2 1.83 .379 Gender of child 30 1 2 1.37 .490 Age of child 30 1 2 1.37 .490 Education background 30 3 5 4.33 .606 Average of household income 30 2 6 4.57 .817
ANOVA Results According to the results from the test of homogeneity (P > 0.05) and ANOVA, the significant items (P < 0.05) are listed in Table 2 and 3.
Table 2. Test results of the influences of the parent-child co-play forms on the intensity of children’s problem-solving skills.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
F Significance
Independent variables
Dependent variables Sum of squares
Degree of freedom
Mean squares
11.279 4 2.820 3.509 .021
Symbolic play materials
My child has good peer relationships
11.743 4 2.936 2.989 .038
My child has excellent interpersonal skills
Fluid construction toys
10.052 4 2.513 3.601 .019
Once my child starts doing something, they always finish it without giving up
4.576 4 1.144 2.834 .046
My child can come up with creative and effective ways to solve problems
12.330 4 3.083 13.920 <.001
Sensory-motor playthings
My child demonstrates a strong vocabulary comprehension ability
13.281 4 3.320 5.349 .003
When reading, my child pays attention to the main characters of the story and meaningful information
5.267 4 1.317 3.105 .033
Numbers and symbols
My child is interested in learning
7.283 4 1.821 8.010 <.001
My child can identify problems in their everyday life
3.917 4 .979 2.756 .050
My child is more motivated to do something when it is challenging
5.059 3 1.686 3.423 .032
Picture/ illustration books
My child demonstrates a strong vocabulary comprehension ability
4.922 3 1.641 3.897 .020
My child is interested in learning
4.674 3 1.558 4.407 .012
My child tends to ask questions when encountering problems
The Influence of Parent-Child Toys and Time of Playing Together 347
Table 3. Test result shows that parenting time will affect child’s problem-solving skills.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
F Significance
Independent variables
Dependent variables Sum of squares
Degree of freedom
Mean squares
1.932 1 1.932 4.903 .035
17:00–17:30 My child can identify problems in their everyday life
2.760 1 2.760 4.244 .049
My child can make quick decisions to solve problems if they have access to resources
5.633 1 5.633 5.143 .031
17:30–18:00 My child has excellent interpersonal skills
4.033 1 4.033 5.465 .027
My child demonstrates excellent language abilities
2.904 1 2.904 6.272 .018
My child is interested in learning
3.115 1 3.115 4.885 .035
My child can make quick decisions to solve problems if they have access to resources
5.633 1 5.633 9.100 .005
My child has a clear approach to problem-solving
6.982 1 6.982 6.668 .015
18:00–18:30 My child has excellent interpersonal skills
5.157 1 5.157 4.637 .040
19:00–19:30 My child has excellent interpersonal skills
6.017 1 6.017 7.341 .011
20:00–20:30 My child handles frustration well
4.267 1 4.267 4.760 .038
When my child senses a problem, they try to understand its cause
3.750 1 3.750 4.895 .035
My child can respond promptly when encountering problems
5.502 1 5.502 5.957 .021
20:30–21:00 My child has good peer relationships
3.259 1 3.259 6.068 .020
My child engages in continuous reflection and analysis of their experiences to solve problems effectively
8.760 1 8.760 11.904 .002
When my child senses a problem, they try to understand its cause
3.813 1 3.813 5.653 .024
My child can reflect on failures and devise new problem-solving strategies
3.401 1 3.401 6.582 .016
21:00–21:30 My child demonstrates a strong vocabulary comprehension ability
6.982 1 6.982 6.668 .015
My child has excellent interpersonal skills
5.345 1 5.345 6.381 .017
When reading, my child pays attention to the main characters of the story and meaningful information
9.503 1 9.503 12.170 .002
My child has good peer relationships
(Continued)
348 Yeh
Table 3. Continued
Table available in the original PDF paper.
F Significance
Independent variables
Dependent variables Sum of squares
Degree of freedom
Mean squares
3.607 1 3.607 6.873 .014
My child engages in continuous reflection and analysis of their thoughts and experiences to solve problems effectively
4.261 1 4.261 5.618 .025
My child can quickly learn from past experiences to prevent repeating the same mistakes
3.007 1 3.007 4.275 .048
My child can reflect on failures and devise new problem-solving strategies
3.227 1 3.227 6.171 .019
21:30–22:00 My child demonstrates a strong vocabulary comprehension ability
4.860 1 4.860 4.328 .047
My child has excellent interpersonal skills
3.840 1 3.840 4.308 .047
When reading, my child pays attention to the main characters of the story and meaningful information
6.407 1 6.407 7.187 .012
My child has good peer relationships
2.940 1 2.940 4.635 .040
My child can identify the crucial factors within complex problems when faced with them
2.940 1 2.940 5.359 .028
My child engages in continuous reflection and analysis of their thoughts and experiences to solve problems effectively
4.860 1 4.860 7.628 .010
My child can reflect on failures and devise new problem-solving strategies
4.167 1 4.167 4.289 .048
22:00–22:30 My child has good peer relationships
2.940 1 2.940 4.635 .040
When facing complex problems, my child can identify the most important factors in the problem
5.607 1 5.607 6.720 .015
My child handles frustration well
2.940 1 2.940 4.166 .051
My child can reflect on failures and devise new problem-solving strategies
CONCLUSION
Female Caregivers In the child development process, mothers primarily serve as caregivers. According to Table 1: Demographic statistics, there is a notable prevalence of highly educated working women serving as primary caregivers for children on a daily basis.
The Influence of Parent-Child Toys and Time of Playing Together 349
Relationship Between Toy Types and Problem-Solving Skills It is undeniable that children often have dolls, puppets, and models (symbolic play materials) as companions, which helps them build better relationships with their peers. Learning toys for numbers and symbols (number cards and letter cards) help children develop logical thinking. They can easily identify problems, become interested in learning, overcome fear of facing problems, and accept challenging tasks. Additionally, the results show that parents and children studying picture or illustration books can develop children’s lan- guage capabilities and foster interest in learning. Children are also more willing to ask questions when they encounter problems.
Rubin, Fein & Vandenberg (1983) stated that children can experiment with various new behaviours and playstyles, which can later assist them in real-life situations that require problem-solving. This aligns with the findings that fluid construction toys and playing with clay can help develop children’s problem-solving abilities in creative ways and enhance their interpersonal skills.
Interestingly, sensory-motor playthings have a significant impact on lan- guage development in children. Furthermore, during reading, they can focus on important roles and content, which is a part that the author had not pre- viously discovered. However, in the past, Lue (2002) mentioned that parents participating in children’s games together, cooperating, and teaching game rules can cultivate children’s problem-solving abilities. In the future, it is worthwhile to further explore which sensory action games are helpful for children’s growth and problem-solving skills.
Relationship Between Parenting Time and Problem-Solving Skills The companionship time falls between 17:00–18:00, the time when parents pick up their child after school, and the results show that 21:00–22:00, bed- time significantly impacts children’s problem-solving skills. This contributes to the child’s ability to ‘analyse problems.’ When facing complex issues, the child can identify the most critical factors. When encountering a problem, the child will first understand the reasons behind it. If the child feels stuck, they will re-examine the situation and conditions related to the problem, finding alternative solutions. During this period of time, parent-child interaction can strongly develop children’s language capabilities and good relationships with their peers. The evidence shows that children have strong vocabulary com- prehension ability and are able to pay attention to the main characters of the story and meaningful information when reading, as well as building trust to develop excellent interpersonal skills.
REFERENCES
Bandura, A. (1986). Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory. Englewood, NJ: Prentice Hall. Chan, S. M. (1989). A study on the correlation variables of creativity and problem-
solving ability among elementary school students. Unpublished master’s thesis, National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei.
350 Yeh
Dü¸sek, G., & Ayhan, A. B. (2014). A study on problem-solving skills of the children from broken family and full parents family attending regional primary boarding school. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 152, 137–142. Henggeler, S., Rodick, J. D., & Hansen, C. L. (1986). Multisystemic treatment
of juvenile offenders: Effects on adolescent behavior and family interactions. Developmental Psychology, 22, 132–141. Huang, D. Q. (2020). Being a good employee or a good parent? The impossible task for dual-income parents. Parenting World. Retrieved September 28, 2023, from https://www.parenting.com.tw/article/5086895. Hung, K. Y. (2023). Taiwan female labor participation rate 51.73% lower than that
of the United States and Japan. Taipei: China Times Online. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.chinatimes.com/newspapers/20230508000354-260110? chdtv. Investigating of happiness rate in Taiwan family. (2014). Child Welfare League Foundation. Retrieved May 20, 2014, from http://www.children.org.tw/news/advocac y_detail/1183. Kiromi, I. H. (2018). Pengaruh Metode Role Playing /Bermain PeranTerhadap Aspek
Perkembangan Bahasa Pada Anak. Ta’lim : Jurnal Pendidikan, 4(1), 57–66. https: //doi.org/10.36835/attalim.v4i1.54 Landreth, G. L., & Bratton, S. C. (2006). Child-parent relationship therapy (CPR): A 10-session filial therapy model. New York, NY: Routledge. Lue, T. (2002). The Correlates of Coparenting in families with preschoolers: Marital
Relations and Sex-role Attitudes. Journal of National Tainan Teachers College, 36, 1–18. Mercer, R. T., & Ferketich, S. L. (1990). Predictors of parental attachment during early parenthood. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 15, 268–280. Norton, Rubin, K. H., Fein, G. G., & Vandenberg, B. (1983). Play. In P. H.
Mussen (Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Socialization, personality, and social development (4th ed., Vol. 4, pp. 695–774). New York, NY: Wiley. Piaget, J. (1962). Play, dreams, and imitation in childhood. New York: Norton. Shiau, S. J. (1993). A comparative study of maternal-child interaction between high and low socioeconomic groups. Journal of National Public Health Association Republic of China, 12(2), 164–174. Wood, D. J., Bruner, J. S., & Ross, G. (1976). The role of tutoring in problem solving.
Journal of Child Psychiatry and Psychology, 17(2), 89–100. Wyver, S., & Spence, S. (1999). Play and divergent problem-solving: Evidence supporting a reciprocal relationship. Early Education and Development, 10(4), 419–444. Yang, S. H., & Chen, C. M. (2007). Inspiring creativity through block play activities.
Journal of Childcare and Education, 5, 87–112.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Usability and User Experience
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-964867-32-8
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional