Jay Kalra, Zoher Rafid-Hamed, Lily Wiebe, Patrick Seitzinger (2022). Medical Error Disclosure: A Quality Perspective and Ethical Dilemma in Healthcare Delivery. In: Healthcare and Medical Devices. AHFE Open Access, vol. 51, pp. 125–132. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002107
1 Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada; Royal University Hospital, Saskatchewan Health Authority, 103 Hospital Drive Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, S7N 0W8, Canada ↗↗↗
2 Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada ↗
3 Department of Pediatrics, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, 103 Hospital Drive, Saskatoon, S7N 0W8, Canada; Jim Pattison Children’s Hospital, Saskatchewan Health Authority, 103 Hospital Drive Saskatoon, S7N 0W8, Canada ↗↗
Medical errors are a significant public health concern that affects patient care and safety. Highlighted as a substantial problem in the 1999 Institute of Medicine report, medical errors have become the third leading cause of death in the United States of America. Failure to inform the patient of adverse events caused by a medical error compromises patient autonomy. Disclosure of adverse events to patients and families is critical in managing the consequences of a medical error and essential for maintaining patient trust. When errors occur, healthcare practitioners are faced with the ethical and moral dilemmas of if and to whom to disclose the error. Healthcare providers face these disclosure dilemmas across all disciplines, locations, and generations and have far-reaching implications on healthcare quality and the progress of medicine. We have previously reported the Canadian provincial initiatives encouraging open disclosure of adverse events and have suggested its integration into a 'no-fault' model. Though similar in content, the Canadian provincial initiatives remain isolated because of their non-mandatory nature and absence of federal or provincial laws on disclosure. The purpose of this study was to review and compare the disclosure policies implemented by individual health care regions/authorities in various parts of Canada to identify quality issues related to medical error disclosure based on several ethical and professional principles. The complexities of medical error disclosure to patients present ideal opportunities for medical educators to probe how learners balance the moral complexities involved in error disclosure. Effective communication between health care providers, patients, and their families throughout the disclosure process is integral in sustaining and developing the physician-patient relationship. We believe that the disclosure policies can provide a framework and guidelines for appropriate disclosure, leading to more transparent practices. We suggest that disclosure practice can be improved by creating a uniform policy centered on addressing errors in a non-punitive manner and respecting the patient's right to an honest disclosure and be implemented as part of the standard of care.
addressing medical errors a priority in healthcare systems around the world (Kalra et al. 2005, Gallagher et al. 2007, Kalra et al. 2013, Kim et al. 2017). Adverse events are injuries to patients resulting from medical treatment rather than the underlying medical condition (Coffey et al. 2010). Existing literature cites that one in eight hospitalized Canadians is affected by an adverse event (Baker et al. 2004). Adverse events can affect patients and their families in any setting and at any time. Medical errors are a type of adverse event and are defined as unintentional acts or the failure to complete planned actions as intended (Bari et al. 2016). Medical errors are currently the third leading cause of death in North America, behind heart disease and cancer (Makary and Daniel 2016). The financial burden associated with medical errors in the United States of America (USA) has been estimated to be between 17 and 29 billion dollars per year in lost income, disability, and other healthcare costs (Institute of Medicine 1999). Disclosure of adverse events, including medical errors, is essential to maintaining patient trust and healthcare qua- lity. Medical errors are often the result of systemic problems that are difficult to detect and measure unless appropriately reported. When there is a need for disclosure, physicians believe that disclosure is the right thing to do but face considerable obstacles and uncertainty of how to disclose errors (Gallagher et al. 2003). We have previously reported the Canadian provincial initiatives encouraging open disclosure of adverse events and have suggested its integra- tion into a ‘no-fault’ model (Kalra et el. 2004, Kalra 2016). While steps have been taken by health jurisdictions across Canada to minimize adverse events experienced by patients, the issue of honest disclosure has remained largely unaddressed. Serious doubts exist if any health care provider would cede the right of self-protection without appropriate legislation to address the issue. The purpose of this study was to review Canadian medical error disclosure policies set forth by the Canadian Provincial College of Physicians and Sur- geons, in addition to disclosure policies enacted by other nations, and discuss steps to navigate this ethically complex challenge.
BARRIERS AND BENEFITS OF ERROR DISCLOSURE Several barriers currently exist to error reporting. First, there is a concern for keeping the identities of providers and organizations confidential due to the threat of legal action. Second, medical professionals may believe that the time spent reporting has been wasted because reported information may not be used. For example, new medical equipment and pharmaceuticals are rigorously tested before they are distributed to medical practitioners, who may believe that the possible risks of new technologies are already known. Risky and aggressive interventions are standard practice in health- care because medical professionals may believe that the benefits outweigh the potential risks. Third, there is a lack of education and training in reco- gnizing medical errors. Fourth, lack of clear standards, tools, and definitions for reporting. Finally, there is a lack of compensation for those organizations undertaking the cost of reporting. The existence of these barriers often hin- ders a healthcare professional’s ability or willingness to disclose any adverse event that may have occurred.
Medical Error Disclosure: A Quality Perspective and Ethical Dilemma 127
Ethical and moral principles can be used to orient the policies and guide the disclosure process to ensure a patient-centered approach is utilized. Despite the obstacles, physicians should seek to disclose medical errors to patients and their families on both ethical and pragmatic grounds. Ethical principles such as veracity, fidelity, beneficence, and non-maleficence are violated when healthcare providers fail to disclose mistakes (Wu et al. 1997). Failure to adequately disclose medical errors undermines patient autonomy and com- promises a patient’s ability to make informed decisions (Edwin 2009). The fact that part of the physician-patient process involves medical consent entails that being denied information will severely impede the patient’s ability to act within their best interests. From a practical standpoint, it has been suggesti- ons that patients would prefer to receive full disclosure of harmful errors but are concerned that healthcare workers may not do so (Gallagher et al. 2003).
THE LEGAL LANDSCAPE Medical error disclosure has been tied closely to the tort system surrounding patient safety issues, which focuses on providing redress for the grievances suffered by patients and families rather than punishment on wrongdoers. Healthcare providers are often fearful that disclosure or an apology can place them at risk for lawsuits (Guillod 2013). They may hesitate to apo- logize and disclose errors as it could increase the chances of a malpractice claim. The gap in disclosure has led many states in the USA to pass apo- logy laws (McMichael et al. 2019). While these laws have the potential to be beneficial, they currently only protect expressions of regret and not the disclosure of error (McMichael et al. 2019). In Canada, there have been mul- tiple legal decisions beginning in the 1980s that established if a physician made an error that harmed or had the potential to harm a patient, they have a legal obligation to disclose this fact to the patient (Hebert 1999). Begin- ning with Stamos v Davies of the Ontario High Court in 1985, where a disclosure duty was first established in Canada, the legal scene continues to evolve (Hebert 1999). Despite medical professionals’ concerns about mal- practice suits brought against them, the literature indicates that disclosing errors honestly and promptly may mitigate legal ramifications (Lee, 2016, MacCourt and Bernstein 2009, Studdert et al. 2006, Volpintesta 2006). Consequently, studies have shown that honesty and openness in disclosing medical mistakes reduce the risk of a malpractice suit and enhance patient trust in the physician (Heilig 1994).
DISCLOSURE POLICIES IN CANADA AND ACROSS THE GLOBE Institutions around the world have taken different approaches to implement medical error disclosure strategies and to operationalize patients’ right to know. These differences are in part attributable to differences in the cultural, legal, and economic landscape in which healthcare systems exist (Kiguba et al. 2015, Shanks et al. 2015, Turillazzi and Neri 2014). In Canada, the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons has promoted the disclosure of adverse
Table 1. Canadian provincial college of physicians and surgeons policies on medical error disclosure.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Province Year Key points
2007 Not an admission of fault or liability
British Columbia 2006 Apology Act-Prevents an apology as an admission of liability Alberta 2011 Include an apology and acknowledge event Saskatchewan 2002 Include an apology Manitoba 2002 Avoid speculation Ontario 2003 Patient can refuse discussion Quebec 2004 Integrated in Code of Ethics Newfoundland & Labrador
2009 Includes education plan
Nova Scotia 2006 Implementation of a “just culture” Prince Edward Island
2008 Includes checklist and flow chart to follow
New Brunswick 2004 Includes checklist to follow North West Territories Yukon Territories 2009 Includes algorithm and mnemonic guide
events, including medical errors, to all partners, including patients in a timely manner (National Steering Committee on Patient Safety 2002).
Almost all provincial regulatory bodies, College of Physicians and Sur- geons, in Canada have adopted some form of a disclosure policy with key points to address medical errors and adverse events (Table 1) (Borsellino 2003, Kalra 2016, National Steering Committee on Patient Safety 2002) These Canadian provincial initiatives, though similar in content, remain iso- lated because of their non-mandatory nature and the absence of federal or provincial laws on disclosure. The designing of an error disclosure policy requires integration of various aspects, including bioethics, physician-patient communication, quality of care, and team-based care delivery. We suggest the implementation of a uniform policy centered on addressing errors in a non- punitive manner and respecting the patient’s right to an honest disclosure be a standard of care.
While each country struggles to navigate unique social and legal land- scapes, lessons can be learned from other healthcare systems around the world that have made progress in different domains of implementing nati- onal disclosure policies. The feasibility of medical error disclosure guidelines is enhanced when enacted in conjunction with strategies to reduce barriers to disclosure. In Australia, barriers to medical error disclosure have been redu- ced by policies that protect healthcare providers by making such disclosures free of implied liability and inadmissible in legal proceedings (Kalra et al. 2020). In New Zealand, no-fault compensation policies are funded by phy- sicians’ insurance premiums. They entitle patients affected by adverse events related to medical care to be compensated and rehabilitated while protecting providers from individual legal liability and tort claims. Similarly in the Uni- ted Kingdom, the National Health Service in 2003 implemented the a ‘duty of
Medical Error Disclosure: A Quality Perspective and Ethical Dilemma 129
candour,’ whereby doctors and managers must inform a patient of an act of negligence or omission that causes harm (Dyer 2003). This offers the patient a package in the form of remedial care, apologies, and monetary compensation without the need for litigation. If patients accept the compensation package, they waive their right to litigate. In the USA, open disclosure of any critical event during medical care to either the patient or family is required for accre- ditation of medical institutions (Paradise 2004). Further research is required to better understand how healthcare providers across all continents, discipli- nes, and stages of training navigate the ethical, legal, societal, and systemic complexities of medical error disclosure (Kalra 2016). Only through colla- boration and shared goals to improve patient care can progress be made to strengthen the quality and transparency of healthcare.
NEXT STEPS IN NAVIGATING MEDICAL ERROR DISCLOSURE DILEMMAS The genesis of medical errors lies in both system and human failures. There is little to be achieved by forcing these reporting systems on healthcare pro- fessionals. Nonpunitive reporting and confidential handling information are the foremost requirements in a successful reporting system. This information is provided to protect patients against a future occurrence of similar events and, therefore, should be used solely for this purpose. Unless reporters are assured of indemnity from liability on reporting, few will step forward to report critical incidents. Inappropriate blame attribution will merely alienate professionals and discourage them from participating in system improve- ment, which is essential for maintaining and enhancing health care quality. Cultural changes to support reporting of errors should be fostered. Increasin- gly unrealistic expectations of patients, society, and healthcare industries for flawless healthcare delivery despite outdated practices of sleep deprivation, time restraints and factors known to precipitate burnout, must be addres- sed. These factors drive many professionals away from their ethical duty and responsibility of honest disclosure of mistakes. Error reporting systems should be built on the focus of systems-oriented change rather than individu- alistic targeted reforms. For medical error and patient safety to be addressed in any form, there needs to be appropriate leadership in all realms, inclu- ding physicians, organizations, and other related authorities. The executive responsibility includes providing clear and specific guidelines for others to follow must be handled by leaders in the profession. The designing of error reporting systems requires the integration of various reporting principles, quality-oriented approaches, and appropriate leadership to make significant contributions to the improvement of quality care and patient safety across all healthcare disciplines.
Implementing a uniform and nonpunitive national policy to address medi- cal error disclosure is no simple task. Improving patient safety requires striking a delicate balance between competing interests to create a culture of safety for both patients and healthcare providers. Although some medical errors may be unavoidable, healthcare systems must remain diligent in redu- cing the prevalence of errors by identifying causes and developing systematic
measures to adverse events. Effective communication between healthcare providers, patients, and their families throughout the disclosure process is integral to developing and sustaining the therapeutic relationship. The focus on enhancing quality care should be supplemented by increased honesty and openness policies with patients. It is imperative for the sake of patient safety and continuous quality improvement in health care that disclosure, reporting, and discussion of errors committed or witnessed be a standard procedure. Only through appropriate disclosure and open attitudes can the cause of errors be identified, and healthcare delivery systems be improved.
CONCLUSION
Medical errors are a growing public health concern in healthcare systems across the world. As the prevalence of medical errors and adverse events continues to grow, healthcare systems are tasked with forming policy and systematic approaches to mitigate these potentially preventable harms. The correction of flaws in the medical system and the subsequent protection of patients’ health should be a top priority. When an adverse event occurs, there is a need for open and honest communication with patients and families. Policy creation, revision, and adaptation can be utilized for systematic tran- sformation. Disclosure policies can provide a framework and guidelines for appropriate disclosure, leading to more transparent healthcare practices. An effective disclosure policy for adverse events is crucial in creating a safety culture.
REFERENCES
Baker GR, Norton PG, Flintoft V, et al. (2004) The Canadian Adverse Events Study: The incidence of adverse events among hospital patients in Canada. CMAJ. CMAJ. DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.1040498. Bari A, Khan RA and Rathore AW (2016) Medical errors, causes, consequences,
emotional response and resulting behavioral change. Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences 32(3). Pak J Med Sci: 523–528. DOI: 10.12669/pjms.323.9701. Borsellino M (2003) Disclosure of harm to be standard of practice. Medical Post 39(11). Coffey M, Thomson K, Tallett S, et al. (2010) Pediatric residents’ decision-
making around disclosing and reporting adverse events: The importance of social context. Academic Medicine 85(10). Acad Med: 1619–1625. DOI: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181f046a6. Dyer C (2003) NHS staff should inform patients of negligent acts. BMJ 327(7405).
British Medical Journal Publishing Group: 7. DOI: 10.1136/BMJ.327.7405.7. Edwin A (2009) Non-disclosure of medical errors an egregious violation of ethical principles. Ghana medical journal 43(1). Ghana Medical Association: 34–9. Gallagher TH, Waterman AD, Ebers AG, et al. (2003) Patients’ and Physicians’
Attitudes Regarding the Disclosure of Medical Errors. Journal of the American Medical Association 289(8). JAMA: 1001–1007. DOI: 10.1001/jama.289.8.1001. Gallagher TH, Studdert D and Levinson W (2007) Disclosing Harmful Medical Errors to Patients. New England Journal of Medicine 356(26). N Engl J Med: 2713–2719. DOI: 10.1056/nejmra070568.
Medical Error Disclosure: A Quality Perspective and Ethical Dilemma 131
Guillod O (2013) Medical error disclosure and patient safety: legal aspe- cts. Journal of Public Health Research 2(3). PAGEPress Publications: 31. DOI: 10.4081/jphr.2013.e31. Hebert PC (1999) Patients must be told of unintended injuries during treatment [7]. British Medical Journal. British Medical Journal Publishing Group. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.318.7200.1762b. Heilig S (1994) Honest mistakes: From the physician father of a young patient. Cam-
bridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 3(4). Camb Q Healthc Ethics: 636–638. DOI: 10.1017/S0963180100005557. Institute of Medicine (1999) To err is human: Building a safer health system (Report Brief). Institute of Medicine Kohn LT, Corrigan JM, and Donaldson MS (eds) (November). Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press (US): 1–8. DOI: 10.17226/9728. Kalra, J., Saxena, A., Mulla, A., Neufeld, H., Qureshi, M. and Massey KL (2004)
Medical error: a clinical laboratory approach in enhancing quality care. Clin Biochemistry 37: 732–733. Kalra J (2016) Medical Error Disclosure: A Point of View. Pathology and Laboratory Medicine 1(1): 1–3. DOI: 10.17140/PLMOJ-1-e001. Kalra J, Massey KL and Mulla A (2005) Disclosure of medical error: Policies and
practice. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 98(7). Royal Society of Medicine Press: 307–309. DOI: 10.1258/jrsm.98.7.307. Kalra J, Kalra N and Baniak N (2013) Medical error, disclosure and patient safety: A global view of quality care. Clinical Biochemistry 46(13–14). The Canadian Soci- ety of Clinical Chemists: 1161–1169. DOI: 10.1016/j.clinbiochem.2013.03.025. Kalra J, Campos-Baniak MG, Saxena A, et al. (2020) Medical error disclosure -
A canadian perspective in improving quality of health care. In: Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 24 July 2020, pp. 26–34. Springer, Cham. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-20451-8_3. Kiguba R, Waako P, Ndagije HB, et al. (2015) Medication Error Disclosure and Attitudes to Reporting by Healthcare Professionals in a Sub-Saharan African Setting: A Survey in Uganda. Drugs - Real World Outcomes 2(3). Springer: 273–287. DOI: 10.1007/s40801-015-0032-7. Kim CW, Myung SJ, Eo EK, et al. (2017) Improving disclosure of medical error
through educational program as a first step toward patient safety. BMC Medical Education 17(1). BioMed Central Ltd.: 1–6. DOI: 10.1186/s12909-017-0880-9. Lee MJ (2016) On Patient Safety: Do You Say “I’m Sorry” to Patients? Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 474(11). Springer New York LLC: 2359– 2361. DOI: 10.1007/s11999-016-5025-7. MacCourt D and Bernstein J (2009) Medical error reduction and tort reform through private, contractually-based quality medicine societies. American Journal of Law and Medicine. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1177/009885880903500402. Makary MA and Daniel M (2016) Medical error—the third leading cause
of death in the US. BMJ 353. British Medical Journal Publishing Group. DOI: 10.1136/BMJ.I2139. McMichael BJ, Van Horn RL and Viscusi WK (2019) “Sorry”Is Never Enough: How State Apology Laws Fail to Reduce Medical Malpractice Liability Risk. Stanford Law Review 71(2): 341–409. National Steering Committee on Patient Safety (2002) Building a Safer System: A
National Integrated Strategy for Improving Patient Safety in Canadian Health Care. DOI: 10.7939/R3-YQ69-GP38.
Paradise A (2004) Why the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations should add new regulations regarding libraries. Journal of the Medical Library Association 92(2). Medical Library Association: 166–168. Shanks L, Bil K and Fernhout J (2015) Learning without borders: A review of the
implementation of medical error reporting in médecins sans frontières. PLoS ONE 10(9). Public Library of Science: e0137158. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0137158. Studdert DM, Mello MM, Gawande AA, et al. (2006) Claims, Errors, and Compensation Payments in Medical Malpractice Litigation. New England Journal of Medicine 354(19). Massachusetts Medical Society: 2024–2033. DOI: 10.1056/ne- jmsa054479. Turillazzi E and Neri M (2014) Medical error disclosure: From the therapeutic alli-
ance to risk management: The vision of the new Italian code of medical ethics. BMC Medical Ethics. BioMed Central Ltd. DOI: 10.1186/1472-6939-15-57. Volpintesta EJ (2006) Medical Malpractice and Patient Safety. New England Journal of Medicine 355(7). N Engl J Med: 734–736. DOI: 10.1056/nejmc061571. Wu AW, Cavanaugh TA, McPhee SJ, et al. (1997) To tell the truth: Ethical and pra-
ctical issues in disclosing medical mistakes to patients. Journal of General Internal Medicine. J Gen Intern Med. DOI: 10.1046/j. 1525–1497.1997.07163.x.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Healthcare and Medical Devices
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-27-8
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional