Jay Kalra, Anjali Saxena, Zoher Rafid-Hamed (2023). Medical Error Disclosure in Healthcare – The Scene across Canada. In: Emerging Technologies in Healthcare and Medicine. AHFE Open Access, vol. 116, pp. 182–188. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1004370
1 Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada; Royal University Hospital, Saskatchewan Health Authority, 103 Hospital Drive Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, S7N 0W8, Canada ↗↗↗
2 Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada ↗
The quality of healthcare is an emerging concern worldwide. Despite the advancement in the medical field, adverse events resulting from medical errors are relatively common in healthcare systems. Disclosure of an adverse event is an important element in managing the consequences of a medical error. We have previously reviewed and compared various disclosure policies that are in practice in Canada and around the globe to analyze the progress made in this area and suggested a non-punitive, “no-fault” model for reporting medical errors. The purpose of this study was to review and compare the disclosure policies implemented by individual health authorities across the Canadian provinces and territories. We evaluated each policy based on the inclusion of the following key points: Apology, avoidance of blame, avoidance of speculation, immediate disclosure, patient support, provider support, provider training, team-based approach, accessibility, and documentation. The clinical significance of the study was to evaluate various health authorities’ policies of disclosure and report a practice model for medical error disclosure across Canada. The three top parameters found within the disclosure policies include an apology or expression of regret, a team-based approach and documentation of disclosure, all three averaging at 98% respectively across the provinces and territories. The bottom two parameters found within the disclosure policies include provider training and accessibility of disclosure policy through the health authorities’ website, both averaging at 34% respectively. We believe healthcare providers' top priority should be correcting flaws in the medical system and protecting patients' health. Despite the obstacles, physicians should seek to disclose medical errors to patients and their families on both ethical and pragmatic grounds. We believe that the disclosure policies can provide framework and guidelines for appropriate disclosure, which can lead to improved quality care and practices that are more transparent. We suggest that disclosure practice can be improved by creating a uniform policy, centered on honest disclosure and addressing errors in a non-punitive manner.
Adverse events are inevitable due to the complexity of the healthcare process. Medical errors have gained significance due to their increased prevalence, which is detrimental to the safety of patients (Aghighi et al., 2022). Medical errors contribute to increased morbidity and mortality of patients. Medi- cal error are suggested to be the 3rd leading cause of death in the United States, after heart disease and cancer (Kalra et al., 2017; Karande et al., 2021). Disclosure of medical error is often a balance between a physician’s ethical duty to disclose versus fear of repercussions. Despite the most sin- cere intentions and proficient skills, healthcare remains an undertaking led
Medical Error Disclosure in Healthcare – The Scene Across Canada 183
by humans, inevitably prone to errors (Gorgich et al., 2016; da Silva and Krishnamurthy, 2016; Bari et al., 2016). While every conceivable effort should be exerted to curtail the frequency of errors, their occurrence stands as a sobering reality that necessitates acknowledgment for effective mitigation. The significance of medical errors lies in their potential to trigger Adverse Events (AEs), which encompass patient injuries stemming from medical inter- ventions, independent of any underlying medical condition (Baker at al., 2004; Kalra J., 2011; Kalra and Kopargaonkar, 2017). Notably, avoidable AEs underscore a systemic shortcoming, signifying a lapse in the healthcare system’s fundamental duty of safeguarding patient well-being. The Institute of Medicine’s (IOM) report “To Err is Human” described medical errors as a public health risk (Insitute of Medicine, 2000). The report stresses that preventable medical errors are common in medical practice, resulting in the deaths of 98,000 people in United States hospitals annually and costing the nation $17-29 billion in health care, lost income, and other injury-related expenses (Rodziewicz, 2023). When an error occurs, a common dilemma facing physicians is whether to disclose the error to the patient. Research findings reveal that patients are keen to know about any error that causes them harm. The patient’s bill of rights demands to have full disclosure of an error. Several studies report that patients prefer disclosure, enhancing their trust in their physicians’ honesty and reassuring them that they receive com- plete information about their overall care (Kim et al., 2017; Gallagher et al., 2009). Furthermore, patients believe that humans are not perfect, they might make mistakes, and “human nature” might lead health care workers to hide errors from patients (Kalra et al., 2005).
Advantages of Transparent Medical Error Disclosure Amidst diverse challenges and significant implications, disclosing medical errors to patients and their families is an indispensable facet of delivering high-quality healthcare rooted in ethical principles and practical considera- tions (Bismark et al., 2006; Mazor et al., 2004). Failing to adequately disclose medical errors carries ethical ramifications, infringing upon the patient’s autonomy (American Medical Association, 2020). This withholding of infor- mation undermines the patient’s capacity to grant informed consent and to engage in well-considered medical choices. The intrinsic link between the physician-patient dynamic and medical consent underscores that denying information significantly impedes patients’ ability to act in their best inter- ests. Instituting policies that guide the proper disclosure of medical errors is a bulwark against breaches of trust while also nurturing the sanctity of the ther- apeutic relationship (Hébert et al., 2001). Such policies play an essential role in upholding the mutual respect and understanding necessary for effective medical care, thus reinforcing the vital bond between healthcare providers and their patients.
Although litigation following medical error disclosure is a significant con- cern, lack of disclosure may further increase risk. Studies have reported that failing to explain and communicate medical errors adequately increases the risk of malpractice litigation (Guillod, 2013). It has been demonstrated that
honesty and openness with the patient can help improve the relationship between the two parties, reducing the legal strain to follow (O’Connor et al., 2010). From a practical standpoint, it has been suggested that patients expect full disclosure of harmful errors but are concerned that healthcare workers will not provide this information (Fein et al., 2007). Consequently, studies have shown that disclosing the medical error promptly and openly enhanced patient trust in the physician by fulfilling a need that the patient did not expect to be fulfilled (Anwer and Abu-Zaid, 2012).
Global Landscape of Medical Errors National and international initiatives and advances to address disclosure fol- lowing medical errors show a range of attitudes toward patients’ right to know and institutional and healthcare providers’ immunity and responsibil- ity. Differences in legal, social, economic, and health care systems, social and cultural factors, and access to health services have historically differed among nations, underpinning patient experiences of care and expectations of qual- ity and disclosure. Across global studies, the prevalence of adverse events among hospital patients has exhibited a range of disparities, with rates span- ning from 3.7% in New York to 11% in the United Kingdom and reaching 16.6% in Australia (Kalra et al., 2005; Kalra et al., 2020; Australia Council for Safety and Quality in Health Care, 2002). Within the Canadian context, these figures vary between 5% and 7.5% (Louie et al., 2010). The significant variability in reported adverse event rates can partly be attributed to dissim- ilarities in research methodologies and patient cohorts. We have previously proposed a ‘no-fault’ model whereby disclosing adverse events to patients is integral to accreditation (Kalra, 2011). The United States Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) recommends that the doctor conduct the disclosure. Although research continues to grow in error disclosure and patient safety, it is evident that a patient-centered model supported by a culture of safety will significantly reduce error rates.
A Canadian Perspective Canada’s current medical error disclosure scene reflects a growing emphasis on transparency, accountability, and patient-centered care. Canadian health- care organizations, guided by ethical principles and patient safety impera- tives, actively promote open communication between healthcare providers and patients when errors occur. Policies, guidelines, and training programs are being developed to equip healthcare professionals with the skills and tools for effective disclosure conversations. Legal protections such as Apology Acts in certain provinces foster an environment where healthcare providers can express empathy and apologies without fear of legal consequences (Robbennolt, 2009; MacDonald and Attaran, 2009). Patient engagement is a central tenet, recognizing the importance of involving patients and families in the disclosure process and subsequent decision-making (Abo-Glele et al., 2021). While challenges and variations in practices persist, there is a con- certed effort to shift the culture towards honesty, learning, and continuous improvement. The evolving landscape of medical error disclosure in Canada
Medical Error Disclosure in Healthcare – The Scene Across Canada 185
reflects a commitment to patient safety, transparency, and building trust in the healthcare system.
Canadian Policies Medical error disclosure policies were reviewed from individual health authorities in Canadian Provinces and Territories. Disclosure policies were obtained through email, telephone, and documents from the health author- ities’ website. Upon receipt of the disclosure policies, the contents were evaluated based on the ten key criteria. The study excluded the province of Quebec due to a lack of complete data availability. In reviewing and compar- ing the medical error disclosure policies across the Canadian provinces and territories, most policies did not differ regarding who should disclose and when the disclosure should be done.
The criteria chosen to compare within medical error disclosure policies were: apology, avoidance of blame, avoidance of speculation, immediate disclosure, patient support, provider support, provider training, team-based approach, accessibility, and documentation. These ten criteria were identi- fied as critical components for any medical error disclosure policy. Although these are all essential features, we have ranked them in order of importance, as summarized in Table 1. This is done to provide the best guidelines for developing current and future medical error disclosure policies.
Table 1. Key criteria of disclosure policies in order of importance.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Key Criteria Order of Importance Apology 1 Patient Support 2 Immediate Disclosure 3 Avoidance of Speculation 4 Avoidance of Blame 5 Provider Support 6 Team-Based 7 Approach Documentation 8 Provider Training 9 Accessibility 10
CONCLUSION
With the escalating concern and economic implications tied to preventable medical errors and adverse events, it has become imperative to institute well- defined protocols. To foster a climate of transparent communication with patients, it is crucial to cultivate a comprehensive understanding of the intri- cate landscape of medical errors. As such, sharing knowledge about this complex topic and developing practical approaches is essential to foster a culture of candid disclosure. Appropriate processes must be executed as pre- ventable medical errors and adverse events become a growing concern and
cost. Sharing knowledge and learning about the complex topic of medical error and how to approach it is necessary to encourage honest disclosure with patients. The disclosure of a medical error is an ethical dilemma that requires deliberative thinking and reflection by the health care providers. Healthcare providers must be aware of the legislation enforced in the jurisdiction under which they practice making disclosure easier and less daunting. Improving the process of healthcare is not a mandate for physicians alone. It is a col- lective effort of healthcare institutions, policymakers, providers, and patients working toward a common goal. Only through such collaboration can med- ical error disclosure become a standard, achievable, and informative practice in healthcare improvement.
REFERENCES
Aghighi N, Aryankhesal A, Raeissi P. Factors affecting the recurrence of medical errors in hospitals and the preventive strategies: a scoping review. J Med Ethics Hist Med. 2022 Oct 25;15:7. Aho-Glele, U., Bouabida, K., Kooijman, A., Popescu, I. C., Pomey, M. P., Hawthorn-
thwaite, L., Ploquin, J., Dunn, S., Trbovich, P., Tétrault, B., de Sousa, M. R. G., Clément, L., & Lungu, N. (2021). Developing the first pan-Canadian survey on patient engagement in patient safety. BMC health services research, 21(1), 1099. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-021-07089-6 American Medical Association. Opinion 8.12 Patient information. Code of Medical Ethics. https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/ama-code-medical-ethics -opinions-disclosing-diagnoses-patients/2011-12. Accessed January 19, 2020. Anwer, L. A., & Abu-Zaid, A. (2012). Transparency in medical error disclosure: the
need for formal teaching in undergraduate medical education curriculum. Medical education online, 19, 23542. https://doi.org/10.3402/meo.v19.23542 Australian Council for Safety and Quality in Health Care. Draft Open Disclosure Standard. Standards Australia, XX 1234–2002, Draft v5.2. Baker, G. R., Norton, P. G., Flintoft, V., Blais, R., Brown, A., Cox, J., Etchells, E.,
Ghali, W. A., Hébert, P., Majumdar, S. R., O’Beirne, M., Palacios-Derflingher, L., Reid, R. J., Sheps, S., Tamblyn, R.: The Canadian Adverse Events Study: the incidence of adverse events among hospital patients in Canada. CMAJ. 170, 1678–1686 (2004). Bari, A., Khan, R. A., Rathore, A. W.: Medical errors; causes, consequences, emotional response and resulting behavioral change. Pak J Med Sci. 32, 523–528 (2016). Bismark, M., Dauer, E., Paterson, R., Studdert, D.: Accountability sought by patients
following adverse events from medical care: the New Zealand experience. CMAJ 175, 889–894 (2006). da Silva, B. A., Krishnamurthy, M.: The alarming reality of medication error: a patient case and review of Pennsylvania and National data. J Community Hosp Intern Med Perspect. 6, (2016). Fein, S. P., Hilborne, L. H., Spiritus, E. M., Seymann, G. B., Keenan, C. R., Shoja-
nia, K. G., Kagawa-Singer, M., & Wenger, N. S. (2007). The many faces of error disclosure: a common set of elements and a definition. Journal of general internal medicine, 22(6), 755–761. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-007-0157-9 Gallagher, T. H., Bell, S. K., Smith, K. M., Mello, M. M., & McDonald, T. B. (2009).
Disclosing harmful medical errors to patients: tackling three tough cases. Chest, 136(3), 897–903. doi: 10.1378/chest.09–0030
Medical Error Disclosure in Healthcare – The Scene Across Canada 187
Gorgich, E. A. C., Barfroshan, S., Ghoreishi, G., Yaghoobi, M.: Investigating the Causes of Medication Errors and Strategies to Prevention of Them from Nurses and Nursing Student Viewpoint. Glob J Health Sci. 8, 220–227 (2016). Guillod O. (2013). Medical error disclosure and patient safety: legal aspects. Journal
of public health research, 2(3), e31. https://doi.org/10.4081/jphr.2013.e31 Hébert, P. C., Levin, A. V., & Robertson, G. (2001). Bioethics for clinicians: 23. Disclosure of medical error. CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l’Association medicale canadienne, 164(4), 509–513. Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Quality of Health Care in America. To
Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System. Kohn LT, Corrigan JM, Donald- son MS, editors. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2000. PMID: 25077248 Kalra J. Medical errors and patient safety: strategies to reduce and disclose medical errors and improve patient safety. De Gruyter; 2011. Kalra J., Campos-Baniak M. G., Saxena A., Rafid-Hamed Z. (2020) Medical Error
Disclosure - A Canadian Perspective in Improving Quality of Health Care. In: Lightner N., Kalra J. (eds) Advances in Human Factors and Ergonomics in Health- care and Medical Devices. AHFE 2019. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, vol. 957. Springer, Cham. Kalra J, Vantomme E, Rininsland V, Kopargaonkar A. 2017. Medical Error Disclosure: Mandate in Quality care and Patient Safety. Internal Med Review. 1(1) pp. 479–493. Kalra J. Medical errors and patient safety: strategies to reduce and disclose medical
errors and improve patient safety. De Gruyter; 2011. Kalra J, Kopargaonkar A. 2017. Quality Care and Patient Safety: Strategies to Disclose Medical Errors. In: Duffy V., Lightner N. (eds) Advances in Human Factors and Ergonomics in Healthcare and Medical Devices. AHFE 2017. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, vol. 590, pp. 159–167 Springer Cham. Kalra, J., Massey, K. L., & Mulla, A. (2005). Disclosure of medical error: poli-
cies and practice. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 98(7), 307–309. doi: 10.1258/jrsm.98.7.307. Karande, S., Marraro, G. A., & Spada, C. (2021). Minimizing medical errors to improve patient safety: An essential mission ahead. Journal of postgraduate medicine, 67(1), 1–3. https://doi.org/10.4103/jpgm. JPGM_1376_20 Kim, C. W., Myung, S. J., Eo, E. K., & Chang, Y. (2017). Improving disclosure of
medical error through educational program as a first step toward patient safety. BMC medical education, 17(1), 52. doi: 10.1186/s12909-017-0880-9. Louie, K., Wilmer, A., Wong, H., Grubisic, M., Ayas, N., & Dodek, P. (2010). Medication error reporting systems: a survey of canadian intensive care units. The Canadian journal of hospital pharmacy, 63(1), 20–24. https://doi.org/10.4212/cj hp.v63i1.864 MacDonald, N., & Attaran, A. (2009). Medical errors, apologies and apology
laws. CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l’Association medicale canadienne, 180(1), 11–13. https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.081997 Mazor, K. M., Simon, S. R., Yood, R. A., Martinson, B. C., Gunter, M. J., Reed, G. W., & Gurwitz, J. H. (2004). Health plan members’ views about disclosure of medical errors. Annals of internal medicine, 140(6), 409–418. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819- 140-6-200403160-00006.
O’Connor, E., Coates, H. M., Yardley, I. E., & Wu, A. W. (2010). Disclosure of patient safety incidents: a comprehensive review. International journal for qual- ity in health care: journal of the International Society for Quality in Health Care, 22(5), 371–379. https://doi.org/10.1093/intqhc/mzq042 Robbennolt J. K. (2009). Apologies and medical error. Clinical orthopaedics and
related research, 467(2), 376–382. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11999-008-0580-1 Rodziewicz, T. L., Houseman, B., & Hipskind, J. E. (2023). Medical Error Reduction and Prevention. In StatPearls. StatPearls Publishing.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Emerging Technologies in Healthcare and Medicine
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-92-6
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional