Alexandra Ávila-Fernandez, Janio Jadán-Guerrero, Johann Jadán-Altamirano, Isabel L. Nunes (2022). Using Intelligent Personal Assistants for Teaching English. In: Human Factors and Systems Interaction. AHFE Open Access, vol. 52, pp. 322–329. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002172
The lack of practice to develop language skills is the main problem in learning foreign languages. The aim of the research is to establish methodological strategies with virtual assistants, for elementary school students through innovative and interactive classes, to develop the macro skills of the English language. The methodological design of this study is based on a mixed qualitative-quantitative approach, with the participation of an expert on "Virtual assistants in the English language", five teachers from the English area and 57 elementary school students from a private school in Ecuador. The data collected from the teachers made it possible to identify the main problems that students have when it comes to developing macro skills in the English language. With the support of the education expert, a strategy was designed using virtual assistants. The personal assistant Alexa, with great programming flexibility, was selected, applying a strategy focused on four macro skills: listening, reading, speaking, and writing. Each activity was aimed to reinforcing each skill according to students’ level at school. For example, for speech skills, students had to engage in a dialogue with Alexa through a game of questions and answers. For listening skills, Alexa would tell a story to determine the level of comprehension. For reading skills, the students were given a reading from which they were asked questions that Alexa could answer and through this the students developed writing skills according to the questions they answered. After the intervention, a post test was applied and it was shown that there was an improvement in the development of skills. It was concluded that the interactive classes motivated the participation of all students. For future work, we intend to carry out a longitudinal study with the use of virtual assistants and a comparison between other devices.
Using Intelligent Personal Assistants for Teaching English 323
assistant can be defined as a computer program that helps in the recognition of human language through text and audio. Virtual assistants have the ability to interact with students in conversations that are becoming more natural. The use of new technology allows the student to develop practical skills, coming to understand the advantages and limitations, thus promoting col- laborative learning through complex tasks in order to collaborate, coexist, learn with the virtual assistant and even compete with it (Wiske, 2011).
The problem evidenced in English teaching, is largely due to the use of traditional teaching methods, for example, the grammar-translation method and the repetition of oral exercises with the audio-lingual method (Hernández Cherrez, 2014). That is why the opportunity was seen to propose the use of virtual assistants through innovative strategies that allow the development of English language skills.
The objective of this research is to establish methodological strategies with the help of the virtual assistant Alexa to develop the macro skills of English language through innovative and interactive classes for children of 10 to 12 years old.
The virtual assistant Alexa was selected, due to the large number of bene- fits and functionalities that it presents and thanks to its capabilities within the Amazon cloud, which can be modified or loaded according to the teach- ers’ needs. This advantage that Alexa presents allows users to access various activities to enhance their knowledge or to maintain practice. Through an Amazon account, skills can be created on any topic of interest for the teacher and additionally it allows configuration in several languages, which gives the opportunity to apply it in English teaching with the purpose of developing language skills (speaking, listening, writing, and reading). In this sense, Alexa becomes an element that allows developing the macro skills of English langu- age since it is an assistant that motivates the educational process, achieving better learning (Saavedra Montejo, 2020; Amazon, 2021).
English teaching is important in Latin American countries for which vari- ous programs have been implemented that allow their population to learn this language (Delgado, 2009), considering that it is one of the most spoken languages around the world, allowing educational and economic relationsh- ips at a global level. In addition, it should be noted that the methods applied correctly strengthen the educational process of English, therefore, these must be linked to the learning objective. In this way we can define what is required for students in each of the skills:
Speaking - the ability to speak fluently and with correct pronunciation, in such a way that a student can establish a basic conversation with another person;
Reading - the ability to have a fluid and comprehensive reading of any text;
Writing - the ability to correctly write words of his own vocabulary accor- ding to age, and to formulate short sentences, with grammatical structure; and
Listening - the ability to understand conversations and audios without difficulty.
RELATED WORK
According to Dorfman et al (2019), initially students see virtual assistants as useless, confusing and overwhelming, but after gaining experience using them, the negative perception they had regarding these resources decreases significantly. It was found that the majority of students feel highly motivated to learn with the use of digital resources, however there is still a percentage that feels more comfortable learning with traditional methods and resources such as texts that allow them to have a clearer understanding of what they need or want to learn.
According to the research of Basantes, Cabezas, and Casillas (2020) the implementation of virtual assistants allows expanding the axes of basic general education using ICTs as a technological resource within the teaching- learning process. In their results it is shown that teachers and students have a great openness for the configuration and use of virtual assistants when lear- ning. Both teachers and students are currently immersed in the technological world that is becoming more and more important in all domains of activity. Countries’ development is intimately related with the advances in technology, and education plays a vital role to be prepared for these changes.
Finally, Palacios et al. (2020) in their research noted the great impact of technology in basic general education since the onset of Covid-19, revealing the little importance previously given to technological progress in schools.
Therefore, digital transition, besides being of great importance, indu- ces the need for designing new activities that allow students to exploit the technological field. In addition, specialized training should be carried out for both teachers and students, allowing them to have an easier handling and a broader knowledge that generates confidence when using technology in different fields. In today’s world there are a multitude of virtual assi- stants with different levels of penetration in the market, such as: Apple’s Siri (86.2%), Google Home (11.6%), Amazon’s Alexa (9.8%), Microsoft’s Cortana (8.9%), Samsung’s Bixby (6.5%) and Movistar’s Aura (2.5%).
Thus, virtual assistants are highly demanded thanks to the characteristics they possess, they are capable not only of receiving and sending information in the form of voice, but they can also work with databases in real time, which allows them to be adaptable to any work environment, location, or application. To define the usability requirements of humans as a fundamental component of the system, it is essential to understand the inherent capability of user populations and their typical operating environment (Booher, 2003).
The following section describes the methodology followed in this research to analyze whether it is feasible to use a virtual assistant in English classes.
METHOD
The methodological framework of this research is based on a mixed qualitative-quantitative approach, an interview directed to an expert who helped us reinforce the use of virtual assistants was applied as a first point (Cóndor-Herrera et al., 2021). The interview was structured in three main questions regarding the configuration and use of Alexa assistant, and the benefits and results of its application within the basic general education
Using Intelligent Personal Assistants for Teaching English 325
domain and in other fields. At a second stage, a survey was carried out to five English teachers to learn about the methodological strategies they apply in each of their classes in order to develop the macro skills of the English language. The SPSS program was used for data processing, both variables and items, through descriptive statistics with graphic representations of the results. In the third and last stage a pre-test and a post-test involving virtual assistants were applied to 57 students of the school in which the four macro language skills were evaluated, based on the grades obtained by the students, which were classified as excellent, very good, good and regular. The results obtained show a favorable acceptance of the virtual assistants by teachers and students as described in the next section.
RESULTS
From the general results obtained in the present research, some benefits were evident from the use of virtual assistants such as the interaction between stu- dents and the assistant. Virtual assistants generate motivation to learn and to use them according to the needs and requirements of the student and also according to the progress that the students want to have in their knowledge. Some weaknesses could also be seen when the virtual assistant is used like, for example, it does not respond quickly or do not understand the question, which generates a bit of discomfort and delay when interacting. However, the results obtained after applying the virtual assistant within the English class are very positive due to a direct and individual interaction that the student has and the possibility of advancing at his own pace. The advance that was observed in each of the skills is quite significant after using traditional resou- rces for a long time and changing to the use of innovative technology. In fact, the development of skills was very positive in more than 70% of students.
Methodological Strategy for Teaching English With the Use of Alexa
Table 1 shows a methodological proposal for teaching the Jobs topic with the help of Alexa, which allowed observing the activities to be carried out to develop each of the English language skills, taking into account the level of understanding of the students and the goals to reach. This illustrates a class plan model that starts presenting the topic, the objective of the class, the course or grade, the materials or resources to use in this class including Alexa, the activities to be carried out in each period and finally extra resources that the teacher can use to reinforce the topic taught.
The results obtained by applying this strategy show a positive acceptance of the virtual assistants by teachers and students, taking into account that they also generate a motivation for learning a foreign language and the deve- lopment of macro linguistic skills in English in an interactive way that can evolve at the pace of learning of each individual student.
CONCLUSION
It is concluded that introducing virtual assistants is positive and motivate lan- guage learning, generating optimal development in each of the macro skills.
It was observed that the same methodological strategies that are used in class can be applied when using virtual assistant. A quite remarkable improve- ment was evidenced after applying the virtual assistant that interacts with the students.
The use of a virtual assistant to create innovative methodological strategies in the English language teaching process stimulated the optimal manage- ment and configuration of the activities by the speakers of the English area.
Very stimulating results were achieved by gathering together conventional methodological strategies with the virtual assistant for teaching English clas- ses with the purpose of developing macro skills of the English language in students, since it motivate them of interact with the assistant in a dynamic way; therefore, generating a significant learning effect.
The authors believe that the learning opportunities offered by the cur- rent voice assistant are immense, and anticipate that they can grow even further since this is an emerging technology that is still being consolidated and improved. This is particularly true considering that it has the possibi- lity of being customizable and modifiable to the user’s taste, as is the case of Amazon Blueprints Skill, which offers a myriad of options; among the options that can be pointed focused on teaching a second language is the ‘Custom Q&A’ that allows the teacher to configure questions and answ- ers customized according to the specific topic of teaching. This way Alexa would no longer be just an object of the class; it would interact as another student who could be wrong or right according to the teacher’s questions. For sure this could greatly motivate students to lose their fear and be more participative.
This also opens the possibility for teachers to give specific definitions or perhaps more pointed examples that could be adapted to the socio-cultural and geographical environment in which the students find themselves. They could become more familiar with what their teacher and Alexa are saying. Thus, ensuring their attention and above all their understanding, as they will relate their learning to real-life situations. Internalizing in the student such learning in a natural way and not as an external environment with examples that are outside their reality.
On the other hand, when talking about teaching children, the same skill allows the creation of interactive tale from a couple of personalized words, as well as to give them a certain external atmosphere. This exercise for the teacher could be useful for listening practice.
Another important thing to mention is the adaptability of the new software that Amazon continues to implement. So the case of APL (Alexa Presentation Language), which mentions that in certain devices such as the Echo Show, TVs and tablets with Alexa. This allows to combine audio and images. The importance of this is that the skilled developer can create a responsive pre- sentation language that allows the user (in this case, the students) to interact in more ways with the assistant. In this context teachers can use this to sup- plement their reading or even grammar classes. Students are more likely to understand the lessons better if they use more senses; in this case complemen- ting the visual with the audio combined with the customizable skills, opens
Using Intelligent Personal Assistants for Teaching English 327
Table 1. English methodological strategy using Alexa.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Topic Jobs and occupations
Learning Objective
Students are able to convey and organize information using facts and details in order to illustrate diverse patterns and structures in writing about jobs with Alexa. Class Fifth level A-B- C-D Week 7 From October 11th to November 15th, 2021 Resources ✓Student’s book 22- 23-24 ✓Electronic Devices ✓Pearson English Platform ✓Sheets of papers
Interactive platforms
Weekly Activities Period 1-2 ✓Explaining the grammar about the future for predictions ✓Inferring jobs vocabulary with Alexa ✓Enlisting jobs vocabulary by controlled speaking with Alexa help. ✓Writing sentences using jobs vocabulary and future manners by transformation drill. Listen to Alexa and write. ✓Naming jobs vocabulary by say after Alexa ✓Writing jobs vocabulary by controlled writing. ✓Answering the questions according to the pictures by questi- ons and answer with Alexa. Period 3-4 ✓Rewriting sentences using a dialogue by controlled writing. ✓Listening a paragraph about jobs by focused listening. ✓Practicing used to using city vocabulary by controlled wri- ting. ✓Reading about the best job to find the best word for descri- bing the story by scanning ✓Distinguishing present simple using jobs vocabulary by con- trolled writing Period 5-6 ✓Inferring grammatical structure of present continuous for future by mind map. ✓Researching information about the best place in the city that the students recommended ✓Selecting the best flyers about the jobs by picture eliciting. ✓Introducing digital tools for making a fact file about jobs. Period 7- 8 ✓Book club. Answer the questions, then look and circle the words that describe the poem ✓Listen and read. What is Lissa thinking about Remember Will for predictions and speak about the future and tongue twister. Extra resources
the opportunity to create better teacher assistants, no matter the age of the students.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge to Universidad Tecnológica Indo- américa and its Maestría en Educación mención Innovación y Liderazgo Educativo for contributing to this research to participate in the 13th International Conference on Applied Human Factors and Ergonomics (AHFE 2022). Special thanks to the students, teachers, and authorities of Academia Militar “General Miguel Iturralde” for participating in this research.
REFERENCES
Amazon. (2021). What is the Alexa Skills Kit? | Alexa Skills Kit. Amazon Developer Documentation. https://developer.amazon.com/en-US/docs/alexa/ ask- overviews/what-is-the-alexa-skills-kit.html Basantes A., Cabezas M., Casillas S., Dennis (2020). Competencias digitales en la for-
mación de tutores virtuales en la Universidad Técnica del Norte, Ibarra-Ecuador. http://dx.doi.org/10.4067/S0718-50062020000500269 Booher H. (2003). Handbook of human systems integration. New Jersey: Wiley. Cóndor-Herrera O., Jadán-Guerrero J., Acosta Rodas P., Ramos-Galarza C.
(2021) Technological Intervention Through the Virtual Assistant Alexa in the Development of Linguistic Skills of a New Language. In: Stephanidis C., Antona M., Ntoa S. (eds) HCI International 2021 - Posters. HCII 2021. Com- munications in Computer and Information Science, vol 1421. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-78645-8_2 Davie N., Hilber T. (2018). Opportunities and challenges of using amazon echo in education. 14th International Conference Mobile Learning 2018. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED590385.pdf Davis J.D. (2019). Alexa, Do You Belong in the Classroom? Edutopia. https://www.edutopia.org/article/alexa-do-you-belong-classroom Delgado M. (2009). Agente Inteligente de apoyo al proceso de enseñanza y aprendi-
zaje. Bolivia. Dizon G., Tang D. (2019). A Pilot Study Of Alexa For Autonomous Second Language Learning. 10.14705/Rpnet.2019.38.994. Dorfman M., Grondona A., Mazza N., Mazza P. (2019). Asistentes virtuales
de clase en la Educación Universitaria, http://www.sustentum.com/sustentum/ pubs/avc_jntaem.pdf Hernández Chérrez E. (2014). El B-learning como estrategia metodológica para mejorar el proceso de enseñanza-aprendizaje de los estudiantes de inglés de la modalidad semipresencial del departamento especializado de idiomas de la Universidad Técnica de Ambato. Madrid: Universidad Complutense de Madrid. Jiménez P., Sanchez J. (2015). de Eliza a Siri: La evolución. Ochoa-Orihuel J., Marticorena-Sánchez R., Sáiz-Manzanares M.C. (2020). Moodle
Lms Integration With Amazon Alexa: A Practical Experience. Applied Sciences, 10(19). https://Doi.Org/10.3390/App10196859 Palacios A., Loor J., Macias M., Ortega W. (2020). Incidencia de la tecnología en el entorno educativo del Ecuador frente a la pandemia del covid-19. Revi- sta Polo del Conocimiento, https://polodelconocimiento.com/ojs/index.php/es/ article/view/1850
Using Intelligent Personal Assistants for Teaching English 329
Saavedra Montejo Á. (2020). Determinantes de la intención de uso de los asistentes virtuales por voz e influencia de la privacidad percibida. Madrid: Universidad Autonoma de Madrid. Serban C., Ioana-Alexandra T. (2020). Alexa, What classes do I have today? The
use of Artificial Intelligence via Smart Speakers in Education. Procedia Computer Science. 176. 2849–2857. 10.1016/j.procs.2020.09.269.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors and Systems Interaction
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-28-5
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional