Florentin Popescu, Rob Warmenhoven (2022). Motivations, Success Factors and Challenges of Open Innovation for Start-ups. In: Human Factors, Business Management and Society. AHFE Open Access, vol. 56, pp. 441–446. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002300
One of the urgent challenges that small and medium enterprises face is the need to follow a continuous growth-path, particularly essential for Start-ups where global challenges force companies to look for even smarter ways to grow. If entrepreneurs agree with the idea that not all smart people work for their company, the embracement of the paradigm of ‘Open Innovation’ is a logical step. In other words, a company does not have to be the owner of an idea to benefit from an idea. Henceforth open innovation explores and exploits knowledge by sharing the innovation processes with third parties creating new opportunities for companies to profit from innovation. However, despite the growing literature on open innovation, so far, there has been little discussion on how start-ups can benefit from open innovation. The purpose of this paper is to clarify the concept of open innovation and to develop insights on how Open Innovation can benefit entrepreneurs who are in the process of creating their own start-up company. Studies in this review employed, show that there is not a generally accepted definition of what open innovation is and how it can be applied to companies in general and start-ups in specific. Additionally, it was noted that most studies in the field have only focused on open innovation using the perspective of a larger company. Very little was found in the literature on the start-up perspective. Therefore this paper discusses the reasons and motives of why students start-ups are encouraged to adopt open innovation practices. Moreover, the success factors and challenges that start-up face that implements open innovation practices are vital for all entrepreneurs to study as via open innovation start-ups can overcome the initial barriers that most start-ups face. This paper focusses on different dimensions of open innovation for students - Open Innovation vs Closed Innovation; Inbound vs Outside-in Innovation; Antecedents of open innovation; models of Open innovation; Success factors and Challenges - and serves as a guiding tool for student entrepreneurs to self-assess their start-up, so they can adapt and change in their start-up before an open innovation practice can be successfully implemented. Taken together, the open innovation paradigm should be in the mind-set of every student entrepreneur right from the start of the development of the business idea and the implementation of the business model, so consequently, the chance of a profitable and sustainable business future will increase for the start-up company.
One of the biggest challenges that small and medium enterprises face is the need to follow a continuous growth-path, particularly essential for Start- ups (Rexhepi et al.,2019). Furthermore, global challenges force companies to look for even smarter ways to grow (Rexhepi et al., 2019). If entrepre- neurs agree with the idea that not all smart people work for their company, the embracement of the paradigm of ‘Open Innovation’ is a logical step. Open innovation assumes that ‘knowledge beneficial for a company is widely dispersed inside and outside the organization, and therefore companies need to collaborate with external parties in order to be successful and achieve a competitive advantage’ (Chesbrough, 2003, p. XXV).
Open Innovation has become a trending topic across the globe. Bogers, Chesbrough and Moedas (2018) state that open innovation might be the answer for some of the significant challenges the world is facing today. Penin et al. (2011), expresses that all kinds of companies, both multinati- onals, and SMEs, who embrace the open innovation strategies can receive the many potential opportunities connected with open innovation. The first time the idea of open innovation was introduced was in 2003 when Henry
Chesbrough coined the term ‘Open Innovation’ to describe the process of ‘the purposive inflows and outflows of knowledge to accelerate internal innovation’ and for external use of innovation in the expansion process to other markets (Chesbrough et al. 2014). In other words, the use of internal and external ideas for innovation as well as the use of internal and exter- nal commercialization channels. Consequently, all kinds of organizations have opened their networks, organizational structures, evaluation processes and knowledge management to third parties (Chesbrough, 2003, p. XXVI). Accordingly, the massive interest of companies, governments, universities and other involved institutions for open innovation is according to Bogers, Chesbrough and Moedas (2018) potentially good news for Europe; with its strong technical and scientific bases. In this respect, many of the new technologies currently being developed in Europe are in the early stages of development, and it is not clear if and how these technologies will lead to success (Bogers, Chesbrough and Moedas, 2018). However, (Penin et al., 2011) warns that open innovation creates besides new opportunities also new challenges for practitioners of open innovation.
The purpose of this paper is to clarify the concept of open innovation and to develop insights (success factors and challenges) on how Open Innovation can benefit young entrepreneurs who are in the process of creating their own start-up company. It discusses in particular the reasons and motives of why start-ups are encouraged to adopt open innovation practices.
START-UPS AND OPEN INNOVATION Starting your own business has become more and more popular because of easy access to new technology and new markets that are accessible for Start- ups (Osterwalder and Pigneur, 2013). A start-up is a company, a partnership or temporary organization designed to search for a repeatable and scalable business model (Dabic et al., 2016). Additionally, Caputo et al. (2016) add that start-ups are an essential enabler of economic growth and are a primary source of newly created jobs. Furthermore, start-ups bring innovative pro- ducts and services to the market based on new technologies (Caputo et al. 2016). However, despite the growing literature on open innovation, so far, there has been little discussion on how start-ups can benefit from open innova- tion (Usman & Haverbeke, 2017). Van de Vrande et al. (2009), noted that the open innovation practices used by medium and large companies cannot be directly applied by small companies and start-ups in the same way. For example, start-ups have to work with limited technical and financial resou- rces while developing commercially promising technology; these limitations trigger them to develop simple but technically sound innovations. Large com- panies, go through an extensive and expensive process to develop a product that will satisfy both the technicians and commercial departments of the orga- nization, which results in a longer time-to-market and higher costs (Usman and Haverbeke, 2017). It can be concluded, following the work from Che- sbrough that collaboration between an SME and a large company might results in positive gains for both collaborators because they complement each other’s weaknesses.
Motivations, Success Factors and Challenges of Open Innovation 443
Yet, there is no guarantee that every open innovation practices by a start-up will be successful, and it is a long and complicated way for start- ups to start from scratch and become a profitable and sustainable business (Usman & Haverbeke, 2016). Caputo et al. (2016), states that despite the success-potential, many start-ups fail because firstly they lack access to cri- tical market- and distribution-channels, secondly are not familiar with the operational, strategic and technical knowledge relevant for the industry, and finally start-ups lack the funds to invest in research and development. In the same way, Bogers et al. (2011), points out that open innovation is a necessity for start-ups in order to overcome “the liability of newness and the liabi- lity of smallness”. “Therefore start-ups look increasingly to the practices of open innovation to source external resources and knowledge and hence open innovation is even more important for start-ups than for large companies” (Usman and Haverbeke, 2017).
ADVANTAGES OF OPEN INNOVATION In the past two decades, numerous studies have attempted to determine the advantages of open innovation. Van de Vrande et al. (2009) discusses that the most important reasons for companies to embrace open innovation are market-related motives. The authors argue that the open innovation methods are regarded as “a way to keep up with market developments and to meet customer demand, which eventually should result in increased growth, better financial results, or increased market share”(Van de Vrande et al., 2009). The advantages of open innovation are mentioned and summarized in table 1 and show an overview of the different findings of the researchers. Later in this paper, the specific advantages and challenges for start-ups will be addressed.
ANTECEDENTS OF OPEN INNOVATION In the previous paragraphs, it was established that start-ups face different issues than larger companies. Since there is a relation between start-up organi- zational performance and the level of innovation, it is essential for start-ups to overcome their innovation weaknesses (Pellegrino, 2017). Enkel et al. (2009) argue that open innovation does not fit with every start-up company and every situation. Therefore all start-ups must assess themselves what motiva- tes them to use open innovation within their start-up and what is it that they would like to reach. Van de Vrande et al. (2009) identified different motives for open innovation adoption, in his research drawing on a database of 605 Dutch SMEs, they showed that the most important reasons to adopt open innovation are market-related motives. Pellegrino (2017) observes that when one of the motives or desires identified by Van de Vrande et al. are present in a start-up, it might be the main explanation why start-ups embrace open innovation practices. Table 2 presents the motives and desires found by Van de Vrande et al. (2009).
Success Factors Pellegrino (2017) argues that when a start-up decides to use open innovation practices, the start-up should first evaluate the success factors and challenges
444 Popescu and Warmenhoven
Table 1. Advantages of open innovation.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Advantages Explanation Researchers Entry to knowledge networks, setting up listening posts to speed up the innovation process Improved development of new knowledge, and advanced technologies against lower costs Kutvonen (2011), (Dahlander and Gann 2010), Chesbrough (2006), Usman & Vanhaverbeke (2016), Van de Vrande et al. (2009) Market expansion, Market growth, increased revenues,
Kutvonen (2011), Chesbrough (2006), Vanhaverbeke et al., (2009)
Shared development of technology can be used to expand to new markets, sell more advanced products and to serve better the needs of customers Kutvonen (2011
Improved learning processes
The knowledge transfer speeds up the capability to absorb new information Decisions must be made what to share/absorb and what to keep/develop
Kutvonen (2011), Van de Vrande et al. (2009)
More focus and control on the core knowledge process
Kutvonen (2011)
Research as a core competence
A new type of companies that foremost focus on R&D as their core business model Kutvonen (2011)
Exerting external control
Increased control/insight into the external environment by keeping up-to-date with (advanced) developments
(Dahlander and Gann 2010)
Access to talent Companies find ways to connect with the expertise and skills of talented people
Kutvonen (2011), Van de Vrande et al. (2009)
Share risks Companies spread the innovation risk and uncertainty among the collaborators; you cannot do it alone.
Reputation increased Companies benefit from the other companies reputation in the market
Usman & Vanhaverbeke (2016)
Table 2. Motives to adopt open innovation. (Van de Vrande et al., 2009).
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Motives / Desires examples Control Increased control over activities, better organization of complex processes. Focus Fit with core competencies, a clear focus of firm activities. Innovation process Improved product development, process-/ market innovation, integration of new technologies. Knowledge Gain knowledge, bring expertise to the firm. Costs Cost management, profitability, efficiency. Capacity Cannot do it alone, counterbalance lack of capacity. Market Keep up with current market developments, customers, increase growth. Policy Organization principles, management conviction that involvement of employees is desirable. Utilization Optimal use of talents, knowledge, qualities, and initiatives of employees. Motivation Involvement of employees in the innovation process increases their motivation and commitment.
Motivations, Success Factors and Challenges of Open Innovation 445
for open innovation to check if the right conditions for open innovation are present. Durst and Ståhle (2013) identified in their literature study several success factors of open innovation. These success factors can be grouped along the following dimensions: relational issues, people, governance, faci- litators, resources, strategy and leadership, culture, and process. Durst and Ståhle (2013) state that these antecedents enable an open innovation within a start-up. Some of these factors can be influenced and altered by the entrepre- neurs. Unfortunately, some other antecedent is related to the relational issues, and are highly depended on the partner selection and hence are difficult to influence. In general, most of the antecedent are factors that start-up can manage and improve, henceforth the chance of successful open innovation practice can increase.
Challenges Earlier in this paper, the advantages and some challenges of open innova- tion were discussed. Van de Vrande et al. (2009) concluded that start-ups and SME face numerous challenges; some were already mentioned by Che- sbrough et al., (2014). The main barriers for start-ups mentioned illustrated by Van de Vrande et al. (2009) are the organizational and culture-related issues that typically emerge when two companies start working together. Furthermore, the balance between open innovation practices and the day- to-day management tasks have a negative influence on the success of open innovation. Interestedly Van de Vrande et al. (2009) notes that the admini- strative burdens increase when the start-up receives governmental subsidies or grants. To sum up, every open innovation practice will create its own uni- que combination of antecedents and challenges between a start-up company and collaborating partners, therefore being able to adapt to challenges may be of use as from the forming of the startup.
CONCLUSION
The purpose of this paper was to clarify the concept of open innovation and to develop insights on how open Innovation can benefit young entrepreneurs who are in the process of creating their own start-up company. Studies in this review employed, show that there is not a generally accepted defini- tion of what open innovation is and how it can be applied to companies in general and start-ups in specific. Additionally, it was noted that most stu- dies in the field have only focused on open innovation using the perspective of the larger company. Very little was found in the literature on the start-up perspective. However, a few writers, for example, Van de Vrande and Vanh- averbeke (2017) have published data focusing on the start-up perspective of open innovation. These studies were helpful in understanding the motives and the advantages and challenges that start-ups face when they think about implementing open innovation practices.
Furthermore, this paper has discussed the reasons and motives of why start-ups are encouraged to adopt open innovation practices. The case-studies published by Usman and Vanhaverbeke were significant examples of how open innovation could work out successfully for small start-ups. Moreover,
446 Popescu and Warmenhoven
the success factors and challenges that start-up face that implements open innovation practices are vital for all entrepreneurs to study as via open inno- vation start-ups can overcome the initial barriers that most start-ups face. Taken together, the open innovation paradigm should be in the mindset of every entrepreneur right from the start of the development of the business idea and the implementation of the business model, so consequently, the chance of a profitable and sustainable business future will increase for the start-up company.
REFERENCES
Bogers, M.Chesbrough, H.Moedas, C.(2018) Open Innovation: Research, Practices, and Policies. California Management Review. 60(2), pp. 5–16. Available from: 10.1177/0008125617745086. Caputo, M. Lamberti, E. Cammarano, A. Michelino, F. (2016) Exploring the
impact of open innovation on firm performances. Management Decision. 54(7), pp. 1788–1812. Chesbrough, H. (2003) Open innovation: The new imperative for creating and profiting from technology. Harvard Business Press. Chesbrough, H. (2010) Business Model Innovation: Opportunities and Barri-
ers. Long Range Planning. 43(2), pp. 354–363. Available from: 10.1016/ j.lrp.2009.07.010. Chesbrough, H. Vanhaverbeke, W. West, J. (2014 New frontiers in open innovation.
Oup Oxford. Dabi´c, M. Baši´c, M. Vlajˇci´c, D. (2016) Introduction to the open innovation paradigm. Dahlander, L. & Gann, D.M., 2010. How open is innovation? Research Policy. 39(6), pp. 699–709. Durst, S. Ståhle, P. (2013) Success factors of open innovation-a literature review.
International Journal of Business Research and Management. 4(4), pp. 111–131. Enkel, E. Gassmann, O. Chesbrough, H. (2009) Open R&D and open innovation: exploring the phenomenon. R&d Management. 39(4), pp. 311–316. Kutvonen, A. (2011) Strategic application of outbound open innovation. European
Journal of Innovation Management. 14(4), pp. 460–474. Osterwalder, A. Pigneur, Y. (2013) Designing Business Models and Similar Strategic Objects: The Contribution of IS. Journal of the Association for Information Systems; J.Assoc.Inf.Syst. 14(5), pp. 237–244. Pellegrino, A.C. (2017) Open Innovation in SMEs: A Process Model for Successful
Implementation. Pénin, J. Hussler, C. Burger-Helmchen, T. (2011) New shapes and new stakes: a portrait of open innovation as a promising phenomenon. Journal of Innovation Economics Management. (1), pp. 11–29. Rexhepi, G. Hisrich, R.D. Ramadani, V. (2019) Open Innovation and Entrepre-
neurship: An Overview. In: Open Innovation and EntrepreneurshipSpringer, pp. 1–7. Usman, M. Vanhaverbeke, W. (2017) How start-ups successfully organize and manage open innovation with large companies. European Journal of Innovation Management. 20(1), pp. 171–186. Van De Vrande, V. De Jong, J.P. Vanhaverbeke, W. De Rochemont, M. (2009) Open
innovation in SMEs: Trends, motives and management challenges. Technovation. 29(6-7), pp. 423–437.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors, Business Management and Society
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-32-2
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional