INTRODUCTION
The field of humanitarian logistics (HL) is characterized by complex and challenging problems that try to reconcile the ever-increasing impact from disasters with a declining funding (Apte, 2009; Besiou & van Wassenhove, 2020). Owing to a highly dynamic operating environment, large number of involved stakeholders, and the need for extremely time-dependent responses, the underlying systems defined by HL can be classified within the umbrella of complex systems (Schiffling, Hannibal, Tickle, & Fan, 2020). Adding to this inherent operative complexity, problems within this field have been fre- quently deemed as “wicked” or “ill-structured”, meaning that an additional layer of uncertainty surrounds these problems, both in formulation and in the acceptance criteria for their solution. Broadly, addressing an ill-structured problem often begins by abstracting away its wickedness, leaving for consi- deration a tamed problem approachable by the paradigm of the explanatory sciences (Alford & Head, 2017; Churchman, 1967).
Specifically for HL, this wickedness embodies complex requirements that cannot be ignored in the design process of proposed solutions. Failing to understand the basic motivations behind these problems, or unwillingly over- simplifying their inherent structure and depth, may lead to misrepresent the situations faced in practice, compromising the provision of humanitarian assistance and its success, and potentially leading to catastrophic outcomes
© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 67
(Apte, 2009; Day, Melnyk, Larson, Davis, & Whybark, 2012). In order to overcome these issues, HL has witnessed an increase in the development and implementation of decision support systems and frameworks, together with the participation of domain experts in academic research. These support systems have facilitated the assessment of large amounts of data and the pro- vision of scenarios, enabling a faster decision-making process, and relieving practitioners from the burden of repetitive tasks. Nevertheless, the pure appli- cation of these systems has been argued to be insufficient for different reasons, such as not being sufficiently grounded in empirical observations (Pedraza- Martinez & Van Wassenhove, 2016) and being capable of creating cognitive biases in the practitioners that use them, e.g. automation bias, should they over-rely in these systems (Skitka, Mosier, & Burdick, 1999). Thus, involving domain experts and disaster management practitioners in academic resea- rch becomes necessary, both to understand the problems in HL, as well as the factors affecting teams in humanitarian assistance, typically outside the logistics literature.
The goal of this paper is to highlight the role of experts and decision makers within the process of designing and validating a decision support framework in HL. To this end, three main expert-defined aspects will be considered, namely the strategic decision-making capability, the capacity for short-term action and the division of responsibilities derived of these decisions and actions.
HUMAN FACTORS AND DECISION MAKING IN THE CONTEXT OF HUMANITARIAN LOGISTICS Owing to an ill-structure, many problems within HL cannot be represented as pure, objective analytical abstractions (Sternberg & Lee, 2009; Tatham & Houghton, 2011). Approaching them means to comprehensibly consider the real-world motivations that justify their existence, as well as the real con- straints that significantly increase their complexity. Concretely, this paper succinctly describes lessons learned while designing an expert-driven relief distribution framework to cope with the aftermath of a catastrophic power outage.
Project Context and Framework Overview The project that precedes this paper focused on designing a relief distribu- tion framework at a strategic level. This meant to simultaneously anticipate strategies for the disaster and provide operative guidelines for immediate action after the event. Both development and concept were jointly defined with experts and practitioners in disaster management. Due to privacy consi- derations, however, most institutional partners as well as sensible details on the project had to be left out of this paper.
Methodologically, the development process merged aspects of Operations Research (OR) with the design sciences, combined under the umbrella of the Design-Oriented OR framework (O’Keefe, 2014). In this sense, optimi- zation and simulation techniques were borrowed from the OR paradigm, while the design sciences guided the development of a usable research artifact
Human Factors and Strategic Decision Making 69
(Hevner, 2007), in the form of a strategic decision support framework. Tech- nically, this framework was built upon a novel mathematical model capable of optimizing distribution strategies under uncertainty, and an experiment environment to create and test strategies under a multitude of disaster sce- narios. Wrapped around these modules, a graphical user interface allows for advance visualization and navigation capabilities, bridging the gap between complex mathematical concepts and the specific needs of the users. For conci- seness, further technical details of this framework will be left out of this paper, focusing instead in the experience of working with domain experts.
The Role of Experts in Designing a Strategic Decision Framework In the context of HL, experts can provide valuable insights on the subje- ctive nature of each problem, as well as the conditions they require for a usable solution. In this sense, roles at a strategic level are particularly well- suited to provide these insights, especially when considering the “strategic macro-level”. This paper places the focus on three expert-defined aspects, broadly connected with foundational concepts discussed, among others, in (Apte, 2009; Besiou & van Wassenhove, 2020), and considering their value for the process of designing and validating a relief distribution framework. The next paragraphs condense a conceptual perspective on these aspects, as described by the experts participating in the project. Following this descri- ption, the next section will analyze how each individual aspect was addressed in the project using a case study.
Strategic Decision-Making Capacities: Timely and sensible decision- making is critical in the redistribution and implementation of relief activities (Rottkemper & Fischer, 2013). It accounts for the process to deliberately select a possibility of action to be realized from a number of given possibi- lities. The available options to select from are characterized by the threat of damage or loss, the decisions taken are subject to risk or uncertainty, and course and result can only be stated as possibilities, but accurate statements about their occurrence are not possible.
Capacity for Short Term-Action: Action is a reason- and mind-based, volitional activity motivated by the higher goal or purpose upon which a deci- sion was made. Acting therefore presupposes decision-making, and includes activities of organization, real-life design as well as knowledge and values. Correct acting assumes reason, understanding and responsibility and must be striven for by the will and pursue a purpose. In this way, while strategic decision-making focuses more on the long-term goals and overall organiza- tion, short term-action looks at the specific activities to be taken given a specific context, in order to achieve the goals defined at the strategic level.
Ability to Take Responsibility Into Consideration: The classical concept of responsibility relates responsibility to the deciding and acting person, who initiates a process with free will in awareness of the framework conditions and thus, if no reasons for exclusion of guilt are present, becomes responsi- ble for his or her actions. It means giving an account of one’s own free and autonomous action and its consequences as a moral person or as an organi- zational unit before an authority. As such, it underlies decision making and
acting processes, delimiting the alternatives to be considered. In an increa- singly complex society, however, with organizations based on the division of labor, the assignment of responsibility is changing. Responsibility, therefore, is not a one-dimensional concept of assignment between decision and action or action and consequences, but a multi-dimensional concept of relation of different elements. Likewise, in the complex field of HL, taking responsibility should be understood as a multi-dimensional concept, concerning multiple actors and their actions, and governed by the four fundamental humanitarian principles of humanity, impartiality, neutrality and independence described in (Hilhorst, 2005).
Having provided a brief description on the three expert-defined aspects that circumscribed the development of the framework in this project, the following section concretizes these aspects, using a generic case study.
ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION An important part of the development process in this project involved the assessment of the underlying models designed for the framework. This followed two main perspectives: the objective metrics associated to the per- formance of mathematical and computational models, and the alignment of the solution with the needs of the community. Concretely, this paper focuses on the later, leveraging the three expert-defined aspects previously introduced (decision, action and responsibility).
The Value of Experts for the Framework Development Following the development cycles of the design sciences (Hevner, 2007), the first crucial step was identifying the relevance of the project, i.e., its motivation. This stage should capture the real-world problem and associ- ated challenges faced by the intended community for whom this research was intended. The study should mirror the cognitive and logistic challenges encountered by the personnel of humanitarian logistic, and account for the complexity and non-linearity brought by the characteristic uncertainty of HL.
Strategically, experts and stakeholders were directly and indirectly consul- ted to describe the problem, to determine assumptions aimed at narrowing its scope, and to define concrete requirements for a solution. Operatively, experts were also relevant when considering the operative capacities, capabi- lities and subjective context of the teams involved, in order to not overwhelm them with unrealistic tasks. In this sense, experts and practitioners (as proxy for the human factor) played a central role in identifying the personnel, enti- ties and organizations that should be involved in the scenario, and selecting which ones should be responsible for the tasks required (e.g., where should the recovery efforts be concentrated).
Additionally, and according to the methodological process proposed by (Hevner, 2007), experts were also central in the assessment of the project output, defining several concrete case studies to evaluate the capabilities of the framework. For the purposes of this paper, only one case study is descri- bed, to clarify the possibilities of this framework. This selected study dealt with strategic aspects of relief distribution in preparation for a long-term
Human Factors and Strategic Decision Making 71
blackout. The motivation and concrete aspects of the problem were based on the latest risk analysis report in civil protection at the federal level (Deut- scher Bundestag, 2020), and jointly developed with experts from the German Committee for Disaster Reduction (DKKV, from its German acronym). The overarching goal was to demonstrate the framework possibilities for stra- tegic analysis in the context of relief distribution under uncertainty. The concrete challenge of this study addressed the development and assessment of distribution strategies, as well as protection and restoration guidelines in preparation for several uncertain blackouts at a regional and national level.
Finally, it is worth noting that the active participation of experts in the project significantly helped aligning the goals of the project with their needs and expected outcomes. The next section further elaborates on this alignment.
The Value of the Framework for Experts and Decision-Makers As previously described, the domain experts had an expectation on the outco- mes of this project, manifested in three different aspects (decision, action and responsibility). The following paragraphs describe how was this expectation addressed in the project.
Strategic Decision-Making Capacity: The application of the developed decision support framework to this case study enabled, at a strategic level, an objective comparison of different relief distribution strategies, some of them requiring some degree of infrastructure adaptation (e.g., larger depots, transshipment facilities or even location/relocation of existing structures). On account of the required investment and planification, the decisions at this level assumed a mid-term planning horizon, and are made in anticipation to the actual disaster (ex-ante approach). In this sense, the uncertainty and risk associated to the decision remains significant. Armed with these insi- ghts, experts and stakeholders can now make an informed decision regarding transportation, location and capabilities of the relief distribution network, to better prepare for a catastrophic blackout.
Capacity for Short-Term Action: The application of the developed frame- work enabled an increased capacity for short term action. This translated into concrete response guidelines for first responders (and grid operators in this specific case study) after the disaster (ex-post approach). The concrete guidelines for action provide, in the aftermath of a disaster, clear rules on how to assign resources to minimize the impact that the disaster has on the system as a whole.
Ability to Take Responsibility Into Consideration: While this aspect pro- ved harder to objectively assess than the previous two, some insights proved useful in this context. The main takeaway being the framework’s capability to divide between pre-disaster planning and response actions, while remai- ning observant of the fundamental humanitarian principles. Through this division, this novel framework incorporated a clear responsibility hierarchy in the decision support system, organically assigning roles according to the stage of the disaster.
CONCLUSION
This paper described the significance of human factors in HL at a strate- gic level. It focused on the lessons learned when designing, together with domain experts, a strategic relief distribution framework, under the umbrella of Design-Oriented OR. Through this methodological paradigm, the research output profited from the experts’ knowledge and experience. Simultane- ously, this development approach enabled decision-makers and stakeholders in HL to find value in the framework, by explicitly addressing strategic decision-making, operative actions and responsibility considerations.
REFERENCES
Alford, J., & Head, B. W. (2017). Wicked and less wicked problems: A typology and a contingency framework. Policy and Society, 36(3), 397–413. https://doi.org/10. 1080/14494035.2017.1361634 Apte, A. (2009). Humanitarian logistics: A new field of research and action. Founda-
tions and Trends in Technology, Information and Operations Management, 3(1), 1–100. Besiou, M., & van Wassenhove, L. N. (2020). Humanitarian operations: A world of opportunity for relevant and impactful research. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management, 22(1), 135–145. https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2019. 0799 Churchman, C. W. (1967). Guest Editorial: Wicked Problems. Management Science,
14(4), B141–B142. Day, J. M., Melnyk, S. A., Larson, P. D., Davis, E. W., & Whybark, D. C. (2012).
Humanitarian and disaster relief supply chains: A matter of life and death. Jour- nal of Supply Chain Management, 48(2), 21–36. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.~1745- -493X.2012.03267.x Deutscher Bundestag. (2020). Bericht zur Risikoanalyse im Bevölkerungsschutz
2019. Hevner, A. R. (2007). A Three Cycle View of Design Science Research. Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems, 19(2), 87–92. Hilhorst, D. (2005, December 1). Dead letter or living document? Ten years of the
Code of Conduct for disaster relief. Disasters. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. https: //doi.org/10.1111/j.~0361--3666.2005.00297.x O’Keefe, R. (2014). Design Science, the design of systems and Operational Research: Back to the future. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 65(5), 673–684. https://doi.org/10.1057/jors.2012.175 Pedraza-Martinez, A. J., & Van Wassenhove, L. N. (2016). Empirically grounded
research in humanitarian operations management: The way forward. Journal of Operations Management, 45, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jom.2016.06.003 Rottkemper, B., & Fischer, K. (2013). Decision making in humanitarian logistics - A multi-objective optimization model for relocating relief goods during disaster recovery operations. ISCRAM 2013 Conference Proceedings - 10th International Conference on Information Systems for Crisis Response and Management, (May), 647–657. Schiffling, S., Hannibal, C., Tickle, M., & Fan, Y. (2020). The implications of com-
plexity for humanitarian logistics: a complex adaptive systems perspective. Annals of Operations Research. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-020-03658-w
Human Factors and Strategic Decision Making 73
Skitka, L. J., Mosier, K. L., & Burdick, M. (1999). Does automation bias decisionmaking? International Journal of Human Computer Studies, 51(5), 991–1006. https://doi.org/10.1006/ijhc.1999.0252 Sternberg, E., & Lee, G. C. (2009). New York city’s healthcare transportation during
a disaster: A preparedness framework for a wicked problem. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, 24(2), 95–107. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1049023X00006622 Tatham, P., & Houghton, L. (2011). The wicked problem of humanitarian logistics and disaster relief aid. Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management, 1(1), 15–31. https://doi.org/10.1108/20426741111122394