Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Capacity Building in GovTech for Measuring and Achievement of Sustainable Development Goals

Tallinn University of Technology, Tallinn 19086, Estonia ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1003888

Abstract

The paper explores the challenges that GovTech industry faces and analyses how existing skills frameworks correspond with these challenges. After this comparison authors seek to define the missing from the frameworks skills that can be recommended for GovTech specialists to possess. Given the variety of areas of expertise where GovTech faces challenges it is recommended to design a collective competence framework on a team and/or organisation level.

INTRODUCTION

Technological transformation is increasing at an exponentially fast pace. The UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have a variety of targets that digital transformation can help with. As governments attempt to cope with the pace of technological change, they have recognized the utility of GovTech for developing in the direction of the SDGs. For GovTech to be effective and scalable though, there is need for competent employees in the skills and com- petences which comprise GovTech, especially in data-driven and relatively new technologies.

Because of the high stakes, a framework is necessary to determine relevant skills that employees engaged in GovTech initiatives can learn. Some compe- tence frameworks identify high level skills like critical and systems thinking. However, in addition it is helpful to have a framework that identifies and defi- nes more detailed and specific skills for GovTech professionals, which can be later used for employment and education purposes. European key compete- nce frameworks are expected to be used flexibly and be adapted for the needs of the users (Bacigalupo, 2022).

The fact that GovTech projects have the potential to have a leveraged effect on the populace of a country requires that people employed in creating these solutions are also able to understand the application and that they will be responsible for ensuring that data driven projects empower humans and do not perpetuate historic biases. This creates an environment in which, to fol- low the guidelines of the SDGs, projects must have the capacity to not only create a solution, but also have the appropriate ethical and trustworthiness audits and data protection controls.

© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 117

GovTech is at this point an under-researched area of the academic litera- ture. There is no unanimous understanding of the term GovTech (Bharosa, 2022). Whether the definition of GovTech is a private sector company, a technology, or a public approach toward using technology in government this brings certain concerns regarding incentives that have ramifications for the skills necessary for successful public-private partnerships. When a private sector corporation is engaged to produce a project or piece of sof- tware for a government entity, there are many issues that are relevant to the ethical and fair treatment of citizens. Any employee of the govern- ment or the private sector company in this case should have certain skills to ensure that the project is planned, developed, and implemented in a manner that preserves freedoms, data protection, and reaches across digital divides.

GovTech is expected to strengthen public services in multiple ways tran- sforming education and culture, health and social care and improving public spaces (Kilian et. al., 2022). The estimated global GovTech market size was valued at USD 430,872.4 million in 2021 and is expected to expand at a compound annual growth rate of 15.56% during the forecast period. This means it will reach USD 1,026,110.6 million, which is USD 1.026 trillion by 2027 (Govtech market size with emerging trends 2022). The GovTech Mar- ket in Europe in 2022 was estimated to be somewhere in the range of 166 Billion Euro (Allen, 2022). Despite the potential to grow, GovTech is facing a number of challenges related to procurement, protection of digital assets, employing all kinds of modern technologies (Kilian et. al., 2022) and others, which will be explained in more detail further.

Business activities are expected to be aligned with the sustainable develo- pment goals. It especially concerns GovTech as these companies are inferred to provide services for common good. One way to make sure that change toward sustainable development is taking place is by having partnerships of government and business that are based on long-term goals, create shared value, and are scalable and transformative (Dauliyeva et al., 2020) (Kilian et. al., 2022). Running a GovTech business in accordance with SDGs requi- res not only general awareness about sustainability matters, but also more concrete knowledge and skills.

Traditional competency frameworks have some flaws like being disconne- cted from the job market and excessive granularity of skills (Huneety, 2022). Fast technological development contributes to the necessity to acquire new skills faster and adapt to the changes all the time. Multiple frameworks are developed in order to understand what qualities, knowledge, skills, attitudes and values need to be present in the specialists hired for a specific job. A lot of them end up being too generic and do not reflect the needs of the industry. This paper aims to define recommended skills for GovTech specialists that aid in achieving the SDGs.

Pursuing this aim, the authors address the following research questions:

1. What are the challenges that GovTech face? 2. What skills are required from GovTech professionals given the industry challenges and the necessity to achieve SDGs?

Capacity Building in GovTech for Measuring and Achievement 119

METHODOLOGY

In order to address research question 1, content analysis methodology has been used. Content analysis represents examination of the data to extract pie- ces of information and make realistic conclusions from it. (Bengtsson, 2016). To map the state-of the-art we consider two sources. First, mapping of the scientific literature on the topic is retrieved from a scientific database Scopus. Second, practitioner sources have been analysed.

The second step was checking if existing skills frameworks address the challenges that GovTech industry is up against. Since GovTech embraces several spheres like public service, entrepreneurship and technology which demand varied skills, and also taking into account the necessity to address sustainability issues, the authors have picked four skills frameworks, Skills for a High Performing Civil Service by OECD, EntreComp, DigComp and GreenComp under the aegis the European Commission. GreenComp with its wording of skills can be applicable to the sustainable development goals in general.

Researchers analysed the skills frameworks and compared them against the specific challenges facing GovTech professionals. Based on the defined gaps in skills frameworks that can address the specificity of the work of GovTech professionals, the search of the European skills, competences and occupations classification (ESCO)was conducted to understand if there are any existing defined skills that could fill in the skills gaps.

After that the authors suggested the skills corresponding with the challen- ges that have not been addressed by any of the analyzed frameworks.

Table 1. The list of documents selected for content analysis.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Author Title Bharosa N. The rise of GovTech: Trojan horse or blessing in disguise? A research agenda Public GovTech in the Netherlands: building a leading GovTech nation World Bank GovTech Maturity Index Joint Research Centre GovTech Practices in the EU Bennett Institute for Public Policy Cambridge

Thinking about GovTech: A Brief Guide for Policymakers Nordic Council of Ministers GovTech in the Nordic-Baltic region

RESULTS

As a result of content analysis 15 challenges have been identified. After that the four selected skills frameworks have been checked to understand how they address the current needs of the GovTech industry. Only five of the identified challenges had corresponding skills in the existing skills framew- orks, which confirms that skills frameworks often do not go in line with the requirements of the industry.

After searching ESCO classification researchers have found skills that correspond with four other challenges (Table 3).

Table 2. Comparison of the GovTech challenges with the skills frameworks.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Challenge Corresponding skills Skills framework Knowledge and skills Continuously learning Teaching lessons Skills for a High Performing Civil Service Learning through Experience EntreComp Culture mismatch Building alliances Working with unusual partners

Skills for a High Performing Civil Service Teamup, collaborate and network Working with others DigComp

EntreComp EntreComp Ability to interact, communicate and collaborate with others through the use of digital technologies, taking into account cultural and generational diversity EntreComp

Funding and resource allocation

Mobilizing resources Financial and Economic Literacy Mobilizing others Fear of failure Trying things out that might not work

Skills for a High Performing Civil Service Risk mitigation Taking risks, but not with time and money EntreComp

Skills for a High Performing Civil Service Coping with Uncertainty, Ambiguity and Risks

Table 3. Skills from ESCO that correspond with the GovTech challenges.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Challenge Skill ESCO description Procurement Implement

sustainable procurement

Incorporate strategic public policy goals into procurement procedures, such as green public procurement (GPP) and socially responsible public procurement (SRPP). Contribute to reducing the environmental impact of procurement, to achieving social goals and to improving value for money for the organisation and for society at large. Trust Build trust Express intentions and behaviour in a coherent and transparent manner, inviting reciprocity and establishing the grounds for a trusting and reliable connection between people and teams Strategy Apply strategic thinking Develop strategy to solve problems

Apply generation and effective application of business insights and possible opportunities, in order to achieve competitive business advantage on a long-term basis. Develop specific goals and plans to prioritise, organise, and accomplish work. Scalability Strive for company growth

Develop strategies and plans aiming at achieving a sustained company growth, be the company self-owned or somebody else’s. Strive with actions to increase revenues and positive cash flows.

Capacity Building in GovTech for Measuring and Achievement 121

Table 4. Recommended additional skills for GovTech professionals.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Legacy Technology Legacy systems migration and integration skills Applying legacy systems modernization strategies Accountability for the service provisions

Interacting with government institutions Managing legal and other documentation that defines accountability Dealing with competition especially from well-established IT companies

Breaking down organizational siloes

Identifying competitors Defining competitive advantages Presenting solutions that meet requirements of pro- curement procedures and documentation Finding and forming strategic alliances across spheres Effective regulation Participating in government decision-making and legislative processes Presenting the position of the company in govern- ment agencies in a way understandable by govern- ment officials Making use of existing preferable regulations and legal sandboxes Fragmentation and duplication of effort, services, processes, and systems Cross-border harmonisation Knowledge and application of cross-boundary interoperability legislation/models

As there were challenges that existing frameworks and classifications did not address, the authors have constructed recommendations through their analysis that helps to mitigate issues related to the challenges faced by GovTech companies.

As it is shown in Table 2, GreenComp does not address specifically any of the challenges. The reason for that may lay in the fact that GreenComp comprises very high-level skills, like, for example, systems thinking and exploratory thinking. Also, it is worth noting that even though GreenComp does not address the current GovTech challenges, it can still be useful in determining the competences needed by GovTech professionals.

Literature that would connect GovTech to SDGs is almost entirely missing. Recent research has identified that some SDGs like zero hunger (SDG 2), quality education (SDG 4), and life below water (SDG 14) are left out in the digital government literature (Medaglia, Misuraca and Aquaro, 2021). Digi- tal government instruments are proven to inform targets from seven SDGs, namely, no poverty (SDG 1), quality education (SDG 4), gender equality (SDG 5), affordable and clean energy (SDG 7), decent work and econo- mic growth (SDG 8), industry, innovation and infrastructure (SDG 9), peace, justice and strong institutions (SDG 16), partnerships for the goals (SDG 17) (Marcovecchio et al., 2019). The UN e-Government survey is expected to provide a deeper exploration of how digital government influences all SDGs in addition to focusing on SDG 16 and SDG 17 (Misuraca, Medaglia and Aquaro, 2021).

Taking into account the imbalance in how GovTech addresses different SDGs, the most relevant competence that GovTech professionals are likely to

need is systems thinking, which according to GreenComp is “to approach a sustainability problem from all sides; to consider time, space and context in order to understand how elements interact within and between systems”.

The list of challenges and potential skills suggests that it is reasonable to look into collective competences framework as the skills belong to different areas of expertese from technology to law and marketing.

As for sustainable development skills and their place in the set of compe- tences of GovTech specialists, in the way they are listed in the GreenComp, they can serve to connect and complement the other skills. At the same time, sustainable devlopment skills can potentially be defined in a more granular way that addresses issues connected with specific goals or going into more details and explores the interconnectedness of SDGs.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Competence and skills frameworks are viewed as the tools to define and eva- luate an individual’s performance, guide employers in describing jobs and employees on potential development. The problem of skills frameworks is finding the balance between going too much into detail when describing skills and being too broad and use the skills that are applicable to any person in general regardless of their profession. This also leads to the problem of skills and competences frameworks being not in connection with the modern requirements of the industry.

In attempt to connect the requirements of the GovTech industry with the existing skills and competences frameworks, it has been demonstrated that existing frameworks do not address a lot of the issues or are using the wording of skills that is too abstract to help either employers or employees. The auth- ors suggested a list of skills that addresses the challenges of GovTech, which, however, need to be in the future embedded into a more comprehensive framework that would include more general skills as well.

Taking into account the multitude of areas of challenges the industry faces, it is impossible to have a single employee that would be able to address all of them. Therefore, collective skills frameworks on the team level and on the organizational level should be considered. Some skills will be required from any GovTech specialist, for example those related to the problem of culture mismatch between public and private sector employees and the fear of failure.

REFERENCES

Allen, P. (2022) The rise of GovTech: Why startups should work with governments (sponsored): EU-Startups, EU. Available at: https://www.eu-startups.com/2022/ 08/the-rise-of-govtech-why-startups-should-work-with-governments-sponsore d/ (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Bacigalupo, M., 2022. Competence frameworks as orienteering tools. RiiTE Revista

Interuniversitaria de Investigación en Tecnología Educativa, pp. 20–33. Bengtsson, M (2016) How to plan and perform a qualitative study using content analysis, NursingPlus Open, Volume 2, 2016, Pages 8-14, ISSN 2352-9008, https: //doi.org/10.1016/j.npls.2016.01.001

Capacity Building in GovTech for Measuring and Achievement 123

Bharosa, N. (2022). ‘The rise of GovTech: Trojan horse or blessing in disguise? A research agenda’, Government Information Quarterly, DOI: 10.1016/j.giq.2022.101692 Dauliyeva, G, Yeraliyeva, A, Sadykhanova, G, Bimendiyeva L 2020 The partnership of governments for sustainable development. Proceedings of the 1st Internatio- nal Conference on Business Technology for a Sustainable Environmental System (BTSES-2020) (BTSES-2020) viewed January 30, 2023 Dener, C. et al. (2021) GovTech Maturity index, Open Knowledge Repository. Wash-

ington, DC: World Bank. Available at: https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/ha ndle/10986/36233 (Accessed: January 30, 2023). DigComp (no date) EU Science Hub. Available at: https://joint-research-centre.ec.e uropa.eu/digcomp_en (Accessed: January 30, 2023). ESCO (no date) The European Commission. Available at: https://esco.ec.europa.eu/

en (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Govtech in the Nordic-Baltic region (no date) Nordic cooperation. Available at: https://www.norden.org/en/publication/govtech-nordic-baltic-region-part-1 (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Govtech market size with emerging trends 2022: Top key players updates, business growing strategies, competitive dynamics, industry segmen- tation and forecast to 2027 (2022), Digital Journal. Available at: https://www.digitaljournal.com/pr/govtech-market-size-with-emerging-tren ds-2022-top-key-players-updates-business-growing-strategies-competitive-dyna mics-industry-segmentation-and-forecast-to-2027 (Accessed: January 30, 2023). GreenComp: The European Sustainability Competence Framework (no date) EU

Science Hub. Available at: https://joint-research-centre.ec.europa.eu/greencomp-e uropean-sustainability-competence-framework_en (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Huneety, S. (2022) Why traditional competency frameworks don’t work, Huneety. Available at: https://www.huneety.com/competency-frameworks/ (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Kilian, M, Raghavan, P, Alles, A. Advancing the GovTech trend will strengthen public services (no date) World Economic Forum. Available at: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/12/how-making-the-most-out-of-gov techs-boom-will-strengthen-public-services/ (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Kuziemski, M. et al. (2022) GovTech practices in the EU, JRC Publications

Repository. Available at: https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/ JRC128247 (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Marcovecchio, I., Thinyane, M., Estevez, E. and Janowski, T., 2019. Digital government as implementation means for sustainable development goals. International Journal of Public Administration in the Digital Age (IJPADA), 6(3), pp. 1–22. Medaglia, R., Misuraca, G. and Aquaro, V., 2021, June. Digital government and

the united nations’ sustainable development goals: Towards an analytical frame- work. In DG. O2021: The 22nd Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research (pp. 473–478). Ministerie van Algemene Zaken (2021) GovTech in the Netherlands: Building a leading Govtech Nation, Report | Government.nl. Ministerie van Algemene Zaken. Available at: https://www.government.nl/documents/reports/2021/06/30/ govtech-in-the-netherlands (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Misuraca, G., Medaglia, R. and Aquaro, V., 2021, October. Re-designing the UN

e-Government Survey in light of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development: Towards a post-COVID digital society. In Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Theory and Practice of Electronic Governance (pp. 198–202).

Skills for a high performing civil service (no date) OECD. Available at: https://www.

oecd.org/gov/skills-for-a-high-performing-civil-service-9789264280724-en.htm (Accessed: January 30, 2023). The European Entrepreneurship Competence Framework (EntreComp) (no date) The European Entrepreneurship Competence Framework (Entre- Comp) - Employment, Social Affairs & Inclusion - European Commission. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=1317&langId=en#: \protect$\relax\sim$:text=EntreComp%20is%20a%20free%2C%20flexible,pr actice%20to%20develop%20entrepreneurial%20skills (Accessed: January 30, 2023). Thinking about GovTech: A Brief Guide for Policymakers (2022) Bennett Institute for Public Policy. Available at: https://www.bennettinstitute.cam.ac.uk/publica tions/thinking-about-govtech-brief-guide-policymakers/ (Accessed: January 30, 2023).

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Factors, Business Management and Society

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Factors, Business Management and Society

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-73-5

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →