Ekaterina Zabelina, Dastan Abdrakhmanovich Smanov (2023). Cognitive nature of procrastination. In: Cognitive Computing and Internet of Things. AHFE Open Access, vol. 73, pp. 143–151. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1003291
One of the typical social problems of the 21st century - procrastination - is defined as irrational postponement of desired goals indefinitely, even when aware of the negative consequences of this delay (Lay, 1997). Although possible causes of procrastination have long been cited, such as irrational beliefs (Ellis, Knaus, 1977), low self-esteem, and fear of failure (Burka, Yuen, 1983), cognitive predictors of procrastination have not been studied holistically as a system. Moreover, it remains unclear which cognitive mechanisms are involved in different types of procrastination. This study seeks to partially fill this gap by finding cognitive features of people prone to procrastination.The results of the study (N = 311) revealed differences in most of the diagnosed cognitive indicators, which suggests an important role of cognitive processes in the shaping of a procrastination tendency. Comparison of cognitive scores in the high and low procrastination groups showed that procrastinators had higher rates of cognitive closure, namely higher scores on the scales of order (p = 0.000), predictability (p = 0.052), decisiveness (p = 0.000), aspiration to cognitive closure (p = 0.000). Cognitive closure means motivation to receive an unambiguous response and cut off unnecessary, contradictory and interfering information. This is consistent with the data on higher stiffness in procrastinators (p = 0.05).Besides, procrastinators have a more pronounced frustational tolerance (p = 0.000), and a sense of self-improvement (p = 0.001). They have less vigilance (p = 0.000), but more overindulgence (p = 0.000), as well as more avoidance in decision-making (p = 0.000). Differences are also found on the temporal focus scale: people prone to procrastination are less focused not only on the future (p = 0, 000), but also on the present (p = 0, 000). Predictably, procrastinators had significantly lower levels of claims (p = 0.004) and self-esteem (p = 0.01). Procrastinators showed lower indicators of self-organization of activities: consistency (p = 0.000), purposefulness (p = 0.000), perseverance (p = 0.024), fixation (p = 0.000), self-organization (p = 0.000), orientation to the present (p = 0.000). At the same time, they have more pronounced cognitive copying strategies: avoiding behavior (p = 0.000), anxiety (p = 0.000), cognitive overestimation (p = 0.000), intolerance to stress situations (p = 0.000).The results of discriminant analysis made it possible to determine the indicators that have the greatest influence on inclusion in the group procrastinators. These are low orientation towards the present, avoidance in decision-making, vigilance, pursuit of cognitive closure, low tolerance of frustration, and low self-organization of activities. The study thus expands the understanding of the cognitive nature of procrastination. The results suggest that cognitive features such as a weak focus on the events of the present, a habit of avoiding decision-making, weakened vigilance, an increased desire for cognitive closure, low tolerance to frustration, and a low level of self-organization of activities are important predictors of procrastination.
The rapidly accelerating development of modern life, built on the widespread use of information technology in all spheres of activity, leads to the fact that most people do not keep up with its rhythm. A huge number of tasks and problems that require urgent resolution are perceived differently by a person. One may strive to do anything and finish everything in time or postpone the decision of important matters for the future, even if this leads to negative consequences for him. The latter phenomenon is called procrastination.
The foundations of the study of procrastination laid by P. Rigenbach, A. Ellis, and V. Knaus (1987) became the starting point of its study as a psych- ological phenomenon. The accumulated empirical experience, however, turns out to be rather fragmentary and does not cover all aspects of the problem. Despite numerous works on this problem (Ferrari, Tice, 2000, Lay, 1986, Milgram et al., 1992; Steel, 2007), determining the causes of procrastination remains a difficult and controversial task, including due to the lack of a clear understanding of its cognitive nature.
There are various approaches to the study of the cognitive sphere of pro- crastination. In the cognitive approach, procrastination is considered a set of irrational attitudes (Ellis, Knaus, 1987), low self-esteem (Burka, Yuen, 2008), and inability to make decisions (Janis, Mann, 1979). The main attention in these studies is paid to the identification of cognitive distortions, which are understood as rolled and habitual ways in which we thought painfully and ineffectively moves, burning incredible amounts of our time, sucking energy, and not creating any values for ourselves or anyone. (Kukla, 2007).
A group of scientists (Ferrari et al., 1995, Chun Chu, Choi, 2005, Kor- macheva, 2021) suggests that the cognitive component of procrastination is based on a decision about procrastination, which is accompanied by an understanding of its negative consequences. The next area of research on the cognitive nature of procrastination is related to the inability to manage goals. Several scientists (Gustavson, Miyake, Hewitt, Friedman, 2015) note that procrastination is based on an irrational inability to support and manage their actions to achieve short- and long-term goals.
According to Russian researchers, the cognitive sphere of procrastination includes internality, maladaptive beliefs, features of time perspective (Ryzova, 2019), ideas about time, locus control, irrational beliefs (Karlovskaya, Baranova, 2008), reflection (Chevrenidi, 2019), etc.
Among the studies of cognitive procrastination are the work associated with the uncertainty and fear of failure (Balkis, Duru, 2019; Haghbin et al., 2012; Ozer et al., 2009), negative thoughts about oneself (Flett et al., 2012), self-criticism (Powers et al., 2007), defectiveness and insufficient self-control (Aftab et al., 2017), the self-blame (Sirois, 2015), self-condemning thou- ghts (McCown et al. 2012), need for cognition and emotional intelligence (Geertman E, Valk A., 2021), poor time management and lack of confidence (Atalayin et al. 2018) However, despite numerous studies and interpretations of the cognitive features of procrastination, there are still many “white spots” in this issue. No holistic model has been identified to explain the cognitive predictors of
Cognitive Nature of Procrastination 145
procrastination. Moreover, it remains unclear which cognitive mechanisms are involved in various types of procrastination.
A particular interest in the study of cognitive predictors of procrastination is specific cognitive characteristics, such as the desire for cognitive closure, self–organization of activities, time focus, coping strategies, and decision- making in difficult situations. The above determined the expediency and relevance of the study, the purpose of which was to identify the features of the cognitive sphere of students with a tendency to procrastinate, as well as cognitive predictors of procrastination.
We assume the presence of certain cognitive features in people prone to procrastination, which force them to postpone solving important tasks, despite their importance and a high degree of urgency.
METHODOLOGY AND METHODS An empirical study of cognitive features and predictors of procrastination among students was conducted in September-October 2022 based on Chel- yabinsk State University and M. Dulatov Kostanay University of Engineering and Economics (Kazakhstan). The total sample size of the study was 311 people aged 17 to 45 years (average age 19 years).
The sample of subjects consisted of 1st-4th year students of full-time study. The gender composition includes 140 women (45%) and 171 men (55%). Specialties are humanities – 42.5%, natural sciences - 9%, and technical ones – 48.5%. By place of residence, the sample was distributed as follows: 224 people (72%) live in the city, 23 people (7.4%) live in district centers, and 64 people (20.6%) live in rural areas.
The following methods were used in the study:
1. The Scale of General Procrastination by K. Lay in the adaptation by O. S. Vendeker and M. V. Osatina. The use of this technique is used to assess the severity of the level of procrastination. The scale includes 20 statements, the answers to which are related to solving and postponing everyday tasks in everyday life. 2. The Need for Closure Scale developed by A. Kruglyansky (M. I. Yasin’s language adaptation) is used to study individual psychological characte- ristics and allows you to measure closeness by five parameters: the desire for order, predictability, determination, dislike of ambiguity, prejudice. 3. The method of diagnosing irrational attitudes by A. Ellis is used to deter- mine the degree of rationality-irrationality of thinking, and the presence and severity of irrational attitudes. 4. The Melbourne Decision-Making Questionnaire (MDMQ) was deve- loped based on the Flinders Questionnaire to diagnose individual decision-making styles. The questionnaire includes four main patterns of decision-making in difficult situations: 1) vigilance 2) avoidance, 3) procrastination, and 4) over-vigilance. 5. The Questionnaire of Self-Organization of Activity (QSOA), developed by E. Y. Mandrikova, is intended for the diagnosis of formation, self- organization, planning, and goal-setting.
146 Smanov and Zabelina
6. Comprehensive Coping Questionnaire (CCQ) (M. McKay, M. Skene, P. Fanning) is used to assess how a person reacts to a threat to cope with it.
Descriptive statistics, the nonparametric criterion for comparing samples, the H-Kruskal-W–Wallace criterion, and the U-Mann-Whitney criterion were used for the mathematical processing of the results. Discriminant analysis was used to identify cognitive predictors of procrastination. Mathematical data processing was carried out using a standardized software package IBM SPSS Statistics v. 26.0.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
At the first stage of the study, based on the results of the Scale of General Procrastination, the total sample (N = 311) was divided into three groups: subjects with a low level of procrastination (N = 70); subjects with an average level of procrastination (N = 146), and a group with a high level of procra- stination (N = 95). The cognitive indicators of these groups’ representatives were compared in the second stage. Cognitive predictors of procrastination were identified using discriminant analysis in the third stage.
The results of the study (N = 311) revealed differences in most of the dia- gnosed cognitive indicators, which indicates the important role of cognitive processes in the formation of procrastination (see Table 1).
As can be seen from Table 1, procrastinators have higher indicators of cognitive closeness, namely, a high average rank of the trait on the scale of propensity to order (p = 0.000), predictability (p = 0.052), determination (p = 0.000), striving for cognitive closeness (p = 0.000). Cognitive closeness means the motivation to get an unambiguous answer and cut off unnecessary, contradictory, and interfering information. This is consistent with the data on greater rigidity in procrastinators (p = 0.05). In general, according to most indicators of cognitive closeness, it can be concluded that students with a high level of procrastination are more prone to an unwillingness to rebuild at the last minute, they differ in a higher level of determination when deviating from their main job, prefer the old familiar ways of behavior and are not prone to situations where you need to flexibly respond to external changes. Students with a low level of procrastination can be observed with a high need to isolate themselves from additional, confusing, debatable information and the desire to have an unambiguous answer to the question.
The results illustrating the degree of severity of the prevailing irrational attitudes of students were obtained in the study. Significant differences were found in such indicators as self-esteem (u = 2233, p<0.000) and frustration tolerance (u = 1975, p<0.000). According to the scale of “self-esteem”, most of the procrastinators showed high scores, which indicates the absence of a pronounced tendency to high self-esteem. In addition, procrastinators have a more pronounced low tolerance to frustration (p = 0.000). Students with a high level of procrastination do not tolerate traumatic events or stressful situations. This is due to their perception of life, which seems to them the way they want, with a quick and easy solution to problems. But when these
Cognitive Nature of Procrastination 147
Table 1. Comparative results of cognitive indicators of students with low and high levels of procrastination.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Indicators The average rank of the feature Level of statistical significance U p low level of procrastination
high level of procrastination
73.24 90.19 2642.000 0.024
Results according to the Need for Closure Scale 1 Striving for order 56.86 102.26 1495.000 0.000 2 Striving for predictability
61.70 98.69 1834.000 0.000
3 Determination 53.12 105.02 1233.500 0.000 4 Duality 83.72 82.47 3274.500 0.868 5 Closeness of thinking 97.35 72.43 2320.500 0.001 6 General closeness 60.76 99.39 1768.000 0.000 Diagnostic indicators according to the Method of Diagnosing Irrational Attitudes by A. Ellis 1 Catastrophization 80.35 84.95 3139.500 0.540 2 Duty to oneself 67.40 94.49 2233.000 0.000 3 Obligation to others 79.08 85.89 3050.500 0.364 4 Frustration tolerance 102.29 68.79 1975.000 0.000 5 Self-assessment 87.94 79.36 2979.000 0.253 Indicators according to the Melbourne Decision-Making Questionnaire methodology 1 Vigilance 107.54 64.92 1607.500 0.000 2 Avoidance 52.55 105.44 1193.500 0.000 3 Procrastination 44.24 111.56 611.500 0.000 4 Super - vigilance 61.19 99.07 1798.500 0.000 Results of indicators according to the Questionnaire of Self-organization of Activity 1 Regularity 105.39 66.50 1757.500 0.000 2 Purposefulness 107.57 64.89 1605.000 0.000 3 Persistence 91.84 76.49 2706.500 0.041 4 Fixing 114.46 59.82 1123.000 0.000 5 Self-organization 111.29 62.15 1344.500 0.000 6 Focus on the present 111.39 62.08 1338.000 0.000 Diagnostic indicators according to the Comprehensive Coping Questionnaire 1 Avoidant behavior 65.34 96.01 2089.000 0.000 2 Anxiety and “winding up”
56.55 102.49 1473.500 0.000
3 Cognitive reassessment
65.27 96.06 2084.000 0.000
4 Intolerance of stressful situations
expectations become negative, procrastinators feel stress and begin to avoid disappointing events, which, paradoxically, leads to increased frustration and even greater mental stress.
The obtained data indicate that procrastinators have a less pronounced vigilance index (p = 0.000). This means that they have a more pronounced desire to avoid responsibility and a tendency to shift the decision of important matters to other people. Such avoidance allows you to postpone a conflict situation, does not require decisive action, and eventually leads to procra- stination. The “Super-vigilance” parameter has particular importance. This suggests that procrastinator students are more prone to impulsive decision- making, which allows them to avoid solving problems, and in crises leads to a “panic” in the choice of alternatives.
148 Smanov and Zabelina
Procrastinators have lower indicators of self-organization of activity: regu- larity (U = 1757.5, at p = 0.000), purposefulness (U = 1605.0, at p = 0.000), fixation (U = 1123, at p = 0.000) and self-organization (U = 1344.5, at p = 0.000), orientation to the present (U = 1338, at p = 0.000), persistence (U= 2706.5, at p = 0.041). Low indicators of self-organization of activities in a group with a high level of procrastination indicate problems with planning activities and following the developed plan in procrastinated ones, difficulties with setting goals and making efforts to achieve them, high distraction and lack of will to complete the things started, lack of commitment and consiste- ncy in their actions, lack of inclination to resort to with the help of external tools that help in time management, which can negatively affect their level of self-organization, and also the unwillingness to live in the present time, preferring the past and the future.
Procrastinators have more pronounced cognitive coping strategies. Signi- ficant differences at a high level of significance were found in all indicators of the methodology: avoidant behavior (U = 2089.0, at p = 0.000), anxiety and hype (U=l834.0, at p = 0.000), cognitive reassessment (U = 1473.5, at p = 0.000) and intolerance to stressful situations (U = 2084.0, at p = 0.000). It can be concluded that students with a high level of procrastination are more likely to apply a strategy of avoiding everything that makes them feel anxi- ous. Stimuli can be a variety of objects: people, places, situations, things, or internal sensations.
At the same time, procrastinators are ready to worry about any change in their lives that is temporarily negative. They, unlike non-procrastinators, are more prone to erroneous assessment, according to which any situation, object, sensation, or person is perceived as a source of threat, although they are not in reality. Additionally, procrastinators are not sure that they can withstand the pressure of certain circumstances and the emotions caused by them.
At the final stage of the study, a discriminant analysis was conducted to identify cognitive predictors of procrastination. The data of the discriminant analysis are shown in Table 2.
The results of the discriminant analysis indicate that such cognitive features as a weak focus on the events of the present, the habit of avoiding decision- making, weakened vigilance, an increased desire for cognitive closure, low
Table 2. Comparative results of indicators of coping strategies in subjects with low and high levels of procrastination.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
F p
Steps Indicators of cognitive components
Wilks Lambda
0.725 26.789 0.000
1 Focus on the present 0.824 32.913 0.000 2 Avoiding decision-making
tolerance to frustration, and a low level of self-organization of activity are important predictors of procrastination.
CONCLUSION
The hypothesis about specific cognitive features and predictors of procrasti- nation has generally been confirmed. However, in the group of subjects with a high level of procrastination, there are no pronounced irrational attitudes, which are the main elements of the cognitive component of procrastination, according to supporters of the cognitive approach. As a consequence, it can be assumed that irrational attitudes are not a key indicator of the cognitive sphere in procrastinating individuals.
Cognitive parameters such as lower indicators of self-organization of acti- vity, and vigilance, but at the same time high indicators of cognitive closeness and low tolerance to frustration were revealed in persons prone to pro- crastination. In addition, procrastinators have more pronounced cognitive coping strategies: avoidant behavior, anxiety, cognitive overestimation, and intolerance to stressful situations.
The results of the discriminant analysis allowed us to determine the indicators that have the greatest impact on the inclusion of procrastina- tors in the group. These are low orientation in the present, avoidance of decision-making, vigilance, striving for cognitive closeness, low tolerance to frustration, and low self-organization of activities.
In general, for further study of the procrastination phenomenon, unique data on the presence of specific psychological characteristics in the cogni- tive sphere of procrastination have been obtained. The main parameters and indicators reflecting the patterns of determining the high or low level of pro- crastination, as well as their significance and orientation, are established. The data obtained in the study make it possible to determine in advance the pre- disposition to procrastination and the ways of its manifestation in various situations, as well as to determine the conditions responsible for its redu- ction. Thus, the study expands the understanding of the cognitive nature of procrastination.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors are grateful to the Head of Chelyabinsk State University.
REFERENCES
Aftab, S., Klibert, J., Holtzman, N., et al. (2017) Schemas Mediate the Link Between Procrastination and Depression: Results from the United States and Pakistan. J Rat-Emo Cognitive-Behav Ther 35, 329–345. Atalayin, C., Balkis, M., Tezel, H., Kayrak, G. (2018) Procrastination and predi-
ctor variables among a group of dental students in Turkey, Psychology, Health & Medicine, 23:6, 726-732 Balkis, M., Duru, E. (2019) Procrastination and Rational/Irrational Beliefs: A Moderated Mediation Model. J Rat-Emo Cognitive-Behav Ther 37, 299–315. Beck A., Rush A., Shaw B., Emery G. (1979) Cognitive Therapy of Depression,
Guilford, New York.
150 Smanov and Zabelina
Burka J., Yuen L. (1983) Procrastination: Why you do it, what to do about it, Da Capo, Cambridge Chevrenidi A. A. (2019) The relationship between time perspective and procrasti-
nation among employees of different official statuses. Dis.... Candidate of Ps. sciences. Moscow (In Rus.). Chun Chu A. H., Choi J. N. (2005) Rethinking of Procrastination: Positive Effects of ≪Active≫procrastination behavior on attitudes and performance, Journal of Social Psychology, 145(3), 245–264 Cigdem, Murat Balkis, Huseyin Tezel & Gul Kayrak (2018) Procrastination and pre-
dictor variables among a group of dental students in Turkey, Psychology, Health & Medicine, 23:6, 726–732 Gustavson D. E., Miyake A., Hewitt J. K., and Friedman N. P. (2015) ≪Understanding the Cognitive and Genetic Underpinnings of Procrastination: Evidence for Shared Genetic Influences With Goal Management and Execu- tive Function Abilities≫. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General Journal, 144(6), 1063–1079 Dzhansen J, Ivrard U. (2002). Definition of male puberty by Isaev DN, (ed). Sexology.
Peter; Saint-Petersburg (In Rus.) Ellis A., Knaus W. J. (1977) Overcoming procrastination, Signet Books, New York Kahneman D. (2017), Think long…solve quickly. ASR, Moscow (In Rus.) Rogers KR. (2001), Personality development. Perspective on psychotherapy. Eksmo-Press. Moscow (In Rus.). Ferrari J. R., Wolfe R. N., Wesley J. C., Schoff L. A., Beck B. L. (1995) ≪Ego-identity
and academic procrastination among university students≫, Journal of College Student Development, 36 361-367 Ferrari, J. R., & Tice, D. M. (2000). Procrastination as a Self-Handicap for Men and Women: A Task-Avoidance Strategy in a Laboratory Setting. Journal of Research in Personality, 34, 73–83 Festinger L. (1984), Introduction to dissonance theory. Modern abroad social
psychology. 97–110. Flett, G. L., Stainton, M., Hewitt, P. L et al. (2012) Procrastination Automatic Thoughts as a Personality Construct: An Analysis of the Procrastinatory Cognitions Inventory. J Rat-Emo Cognitive-Behav Ther 30, 223–236 Gardner, R. W., Holzman, P. S., Klein, G. S., Linton, H. B., & Spence, D. P. (1959)
Cognitive control: A study of individual consistencies in cognitive behavior. International Universities Press Geertman E, Valk A. (2021) Academic procrastination: the underlying psychological and neurological factors. J Radboud annals of medical students. 19, 11–17. Gordeeva T. O. (2006) Psychology of achievement motivation: studies. manual for
university students studying the direction and specialties of psychology. Moscow: Sense (In Rus.). Haghbin, M., McCaffrey, A., & Pychyl, T. A. (2012). The complexity of the relationship between fear of failure and procrastination. Journal of Rational-Emotive & Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 30(4), 249–263. Karlovskaya N. N., Baranova R. A. (2008) The relationship between general
and academic procrastination and anxiety in students with different academic performance // Psychology at the university. No. 3. pp. 38–49 (In Rus.) Kholodnaya M. A. (2004) Cognitive styles. About the nature of the individual mind.
St. Petersburg: Peter (In Rus.) Kormacheva I. N. (2021) Emotional, volitional and motivational determinants of personality procrastination (on the example of educational activity): dis.... Candidate of Ps. sciences. St. Petersburg (In Rus.)
Cognitive Nature of Procrastination 151
Kukla A. (2007) Mental Traps: Stupid Things That Sane People Do to Mess Up Their Minds. McGraw-Hill, New York Lay, C. H. (1986). At last, my research article on procrastination: A search for types.
Personality and Individual Differences, 8, 705–714. McCown, B., Blake, I. K., & Keiser, R. (2012). Content analyses of the beliefs of academic procrastinators. Journal of Rational-Emotive & Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 30(4), 213–222. Maddi S., Kobasa S. (1984) The Hardy Executive: Health under Stress. Homewood
(IL): Dow Jones – Irwin Milgram, N. A., Gehrman, T., & Keinan, G. (1992). Procrastination and emotional upset: A typological model. Personality and Individual Differences, 13(12), 1307–1313. Özer, B. U., Demir, A., & Ferrari, J. (2009). Exploring academic procrastination
among Turkish students: Possible gender differences in prevalence and reasons. The Journal of Social Psychology, 149(2), 241–257. Powers, T. A., Koestner, R., & Zuroff, D. C. (2007). Self-criticism, goal motivation, and goal progress. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 26(7), 826–840. Pratkanis, A. R., Breckler, S. J., & Greenwald, A. G. (Eds.) (1989) Attitude structure
and function. Psychology Press, Philadelphia, PA Ryzova S. V. The influence of procrastination on the psychological adaptation of students and their psychological correction by methods of cognitive behavioral psychotherapy. Dis.... Candidate of Medical Sciences. M.; 2019. Sirois, F. M. (2015). Is procrastination a vulnerability factor for hypertension and
cardiovascular disease? Testing an extension of the procrastination–health model. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 38(3), 578–589. Steel, P. D. G. (2007). The nature of procrastination: A meta-analytic and theoretical review of quintessential self-regulatory failure. Psychological Bulletin, 133(1), 65–94. Yasin M. I. (2020) The concept of cognitive closure: history and related concepts //
Bulletin of Kostroma State University. Series: Pedagogy. Psychology. Sociokinetics. Vol. 26, No. 1. pp. 174–181 (In Rus.).
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Cognitive Computing and Internet of Things
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-49-0
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional